3 ms·
I will offer the voice of dissent. Snowden is a slightly improved version of Chelsea Manning and deserves a similar fate as her. Both revealed legitimate issu
by slg 10y ago
I will offer the voice of dissent. Snowden is a slightly improved version of Chelsea Manning and deserves a similar fate as her. Both revealed legitimate issues that they deserve praise for highlighting. However, both also revealed information that has little public interest, isn't illegal activity, and can really only be categorized as releasing privileged material (look to The Intercept and this weeks SIDtoday releases for the most recent examples of this). The intentions of both were noble, but you can't simply say the good outweighed the bad. That isn't how the law currently works or in my opinion should work. You have to take all of the good and bad into account.
As a nation, we also can't set the precedent that any person with classified information has the right to release information they morally object without any legal repercussions. If you are going to ask for whisteblowing protection, you need to be fairly focused on things that are either illegal or at the very least objectively amoral. Neither Snowden or Manning did that. They instead grabbed everything they could get their hands on in the off chance it was something they were looking for. Isn't that the exact problem we have with mass surveillance in the first place?
- donatj 10y agoI'm going to place the contrarian argument that for there to be a nation of the people there needs to be total transparency in the governments actions. Anything less is tyranny. You cannot possibly make an informed vote when the government is a black box you cannot see into. The entire inner workings should be public knowledge. This mountain of secrecy left over from the cold war does not make for a free society and has no place in a just world. My argument boils down to the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- slg 10y ago>My argument boils down to the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral. That is an idealistic viewpoint that simply isn't possible in the real world. Yes, I believe the government should be more transparent about these things, but they can't be transparent about everything. How do you protect a country like the United States without any intelligence or military secrets?
- mixmastamyk 10y agoYou protect it by not picking fights and minding your own business.
- slg 10y agoOnce again, this is a naive and idealistic viewpoint that doesn't have a place in real world governing. There is a reason why even countries like Switzerland have intelligence and military arms. Simply "minding your own business" only goes so far and isn't a fool-proof protection scheme.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoWhere did I mention closing military or intelligence? The question at hand is whether the govt should be more transparent.
- slg 10y ago>Where did I mention closing military or intelligence? Where did I mention closing them? I am just making the connection those are two aspects of governing that require some level of secrecy. If countries "minding their own business" need secrecy there, then it isn't a path to the US abandoning secrecy. >The question at hand is whether the govt should be more transparent. If that is your argument, I agree with it. But that wasn't the original argument. The original argument was complete transparency and "the government keeping secrets first place is inherently amoral."
- mixmastamyk 10y ago> why even countries like Switzerland have intelligence and military arms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowback_%28intelligence%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowback_%28intelligence%29 I'm not interested in arguing absolutes, as perhaps the original ancestor was.
- aarpmcgee 10y ago
- twblalock 10y agoDo you think the government should release plans and schematics for nuclear and biological weapons? Or maybe the IRS should release every tax return it has ever received? Or in a time of war, we should announce where all of our troops are going in advance?
- DanBC 10y ago> Or maybe the IRS should release every tax return it has ever received? That's not so bizarre. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Finland#Publicity_of_income_taxes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Finland#Publicity_... > Even when information of earnings and the taxation procedure of individual persons and companies are not public, the amount of taxes carried for each person and company is public information. Tax Administration authority is required to submit information for free if request is targeted. Larger records are submitted for journalistic purposes. Capital income and earned income, are both public information, while taxation of dividends from unlisted limited company is not
- dror 10y agoCloser to home, I can see exactly how much property taxes each and every one of my neighbors pay: https://www.acgov.org/ms/prop/index.aspx https://www.acgov.org/ms/prop/index.aspx
- jazzyk 10y agoThe nuclear info should be secret because it protects us from our enemies. The info on population surveillance should be secret because? Oh wait, the government thinks we are the enemy...
