13 ms·
Going dark: online privacy and anonymity for normal people
- jrcii 11y agoI really object to the language of "dark" to describe privacy or anonymity, which are thereby painted with a sinister connotation.
- stephengillie 11y agoSimilar to /s/blacklist/blocklist, maybe we can replace this with "Going Transparent" to describe privacy or anonymity.
- Kristine1975 11y agoInspired by this comic: "Going other": http://www.robot-hugs.com/other-five/ http://www.robot-hugs.com/other-five/ P.S: Dark is cool ;-)
- etiam 11y ago"Going Clear"?
- pdkl95 11y agoA better term already exists: "blank" Computer Court 9: "Guilty. Take her down." Convicted Blank: "I know my rights. I won't be judged by a machine!" Dragul: "You don't have any rights. You're a Blank." Convicted Blank: "Blank is beautiful! Blank is beautiful! Blank is beautiful!" Max Headroom, Episode ABC.1.6 "Blanks"
- newman314 11y agoAlt
- astrobe_ 11y agoI suggest the german "Geist" which means spirit or ghost (as in Poltergeist). It sounds a bit like "Guest" and Ghostery uses this metaphor already. Plus, german is cool.
- huuu 11y agoDoesn't this create a risk of committing fraud and identity theft in some countries? I can understand it wouldn't be a crime to create a random email address but creating a fake house address and using this for payments sounds a little tricky.
- Jedd 11y agoIt doesn't create a risk of these activities. It may make it easier for people to commit fraud, though I suspect anyone considering that career choice is probably slightly ahead of the content of this article. As to identity theft - I can't see how this article would help or hinder anyone in that pursuit. I guess if you follow one of the practices described - unique ID attributes at your various throwaway / anonymity-desired sites you visit - you may make it slightly harder for someone to pinch your identity.
- pdkl95 11y agoWhat you call "fraud" I call "privacy". Anonymous transactions happen all the time with cash, and any new payment method needs an equivalent. In the modern era where it is no longer possible to gain privacy by being unobservable, a new definition of privacy is required. Dan Geer has a very good replacement definition; privacy is "the effective capacity to misrepresent yourself"[1]. If cash isn't possible, misrepresentation is the only option. [1] http://geer.tinho.net/geer.blackhat.6viii14.txt http://geer.tinho.net/geer.blackhat.6viii14.txt
- huuu 11y agoWhat you call privacy might be called fraud in some countries. That's what my question is about.
- tunap 11y agoI concur & I tread lightly in my guerilla tactics. My bank, my insurance company my Dept Of Motor Vehicles & the other "legit" govs that require my info get it(and I use offline services as exclusively as/while I am still able). For every other "reg required" service, discount card "brick & mortar" or any other entity that requires a unique account, they get all the mis-info I can feed them. In the end, they get their unique identity to track and disseminate, it's just a falsey. *Granted, it is an easily unravelled ball of lottery hotlines & public spaces addresses that could easily be traced back to the real "me", but I'm not really hiding, just preserving my right to be left alone from prying marketeers and... ahem.... data scientists.
- btrask 11y agoThis is just a list of more things for them to clamp down on. I'm thinking about going in the opposite direction, and broadcasting all of my personally identifying information (credit card, SSN, etc). Obviously I would have to set aside a large amount of time to deal with issuing fraud reports, and make sure that I wasn't risking anything that I can't afford to lose--but it does seem simpler in some ways. After all, if you don't have anything to hide, you're bulletproof, right?
- WA 11y agoThe problem: "Nothing to hide" depends on the context. Maybe you don't have anything to hide under the current laws, but what about laws in 20 years from now? Maybe times change and suddenly, you've got a lot to hide.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rkrzr 11y agoTLDR: Use a VPN + Incognito mode + fake email and info The VPN hides your IP. Incognito mode prevents your cookies from giving away your identity. And the fake info helps with things like sites being hacked and the data being dumped online.
- htns 11y agoAnd you really should try to use a reputable VPN, like the one they recommend in the article. Plenty of VPN services are in the business of injecting ads and malware, logging your traffic, stealing passwords and credit card numbers, etc.
