8 ms·
Credit-Card Debt Nears $1 Trillion as Banks Push Plastic
- olivil 11y agoIs there a way to read the article without signing up or subscribing?
- mmastrac 11y agoClick the "web" link above.
- robsears 11y agoGoogle the first sentence. WSJ doesn't ask you to subscribe if you are referred by Google.
- oarsinsync 11y agoI have this bookmarklet that I click every time I visit a page that is paywalled, as many are open if referred via Google: javascript:(function(){location.replace('http://www.google.com/search?q='+document.URL)})()
- killerbat00 11y agoIf you update this to use window.location.href = url, you won't lose history :)
- askyourmother 11y agoBest part is credit card debt is typically unsecured - spend, consume, enjoy, stick up middle finger when repayment is due. Those who do repay will of course sub those who don't over the long course in the variable rates and fees.
- koolba 11y ago> Best part is credit card debt is typically unsecured - spend, consume, enjoy, stick up middle finger when repayment is due. Those who do repay will of course sub those who don't over the long course in the variable rates and fees. Those that pay it off entirely every month are the one's being subsidized. It's effectively an interest free loan for 30 days. Plus you get 1-2% back as "rewards". That's what contributes to the ~3% transaction costs for credit cards.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoSticking up a middle finger will trash your credit rating and make it impossible to get a mortgage. In the UK you'll also be put through collections, which can include attempts to force you to sell a property - if you own one - and/or most of your possessions to repay the debt. Credit cards may not be secured, but lenders have risk management divisions who make some attempt to estimate default rates. The biggest problem is the ridiculous rates for the riskiest borrowers. A few cards have an APR of 99.9%, which guarantees a default for anyone on a low income who has to make an unexpected payment for any reason at all.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Sticking up a middle finger will trash your credit rating and make it impossible to get a mortgage. I walked away from an underwater mortgage on a townhouse. It only caused my dropped my credit score ~100 points, and was eligible for another mortgage after 3 years (My credit card provider didn't blink, and had no problem allowing me to keep a charge card with high five figures of credit available). The repercussions of credit default are highly overrated.
- shanecleveland 11y agoThat's incredible. I wonder how typical your experience is. I've considered this strategy on a home we are forced to rent at a loss, as we'd be unable to sell. But I couldn't bring myself to do it.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAt the time, I was backed into a corner so to say. It wasn't something I went into willingly. My HOA would not allow me to rent the townhouse out (too many rentals already), nor could I come up with the $150K to bring the mortgage down to the new fair market value. So, mailed the keys back to the bank and walked away.
- dragonwriter 11y ago
- rco8786 11y ago> stick up middle finger when repayment is due Err, what a terrible idea. That might work once, sure. Then you're pretty fucked for a long time. The only way to avoid the collections would be to full on declare bankruptcy. Honestly there's basically no situation in which that's a good idea unless you're actually bankrupt.
- vox_mollis 11y agoThen you're pretty fucked for a long time Depending on amount owed, this may not be true. Any unsecured default under ~$10k, the only consequences are usually a credit report hit and incessant calls from debt collector call center workers. Over ~$10k, and yes, you're talking attorneys, judgments, garnishments, etc.
- FireBeyond 11y agoHah. I got divorced. I got served a while back over a joint debt that got overlooked. The principal was $1,050. The firm had also tacked on $2,000 in "preparation and legal costs, filing fees". Which is pretty rich for what likely amounted to a mail merge in Word. But it's no coincidence that most collection firms are owned by lawyers.
- mkj 11y agoWhat's the amount carried over each month (and interest paid)? That seems the more interesting figure.
- hyperpape 11y agoGiven that this is > $12,000 for a family of four, I'm guessing that it's not that much less, and at least half of it is carried over month to month, if not more.
- morgante 11y agoWhy do you assume that? I'm single but will sometimes have a debt of $10k in a month but never carry any over.
- mac01021 11y agoImpressive income.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoOr good with buffering/saving.
- hyperpape 11y agoMean (not median) household income in the US is $70k, I saw one source that it's more like 100-110 for married households with children. It is literally impossible for those families to pay off a $12k balance every month. Factor in that you often can't pay rent, mortgage or car payments from a credit card and it's not even close. (The fact that you save up and spend and then pay 10-12k in one month is irrelevant. Because of aggregation, what's relevant is your average month).
- throwawaykeno 11y agoOne thing that's unclear for the article: does this include debt that never incurs any interest? I typically have an outstanding balance in the 3-4 figures on my credit card because I pay for rent, gas, and airline tickets with credit. However, it gets paid off every month. I guess that's technically debt, but it's not problematic or anything... I feel like the majority of credit card debt is the type of "debt" that I incur every month.
- markhall 11y agoI would venture to guess that 'your type of debt' [like mine] is actually the minority. Most Americans actually carry a balance, hence why the card companies continue to push/prey as they do.
- losteric 11y agoCompared to the average American, your credit card usage is incredibly unusual. The average home carries around $15,000 in credit card debt alone. I find this to be extremely worrying... especially considering the average college graduate starts working with $25,000 in student loans.
