11 ms·
Pilot-Wave Theory Gains Experimental Support
- GregBuchholz 11y agoNot necessarily directly correlated, but I couldn't resist posting about the Couder/Fort oil drop experiments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9yWv5dqSKk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9yWv5dqSKk https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.4356 https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.4356
- c3534l 11y agoIt's funny, because there's actually criticism in the comments that the problem with that video is it implied Pilot-Wave Theory is true.
- Natanael_L 11y agoI'm just wonder if Delayed Quantum Eraser can be replicated with it. I'm not so sure, unless the pilot wave is more of a field.
- Strilanc 11y agoMaking a delayed eraser would be neat, but it's just a matter of having the signal particle bias the eraser particle. It doesn't require non-local interactions (thanks to the delay). The actually difficult task, the one protected by mathematical theorems that should apply to oil droplets bouncing on water, is passing Bell tests.
- GregBuchholz 11y agoMight be of interest: http://arxiv.org/abs/1406.0901 http://arxiv.org/abs/1406.0901 No-Go Theorems Face Background-based Theories for Quantum Mechanics "Recent experiments have shown that certain fluid-mechanical systems, namely oil droplets bouncing on oil films, can mimic a wide range of quantum phenomena, including double-slit interference, quantization of angular momentum and Zeeman splitting. Here I investigate what can be learned from these systems concerning no-go theorems as those of Bell and Kochen-Specker. In particular, a model for the Bell experiment is proposed that includes variables describing a 'background' field or medium. This field mimics the surface wave that accompanies the droplets in the fluid-mechanical experiments. It appears that quite generally such a model can violate the Bell inequality and reproduce the quantum statistics, even if it is based on local dynamics only. The reason is that measurement independence is not valid in such models. This opens the door for local 'background-based' theories, describing the interaction of particles and analyzers with a background field, to complete quantum mechanics. Experiments to test these ideas are also proposed."
- kkylin 11y agoThat's interesting. I haven't seen this paper before. None of the others I've read before (e.g., from Couder & collaborators on bouncing droplets) feature a fluid analog of entanglement. (For anyone interested, an example of a theory that derives Schroedinger from a classical particle interacting with a fluctuating background field can be found here: https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/books/qf.pdf https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/books/qf.pdf .)
- anotheryou 11y agoeven prettier replication: https://youtu.be/YF5iHQMjcsM https://youtu.be/YF5iHQMjcsM edit: and some double-slit https://youtu.be/nsaUX48t0w8?t=4 https://youtu.be/nsaUX48t0w8?t=4
- Frompo 11y agoThis must be one of the most amazing fluid dynamics videos I've seem :)
- andybak 11y ago> According to Englert [...] the Bohm trajectories exist as mathematical objects but “lack physical meaning.” That sounds strange coming from a defender of orthodoxy. By my (layman's) understanding the rallying cry of the Copenhagen school could be paraphrased as "Just do the maths. Everything else is just metaphysics" or to put it another way - questions about what the equations 'mean' are unscientific and Occam's Razor supports Copenhagen because it is the simplest interpretation that doesn't contradict observation.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoTypically the phrase is, "Shut up and calculate".
- GregBuchholz 11y agoFor another take on "Just do the math" see, "Clearing Up Mysteries - The Original Goal" by E.T. Jaynes: http://bayes.wustl.edu/etj/articles/cmystery.pdf http://bayes.wustl.edu/etj/articles/cmystery.pdf >While it is easy to understand and agree with this on the epistemological level, the answer that I and many others would give is that we expect a physical theory to do more than merely predict experimental results in the manner of an empirical equation; we want to come down to Einstein's ontological level and understand what is happening when an atom emits light, when a spin enters a Stern-Gerlach magnet, etc. The Copenhagen theory, having no answer to any question of the form: What is really happening when - - - ?", forbids us to ask such questions and tries to persuade us that it is philosophically naive to want to know what is happening. But I do want to know, and I do not think this is naive; and so for me QM is not a physical theory at all, only an empty mathematical shell in which a future theory may, perhaps, be built.
