9 ms·
I worked on Facebook's Trending team
- smt88 11y ago> "Working at Facebook, even as a contractor, was supposed to be the opportunity of a lifetime." Does anyone really say that working at a tech giant as a non-engineer is an opportunity of a lifetime? I have had multiple friends who worked at Google on AdSense sales, and it certainly didn't do anything for their careers. I can't imagine it did much for their savings, either.
- emodendroket 11y agoGetting paid $60k a year probably sounds fantastic if you are a journalist working freelance and grinding out a bunch of free "exposure" on sites that refuse to pay for content.
- lucasmullens 11y agoGoogle is a powerful name, no matter what you did there. It got Google on your friends' resumes, so certainly that has some impact to some recruiters.
- parennoob 11y agoIt certainly seems so to those of us who work in tech, but is that true for "real" newspapers? I'd imagine (and perhaps even hope) that when interviewing for a newspaper job at, say, the New York Times, "Reporter for [unknown local newspaper]" would carry more weight than "Curator of social media at [third party] contracting for Facebook".
- toyg 11y agoA "newspaper job", how quaint! Most editorial jobs nowadays want exactly "social media curator at <Big Internet Co>", because that's where the market is going.
- shostack 11y agoPerhaps if they are switching fields to one where people aren't knowledgeable about the actual role. To those of us who have encountered the people in the example, the AdSense sales reps, on an ongoing basis...yeah, I'm not sure that would win them any bonus points.
- home_boi 11y agoIs it really? I'm thinking about the reverse case with a Software Engineer at a bulge bracket bank, which isn't seen as a resume boost at all.
- clappski 11y agoI think it depends what you do there. If you're a quant developer, or actually working in the investment bank (rather than retail) it's a really good thing to have on your CV. Especially if you actually want to work in fintech.
- ucaetano 11y agoYes, in the worst case it will help your resume be picked up from a very large pile of nearly identical profiles. Unlike SWE, journalism (and many other careers) isn't really a career where recruiters just jump at you from the bushes if you're distracted. A lot of people actually go on unpaid internships to try and get a job.
- molecule 11y ago> > "Working at Facebook, even as a contractor, was supposed to be the opportunity of a lifetime." > Does anyone really say that working at a tech giant as a non-engineer is an opportunity of a lifetime? The author is a journalist, practicing in a field which has been decimated, writing about working @ the most popular platform on the planet.
- balls187 11y ago> working @ the most popular platform on the planet. Working as a contractor.
- emodendroket 11y agoThe "even as a contractor" there suggests awareness of that.
- youssifa 11y agoIt really depends on the perspective you bring and what you're comparing it to. If the equivalent alternative to working at Google on AdSense sales is working as a consultant at McKinsey or at Goldman Sachs as an investment banker, then no it may not necessarily be the "opportunity of a lifetime". To someone in the Silicon Valley bubble comparing a PMM role at Google to a PMM role at Uber or Airbnb, it may be difficult to see the real value of Google on a resume. However, to most people in the world those roles are all opportunities of a lifetime. If you look at my peers in every job I've held since working at Google and treated Google as a neutral company (i.e. not having any real career boosting value), I would have been by far the least qualified individual in many of those roles. Having Google on my resume landed me interviews and job offers I would not otherwise have gotten. It also suggests a credibility to employers in the non-engineering world because many believe that an employee at Google must be super intelligent and highly competent. Believe it or not, I'd venture to say that this is more so true outside of Silicon Valley (where Google isn't as common of a former employee among job applicants) than inside. But I think it boosts your career prospects either way. The key, like most things in life, is how the individual chooses to leverage the name recognition on their resume and supplement that experience with other experiences.
- uola 11y agoThe tech industry is full of stories of meritocratic success, sophisticated technology and abundance of wealth. For the average person working at, or with, one of the big tech companies is going to sound like a good idea. Maybe not the opportunity of a lifetime, but few people can afford to search for those, just a decent job in an industry on the rise. They can't really know that the janitor isn't getting rich anymore, heck he probably can't even afford to live anywhere near the offices.
- codemac 11y agoIt's not the opportunity of a lifetime, but it will feel like it to them. There are no journalism/writing jobs that have the kinds of perks that big tech firms have. Free lunch every day?!
