3 ms·
What do the supposedly useful humans usefully accomplish today? If we measure 'useful' by money earned then the most useful are supposed to be hedge fund manage
by ilaksh 11y ago
What do the supposedly useful humans usefully accomplish today? If we measure 'useful' by money earned then the most useful are supposed to be hedge fund managers that don't actually solve any problems.
The truth is that what really makes people 'useful' is there interactions with other humans. No matter how sophisticated the technology or what level of super-human super-intelligent or even as he speculates super-empathetic type of AI, human relationships will still be the true measure of value for people.
This concept of 'useless human beings' only makes sense if you have a primitive elitist Malthusian view in the first place. Which unfortunately many people do have that.
We should expect unenhanced human 1.0 to become the next chimpanzee analog in the hierarchy. We should hope he is right that the AIs are more empathetic towards their inferiors than we have been.
- ArkyBeagle 11y ago"Useful" is "creates consumer surplus", best I can tell. I don't know as well that hedge fund managers do that nearly as much as a guy selling produce on the side of the road. It depends on what you mean by "earned".
- TeMPOraL 11y agoFor better or worse, economic "usefulness" is directly tied to you having food in your belly. We can talk all we want about how "primitive elitist Malthusian" it is, but it doesn't change the fact that economically useless people go hungry, and we're all about to become economically useless. Fully automated economy can run fine without us.
- davidivadavid 11y agoPlease explain how that works. So you've got a completely independent "fully automated" economy of robots creating "goods" (as defined by humans) and exchanging them with one another while humans starve to death watching that?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoExactly. When robots do the manufacturing and delivery, algorithms do the orders and stock trading, you can imagine the moment when increasing automation will eventually remove humans from the loop. The market can and does get stuck in weird stupid-ass loops. Consider, for instance, the advertising industry. Most of its output is aimed at cancelling itself out (e.g. when you and I compete for the same group of customers, my advertising expenditure goes mostly to cancel out yours, and vice versa). Also in on-line advertising, a lot of money is being moved over nothing - consider, for instance, analytics. Many people in Internet marketing are clueless about statistics, but so are their clients - so as long as they can bullshit the customers that their service is helping (graph is going up!), they get paid, and customers are happy, because they're clueless too and can't verify the effectiveness of the service they paid for. And now for a funny twist - people making those analytics tools know this too, and guess what - they're starting to offer statistically invalid measures that are likely to look like the changes marketing people introduced are working. So those marketing people are being bulshitted by their tools now. It's not a circle per se, but it shows another example of money moving around over no value created.
- davidivadavid 11y agoActually, no, I can't imagine that moment, and that's why I'm asking for someone to come up with a sensical narrative that takes us from here to there. Humans dictate what the "loop" is. They define what gets manufactured, and who it gets delivered to. How do they get out of the loop? I believe the whole idea of humans becoming "useless" or "obsolete" is the biggest piece of nonsense I've come across in the last few years.