6 ms·
Really odd how articles criticizing a weed killer rile up such emotion. Your response is a good part ad hominem and emotional attacks. Do you have any facts t
by colordrops 11y ago
Really odd how articles criticizing a weed killer rile up such emotion.
Your response is a good part ad hominem and emotional attacks. Do you have any facts to back up your claims? Seralini is a fraud according to who? He is well respected and has won awards from the German Federation of Scientists. He has actually won court cases against special interests that have attempted to libel him. Seems that you were influenced by this libel.
And why should I trust your judgement over WHO on carcinogenicity?
Talking about "riding dicks" doesn't help your cause either. You come off as immature and it hurts your credibility. I'm surprised you've been voted to the top.
- davidw 11y ago> Talking about "riding dicks" doesn't help your cause either. Yeah, whatever else is true in his comment (and I think most of it is), I didn't care for that at all. I think people get riled up about this stuff because Monsanto is a particular bête noire of some leftish anti-science people. BTW, the guy in question is very definitely controversial and has an Agenda with a capital A. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair
- Chathamization 11y ago> I think people get riled up about this stuff because Monsanto is a particular bête noire of some leftish anti-science people. The reverse is true as well. Monsanto/GMO debates seem to be mostly about posturing/signaling, with the two sides throwing pseudoscience and FUD at each other and absolutely no chance of either side reconsidering their stances or taking a close look at the facts. It's more akin to the argument between different religious fanatics, and agnostics or non-believers don't have much to gain by getting in the middle of it.
- davidw 11y agoA lot of it seems to be the anti-science folks who are against GMO's and the like, and Monsanto is a convenient bad guy. Most of the actual science and law doesn't seem to look that bad for them once you get past the "outrage!" articles. Of course, like many a large company, they do have some ugly history in their past, and I'm sure they're not perfect, so I guess that makes it more convenient. However, yeah, it does make discussing specific things kind of difficult.
- Melk 11y agoNo one commenting here are part of the anti-science folks and you're unlikely to find them on HC. Meanwhile /u/searine is a well-known reddit mod for /r/GMO and his argumentative style of writing isn't new either. IMHO it's people like him who give the industry a bad name.
- davidw 11y agoHN is pretty big these days. There are plenty of anti-science folks of various kinds.
- searine 11y ago> Meanwhile /u/searine is a well-known reddit mod for /r/GMO You flatter me. But seriously. Stop by https://www.reddit.com/r/gmo https://www.reddit.com/r/gmo . We actually try to be very inclusive of all opinions. So few people are interested in this topic that we really love to have everyone there. Usually its just kids asking for help on school projects... >his argumentative style of writing isn't new either. IMHO it's people like him who give the industry a bad name. See here's the thing. I know I won't ever change the mind of anti-science true believers. As a scientist, I've had to deal with climate change deniers, creationists, anti-vaxxers, and anti-gmo kooks. To me they are a lost cause. However, I can impact how the audience views them. I may be crass, but I cite my sources, and I expose poor arguments. Deal with it.
- davidw 11y ago> I may be crass One of the guidelines we have on HN that works well is: pretend like you're saying something to someone in person. You could certainly state a strong opinion that way, but it's less likely that most people would be outright rude and vulgar about it. I think your're on firm enough ground, scientifically, that you can state things strongly without being crass.
- scott_s 11y agoI'm glad you're here and, as an expert in the field, able and willing to explain why an article has poor scientific reporting. But, I agree with davidw: we take the guidelines seriously. Please consider them when responding: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I think people get riled up about this stuff because Monsanto is a particular bête noire of some leftish anti-science people. Monsanto is also a particular bête noire of lots of pro-science people working in the same industry. For a tech-industry comparison, think of the worst views of Microsoft at the height of its monopoly. Unfortunately, some people use (sometimes legitimate, sometimes not) issues with Monsanto to attack the idea of GMOs generally.
- searine 11y ago>Do you have any facts to back up your claims? Because it is the widely publicized scientific consensus. But if you insist. EFSA : http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/4302 http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/pub/4302 EPA: https://www.epa.gov/ingredients-used-pesticide-products/glyphosate https://www.epa.gov/ingredients-used-pesticide-products/glyp... NAS : http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/national-academy-of-sciences-finds-no-evidence-of-gmo-health/article_a7ffbe9a-5848-5826-aa28-6b75b3c947d2.html http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/national-academy-of-s... > Seralini is a fraud according to who? Every scientist I've ever talked to. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9ralini_affair >And why should I trust your judgement over WHO on carcinogenicity? Because they don't have proof glyphosate is a carcinogen, just general harm classifications. Glyphosate is in a class of carcinogens similar to dietary meat, and other everyday minor exposures. >You come off as immature and it hurts your credibility Sometimes you have to be crass to put a spotlight on bullshit.