- noja 11y agoIncognito mode is per session, not per tab or window.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sixhobbits 11y agoI'm surprised he doesn't mention NoScript, Privacy Badger, etc. "Normal people" should be more concerned about about the highly detailed profiles that companies are building based on browsing habits. "Normal people" read about data breaches and embarrassing leaks that force politicians to resign. "Normal people" know nothing about the behind the scenes tracking that goes on when you google medical symptoms[0] or visit pages which have Facebook like buttons as footers[1]. Yes, this article is targeted at people who don't understand the problem of using their .gov email address to sign up for dodgy sites, but think about whether you'd rather have your bank statement made public or a large, visualizable data set representing most of your browsing history. I would love to see more work done on privacy through noise/obfuscation, such as that started by Adnauseum[2] and TrackMeNot[3] - not necessarily publishing your credit card details online as suggest in another comment here, but in making random search queries and clicking on random ads when your device is idle. Most of us have sufficient processing power and bandwidth for the overhead not to be a problem. It's sad that it looks like both add-ons have failed to make a splash, and seem to have fallen out of active development (end of 2015 marks the last commits for both projects, which is too soon to pronounce them dead, but they definitely don't seem to be hives of activity). [0] http://motherboard.vice.com/read/looking-up-symptoms-online-these-companies-are-collecting-your-data http://motherboard.vice.com/read/looking-up-symptoms-online-... [1] http://www.allaboutcookies.org/cookies/cookie-profiling.html http://www.allaboutcookies.org/cookies/cookie-profiling.html [2] http://adnauseam.io/ http://adnauseam.io/ [3] http://cs.nyu.edu/trackmenot/ http://cs.nyu.edu/trackmenot/
- geocar 11y ago> think about whether you'd rather have your bank statement made public or a large, visualizable data set representing most of your browsing history. If someone got access to my banking details, they could do far more damage than just make my bank statements public. Now I've dealt with identity theft and credit card fraud, and I work in digital marketing, so I know which one I'd choose: Nobody is going to visualise my individual browsing history, and even if they did (for what reason I can't imagine), I can't imagine what they'd do with it! I can imagine someone might try to build a demographic profile about me to sell me stuff that I'd like, but that's good because it would be stuff that I would like.
- frontendthing 11y agoVery important also: avoid webmasters that put lots of trackers on their websites - for a few bucks they are selling your identity and make you trackable, these guys have no morality and are thiefs. Some of them even go so far to fabricate postings about how to use the web "anon" and still put lots of trackers on their website to make you identifiable! Also some of these webmasters allow discussion only via a centralized service that again wants to identify you - also that centralized service is great to track your activity. Even more: these centralized discussion services will censor your comment when you are using any kind of vpn or tor or a mailinator address - you can identify collaborateurs of the privacy-destroying industry very easy by this alone. All these webmasters and centralized services are the real scum of the web and must be avoided.
- apecat 11y agoGreat article. The only real omission I noticed is the lack of mention of advanced browser fingerprinting techniques that can be used against browsers, even if caches are emptied, 'porn modes' activated, VPNs opnened. As demonstrated here by the EFF's Panopticlick initiative. https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/ One of the most important points about the anonymity provied by the Tor project to remember is that the Tor Browser is painstakingly hand crafted to avoid many of these problems. In other discussions about TOR it is worryingly common to see other ways to route browser traffic through TOR, without mentions of the implications. For those interested, here's a recent look into the Tor Browser system by one of the developers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rq5Qbj2Aouo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rq5Qbj2Aouo
- tiatia 11y agoWhat do you mean with "VPNs opnened"? The article is wrong about Tor being an alternative option to a VPN. If anonymity is your concern, you should use TOR to connect to a VPN (paid with Bitcoins).
- auganov 11y agoWith a properly setup TORbrowser it will use a different tor circuit for every host. Using a [single] VPN "centralizes" your exit connections. For HTTPS enabled sites TOR is perhaps a better choice, just have to be careful of sslstrip.
- tiatia 11y agoI even vaguely remember that in one of Snowdens released documents, the NSA wrote in a powerpoint presentation that this setup causes head aches. Will try to find it again.
- MichaelGG 11y agoIt's important to note which things are theoretically hard vs lack of tooling. Using a VPN after Tor might defeat a bad exit node sniffing or changing content. But a VPN absolutely hurts anonymity. Plus there's no way to be sure the VPN op isn't keeping logs. If I were at the NSA and concerned about any of this, I'd start a few VPN companies. And run Bitcoin exchangers/vendors.
- amelius 11y ago> Going dark: online privacy and anonymity for normal people Caveat: normal people don't care about such things.
- belorn 11y agoI have found that normal people are those that care most about it, once they experience that the social contract that governs private space has being violated. How many people become victims to identity theft per year? How many people end up in a bad breakup where their ex uses private information in some action of revenge? How many people get falsely accused each year by the police? Ask them if they care about privacy and anonymity, or as it is more commonly phrased, personal security.