- int_19h 11y agoOf course, all such objections rest on the implicitly defined concept of "what is REALLY happening". But trying to strictly define this - which is necessary before we can meaningfully talk about it - is very tricky, and is firmly in the metaphysical / philosophical realm, and not science.
- sampo 11y agoAs far as I understand – and Wikipedia seems to support this – pilot wave theory, or actually any hidden variable theory, or actually any interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, they are different mathematical models that produce exactly the same predictions for experimental outcomes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilot_wave So how can, even in theory, any experiment support one interpretation any more or less than all the others?
- jessriedel 11y agoThey can't. The article is grossly misleading.
- ewjordan 11y agoYou're 100% correct - this is merely a direct presentation of the weirdness that results if you choose to interpret this experiment in the language of pilot wave theory. The physical results are the same as you would predict using normal methods, and as such it's a real stretch to consider this experimental support for Bohm's interpretation.
- dandelany 11y agoOne thing I've never been clear on is whether this is empirically the case, or theoretically the case. That is to say, is it theoretically possible that someday we may find evidence that supports Bohm's interpretation and falsifies the others? Or are they truly mathematically equivalent theories?
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThe only keyword in that article is the "If," before, "Results stand up to scrutiny." That, if you're familiar with the nearly religious proponents of deBB QM, is a BIG "if".
- joe_the_user 11y agoI know "Many Worlds" and Copenhagen are different interpretations of Quantum Mechanics. If Bohmian theory is one more interpretation, then we're talking about explanations that give the same experimental results and thus we aren't talking about a situation where an experimental result could prove one against the other. And it seems the experimental result described isn't a proof or disproof but a "demonstration how this could make sense" - a sort of "this analogy is still valid here" claim of the type that isn't a proof or a disproof.
- tremon 11y agoAs I understand it, it is a "proof" that the ESSW paper does not disprove Bohmiam theory. As to whether ESSW really did disprove it in the first place, I agree with your point.
- kordless 11y agoAKA, India's Net.
- kordless 11y ago> In the Bohmian view, nonlocality is even more conspicuous. The trajectory of any one particle depends on what all the other particles described by the same wave function are doing. AKA India's Net.
- anotheryou 11y agoSo how does it explain the 2 bands of the observed doubles slit experiment?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe particle goes through one slit, but the wave goes through both (all) and continues to influence the particle.
- anotheryou 11y agothat explains the interference pattern, but not the 2 clear bands you see when you measure it one slit (or am I wrong here and that never happens?)
- Natanael_L 11y agoThe measurement would affect the wave which would affect the particle.
- grkvlt 11y agoThat's just one band per slit, depending which one it went through...
- smilliken 11y agoSome nit-picks: > Until a particle is observed, an act that causes the wave function to “collapse,” The "collapse" is a overly-simplistic way to interpret QM experiments. It's not well-defined because no one's ever been able to define the "observer". > Quantum mechanics, in contrast, is inherently nonlocal. This is false, and a common misinterpretation of QM. We do not have any evidence of information travelling faster than the speed of light.
- ewjordan 11y agoThat's not fair - plenty of people have defined "observer" in plenty of different ways (including defining it away, like decoherence supporters would prefer), it's just that there's no consensus because it's mostly a matter of philosophy without any experimental consequences. As for nonlocality, entanglement is a fundamentally nonlocal feature of quantum mechanics. There's no way to excise that from the theory, even if you can't exploit it to transmit information faster than light. I'd say calling it inherently nonlocal is entirely fair, that's a very different claim than that we can transmit information faster than light. ...which, as an aside, would not even in and of itself necessarily be problematic, closed timelike loops (for instance) are perfectly fine and good as long as you account for the fact that quantum interference will have very strong effects even at a macro scale in such geometries (the grandfather paradox gets interfered away, more or less, even if macroscopically unlikely things need to happen to end up with a reinforced consistent timeline).
- VladKovac 11y agoQuantum mechanics given a single world would have to be nonlocal based on bell's theorem. Only Many Worlds can give a local account which might work.
