3 ms·
You're right about 1 and 2, but you've got the order wrong for 3-5. Most grad schools view GPA and GRE scores as an initial, binary filter (with the emphasis o
by timr 19y ago
You're right about 1 and 2, but you've got the order wrong for 3-5.
Most grad schools view GPA and GRE scores as an initial, binary filter (with the emphasis on GRE scores), and then use the other criteria to rank the remaining applicants in a somewhat flexible way. A 4.0 from MIT is obviously not going to hurt you, but I wouldn't go so far as saying that a 3.6 from MIT is "better" than a 4.0 from a second-tier school. That's just snobbery.
- mercurio 19y agoThose numbers were just an example to say that both the gpa and school are factors. That is, an admissions committee would not do a straight comparison between gpas, but would factor in a weight for the school. This is not snobbery, just the facts of life. I am not saying that a 4.0 student from an unknown school is worse than a 3.6 MIT student. There is no way to objectively know that. Also gpa matters more than you seem to think. A 4.0 from MIT would do more than not hurt. It would get you admission into a top tier program. The reason graduate programs give importance to gpa is because it takes a sustained effort over 4 years to have a great gpa when you apply. This shows an ability to work hard over a sustained period of time which is a prerequisite for success in grad school and research. Finally, as I originally said, most undergrads do not have any significant research experience when they apply, and so the recommendations and gpa become more important in those cases. There is a strong correlation between recommendations and gpa, with the difference that a gpa is an objective measure. Most competent students manage to find people who will write positive recommendations for them. Its much harder to finesse your gpa this way. Admission committees are well aware of these issues.
- timr 19y agoI understand what you believe to be true, but I'm not speaking from a hypothetical perspective. I've seen the 3.6 MIT student get rejected, while a 4.0 student from a "lesser" school gained admission. It happens. As I said, a high GPA from MIT isn't going to hurt you, but it's not a golden ticket, either. If nothing else, grad schools like the GRE because it's a standardized metric. Still, neither GRE score nor GPA are particularly good predictors of success in graduate school, and the committees know this.
- mercurio 19y agoI think we possibly have a different understanding of what is a lesser or second tier school. I based my opinion on the original poster's response to pg's comment, where he states that his cs program is like "trade school". I doubt that a 4.0 from such a program would count for much in comparison to an applicant from a top CS department. As for your anecdotal example, could it not be that the other factors were the deciding ones in this case (like the student from the lesser school having much stronger recommendations or published a paper)? In any case, all I meant by making up this 3.6/4.0 example was that the school matters too. If I read you correctly, you also seem to be saying that GRE scores are more important than GPA. This is not true at all. In fact GRE scores count for very little compared to your GPA (which counts less than recommendations and research). Remember that we are discussing admission to top-tier schools. MIT does not even consider the GRE in their admission procedure. Also, what makes you assume that I'm talking from a hypothetical perspective? At my undergrad school, I have personally known about 50 people who've applied and gone to grad school, and GPA correlates very strongly with the ranking of the department they joined. Since then these views have been confirmed by the faculty (including my advisor) that I have talked to at my grad school. In any case, we have our grad recruiting weekend coming up next week, and I'll do some field research and report back :)
- timr 19y agoMy post was based on my own knowledge of the recruiting process (and the background of many fellow grad students) a top-tier school: 1) GPA and GRE scores are typically the basis for an include/exclude decision to filter a large pool of applicants down to a smaller pool. They don't typically play a primary role in determining the ranking of the candidates after this step. That's a far more holistic (read: subjective) decision. 2) In terms of #1, committees tend to weight both GPA and GRE equally, with a slight preference given to the GRE, because it is the only direct quantitative comparison available between all applicants. But this debate is mostly navel-gazing, because admissions committees are famously capricious; the exact method used depends on the members of the committee, and their particular biases. The only point I'm trying to make here is that your chances to get admitted to a top-tier school aren't necessarily higher if you went to MIT as an undergrad. That's a myth that is dearly loved -- by MIT undergrads. (And by the way? Two seconds of googling tells me that you're wrong about MIT and the GRE: http://web.mit.edu/admissions/graduate/requirements/testing_req.html http://web.mit.edu/admissions/graduate/requirements/testing_...)
- falsestprophet 19y agoI would say a 2.0 from MIT is much better than a 4.0 from a random cardinal-direction state school.
- sanj 19y agoI vehemently disagree. MIT has its set of acceptance mistakes. Many (perhaps even the majority) of those make it through its grind and graduate. At the end of the day, it is a big, big deal to fail a student. Or to put them on a path to take a core class over. Instead, most professors will give them a barely passing grade simply to be done with them. By the same token, your "cardinal-direction state school" has a lot of folks works really hard and busting their hump for that 4.0. Sure, you could argue it isn't the same as an MIT 5.0 (yes, MIT's scale goes to 5...), but it's damn sight better than a marginal pass. There's one exception to this: the apocryphal brilliant and distracted MIT student who can't be bothered to get good grades because they're too busy working on cooler stuff. I've had the honor of working with a pair of those folks, and it wouldn't have mattered where they went to school. Heck, one of them transferred into MIT from a two year junior college. But that's not who we're talking about here.