- developer2 11y agoThe term "normal person" is referring to your average person, and the average person has not been through such an experience. Also, the whole "once it happens to someone, they care" applies to pretty much anything. Find someone who invests a lot of their time speaking in public for any cause you can imagine. Someone who talks to audiences about the perils of alcohol, drugs, any cancer or disease - basically anything that is harmful/dangerous/deadly. How many of them do you think ever gave a second thought to their cause, before it affected their lives personally (themselves, a family member, or close friend)? Practically none of them. People generally don't care about the consequences of anything until they've been slapped in the face by it.
- DarkContinent 11y agoPrivacy is for everyone, not just the privileged few.
- nobodyshere 11y agoIt isn't about privilege. It is more about whether privacy is something that you are worried about or not. Most people don't care about it and don't even think about protecting it.
- xrorre 11y agoI appreciate the intention of this article. Written for people only starting to change their surfing habits in light of Snowden. But the example of the tools they should use are not thought out very well. First: Freedome by F-Secure is closed source and there is no OpenVPN alternative. Always choose a VPN that has OpenVPN so that users can configure the connection to their needs. No need for this bloated mess. Second: Whilst disposable Google accounts might seem like a good idea, there are any number of ways for Google to cross-correlate a disposable identity with your actual identity using fingerprinting captchas or even your screen resolution. Google does this to spot serial re-registrations and to stop people gaming Google Plus voting rings and spammers in general. Third: Be careful of online websites offering fake-name services. Most of this data is generated server-side and logged for the purposes of cross-correlation with your IP address and useragent string. Quite possibly the vast majority of fake-identity sites are run by LEA - I like to write some quick and dirty ruby gems to generate fake identities because then it can't be correlated. (The names are pulled in from disparate sources and I always ensure true-randomness). - In terms of email, use things like Riseup which use TLS at every hop so that passive dragnets cant sniff the password. 99% of all IMAP and SMTP services can be passively sniffed because they use weak STARTTLS. - Use 'honeywords' in an email to correlate different emails with different activities. For example: john.doe+shopping@riseup.net john.doe+gaming@riseup.net john.doe+correspondant@riseup.net This way you can whitelist those addresses for the purposes of filtering out spam and phishing attempts.
- craigds 11y agoI don't see the point of using honeywords. I mean, I've used them a bit, but any spammer is going to strip them immediately, so they're useless for identifying which provider leaked your address, right? And now to login, you need to remember the honeyword you used to register, which is a big inconvenience for anyone not using a password manager. (Use a password manager!)
- Jtsummers 11y agoIf you primarily use honeywords, then you can filter out anything going to craigds@host.tld as spam. The hard part would be transitioning people you want to communicate with to craigds+{family,friends,correspondence}@host.tld. Optionally, retain craigds@host.tld for personal and professional communication/correspondence, and move everything else to craigds1+{something}@host.tld (or a different host).
- ikeboy 11y agoThe SMS receiving sites don't work so well IME. They tend to use a single number for everyone, and the demand by spammers etc is so much higher than the free supply that for any given service, your number will probably already be blocked. Or the receiving will be unreliable, etc. I've gotten it to work sometimes, but usually not. Definitely too hard and time consuming for "normal people". Is there a site that sells phone numbers for viop and sms for bitcoin without requiring identity?
- slvrspoon 11y agoIdentity is required by us (and by most "foundational" financial and phone providers) but for external use with other 3rd parties, not at all. www.abine.com
- maglavaitss 11y agoThis submission has some more tips for preserving your privacy https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11706680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11706680
- coldpie 11y agoIs this really still the best way to pay for stuff anonymously online? Lie to a financial institution? I understand the desire to avoid fraud, but boy does that irk me. Hrmm...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kevingrahl 11y agoSkimmed the article, saw that he reccomended using Googlemail. Looked at the title of the post again. Looked at Googlemail reccomendation. Laughed and made a mental note not to trust "Troy Hunt".
- Intermernet 11y agoMaybe try reading the article instead of skimming. He mentions options to Gmail if you don't want to deal with them. Pro tip: don't comment if you've just "skimmed the article".
- jontas 11y agoWhat is wrong with using gmail if you are following all the other safeguards he suggests (VPN, false identity, etc.)?
- reality_czech 11y agoHi, I'm Troy McLure. You may remember me from such articles as "Beans: The Forgotten Fruit" and "Making your Millions on Mt. Gox".