- sndean 11y agoAnother good reference for the current lack of a connection between cancer (specifically Hodgkin lymphoma referenced in the article) and glyphosate: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27015139 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27015139 Just published, meta-reviews are generally best, and the authors are pretty well-regarded.
- esaym 11y agoRead the article, it is not pointing the finger at Roundup's main ingredient "glyphosate". But they are putting toxic chemicals in their products without listing it anywhere on the label: "POEA — officially an “inert” ingredient — was between 1,200 and 2,000 times more toxic to cells than glyphosate, officially the “active” ingredient."
- searine 11y agoSee the following review : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15862083 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15862083 "There is insufficient evidence to conclude that glyphosate preparations containing POEA are more toxic than those containing alternative surfactants" Surfactants, in general, are toxic. There is nothing special about POEA. Used properly, surfactants can be of good use and result in safe improvement of agriculture.
- JshWright 11y agoThe WHO is _super_ broad about how they define things that _might_ cause cancer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOVBOwbqcT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOVBOwbqcT8
- Oletros 11y ago> And why should I trust your judgement over WHO on carcinogenicity? Glyphosate is in the same list as drinking hot mate or red meat. The IARC list doesn't asses risk, just states that some substance is potentially carcinogen.
- tynpeddler 11y agoYou have to understand that for many scientists, work like this is darn near akin to climate change denial. You can only repeat yourself so many times debunking this garbage before you start trying to be creative. And you can only be so creative before you go crazy. *It's not exactly like climate change denial. There's still a small chance that glyphosates have serious dangers and there are always other chemicals, and combinations of chemicals to research. But that doesn't excuse the shoddy science and hysteria that swarms around these issues like flies on turds.
- shiro 11y agoOn WHO carcinogenicity---note that their "probable human carcinogens" include Red meat, Hot mate, Emission from household combustion of wood, etc. That doesn't mean the list is meaningless. They just say those are "probable" carcinogens in the literal sense, based on limited evidence on humans and sufficient evidence on experimental animals. It may be wise to avoid exposure to them more than necessary, but you don't want to take the list as if they're deadly chemicals or something.
- tiredgrad 11y agoRegarding Seralini: RetractionWatch, who are well-respected in the scientific community, has seven posts discussing his work (http://retractionwatch.com/category/by-author/gilles-seralini/ http://retractionwatch.com/category/by-author/gilles-seralin...). I won't go into the detail of the retracted article, its subsequent republishing without peer review, or his various conflicts of interest around his books or the funding of his group by 'pharma' companies selling plant-based homeopathic products claiming to be able to 'detoxify' Roundup residues (there's some detail on this in his Wikipedia entry - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilles-%C3%89ric_S%C3%A9ralini https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilles-%C3%89ric_S%C3%A9ralini) With respect to his 'court cases' - he won a defamation case against a journalist writing for a French magazine that had accused him of fraud and forgery. Incredibly few critics of Seralini have accused him of fraud; the court decision makes no statement as to the merit of what is the serious criticism of Seralini's work (in terms of the statistics, methods and analysis employed). Regarding the German Federation of Scientists - he was awarded a 'whistleblower' award, not one for scientific merit. The jury/committee that awarded him this had a CRIIGEN board member (his host institution) and public supporter of Seralini as a member; there is not, as far as I can see, any information to suggest that she recused herself for this decision. The other scientist on the jury is a well-respected metrologist; all other members of the jury are legal professionals. For the sake of balance, the full decision of that jury is listed here - http://neu.vdw-ev.de/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Full-Reasoning-S%C3%A9ralini_en.pdf http://neu.vdw-ev.de/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Full-Reasoni... On a personal note though - Seralini has several anti-GMO and anti-glyphosate books, releases papers in concert with documentaries, and appears to believe in 'detoxification' and homeopathic plant-based treatments in order to 'detoxify' Roundup residues. This behaviour and these views place him quite outside the usual behaviour of a scientist - it's simply not done that you write a paper and time it for an accompanying book launch and documentary release.