- naasking 11y ago> This is false, and a common misinterpretation of QM. We do not have any evidence of information travelling faster than the speed of light. It's actually not false as stated. The author didn't say information travels FTL. Copenhagen gives up realism to satisfy Bell's theorem, but is still non-local.
- btilly 11y agoThe title is misleading. Here is what the experiments actually showed. Quantum mechanics continues to predict things correctly in an experiment that has a fun interpretation within pilot-wave theory. We also received the standard lecture on why pilot-wave theory makes more sense than the standard Copenhagen interpretation. And a passing acknowledgement of the many-worlds interpretation. There is no explanation of the fact that many-worlds also explains the result, also is mathematically simple, and lacks the explicit non-locality that is troubling in pilot-wave theory. There is also no note of the fact that all interpretations of quantum mechanics can explain all possible experiments that fit the predictions of quantum mechanics. Therefore no experiment can support one interpretation over another UNLESS the result is in contradiction to quantum mechanics. (In this case the result was emphatically not in contradiction to prediction.)
- DavidPlumpton 11y agoThe Everett FAQ makes even stronger claims about the status of Many Worlds. See http://www.hedweb.com/manworld.htm#interpretation http://www.hedweb.com/manworld.htm#interpretation
- sp332 11y agoThat is just plain bombastic. It says "All the other theories fail for logical reasons." No reasons given. It has a link, but the very first section in the link says "Copenhagen Interpretation... not fatal, but unpleasant". Well OK, you don't like non-locality. That's not a real argument! And a bunch of the questions about linearity ignore the fact that gravity is clearly non-linear.
- pierrebai 11y agoAh, why do these kind of Physics FAQ always claim to be objective and then obviously are not? This fact commits all the sins of the typical physics FAQ. For example it claim sthat only many-world is scientific, that other interpretation requires extra assumptions. It even labels Copenhagen as being "vitalist". It also does not address some very valid cristicisms: 1. Conservation of energy. 2. Relativistic observers seeing multiple decoherence events in different orders. 3. Experiments that affect whether a particule pair did decohere inthe past. (i.e. quantum state recombination.) Basically, MW assumes that the probability wave exists and that all outcomes exist, which is a very big assumption, which that FAQ gloss over rapidly. (And then explictly call other interpretations' assumptions as a negative...)
- exratione 11y agoHere's another alternative interpretation that's been around for a couple of decades: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transactional_interpretation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transactional_interpretation Though at a much earlier stage in the development of such things.
- _kst_ 11y agoFrom the article: "In Bohmian mechanics, every electron always has a definite position, even if observers are ignorant of what it is. An electron is pushed around by a guiding "pilot wave" that influences the electron's location. While each electron travels through one slit or the other, the pilot wave passes through both slits simultaneously. Interference in the pilot wave leads to the observed interference pattern." In the unlikely event that I understand this correctly, isn't what Bohmian mechanics calls "the pilot wave" just what the Copenhagen interpretation calls "the electron"? (Or perhaps "the electron's probability distribution"?)
- digi_owl 11y agoKinda. But while with the Copenhagen interpretation the "wave" is internal, Bohmian mechanics makes it external. And thus the question becomes, what is the source of this wave, how can it be affected by events, etc etc etc. And thus you get nonlocality. Where distant events generate a "bohmian wave" that impact local experiments even if they carry no particles. I guess you may see it as a case of unobserved butterfly on Pluto cause avalanche on earth, simply because the wing flap set a pilot wave in just the right motion.
- effie 11y agoIn Copenhagen, electron is "mysterious quantum object", unlike wave, unlike particle, just showing off properties of both in different experiments. It is not meant to be the same thing as \psi function, which is regarded as mere calculational device that describes this mysterious quantum object. The pilot wave in de Broglie-Bohm theory is just the \psi function with the addition that this function is "real", that is exists objectively and not merely on paper.
