2 ms·
I've thought this too - if the conditions for life existed at one point on the planet the chance they didn't exist at some other point seems infinitesimal. Down
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
I've thought this too - if the conditions for life existed at one point on the planet the chance they didn't exist at some other point seems infinitesimal. Down-thread someone argued that the subsequent genesis events would fail to produce new "roots" of the tree of living things. However, if the new roots fill a different niche (eg geographically), or quickly mutate to fill a different niche; or if the earlier roots evolved to higher forms that operate in a different niche then that objection doesn't seem so strong.
Weigh that idea against the possibility of life elsewhere: if life only started once on Earth where the conditions for life to be created were perfect then the chances of life occurring elsewhere, life that follows the same forms at least, is surely so close to zero that we shouldn't ever expect to find extra-terrestrial life similar to forms on Earth? [It's not a watertight argument, I can see 2 flaws right off, but it's an interesting suggestion as a corollary to the "single terrestrial genesis event" idea.]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]