4 ms·
I believe software only bring out the danger of patents into the open, not because it is a poor fit. Imagine that people are starting to have a printer that ca
by kiba 17y ago
I believe software only bring out the danger of patents into the open, not because it is a poor fit.
Imagine that people are starting to have a printer that can print any objects from any design at will, including the biological kind. They benefit from sharing designs over time, because not only that their machine can print newer design, but their machine also allow them to recycle objects into new and better one. All that is left is the distribution mechanism for raw material, but once you reach a certain amount of material, you can basically transform old objects into new ones at will, barring the need for new raw and rare exotic materials. Perhaps, people who is able to complete a design will be rewarded with especially rare materials for them to experiment with?
Now what happen if the patent system is still in effect? That mean every person with a 3D printer is barred from printing designs from a patent of an inventor. In order to make lot of money, he essentially bar the people with 3D printers from printing so that he can sell his invention at the market for really high fees. If he come up with an innovative design for a self-replicating machine, he can bar the people with 3D printers as well from doing as they like for twenty years. For whatever reason, he rather have the power rather than becoming one of those nobodies in a society where everyone is become wealthier.
He can practically stop whole community of inventors who don't use patent and have a totally different idea toward sharing the design of invention.
Now imagine an innovative software entrepreneur stopping the open source software community and industry!
Patents doesn't need to be frivolous in order to be dangerous to the progress of technology. It can be innovative and life changing.
But an equally self-interested community of inventors who does thing in the open, may also give you inventions that is innovative and life changing as well.(And it may be just one inventor in the whole community who come up with it as well)
Which path do you want to explore?
- thwarted 17y agoImagine that people are starting to have a printer that can print any objects from any design at will, including the biological kind. ... That mean every person with a 3D printer is barred from printing designs from a patent of an inventor. In order to make lot of money, he essentially bar the people with 3D printers from printing so that he can sell his invention at the market for really high fees. If you had a replicator that could produce anything, why would you need money at all? There wouldn't even be markets as we know them today where an inventor could command really high fees. And without needing money, you wouldn't need the government enforced monopoly that is patents to allow restricted exploitation of an idea. Besides, stupid people would think they'd be being smart by have their 3D printers print money, there by making money worthless. In this thought experiment, I want to be part of and explore the sharing/open community, because I don't think a community that hides its best (and only assets), it's ideas, when production costs don't exist won't be able to grow as fast as a community that shares. When the key resources, and those that provide the basic necessities, are unlimited, there's no reason not to share.
- camccann 17y agoIf you had a replicator that could produce anything, why would you need money at all? Even if manufacturing becomes effectively free, resources won't. You'll still need energy and raw materials. There wouldn't even be markets as we know them today where an inventor could command really high fees. Just like the internet made the market for copyrighted information go away, right?
- kiba 17y agoJust like the internet made the market for copyrighted information go away, right? Most people are afraid to experiment without copyright and does not have a business model to exploit a non-copyright paradigm. However it does not mean that a non-copyright or at least copyright without much competitive deterrent would not thrive. Indeed, the open source software industry is one huge example. RedHat, for example effectively does not deter competitors from making copies of their distribution and selling it. However they still make lot of money. Arduino, an open source hardware platform, is another example. Chinese manufacturers copied their design, but the firm behind arduino still manages to sell a boatload of them.
- joe_the_user 17y agoEven if manufacturing becomes effectively free, resources won't. You'll still need energy and raw materials. Uh, print space ship, print fusion reactor, No, if you can make anything, then everything would be free. Of course, states would be first in line for the omnipotent power, so things wouldn't necessarily be easy...
- joe_the_user 17y agoJust like the internet made the market for copyrighted information go away, right? The Internet has torn big chunks in this market and remaining players of old media seem determined to stop this even if it means killing the net. Things haven't settled down and I don't think they will for a while...
- kiba 17y agoIf you had a replicator that could produce anything, why would you need money at all? There wouldn't even be markets as we know them today where an inventor could command really high fees. And without needing money, you wouldn't need the government enforced monopoly that is patents to allow restricted exploitation of an idea. The only market that might be left, assuming the replicator machine is duplicated enough, is the commodity and energy market, or the sale of extremely rare and exotic materials. In anycase, people still make money off open hardware these day. Besides, stupid people would think they'd be being smart by have their 3D printers print money, there by making money worthless. It would mean that form of money is inferior. If there are still markets left, it would still mean that the phenomena of money will still arise. In this thought experiment, I want to be part of and explore the sharing/open community, because I don't think a community that hides its best (and only assets), it's ideas, when production costs don't exist won't be able to grow as fast as a community that shares. When the key resources, and those that provide the basic necessities, are unlimited, there's no reason not to share. Indeed, this is the superior choice for those who wish for economic progress and greater wealth in general. It would seem that today, my thought experiment seem fail in many way to demonstrate what I proposed to demonstrate, because I jump around making too many assumptions and leaps. My argument would stick more if I use present day maker communities, open source hardware and their manufacturer and firms.