6 ms·
This is exactly it. Now if LendUp would lend someone $200 for 30 days for a $1.50 (APR of 9%) they wouldn't be extortionate in their rates, but they would be le
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
This is exactly it. Now if LendUp would lend someone $200 for 30 days for a $1.50 (APR of 9%) they wouldn't be extortionate in their rates, but they would be leaving money on the table that they could be taking from people who really need a loan. And what lender ever likes to leave money on the table?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThere's a fine line between a predatory payday lender and one that must charge high interest rates to absorb the above-average default rate of borrowers who need a short term loan. I don't know LendUp personally, but it seems like they're trying to be socially responsible.
- mikestew 11y agoYou originally said "completely reasonable loans". On which side of that fine line between predatory and reasonable do you feel a 369% APR falls?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe line is set by how long the note exists for. Two weeks? Reasonable. Rolled over every two weeks for a year? Unreasonable. The middle ground lies somewhere between. http://thehill.com/regulation/237538-borrowers-default-on-nearly-half-of-all-payday-loans-in-2-years-study-finds http://thehill.com/regulation/237538-borrowers-default-on-ne... > In studying payday loans in North Dakota, the Center for Responsible Lending found that nearly half of all borrowers default on a loan within their first two years of borrowing. At that default rate, you will not exist as a lender charging low interest rates.
- ChuckMcM 11y ago"low" versus "extortionate" ? We've also got modern biometric technology that would allow a lender to never lend to someone who was delinquent twice. This significantly reduces the default rate over time as the pool of possible borrowers is characterized. And default comes in many forms, from not repaying to partial repayment. Credit cards are about 3.75% [1] so a filtered borrowing pool will be what 6%? 8%? Check my math here, so lets say you charge 10% for 30 days (120% APR) so your $200 loan has a $20 interest fee. Now if every year, one month out of 12 the lender turns out to be a deadbeat and doesn't repay anything, your net income on the $200 for the year is $40 and 1/12 or 8.3% of your loans aren't being repaid. $40 is 20% of $200 giving you a net APR of 20%. I have to take the North Dakota numbers with a large grain of salt. It seems like if 25% of your lenders were defaulting and you were not re-lending to them, you are doing something else wrong. [1] http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/credit-card-delinquency-statistics-1276.php http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/credit-card-deli...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAt what interest rate would you be willing to lend your savings to the borrowers who require the sort of financing offered by payday lenders? Its easy to say what the interest rate and loss ratio should be when its other people's money. EDIT: Rereading your comment, I agree your math is sound (even with an assumption or two in there). The problem is we need a larger corpus of payday lender data. Anyone know where we can get that?
- cscurmudgeon 11y ago> Its easy to say what the interest rate and loss ratio should be when its other people's money. Isn't the issue that Google is making a statement about the same issue while taking the opposite stand.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI think the issue is that Google is making a statement about what they perceive to be predatory lenders while giving a newcomer a chance to execute their business differently. Which is totally within their right as a business. No different (my opinion, two cents) then Google banning bank ads but allowing credit unions. Its a bit more gray since LendUp is still a for-profit concern, but it appears they're making an effort to hold themselves to a higher standard.
- cscurmudgeon 11y ago> Which is totally within their right as a business. And it is within our rights as consumers to subject them to scrutiny and higher standards (Don't be evil) and for governments to subject to regulation.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoGo for it. Like yelling into the wind. They can pick and choose their ad customers, and no one is going to stop using Google over this. If anything, it provides additional goodwill to their business.
- WalterBright 11y agoIf a payday lender was making outsized profits on the loans, wouldn't that attract more lenders and competition would drive the rates down?
- ikeboy 11y agoOnly if the target market was price sensitive and invested time to find lower rates.
- swyman 11y agoThis point is missed so often. The same applies to lots of things that are urgent, immediate demands like urgent care, car repair, and even addiction.
- WalterBright 11y agoOne wonders how banning them from Google would help matters.
- ikeboy 11y agoThey're banned from advertising only.
- gtremper 11y agoConsidering their default rate is surely higher that 0.75% (1.5/200), how is that sustainable?
- sev 11y agoCouldn't a rate in between these 2 extremes work? Like a 70% APR?
- gtremper 11y agoThat's breaking even at a ~5.83% default rate, which is still unrealistically low. If they have a default rate of 20%, they'd need at least 240% APR to break even (assuming 1 month loans).
- Kinnard 11y agoThe default rate would be lower with a lower interest rate. #secondordereffects
- zo1 11y agoSomeone has more trouble paying off $228 instead of $200? Granted, it could be right at an invisible tipping point, but let's be honest.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> Someone has more trouble paying off $228 instead of $200? Yes? That's like a month's food for some folks.
- FireBeyond 11y ago$28 is a month's food?
- 11y ago
- cortesoft 11y agoIf they only charged $1.50, they would lose a ton of money due to all the defaults. The people who need these loans are high risk for default; there is no avoiding that fact. They have to charge a high enough rate to not lose money. My big problem with payday loan companies is that they do a very good job of hiding their true costs to their customers. If we completely ban high interest rate loans, however, the result would be no one would loan money to a high risk applicant. There are situations where a high interest loan is preferable to no loan at all.
- Lazare 11y ago> if LendUp would lend someone $200 for 30 days for a $1.50 (APR of 9%) they wouldn't be extortionate in their rates They also wouldn't be making money. Keep in mind: 1) APR rolls up all interest, charges, surcharges, fees, etc. (which is fine) 2) Small short duration loans have a significant amount of paperwork (and it just increases with new "know your customer" laws, money laundering rules, anti-terrorism rules, etc.), plus all the normal overheads of business: Staff, training, rent, buildings, insurance, whatever. A fair interest rate on a loan of the type being discussed is, sure, a few percent, maybe even under 10% (although, you know, my credit card has a higher rate than that, so let's not go overboard here). But a fair fee to process a loan app is going to be fairly high; $20-30 is honestly low if you're doing the application in person at a storefront. But if you lend someone $300 for two weeks at a 5% annual interest rate and a $25 fee, the APR isn't 5%, it's well over 200%. Nonprofits which have tried to venture into the payday lending space have found themselves forced to charge eye-watering APRs, not because they're trying not to "leave money on the table", but because you cannot usefully compare an APR between a 20 year mortgage and a two week payday loan, because the cost of processing an app for a $500k mortgage and a $50 payday loan is a lot less different than the face value would suggest. I see a lot of people are talking about defaults, but it's not the defaults (which aren't even that high), it's the fees when calculated on low value, short term loans. Edit: Not saying payday lenders are amazing (or even that they should be legal) just that a naive comparison of the APR of a payday loan to an auto loan conceals more than it reveals. Payday loans are a very expensive product which some very poor people really, really need. Wishing it was cheap doesn't make it less expensive; banning it doesn't make the need go away. There's not a lot of good answers.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIt seems like the solution might be to make the term of the loan longer. Paying $30 of interest on a $200 payday loan once shouldn't really break anybody, the problem is people are doing it every payday. What happens if you borrow $200 and pay it back at $20/month over the course of a year? Then next month you don't need another loan because you still have $180 left from the original loan, instead of having -$30 from having already paid it back with interest.
- lujim 11y agoWhat happens when every other person defaults on the 9% APR loan? The less sensational truth is that LendUp goes out of business in 6 months.