- ljk 11y ago> Working at Facebook, even as a contractor, was supposed to be the opportunity of a lifetime. Sentiment like that probably played a part at such toxic environment at places like these..
- Smaointe 11y agoThe Trending Team seem to be treated as if they are a tool of the engineers. A very good piece of software that the engineering can make use of and integrate into their systems. They mustn't forget that they are actually people!
- multinglets 11y agoWhen people at large start to notice that a given publication or platform -- reddit for instance -- has been compromised by certain left-wing ideologies, you will inevitably see a narrative about its behind-the-scenes/"subtle" sexism/discrimination in very short order. It's becoming a very predictable trick. I can't imagine I'm the only one who sees this.
- hnamazon123 11y agoThis is very interesting. Can you expand on what you mean?
- to3m 11y ago"Certain left-wing ideologies"? Which ones?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoReddit appears to have been taken over by Trump supporters for a while now.
- venomsnake 11y agoThe_Donald has 130000 subs ... that is peanuts. It is on par with fatlogic.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoCan't say I've seen it. Donald routinely has spam-like levels of highest ranking post. To me it appears to be the most active sub by far.
- powertower 11y ago> There is no political bias that I know of and we were never told to suppress conservative news. There is an extraordinary amount of talent on the team... I don't use Facebook, but over the last several years I kept hearing from a number of non-PC type news outlets (that I subscribe to) that even as their media platform grew and doubled and tripled, at the same time their Facebook engagement became a small fraction of what it used to be. I've also heard that one of the quickest ways to get your Facebook account terminated in Germany is to say anything negative about the current migration situation that becomes popular or starts to get views. This article IMO is a way to hide the real story with another story.
- mulmen 11y agoDo you have any evidence of this beyond what you have heard? I believe the down votes are a result of your lack of evidence. I'm not defending Facebook but I have yet to see any substance to the argument that they are manipulating the conversation on their platform.
- powertower 11y agoOnly anecdotal. And you can see some of it if you google 'facebook censorship'. But here is one about Germany - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/26/mark-zuckerberg-hate-speech-germany-facebook-refugee-crisis https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/26/mark-zuck... Though to understand what it is really talking about, you have to understand the redefinition of "hate speech" that has happened through-out the EU.
- mulmen 11y agoCan you elaborate on the redefinition of "hate-speech"? How was it previously defined and how has that definition changed? Who changed it? As an American this is especially interesting to me because we place such value on our freedom of speech but also pay a high price in the hate speech that is viewed as a necessary evil. It seems that the EU has made an attempt to manage this hateful speech but I'm not familiar with the specifics.
- pervycreeper 11y agoUnfortunately, the article provides no insight about the recent allegations regarding political bias in "trending" topics.
- lucasmullens 11y ago"Most, if not all, of what you’ve read about Facebook’s Trending team in Gizmodo over the past few weeks has been mischaracterized or taken out of context. There is no political bias that I know of and we were never told to suppress conservative news." That sounds like an insight to me.
- ecdavis 11y agoI disagree. The article states: > There is no political bias that I know of and we were never told to suppress conservative news. But then later goes on to say: > “Facebook relies heavily on just 10 news sources to determine whether a trending news story has editorial authority.” The problem is, even after repeated questions and requests for guidance, no one ever explained what that meant. Much of it was left to interpretation for curators and copy editors. Topics are treated differently depending on who you are working with. Which leads to a fairly obvious observation: providing insufficient editorial guidelines leaves room for unconscious bias to take over. Of course, qualified journalists should be aware of their own biases and be able to compensate for them. Unfortunately, journalism in the US is becoming increasingly less valued and more partisan. I wouldn't be surprised if this whole bias fiasco was an unexpected side-effect of Facebook hiring largely left-leaning editorial staff.
- jyrkesh 11y ago> I wouldn't be surprised if this whole bias fiasco was an unexpected side-effect of Facebook hiring largely left-leaning editorial staff. I always assumed that this was exactly what's going on. You don't need a handbook that says "stifle conversative stuff", you just need vague rules, managers playing the world's worst game of corporate telephone, and a bunch of disorganization. Life at large companies...
