5 ms·
An aside: doctors shouldn't be discussing people's test results, even if they anonymize and/or aggregate the patient data, without previously receiving consent,
by dekhn 11y ago
An aside: doctors shouldn't be discussing people's test results, even if they anonymize and/or aggregate the patient data, without previously receiving consent, and even then I don't think it's really wise to provide quotes like this to reporters.
- pvnick 11y agoActually, sufficiently aggregated health data is generally fine to release publicly since it can not be tied to an individual. Anonymized data you must be very careful with, since individual data elements can frequently be combined to re-identify someone.
- sopooneo 11y agoIn support of your point about "sufficently aggregated" data, I occasionally work on projects that publish aggregate health statistics, and you have to be very careful about the size of your denominators. For instance, even without telling what numbers you are dividing, you probably couldn't publish the percentage of HIV positive results among pacific islanders in Nebraska. Because there might be only six such people.
- pvnick 11y agoGood point!
- facetube 11y agoIIRC this is why HHS and HIPAA regulations specify "all ages over 89" as protected health information for purposes of data deidentification – there just aren't that many people who have lived that long.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIt also specifies all date elements for patient-specific events (including treatment) more specific than the year must be removed for deidentification generally.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- robryk 11y agoSo "I treated a skier with a broken leg in the last skiing season" is something a doctor can't say? (Skiing season is shorter than a year.) Actually, giving a year of a winter/summer sport-related accident already provides a shorter window for when the accident has occurred. So should all case reports about such be giving at least a two year long window?
- sib 11y agoOddly enough, it turns out to be 836(!), which is definitely higher than I would have guessed. http://www.infoplease.com/us/census/data/nebraska/demographic.html http://www.infoplease.com/us/census/data/nebraska/demographi...
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThose are presumably not all HIV positive.
- sokoloff 11y agoYes, but what personal or privacy-compromising information does "6 of this list of 836 people have HIV" convey? That that population has a higher-than-normal incidence of HIV as compared the US at large? That's potentially valuable aggregate health information, but I don't see how that compromises anyone's privacy. It would if you reported "6 of 836 were HIV+ on Tuesday. The next day, a new couple moved into town. On Wednesday, 7 of 838 were HIV+." I don't think the aggregated data that is contemplated here is released on nearly that frequency.
- dekhn 11y agoAll of the responses to my comment are missing the point: you're discussing medical researchers. This was a random doctor in the affected area who spoke to reporters. I'm quite aware of what is acceptable to release in a medical context; this was not that.
- pvnick 11y agoI'm not sure what the problem is though. In all likelihood the doctor has been trained on HIPAA procedures.
- dragonwriter 11y agoAnd yet seems to have violated them (I've cited the specific section of regs elsewhere in the thread). But deidentification is one of those things people who don't freak with it often, even trained in the rules, always seem to think is easier than it is.
- dekhn 11y agoI never said the doctor violated a law. I think what the doctor said (in speaking about a specific patient): "The doctor said one corrected report is for a patient she sent to the emergency room after receiving abnormally elevated test results from Theranos in late 2014." was ethically dubious. Most of the people who are replying negatively to my comments are misinterpreting my position: either suggesting that I implied there was a HIPAA violation, or that I think medical research data should be suppressed. Neither of those is true.
- CamperBob2 11y agoI'm quite aware of what is acceptable to release in a medical context; this was not that. I'm sure you'll be able to cite the regulation that was broken, then.
- jonlucc 11y agoThere are well-considered standards for patient anonymity. Saying "I had a patient with X disease" is not compromising the identity of the patient. Without that, doctors couldn't teach medicine to med students or explain their cases at conferences.
- SilasX 11y agoFair enough, but I'm not sure that will be good enough for much longer. With bigger and better datasets it should be increasingly easy to de-anonymize someone based on just knowing something like that.
- rhizome 11y agoSomething like what, that a specific doctor has treated someone with a specific condition? I'm not sure that's enough metadata.
- Dr_tldr 11y agoI can confirm that's not and could never be a HIPAA violation. The information that Doctor X once ordered a blood test for John or Jane Doe with Result Z is totally fine. There's no non-HIPAA violating metadata that could make that information useful.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- iofj 11y agoThere are papers about de-anonimizing patient records and they show that for instance, patient records + facebook is definitely enough to fill in the names correctly.
- jonathankoren 11y agoYou do realize that with your standard of never-say-anything you're calling pretty much 200 years of medical study on violation.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoThat's not quite how HIPPA works. I don't see anything wrong with the amount of information given here. How else could they talk about stuff like this, anyway? It's important to get out there for people to be aware of.
- kosmic_k 11y agoAs long as HIPAA rules are followed I don't see an issue. Further more I would argue that the doctors in this case have a moral imperative to inform the public just how harmful these faulty test results have been. It is becoming clear that Theranos has harmed patients and public knowledge of this is crucial to discover more cases and inform those whom may have had medical decisions made on faulty testing.
- dragonwriter 11y agoUnless specifically cleared by a deidentification expert as provided in 45 CFR 164.514(b)(1), this doesn't meet the requirements of HIPAA for deidentification of information derived from PHI, since it does not remove "All elements of dates (except year) for dates directly related to an individual, including birth date, admission date, discharge date, date of death" [0], in that it includes the specific month of the test. [0] 45 CFR 164.514(b)(2)(i)(C)
- aub3bhat 11y agoNo your interpretation is wrong. Date does not means month. Date contains Day/Month/Year. Here are 2.5 Million raw inpatient visits released by New York State meeting criteria for HIPAA Limited data, as you can see not only do they contain month and year but also day of the week. [1,2] [1] http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/institutional_review_board/hipaa_research/limited_data_set.html http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/institutional_review_board/hi... [2] https://health.data.ny.gov/Health/Hospital-Inpatient-Discharges-SPARCS-De-Identified/u4ud-w55t https://health.data.ny.gov/Health/Hospital-Inpatient-Dischar...
- ramchip 11y agoI might be missing the obvious, but I don't see any months in the de-identified dataset you linked? Your second link also says a limited dataset is considered PHI and can only be shared with third party under certain conditions and with a data use agreement.
- dragonwriter 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ldehaan 11y agothat's the kind of thinking that is the reason we have such bad medicine. medicine and all its research needs to be open, people have no privacy anywhere else, and to keep insisting on it for medical data is only allowing governments and huge corporations to take advantage of our lack of knowledge about drug affects etc.. the major reason there is even a debate about vaccines is because of this weird belief that we need to keep medical records siloed from researchers and the public when this information is probably of the highest value to us as a society. but instead we just post everything else about ourselves on the Internet and those things can actually be used to hurt or segregate us from knowledge that will help us overall. one of those weird things I've never understood about society's ability to be completely distracted from its own self interest.
- zodiac 11y agoAre you suggesting all health records should be available to the public?
- intopieces 11y agoYes, they should. And they should make it easier to do so. Privacy in medicine is holding us back.