4 ms·
Economics are the reason high end housing gets built. The fixed costs of development are similar regardless of affordability. Assuming uniform margins gross pro
by brudgers 11y ago
Economics are the reason high end housing gets built. The fixed costs of development are similar regardless of affordability. Assuming uniform margins gross profits are higher at the high end as are internal rates of return [due to constant fixed costs].
Going further, there's more money to be made on larger loans and hence incentives for any developer financing purchases. Easier to sell on mortgages backed by higher quality assets.
Affordable housing development is a specialty. It requires relationships with politicians willing to forgo maximizing the property tax base, specialized lenders, and a unique deal flow pipeline. E.g. think about the attractiveness of the 30 year affordability requirements in the legislation to the commercial market.
Anyway, the effects of legislative changes will be felt ten to twenty years out...many of the shovel ready projects funded by the stimulus are still under construction.
- jessriedel 11y ago> Affordable housing development is a specialty. I don't necessarily dispute this, but your putative arguments could be applied to lots of industries, and seem inconsistent with the wide range of quality / price points for most products.
- apsec112 11y agoIn California newspeak, "affordable" housing means government-subsidized housing, while "luxury" housing means any housing built for profit (even if it's tiny studio apartments).
- dragonwriter 11y ago> In California newspeak, "affordable" housing means government-subsidized housing, while "luxury" housing means any housing built for profit (even if it's tiny studio apartments). This is false. Direct subsidies are one of many means used in California to achieve targets for affordable housing, but affordable housing does not mean subsidized housing. That's particularly important in the context of this proposal, a key part of is proposing additional non-subsidy mechanisms to encourage affordable housing (by reducing the local-review barriers to new developments which include it, and reducing regulatory barriers to new units on existing lots.)
- apsec112 11y agoIME, that's how the word affordable is always used; do you know of any counterexamples? SPUR had to come up with a new term, "affordable by design", to distinguish housing that was built to minimize construction costs from housing that was government subsidized (http://www.spur.org/publications/spur-report/2007-11-20/affordable-design http://www.spur.org/publications/spur-report/2007-11-20/affo...). When bills like this talk about "affordable" housing in new developments, they don't just mean "the rent in this unit has to be kept below $X per month" (as in rent control). The "affordable" units are turned over to a government agency, such as the Mayor's Office of Housing in San Francisco (http://sfmohcd.org/ http://sfmohcd.org/), which administers them and decides who gets to live in them. For example, last year, the city of San Francisco decided that people who lived in the same neighborhood as a building would be first in line for that building's affordable units (http://www.sfexaminer.com/affordable-housing-lottery-being-tweaked-to-benefit-long-time-residents/ http://www.sfexaminer.com/affordable-housing-lottery-being-t...). The building owners' approval was not required, because the program is run by the city.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> IME, that's how the word affordable is always used; do you know of any counterexamples? Well, the most relevant counterexample here would be the California Health and Safety Code Sec. 50052.5 [0], which provides the cost-based definitions of "affordable housing" which apply to various income tiers (which are also those relevant to the present proposal from Gov. Brown.) (These definitions are often prerequisites to certain subsidies, but it is meeting the definition, not the subsidy, that makes it "affordable housing".) > The "affordable" units are turned over to a government agency Proposals (including the present one from Gov. Brown [1]) conditioned on a certain share of affordable housing usually require that the developer make a commitment that they will meet the applicable cost-based definition of "affordable" for a period of time, and that that commitment will be enforceable by a public agency (the present proposal requires that this be done by the developer recording a land-use restriction enforceable by the public agency.) This does not require that the property be turned over to (or even managed by) a public agency, though certainly there are affordable housing developments that have occurred where there was either direct ownership or management of the units by a public agency, nor does it require that the housing be subsidized in any way (though at the "lower income" tier, the population for whom they are targeted to be "affordable" to is also the population eligible for Section 8 housing subsidies, I believe.) [0] http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=hsc&group=50001-51000&file=50050-50106 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=hsc&gr... [1] http://www.dof.ca.gov/budgeting/trailer_bill_language/local_government/documents/707StreamliningAffordableHousingApprovals_000.pdf http://www.dof.ca.gov/budgeting/trailer_bill_language/local_...
- steveax 11y agoI assume you are excluding the government subsidy of the mortgage interest deduction for the "luxury" housing?