- shanecleveland 11y agoI wondered the same thing. My balance is typically <$1000, but I've never had an interest-accruing balance.
- empath75 11y agoIt's pretty great having a few grand in cash to throw around every month, but man do you live in a bubble if you think 'most' people do that.
- throwawaykeno 11y agoI make less than 30k/year, so I'm not exactly rolling in it. Although I'm highly unusual because my very realistic earning potential is 3x what I currently make (STEM grad student). Still, putting only rent on a CC = 1k+/mo where I live.
- fbdjfhhcbd 11y agoIt's interesting to watch how the financial industry is pushing debt as a substitute for income. That way people can still purchase the products from companies listed on the equities market, without those companies needing to spend nearly as much on labor overhead. It makes you wonder how sustainable our economy is when it's based on borrowing instead of earnings...
- tremon 11y agoI can't read the article, but the title is a non-sequitur: overdrawing is not inevitably tied to bank cards. Other societies have things like a direct debit infrastructure which allows consumers to use plastic cards without the risk of overdrawing. That doesn't mean it's impossible though: many Dutch banks allow the customer to choose his overwithdrawal limit. Mine is set to zero.
- siscia 11y agoHonest question. There aren't debit cards in the united states? They are simple plastic cards like credit carda but the bank is withdrawing your money directly from your account. There is not debt involved.
- wf 11y agoYes, of course there are. But how would we buy things we can't afford now without a credit card?! /s
- tootie 11y agoThey exist and I think probably most people have them. What they don't have is money in their bank accounts.
- duaneb 11y agoWell, sure the US has debit cards. But people use credit cards because they want the credit.
- bradleyjg 11y agoThey do exist. However "as a convenience" they allow overdrafts at ridiculously high costs. AFAIK you can't shut this feature off and just have charges declined if there isn't enough money in the account.
- jdmichal 11y agoThat completely 100% depends on your bank. I can and have completely disabled overdraft on my debit card. It will reject transactions if my account is empty. (I actually can't imagine a bank not offering to completely disable this, especially if they charge fees for the same. But I'll accept your word on it.)
- Noted 11y agoI thought all overdraft protection is opt-in now? (I thought they passed a law about it in the past few years)
- Overtonwindow 11y agoIt was interesting that a year ago the media was saying that Americans were pulling back on credit use, and paying it down. [1] I'm curious if that was honest reporting, or if something changed which caused people to spend more? [1] http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2015/04/07/americans-pull-back-on-credit-card-debt-in-february/ http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2015/04/07/americans-pull-bac...
- prostoalex 11y agoThat is correct, the total outstanding debt was down as of year ago (side benefit of lower gas prices leaving more cash in the pockets of consumers), but the article mentions the banks have revved up their credit card distribution since then: "Because many creditworthy consumers are still cautious about spending, lenders are turning more aggressively to subprime borrowers. Lenders issued some 10.6 million general-purpose credit cards to subprime borrowers last year, up 25% from 2014 and the highest level since 2007, according to Equifax." "Overall, lenders gave out more than 104 million general-purpose and store credit cards in 2015, up 6.5% from a year earlier and up 47% from the bottom in 2010, according to Equifax."
- winslow 11y agoSo we are back at the subprime lending model. Correct me if I am wrong but from my understanding this is what ultimately caused (or one of the biggest factors along with adjustable rate mortgages) the housing collapse and economic downturn circa 2007/2008. So how is this subprime lending any different via the credit cards? We could hypothesize that credit card debt won't be as massive as mortgage debt and thus may not cause catastrophic events. However, on the flip side there is little to no collateral in credit card debt that a creditor would get in return of defaulting on your credit loan. The more I look at credit debt, student loan debt, and fairly recently CDO's (Collateralized Debt Obligation) that banks are doing again we are setting ourselves up for failure again. Anyone have any thoughts on all this?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- n42 11y agoSorry for being pedantic, but the correct term is "could not care less". Otherwise you are suggesting that they do care.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIt is of my opinion that if a word or phrase is logically improper but the meaning is widely understood, then societal acceptance grants it validity. Edit: This post is receiving a fair amount of downvoting. I would be very interested to hear arguments that are not from my own viewpoint.
- DigitalJack 11y agoI downvoted you because it goes against the way I think. While I accept the basis of solipsism, it's simply not a practical way to live one's life. However, language is not math, and adhering and enforcing rigid definitions might pave the path to newspeak. So after having thought about it, I regret downvoting you.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y ago:) I really appreciate your perspective. The internet makes it too easy to "fire and forget." I hadn't even considered my own opinion in the way in which you framed it. Thank you.
- throwanem 11y agoThe initial usage is correct; credit card companies could care less about customers who pay off their balances every month, because such customers generate negligible revenue and are thus on the whole a nuisance.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIf credit card processing fees are so high as to encourage small businesses to refuse payment by credit cards unless the total exceeds a minimum sum, I would hardly call that revenue "negligible." Otherwise, there would be no reason to offer (paltry) "rewards" points. Not to mention, people who regularly pay off their card in full are more able to spend far more than than their credit limit in a given month.
