6 ms·
Whiskey Can’t Hide Its Age
- peterwwillis 11y agoI had a bottle of Renegade, a 100% malted barley distilled in steel barrels with white oak chips for 60 days. It was.... weird, to say the least. Confusing. I don't usually drink malt whiskey other than scotch, so that could have just been totally new to me, but I wasn't a big fan.
- etherealmachine 11y agoNot a very good article since it doesn't mention Lost Spirits (www.lostspirits.net), with working technology that can age Whiskey and other spirits in a week. Maybe it's technically true that you can't hide the age, but apparently you can just fake it.
- klodolph 11y agoI don't understand how mentioning one recent startup which barely has samples out can make or break an article like this.
- kristofferR 11y ago"Barely has samples out" is not really true. Rational Spirits Santeria Rum, produced with his rapid aging tech, has been sold for months now.
- hinkley 11y ago...typo
- kristofferR 11y agoHahaha, whoops. What a typo... I fixed it now. Thanks
- kbenson 11y agoI believe there was a story a few years back about someone who developed a new technique for aging whiskey which was supposed to be much faster but the chemically identical (or very similar) to longer barrel aging. I don't think it's as simple as the small barrel aging they mention, because it was more recent and was getting a lot of attention. Edit: Found it[1], although it's rum, not whiskey. Thanks to etherealmachine for pointing me in the right direction. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9369387 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9369387
- mathattack 11y agoThe stakes are too high for this problem to be unsolved. People can accelerate the aging of wine as a chemical process. With billions on the line, people will figure it out for Whiskey too. This will dramatically bring down the cost of whiskey too. First comes from simply increasing the supply. More importantly, most of the cost of whiskey is time. If I spend $5 today making a bottle of 18 year whiskey, and I have a cost of capital of 6% higher than inflation, then I'll need to sell it at $14.27 (5*1.06^18) inflation adjusted just to break even.
- glup 11y agoEven if the result is effectively the same, won't there still be a place for a small number of high-end distilleries that age things naturally? The ridiculous duration is part of the appeal of the product, and something that (some) consumers want to signal, right?
- stepvhen 11y agoBuffalo Trace will probably never change its ways; they have been in constant operation for over 120 years I belive (even through prohibition, selling "medicinal" whiskey). And their products are consistently fantastic. But age as a signifer of quality is archaic, as distillers have gotten much smarter about how to make a good product rather than just letting things go for a long time and hope for the best. Honestly if you're buying a bourbon older than 10 years you're overpaying for diminishing returns. Most of the best bourbons/american whiskeys I have had are right around the $40-$70 range, and most don't mention age. I feel similarly for scotch but thats far trickier territory. Source: I worked three years in an upper-scale wine and spirits shop.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoInteresting claim. I don't drink bourbon, Scotch is my preference. The difference between Highland Park 12y and 18y is almost night and day. They're both lovely, but 18y is smoother and much more complex, with far more taste of the oak. 25y is almost spicy, and most definitely a sipping whisky that you want to last.