- 11y ago
- amaks 11y agoThe most disturbing to me is not even favoritism and sexism conditions at work (which is ironic given Sheryl Sandberg's book and official line), but the fact that Facebook: 1. uses humans to pick the trending topics, which are inherently biased in one way or another; 2. the trending sources are very limited and curated (e.g. no Twitter), which is clearly anti-competitive practices.
- ryanSrich 11y agoIndeed. Facebook is one of those incredibly evil companies that has duped the public into giving them all of their data. There's no going back either.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoWhat obligations does Facebook have to include Twitter sources, or to ensure trending topics are unbiased?
- balls187 11y agoUser Trust. Also this isn't just about censoring Twitter as a source, but rather twitter as a topic in an trending topic. Tangentially related: should facebook hide posts made by Twitter employees?
- Animats 11y agoWikipedia doesn't consider Twitter a reliable source. Why should Facebook?
- ucaetano 11y agoFacebook uses Facebook as a source, which is as reliable as Twitter.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoPerhaps that obviates the need to include Twitter
- JacobJans 11y agoThis was eerily similar to The Circle, by Dave Eggers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_%28Eggers_novel%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circle_%28Eggers_novel%29
- dmix 11y agoThe majority of this sounds like low grade managerial issues. Not much here sounds like a big deal IMO. The type of stuff you hear people complain about often when they work at big corporate machines. Even more so when they're stuck in non-core business units, staffed with contractors. I have a feeling the curators were seen as a necessary evil until the machines were good enough to replace them. So they were treated as such and their work wasn't well planned/prioritized from the top. The lack of direct guidelines and hand-holding from management indicates that there wasn't much interest in establishing long-term processes. Which high-turnover contractor worker bees usually require, compared to leaving them alone where they are required to make their own decisions (with potential consequences).
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, maybe so, but it's hardly surprising that people feel a little resentful about this when they're working at one of the world's premiere workplaces and can see people right in front of them doing much better.
- ludamad 11y agoI'm not seeing when they'll be able to remove humans entirely if they want quality blurbs about news attached
- mrits 11y agoI have tons of friends at Facebook and have gone to the Holiday parties for the last 7 years. I have heard a few similar stories, but the vast majority seem to love it. I think if someone is willing to publicly shame a company so big because of their bad experience, it really shows their lack of intelligence. Certainly experiences vary and if it was really a toxic environment for women, why do so any women love it?
- fieryeagle 11y agoContractors are second-class citizens at best, at any places so what was she expecting exactly? I don't mean to deride the writer but I'm honestly not sure if the janitors would think that working at FB is the opportunity of a lifetime, and I place more values at keeping places clean and tidy than curating news with an obvious bias (hint - I don't read them). There is nothing world-changing about picking out articles as a stepping stone for being replaced by algorithms. If you can't speak up, it means you are weak, the environment is toxic or both. So do something about it, or walk away like what the men do.
- k__ 11y agoDepends in what you do for the company. If they just need you to get more work done, you may be right. But if you got a skill no one else at the company has, they are rather nice to you.
- fieryeagle 11y agoWhen you have the unique skill, you're better off being labelled as 'consultant'. The terms might be used interchangeably yet I've seen the power dynamics being consultant > full-timer > part-timer > contractor.
- bluegate010 11y agoOff-topic, but The Guardian's article landing page really needs to be cleaned up: http://i.imgur.com/3LGXU7g.png http://i.imgur.com/3LGXU7g.png I can't make heads or tails of what I'm supposed to pay attention to.
- mrweasel 11y agoSadly that seems to be a trend. Sites started to assume that your screen is taller than it is wide a while back. It might be a combination of designers and writers working on large monitors, having multiple tall narrow windows open, and people using iPads in portrait mode. Users of 11" and 13" laptops seems to have been forgotten in this new design trend.
- airtonix 11y agoOh cool. Is that why reports on Muslisms Raping in Europe were so freely published, and not deleted heavily from default subreddits? /sarcasm
- jsprogrammer 11y agoNot sure. It's impossible to know all of the site drama, but I only casually browse and still I have seen quite a few posts at the top of reddit appearing from the_donald that cover those or similar stories.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoYou've posted several inflammatory political comments here recently. Please stop doing that. It's not what this site is for. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11727133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11727133 and marked it off-topic.
