4 ms·
200 years is only a blip in human history. First the machines automated physical labor, then they started automating mental labor, and now they're even starting
by taylodl 10y ago
200 years is only a blip in human history. First the machines automated physical labor, then they started automating mental labor, and now they're even starting to automate creative labor. As a friend of mine is fond of saying, society has yet to deal with all the ramifications brought by the steam engine. And we're moving way beyond that.
- lisivka 10y agoWhen machines will automate making of children, I will start to worry.
- billmalarky 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_vitro_fertilisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_vitro_fertilisation (sorry, couldn't resist ;-)
- iofj 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ectogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ectogenesis
- billmalarky 10y agoImprovements in this technology will be a godsend for women with hysterectomies.
- xiphias 10y agoThe big difference now is that the progress is fast enough for people to start to understand that their job may be automated in their life. Smart truck drivers in rich countries know that they have only at most 10 years left. Children from villages need to move to big cities to survive, as they understand the trend that farming jobs will worth less over time. Also more people that I know are getting interested in programming, though they do that for the money, not because they would understand the power of creation with code.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The big difference now is that the progress is fast enough for people to start to understand that their job may be automated in their life. The other big difference is that US hourly wages peaked in the 1970s, and there are enough people experiencing the divergence between expectations of continued improvement and reality since then that its no longer a prediction of harms that might occur in the future, but an explanation of harms that are being experienced in the present.
- sp332 10y agoThe world's population has almost tripled since 1950, so that timescale is highly relevant to "human history".
- sgnelson 10y agoI don't believe that's what the parent comment was saying. Also, in a way, I believe that supports his argument. Why is it that the world's population has tripled since 1950? It's not just because people are having more sex. It's because of the changes in technology in the past 200 years. ie innovations in agricultural, healthcare, and energy production. [0] While I won't argue that technology remained stagnant before that, I will argue that technological growth was very very slow. I would argue that many places in the world looked very similar at 400AD and 1400AD (in a technological sense). But in the past ~200 years, we've broken through whatever cultural barrier was holding us back technologically, and as such, the world is a vastly different place than it was 200 years ago. I disagree at least in part with the article, jobs have always been replaced by machines (as well as globalization, which I don't have time to get into). But just as the technological pace of the world has quickened, so has the pace of job loss. What is different is that at the "middle" of industrialization, it would be normal for someone to lose the job, but possibly find a new job, especially in the service industries. (And thus we have post-industrialization). However, what I would argue is happening now is that it becomes more and more difficult (especially with ever more specialization in jobs)to lose one job, and then quickly replace it with another job. That's one of the difference between then and now. As the parent posted, once the service industry jobs have been automated away, and then "creative" jobs, what then? "Post-Creative Jobs?" (Seriously, if anyone can answer this for me, please let me know.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition (note: a number of people argue that there is also a stage 6) Hi, my name is sgnelson, I'm a post-creative. I need a job.
- tariqali34 10y agoThe only jobs that probably won't be automated away is programming. Even if you build layers and layers of abstraction, you still have to code on top of the highest layer...and debug the machines when they go wrong (and they will go wrong; machines aren't perfect). I can imagine a future where the lucky few who still have jobs don't actually do any work. Instead, they speak "New COBOL", a debased imitation of natural language, to machine learning algorithms, convincing them to do the stuff that previous generations would have to do 'manually'. "Please make the shark fiercer", these job-holding people would say to the algorithm, before feeding it huge troves of data that would teach the machine basic concepts such as "shark" and "fierce". Obviously, some media commenters would claim that programming has been rendered now obsolete by the rise of New COBOL, but in reality, these lucky few speaking 'New COBOL' are the new programmers of that era. In a world where algorithms eat the world, someone still has to babysit the algorithms.
- laughinghan 10y ago200 years is over an order of magnitude longer than the time people typically predict we have left before robots "take all our jobs", which is usually like 5 or 10 years [1]. It is also several times longer than it takes each time for the economy get better, unemployment to fall, and this fear to subside, as demonstrated by the article. This suggests that the current rise in fear will likely reverse long before it becomes any more of a problem than it was the previous many times. That's the point of the article. What's your point? Why is it relevant to compare against whatever arbitrary definition of "human history" you chose? (Since the "civilization"? Since the Agricultural Revolution? Homo sapiens? Homo erectus?) [1]: e.g. http://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/robot-may-take-your-job-next-few-years-n499556 http://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/robot-may-take-your-jo...
- ommunist 10y agoI am afraid, 200 years is all of the modern industrial history.