- mirimir 11y agoIt's a good piece, but the treatment of VPNs is bad. There's a new site about choosing a VPN service: https://thatoneprivacysite.net/ https://thatoneprivacysite.net/ It summarizes a huge amount of information, for 159 VPN services.
- fulafel 11y agoThe article exemplifies why the widespread misappropriation of of the VPN term is unfortunate (in same series as "router" for NAT boxes...), it serves to confuse people about the potential of real overlay networks.
- mirimir 11y agoPlease say more about "the potential of real overlay networks".
- fulafel 11y agoWell, tunneling your web traffic to some random "VPN" provider and having all traffic flow out in the open to the internet is just defending against your last mile ISP basically. A real encrypted overlay would be a fully connected mesh between all the nodes of the network. Like IPSec was originally meant to work (transport mode, anyone being able to set up a security association to any other IP address with common PKI)
- mirimir 11y agoThanks. > Well, tunneling your web traffic to some random "VPN" provider and having all traffic flow out in the open to the internet is just defending against your last mile ISP basically. People use VPN services because they can't trust their ISPs. ISPs log traffic, shape traffic, share data with adversaries, etc, etc. People instead choose to trust VPN providers. Typically, there are few ISPs to choose from. But there are numerous VPN services. > A real encrypted overlay would be a fully connected mesh between all the nodes of the network. Well, there are https://peervpn.net/ https://peervpn.net/ and https://www.onioncat.org/ https://www.onioncat.org/ (which connects through Tor). From years ago, I recall one from some Russian with a friend in Antarctica. But not even the name :(
- fulafel 11y agoAlso http://hack.org/mc/projects/btns/ http://hack.org/mc/projects/btns/
- astazangasta 11y agoI'm interested in 'phishing and malware protection', which I think means all my traffic gets reported to Google. This plus Google Analytics means the electric eye is on me wherever I go. Tips to browse safely without these?
- tmaly 11y agoAs I am cranking away on some Go services on my laptop on my local coffee shop wifi, I see log entries popup of people trying to access php pages. I go and ask the staff, and they said their POS is full of some weird software. a good VPN provider is worth it, but finding one that will not keep logs on you is another story.
- ChefDenominator 11y agoThe article recommends going to Fake Name Generator (tm) to get a random online identity. The page is not encrypted and looks very, very fishy. That page recommends going to Social Security Number Registry. Again, an unencrypted totally scammy looking page. If you enter a random name and select a random state, it will 'verify' that your identity has been stolen. Then, if you click on 'Validate', you can enter your SSN (unencrypted, of course). I don't even know how to code, and this is a news site for hackers? This tripe makes it to the top of the front page?
- huehehue 11y agoFWIW, there is a "secure" version of the fake name generator, but you have to pay $1.99/year and sign in with Google, which is hilarious.[1] Also, as explained by the creator[2], the SSN registry site is worthless and apparently a joke (although I'm not going to poke around on the site to verify). [1] https://www.fakenamegenerator.com/premium.php https://www.fakenamegenerator.com/premium.php [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2014/02/03/the-mormon-who-creates-billions-of-fake-identities-every-month/#772f8a467582 http://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2014/02/03/the-mormon...
- ChefDenominator 11y agoThat really just makes everything worse, because this site, HN, presents the blog post as if it is a legitimate guide. The Fake Name Generator(tm) page states: "You should click here to find out if your SSN is online." Making no mention that the site is intended to be a joke. Apparently, HN is a joke. (Note that the only way to view the Forbes article you linked is through the cached version.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bunkydoo 11y agoHere's the thing, if you are a normal person - you aren't going to read a guide on something like this. I have a 1 sentence guide on this for the 'normal person' - If you wouldn't want your grandma to see it, just don't enter it in an internet browser.
- mirimir 11y agoSadly enough, I tend to agree with you. I will note, however, that you display some naiveté about grandmothers ;)
- descript 11y agoIt is so difficult to balance productivity/convenience and privacy/security. Only recently did I stop worrying about privacy/security, and frankly my online experience is much better. I can now participate in any services/apps that catch my eye, I now save CC data at some sites, don't have a VPN/Tor slowing traffic and giving me cloudflare walls/"im not a bot" verification, don't have noscript/ublock/privacy badger breaking most sites, can sync across devices and backup online. Having both secure & private online behavior is a massive inconvenience. You basically can't participate in the online world as it exists. (There are definitely opportunities to create secure/private versions of existing tools)