3 ms·
If you had a replicator that could produce anything, why would you need money at all? There wouldn't even be markets as we know them today where an inventor cou
by kiba 17y ago
If you had a replicator that could produce anything, why would you need money at all? There wouldn't even be markets as we know them today where an inventor could command really high fees. And without needing money, you wouldn't need the government enforced monopoly that is patents to allow restricted exploitation of an idea.
The only market that might be left, assuming the replicator machine is duplicated enough, is the commodity and energy market, or the sale of extremely rare and exotic materials.
In anycase, people still make money off open hardware these day.
Besides, stupid people would think they'd be being smart by have their 3D printers print money, there by making money worthless.
It would mean that form of money is inferior. If there are still markets left, it would still mean that the phenomena of money will still arise.
In this thought experiment, I want to be part of and explore the sharing/open community, because I don't think a community that hides its best (and only assets), it's ideas, when production costs don't exist won't be able to grow as fast as a community that shares. When the key resources, and those that provide the basic necessities, are unlimited, there's no reason not to share.
Indeed, this is the superior choice for those who wish for economic progress and greater wealth in general. It would seem that today, my thought experiment seem fail in many way to demonstrate what I proposed to demonstrate, because I jump around making too many assumptions and leaps.
My argument would stick more if I use present day maker communities, open source hardware and their manufacturer and firms.
- joe_the_user 17y agoThe only market that might be left, assuming the replicator machine is duplicated enough, is the commodity and energy market, or the sale of extremely rare and exotic materials. No, there would obviously be no market whatsoever at that point. The step for making most useful things to make absolutely anything will be much smaller than the step from here to making most useful things. The problem is that without trade or mutual dependence, people might relate in the other most common manner we have - war, with new, ultra-powerful weapons. Not a pleasant thought. There are a number steps which essentially lead to the "singularity". Once you are there, ALL the old assumptions break down. Citing what people have generally done in the past will no longer make any sense. This isn't to say that it will Hell or Heaven but it will be intense. It's not by any means certain that the human beings will get to The Singularity . But there are a number of achievements one can specify such that if we reach these levels, then The Singularity will become virtually inevitable. A machine which produce itself and a variety of useful objects is one of these levels.
- kiba 17y agoNo, there would obviously be no market whatsoever at that point. The step for making most useful things to make absolutely anything will be much smaller than the step from here to making most useful things. I didn't realize that my 3D printer has now morphed into matter creators.