- billhendricksjr 11y agoThe broader conversation is very interesting on a number of levels, but I have a specific question for this audience... do you actually pay attention to the trending topics on Facebook? They're not prominently displayed and if FB really wanted to influence the conversation on X, they could be doing so much more IMO. I feel like they're still trying to test their way into this experience.
- emodendroket 11y agoOnce in a while.
- exodust 11y ago> "I still carry the fear of speaking up with me. I find myself holding back when I see a problem or afraid to speak up when I have an idea." This sounds a bit drama-queeny. She manages to seamlessly blend workplace sexism with product failures and other complaints all in a few sentences. To me that sounds like a broad swipe at her employer, the details and truth of which are far from conclusive based on her words alone. It's not an easy topic to sum up neatly, but sexist allegations often have an unjustified momentum. Joining dots and drawing conclusions about co-worker and manager intent, when often the explanation is quite different. For example, the first time someone complains about a discrepancy, it may be ignored not because the complainer was a woman, but that it was the first complaint. When others start to complain about the same thing, action is more likely to happen. A woman seeking evidence of sexism in the workplace will ignore the sensible explanation, and hurry to point the finger: "you ignored my complaint because I'm a woman". Cognitive bias in the workplace is unfortunately the more likely story, less interesting as it may be. I enjoy a good "what did FB do wrong now" article, but I can't swallow this one.
- xufi 11y agoFB in my view can pretty much dictate what it wants news wise which doesn't affect me because I don't get my news from once source but I wonder whom the people that sort of the stories are after they are spit out by the algorithm ?
- rdlecler1 11y agoReading her comments it made me wonder if women might be disposed to scar more easily (or men are more defiant) from this kind of treatment, creating a negative feedback loop in subsequent jobs and roles which negatively affects their careers. This is not intended to be a criticism of women, but rather it's question which may have important implications. Men may externalize this kind of sandbagging and stonewalling while women may tend to internalize it. If so it may be a much bigger deal than it may appear to a man because we're damaging our talent pool.
- timmytokyo 11y agoThat's a whole lot of hypothetical generalizing about women and men, based on absolutely no evidence. Try swapping "men" for "women" (and vice versa) in your comment to see how obnoxious it sounds.
- sbmassey 11y agoIt doesn't seem particularly obnoxious either way, as far as I can tell. Do people really have to be scolded for hypothesizing about correlations between sex and other characteristics?
- oneloop 11y agoWhat kind of argument is this? You seem to believe that if the reverse hypothesis "sounds obnoxious" then the direct hypothesis must surely be false. The fact is that if what the parent is saying happens to be true, then the reverse is bond to sound obnoxious.
- thenomad 11y agoLet's see: "Reading his comments it made me wonder if men might be disposed to scar more easily (or women are more defiant) from this kind of treatment, creating a negative feedback loop in subsequent jobs and roles which negatively affects their careers. This is not intended to be a criticism of men, but rather it's question which may have important implications. Women may externalize this kind of sandbagging and stonewalling while men may tend to internalize it. If so it may be a much bigger deal than it may appear to a woman because we're damaging our talent pool." Could have maybe used a couple more "tend to" statements, but doesn't seem horribly unreasonable to me. (And looks, in many ways, equally valid as a hypothesis. Not in all elements, but there is a culture of the "strong man" who simply internalises stress and conflict in a lot of places.)
- kukx 11y ago>"Every day, I sifted through hundreds of topics (or “keywords”) that Facebook told me were trending on the platform. Then I’d choose a story about the keyword(...)" >“Facebook relies heavily on just 10 news sources to determine whether a trending news story has editorial authority.” >"Several times curators were penalized for using Twitter in descriptions." It seems that Facebook is likely to manipulate the news by selecting the "right" sources. If there's bias it most likely come from the selection, I wonder what are the source titles. Also, penalizing for mentioning Twitter shows that they put their own intrest over their users. It is understandable to some degree from the economic point of view, but it also shows the danger of having one company dominating the market. Facebook is not that benign, even now.
- chris_wot 11y agoEven if you have the score and sources, I still think you'd need good guidelines. The problem is, nobody seems to know what these guidelines are in Facebook, and nobody outside of Facebook can review them!
- sidcool 11y ago>"A former contractor says that while the social media company did not impose political bias upon news ‘curators’, she and other employees were subject to poor management, intimidation and sexism that left them feeling voiceless" That's quite disturbing