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> The intentions of both were noble, but you can't simply say the good outweighed the bad. That isn't how the law currently works or in my opinion should work. You have to take all of the good and bad into account. Isn't saying the good outweighed the bad how you take all of the good and bad into account? Anything else is to say that everyone who is not without sin should be in prison, which is... everyone. The problem with your alternative is that no one looks to the sins of mostly-good common people, but anyone who moves against the establishment is thrust into the spotlight where any human fallibility is seized as an excuse to punish them, not for the thing being punished, but for the thing that put them in the government's cross hairs. High ranking government officials have been known to reveal classified information when it's in their political interest and not be prosecuted because no one was out looking for an excuse to prosecute them. There is no justice if the same thing doesn't happen in the case where the thing revealed is inconvenient to the government.
- nabla9 10y agoYou should see Snowden in context. Whistleblowers before Snowden (Drake, Binney) tried to do it the normal way. They were investigated, prosecuted, charged in secret and shut down. They were the only people investigated. Only Snowden has changed things. http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-punished-nsa-whistleblowers http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-...
- pizza234 10y ago> revealed information that has little public interest This is false, in a very strict sense; after almost 3 years, the entire world is still debating about his work - if this is not "public interest", what is? > isn't illegal activity > you can't simply say the good outweighed the bad This is actually a serious problem of it. Actually, under a certain interpretation, this is the radical problem - lack of accountability. The Clappers of the situation can do/say whatever they want, and get away with it. If you put this in a political context where if you make a documentary about Iraq you go in the government dissidents watchlist [Poitras], you see the direction towards authoritarian themes; in my book, this is as bad as it gets. > has the right to release information they morally object without any legal repercussions. This is misinformed; Snowden said he would have come back in his home country, if there had been a fair trial. Whether this is true of false, everybody knows, that the alternative to "without any legal repercussions" is being crushed by some draconian laws of the early 20th century. > They instead grabbed everything they could get their hands on in the off chance it was something they were looking for. Isn't that the exact problem we have with mass surveillance in the first place? If we put aside rhetoric, then definitely are very different problems. There are several reasons why the Mannings/Snowdens could actually keep releasing documentation (including survival, or keeping the public interested, or in unrealistic worst case, frivolousness, arrogance or else), which are radically different from the reason of mass surveillance, which boils down to power.
- lewisl9029 10y ago> They instead grabbed everything they could get their hands on in the off chance it was something they were looking for. I'm generally in favor of what Snowden did, but I agree that he should have been a lot more selective in what material he handed off to the press. In dumping everything he could get his hands on without exercising any discretion, he definitely neglected one of his basic responsibilities as a whistleblower. The situation calls for a nuanced approach, but it seems neither side has the capacity for it, with one side hailing him as an infallible beacon of justice and the other as a traitor that must be punished and made an example of, due process be damned. I'm sure at this point Snowden himself would be happy to return to his homeland if he could just be granted a fair and open trial in the court of law, but that seems rather unlikely in our current political environment.
- maxander 10y agoOther commenters have voiced objections to various bits of this argument which I won't repeat, but I want to highlight a point that is extremely important in cases like Snowden; we agree that his action was unlawful, but this says little about it being immoral when the relevant laws are condoning immoral behavior. He certainly did things that in general people shouldn't do, and that the law doesn't allow for; but he did them for reasons that, we'd contend, outweigh the reasons he shouldn't have. Absolutely, the law doesn't work in a "does the good outweigh the bad" fashion, but morality often does (namely, if we ascribe to the view of moral utilitarianism, which is extremely popular both in everyday intuition and academic philosophical circles.) So morally speaking, there isn't necessarily a serious problem with Snowden or Manning's grab-everything approach, either- the damage from what they shouldn't have released can be judged less important than the benefit from what they wouldn't have made available if they were going more carefully. Snowden getting pardoned would be an individual act of some politician(s) intervening on the legal system, and different from institutionalized whistleblower protection as discussed in the article. The latter is an attempt to get the law back into sync with morality, both directly and through allowing a legal channel for individuals to spur changes to existing immoral systems. There's definitely a tension between whistleblower protection programs that would satisfy both the demands of morally-minded government agents and also the necessities of secrecy-centric government capabilities.