- brudgers 11y agoReal property is, in some meaningful ways, different from goods and chattels. It can be improved but not manufactured and of course cannot be relocated. It doesn't matter how much demand there is, some new real-estate entrepreneur isn't going to disrupt Palo Alto with $150,000 detached single family homes. In so far as real-estate is a product, differentiation between quality and price points is primarily a function of location...as Peter Thiel might put it [but probably doesn't], each lot is a monopoly. There is cheaper housing in Detroit and solely based on the opportunities afforded by location and not necessarily the nature of improvements one might deem it of lesser quality than a similar structure in San Francisco. Anyway, I've been involved in a bit of housing development over the years. The few developers I know who do affordable housing specialize in it [as the many upmarket developers do in the upmarket]. Developers who don't specialize in affordable housing typically don't do it. The market analysis and proper institutional investors are not orbiting the market rate housing and general commercial development herd...and most developers stick to their track record.
- jessriedel 11y agoYes, real property is different from goods and chattels in meaningful ways. But I don't think your initial arguments for a dearth of affordable property exploit on any of them.
- timr 11y agoThis is the correct answer. Labor and materials costs, nationwide, exceed $300 per square foot (and often much higher) for a high-rise project [1]. Once you factor in efficiency, land, insurance, financing, sales and marketing, and all of the other costs of a project, it's difficult to make a profit until costs start pushing the $1000/sq.ft. range. That's luxury housing. However broken SF's development process may be, it isn't the limiting factor to new development. SPUR estimates the regulatory costs for a San Francisco project at about 20% of the total costs [2], and most of that is the low-income housing set-aside (which is ~10-15%, varying by project). The majority of the costs of any new project are land, labor and materials. And San Francisco truly is an exception, in that it's one of the few cities in the world where there's no more undeveloped land. People love to make generalizations based on community meetings (which are always a circus, in any city) and the cost to do a bathroom renovation or alter a garage door, but to a large construction project, these kinds of bureaucratic costs are a fixed expense. Land, labor and materials drive everything. Edit: I'm stating facts here, and citing sources for those facts, directly from developers. I have no idea how you can downvote factual information. If you want to have a reasonable conversation about housing in SF, you have to take these basic economic questions into account. They matter. [1] https://westnorth.com/2014/03/18/between-rocks-and-a-tall-place-two-height-limits-hold-back-affordable-mid-rise-construction-in-dc/ https://westnorth.com/2014/03/18/between-rocks-and-a-tall-pl... [2] http://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2014-02-11/real-costs-building-housing http://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2014-02-11...
- apsec112 11y ago"it's difficult to make a profit until costs start pushing the $1000/sq.ft. range." The data shows, clear as daylight, that prices are only ever this high in cities which refuse to build any new housing: http://www.spur.org/sites/default/files/wysiwyg/asking.prices.png http://www.spur.org/sites/default/files/wysiwyg/asking.price... In Houston, which famously has no zoning, you can buy a condo in a downtown luxury high-rise for $200 per square foot (http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Houston-TX/condo_type/62594118_zpid/39051_rid/any_days/globalrelevanceex_sort/29.772759,-95.343261,29.740308,-95.396262_rect/14_zm/ http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Houston-TX/condo_type/6...). "few cities in the world where there's no more undeveloped land" Downtown San Francisco is full of undeveloped surface parking lots. Here are some maps I made: http://i.imgur.com/iSik6Zw.jpg http://i.imgur.com/iSik6Zw.jpg http://i.imgur.com/zNFjk6v.jpg http://i.imgur.com/zNFjk6v.jpg http://i.imgur.com/HygnC5e.jpg http://i.imgur.com/HygnC5e.jpg http://i.imgur.com/SJs576L.jpg http://i.imgur.com/SJs576L.jpg "The majority of the costs of any new project are land, labor and materials." That's highly misleading, because if development gets easier then rents go down, and if rents go down then land prices go down. The paper at http://faculty.washington.edu/te/papers/Housing051608.pdf http://faculty.washington.edu/te/papers/Housing051608.pdf estimates that excessive regulations are responsible for half of San Francisco's housing costs. That was in 2006, so it's almost certainly more now.
- tryitnow 11y agoI would add a little to this: It only holds true if there's nearly endless demand for high end units relative to supply. In SF, Manhattan, London, and other major cities this is true. There will always be a bunch of rich people willing to move in and pay high rents. Otherwise, your logic implies developers in a place like Houston should only build high end units. That obviously doesn't make sense.