- beloch 11y ago"During the aging process, changes in heat and pressure push and pull the alcohol in and out of the wood. There is a constant back-and-forth between aldehyde and acid, until the acids accumulate en masse and turn permanently into esters, adding complex character and deep flavors." This quote I found interesting. It would seem an important ingredient in making whisky is a locale with reasonably varied weather. I wonder if anyone has tried the equivalent of putting their whisky barrels in a giant iron lung? Pushing and pulling the whisky in and out of the wood more often might speed up the aging process. "When it opened in 2003, Tuthilltown started experimenting with accelerating the maturation of single malt, rye, and bourbon whiskeys by letting the alcohol settle in 2- to 5-gallon oak barrels, instead of the industry-standard 53- to 55-gallon oak casks, increasing the alcohol-to-barrel-surface ratio. The small barrels sped up aging significantly; we could get to market in months, instead of years,” says Tuthilltown co-owner Ralph Erenzo" Laphroaig takes 5-year old whisky and then ages it in "quarter casks" (~80 L or 20 gallons) for several months. The result is actually pretty tasty for a relatively cheap scotch. (Warning: must like Islay's or this one will slay you). Their 10-year old bottling is a bit nicer, but almost twice the price. It's worth noting that more years in the barrel doesn't always improve a whisky. Islay's tend to lose their famous medicinal character if aged for too long, and other scotches often just get musty. I once had a 30-year old bottling of a rye that tasted like licking a steel drum. I'm not sure what went wrong there. Unlike many other things, there isn't so much a point of diminishing returns, but rather, a point after which a whisky will start getting worse, even as the prices continue to grow exponentially. "Bourbon made in less than a year may be financially savvy, but most bourbon experts say it falls short on taste. “I don’t think new methods are producing whiskey that is comparable,” Bryson says. “Some accelerated whiskeys don’t feel right. They feel too thin; they don’t have the proper ‘roundness.’ ” I'd have to do a double blind taste-test to be convinced this is true. Are whisky aficionados really more accurate than wine tasters, who famously aren't good at telling what they're drinking at all? I'm certain I could tell an Islay from a Rye or a Speyside, but could I tell a 5-year-old Bourbon from an 8-year-old Bourbon made by the same distiller if they were messing about with these accelerated aging methods? Aging issues aside, it will be interesting to see how consumer tastes evolve over the coming decades. Scotch has come on big in the last couple of decades and demand for Bourbon is also exploding. Rye (especially Canadian Rye) remains a bit of a niche drink though, but public interest seems to be picking up. Last year, Jim Murray declared the #1 new whisky in the world to be Crown Royal Northern Harvest Rye, which is a good rye for the price, but nothing particularly special. There are several Canadian Rye producers that could easily produce higher end bottlings if the market demand was there, and it does seem to be developing. It would be a fine day indeed if Alberta Premium started regularly producing 20-30 year-old bottlings instead of tricking an extremely limited bottling out every 5 years.
- sverige 11y agoI do like bourbon, but not nearly as much as rye. There have been a number of new American ryes in the last decade. I'm not going to tell you my favorites, though. I don't want the price to go up.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's ok. Most of them are interchangeable MGP whiskeys anyways, and will always have some lower-priced lesser-known entirely-equivalent cousins.
- sverige 11y agoTrue enough. I've sometimes thought about distilling my own as an experiment. It takes a long time to find out the results, though, and you're in constant danger from the revenuers.
- noarchy 11y agoBuying whiskey in Canada is often a exercise in frustration, with the provincial monopolies cranking the prices into the stratosphere. But we do have a fair number of good ryes that have popped up of late. Even the big brands like Canadian Club have started to offer up more real rye options (not all Canadian whiskies are made from rye, contrary to what some may think).
- cplease 11y agoEh. Price will go up to match demand, the market will clear. Meanwhile, turnaround time on a serviceable corn whiskey is less than thirty days from cob to bottle. No one is going to die for lack of drink. Whole story is a bunch of hype.
- tptacek 11y agoWait, what serviceable 30 day whiskey are you referring to? What's the service model?
- cplease 11y agoI can't from this whether you are asking an honest question or if you can't google "define:serviceable", or can't google "corn whiskey" and see the first result in either case.
- lumpypua 11y agoWhiskey fresh out of the still ("white dog") is pretty rough. Whiskey with 30 days of attentive oaking isn't awful (I'll happily get fucked up on it), 90 days will be pretty decent.
- venomsnake 11y agoHere is a free tip to rapid agrers - add sunlight. Putting a bottle of good stuff in the sun for the summer destroys it. But it smooths out the rough stuff a lot. Source - forgot some bottles of cheap scotch on the balcony in my college days.
- hobarrera 11y agoI wonder if you can put the whiskey in some non-reacting container, and dump the oak inside of it. This way, the exposed surface of the wood is twice as much (since both sides touch the whiskey), reducing the amount of oak needed.