4 ms·
>My argument boils down to the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral. That is an idealistic viewpoint that simply isn't possible in the r
by slg 10y ago
>My argument boils down to the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral.
That is an idealistic viewpoint that simply isn't possible in the real world. Yes, I believe the government should be more transparent about these things, but they can't be transparent about everything. How do you protect a country like the United States without any intelligence or military secrets?
- mixmastamyk 10y agoYou protect it by not picking fights and minding your own business.
- slg 10y agoOnce again, this is a naive and idealistic viewpoint that doesn't have a place in real world governing. There is a reason why even countries like Switzerland have intelligence and military arms. Simply "minding your own business" only goes so far and isn't a fool-proof protection scheme.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoWhere did I mention closing military or intelligence? The question at hand is whether the govt should be more transparent.
- slg 10y ago>Where did I mention closing military or intelligence? Where did I mention closing them? I am just making the connection those are two aspects of governing that require some level of secrecy. If countries "minding their own business" need secrecy there, then it isn't a path to the US abandoning secrecy. >The question at hand is whether the govt should be more transparent. If that is your argument, I agree with it. But that wasn't the original argument. The original argument was complete transparency and "the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral."
- mixmastamyk 10y ago> why even countries like Switzerland have intelligence and military arms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowback_%28intelligence%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowback_%28intelligence%29 I'm not interested in arguing absolutes, as perhaps the original ancestor was.
- aarpmcgee 10y agoSmall imagination :)
- thawkins 10y agoAhhhh, don't you love the smell of rancid corrupt realpolitik in the morning..,..,
- joe_the_user 10y agoThat [ending state secrecy entirely] is an idealistic viewpoint that simply isn't possible in the real world. If anything, the dynamics of the our "real world" show that we heading towards a future of either complete openness or unlimited state secrecy (with unlimited state secrecy sadly looking the likely winner). Beyond the particular illegal (or simply immoral) activity revealed by Snowden's revelations, we see the ability of secret powers to extend themselves secretly and thus grow without being bounded by any democratic norms or public debate. And we see the scale of the state and the scale of technology as only accelerating this. It seems that NSA hacks every single hackable subsystem of every electronic device out there, keeping the cleverest things things for national security (the ability to track cellphone location even with batteries removed was considered a crucial tool for drone-killing Taliban/Al Qaeda leaders, etc). The existence of an intelligence agency's "crown jewels" implies that "parallel construction" must be used with the information that these "crown jewels" gather, in the fashion Alan Turing's crowd already only selectively using their interceptions against the NAZIs. But here we see that what in the 1940s a small region of secrecy and control can be in 2016 a potentially limitless area where a military paradigm is mobilized against the individual and where institutions like the courts serve the military purpose of decoys and misdirections (with even the secret courts winding up manipulated through even-more-secret programs and methods, etc). A military facing an opposing state wants to find weapons that give its opponent no recourse - secretly the opponents plans being one a great instance of this. But the court system and the democratic requires real debate, a real fight of opposing positions and thus the reality of democracy and rule of law is progressively degraded. The existence of the means of secrecy justifies their expansion (discussion of the "most important" secrets requires more secret action to stop said discuss, etc) and this expansion naturally must be secret. Clearly, this complex will either rise to omnipresence or come to an end as things go forward. Sadly, it's hard to see how it will come to an end.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> How do you protect a country like the United States without any intelligence or military secrets? It isn't about having no secrets, it's about minimizing secrets. Which improves security, because secrets are a liability. They consume resources to keep and cause harm when revealed. The more of them you need the less secure you are. Government secrets are attack surface, not an unmitigated good.