- nhaehnle 11y agoSome physicists are drawn instead to the Many Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, in which observers in some universes see the electron go through the left slit, while those in other universes see it go through the right slit This phrasing is so unfortunate - a much better understanding of MWI comes from looking at its original name, the "theory of the universal wave function": there is only one universe, it just happens to be described by a single wave function that describes the superposition of many different possible states that the universe could be in. The nice aspect of this theory is that it is mostly identical to the Copenhagen interpretation, but resolves the problem of wave function collapse in a perfectly clean way: there is no collapse, it's just that the act of observation causes the observer to become entangled with whatever it is that they're observing. If you really want to talk about multiple universes, you should at least clarify that it is the act of observation that causes the split between universes. So it's not like there are multiple pre-existing universes, and in some of them the electron goes left while in others it goes right. Rather, you as the observer start it one pre-existing universe, and by the observation the universe splits into a "left version" and a "right version". It's a subtle but important difference.
- rdtsc 11y ago> and by the observation the universe splits into a "left version" and a "right version" Isn't observation just a particle interaction? Or do you mean a human brain should be present in the loop to register the value.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoFrom what I understand, the answer to your question is this part of GP's comment: > the act of observation causes the observer to become entangled with whatever it is that they're observing. AKA particles interacting => particles get entangled. So they do not factor out cleanly as independent from each other anymore.
- tremon 11y agoBut I feel that that interpretation is unhelpful as a scientific theory, as it seems to make no testable predictions. In this view, what determines the split? Is there any action the observer can take that could theoretically affect the outcome? The article seems to imply that at least for the Bohmian model, the measured results have a correlation with the timing of the observer.
- spottedquoll 11y ago> the standard view of quantum mechanics, often called the Copenhagen interpretation No. The Copenhagen interpretation is not the "standard view."
- effie 11y agoThat is a surprising claim. What is your basis for saying so? Perhaps some polls?
- spottedquoll 11y agoThe many worlds interpretation is far more common amongst the physics community (well, the parts that care about this sort of thing.) We don't do things in physics with polls, really. We tend to prefer maths. And, much of the in-your-face weirdness of QM simply goes away with MW. You only have to accept that all paths are taken, but only one is observable to you. Not surprising, since you're an entity that obeys quantum mechanical laws. Since the actual predictions and experimental evidence for Copenhagen and MW are identical, it doesn't matter which you prefer. If you're not careful you run into philosophy pretty fast here - fun, but not useful. Copenhagen (kinda, sorta, not really when you do the maths) leads people to think (and I have been guilty of this) that there could be some sort of magical non-quantum 'observer' that causes the wave function to collapse. Which is bollocks. Many worlds forces you to consider the environment of the system (including the mythical 'observer') as fully quantum systems. Which is much closer to what the maths actually says. Copenhagen and MW give the same answers, but Copenhagen gives sloppy thinkers a silly avenue to get lost in. "I am a privileged, magical Observer, who is not at any point affected by the measurement I make." And, hidden variables are so strongly constrained by experimental results that you are out there in the wilds if you propose it. Not actually a crank, but carrying the burden of evidence. We are an epiphenomenon of quantum objects interacting under the laws of quantum mechanics. And the Many Worlds interpretation allows us to move past the philosophy and make actual, real, testable prediction.
- gaze 11y agoWhat is with hacker news' obsession with pilot wave theory? Many in quantum information consider uncertainty to be a feature, not a bug.
- effie 11y agoThe pilot wave theory is attractive partly because it is more easily understandable theory of microscopic particles, atoms and molecules than the alternatives (better visualizations and less bad philosophy talk). Also I suspect it is quite popular in some circles because the minions of orthodoxy could not convincingly refute it for decades now. Still a minority theory that has to fight for its place under the sun, it somehow reminds of the story about David against the Goliath...
- justifier 11y agoi hate when talks of qm use vague standin words like measure or observe stead describing the process especially when those things are shown in diagrams with a little image of an eye like in this article observation of quantum events is very intrusive, and i would argue has an obvious affect on the event's original outcome it is different from having someone throw a ball in a well lit room, and either having your eyes open or closed
- namuol 11y agoThere sure are an awful lot of interpretations of quantum mechanics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mechanics#Comparison_of_interpretations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpretations_of_quantum_mec... :)
- tomp 11y agoHow does the Pilot-Wave theory explain the GHZ experiment?