- joslin01 11y agoGather round and I'll tell you a tale of how to lose at the credit card game. When I turned 18, I got my first credit card. I asked my father "good idea?" and he said yea, good to build up credit. Ok then. A week later, my new card with a whopping limit of $750. Never having experienced not paying with cash I had, it gave me an odd thrill and I went out to eat with my friends and joked "It's like free money!" And despite knowing better, it certainly felt like free money because the numbers didn't change in my bank account. Sure I knew I'd have to pay it off, but whatever, I'd do that later. Now, like all good citizens, I spent the first couple years always paying off the balance I owed. Nor was it long before credit card offers came to me and I said "hey good to build up credit" and signed up for them. My next big one had something like $1500 limit and I was 19. Soon enough, I was doing great -- my credit was high & debt low -- looks good for credit. Well, soon enough I was in Boston going to college and working part-time. One day at work, I got another one of these offers and thought "why not?" This time was special though because it asked me what is your household income -- not my income. Well.. my parents didn't make much but we weren't poor either, so I added together the incomes and said my household income was $150k. I felt a bit mischevious putting it down -- was it the truth? What was going to happen? Would they check to see if I made that much? No, instead, they were more to happy to oblige and gave me (a 20 y/o) a new credit card with $12,500 limit. Holy shit! I thought to myself, I have a LOT of free money! Over the course of the next 4 years in college, I would eat out whenever I pleased and generally kept my credit under control, but slowly & surely my credit usage was rising. Fast forward a few years after that, and I have a total credit line of about 30k -- all maxed out. Was I being outright financially foolish ordering $100 bottles of Chardonnay at the club? Not at all. Was I being financially negligent ordering whatever small thing came my way that I wanted? Yes -- because I could. So then you find yourself in deep debt, and what do you do? You start paying the minimum off and then re-using that credit. Do you care so much about paying it off? No that seems like an eternity away, paying the minimum is easier. Do you know it's wrong? Of course. Do you care? Not as much as you should. This my friends is how you lose at the credit card game and end up just paying fees to bank execs. It can be fun, but I do not recommend.
- askldfhjkasfhd 11y agoCan you elaborate on how you perceive the difference between the two examples here? Being financially foolish and negligent seem both to apply to your experience. "Was I being outright financially foolish ordering $100 bottles of Chardonnay at the club? Not at all. Was I being financially negligent ordering whatever small thing came my way that I wanted?"
- superuser2 11y agoI propose that credit card debt is simply the earliest signal of "not making enough money to sustain the life you think of as normal." We have not yet come to terms with the fact that the overwhelming majority of people outside of a tiny sliver of elites are going to be lucky to afford bare subsistence in the years to come. Credit card debt lets us delay confrontation with the reality that wages have not grown enough, employment is not strong enough for most people in middle-class jobs to live the lives we used to think of as middle class. Of course you reach for plastic before you stop buying groceries.
- nametakenobv 11y agoPlease stop with this heart-breaking narrative about the unequal in income, starving americans. It's about iphones and clothes, not groceries.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Nearly half of Americans would have trouble finding $400 to pay for an emergency. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secret-shame/476415/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/my-secre...
- kdamken 11y agoI'd be interested to see your (or anyone from that article's) monthly spending/expenses and income. Do you have crazy medical bills or student loans that you can't avoid? Do you budget your money out and track every transaction? It sucks to be in that situation, but there are always things you can do to improve it.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI've edited the comment. The part "I'm one of them" is from the article title.
- 11y ago
- throwaway9574 11y agoI know some may criticize this, but I cut up my credit card soon after moving into my first apartment. My wife and I use debit cards exclusively, but I know it's only a matter of time before our card numbers get skimmed online or through a hacked terminal. Does anyone know of any measures we could take to minimize the effects when that does happen?
- yrro 11y agoUse a separate card for online purchases--for instance, a credit card that you pay off, in full, every month.
- JoshGlazebrook 11y ago(not affiliated in any way) but privacy.com lets you hook up to your bank account and lets you generate one time use card numbers for individual bills, etc. They recently expanded to 15,000 banks/credit unions. It won't help with physical card skimming, but for online stuff it can. https://privacy.com/ https://privacy.com/ Another option is to use one credit card, and only use it for bills/budgeted expenses and NOTHING more. Then just pay it off every month. This will prevent your real money from being being stolen/frozen in the event of your card number being lost/skimmed, and it can also gain you cash back and/or rewards.
- blindfly 11y agoNot affiliated either but I love privacy.com! I've been using them since I saw it on HN a few weeks back and no looking back. I regularly get to exchange messages with the team and they've fixed many bug reports in record time (nothing serious, just finicky stuff). Unlike my credit card companies who refuse to get with the program and show me auths and captures in somewhat real time. Having to wait days to find out what went through is such a joke. I thought cards were supposed to be easier... if I spent $10 in cash I know I've spent $10, with a CC I wait 3 days and find out butterfingers misplaced the decimal and I'm left trying to hunt down $1000.00 that's now on my account while I'm miles away.
- purplecpa 11y ago
- Bombthecat 11y agoOne trillion doesn't sound much compared to the rest.