6 ms·
> Unfortunately, you’ve got a lot of police misconduct, but I never thought it would be on this level. [...] You’re innocent until proven guilty. I was guilty u
by mcphage 11y ago
> Unfortunately, you’ve got a lot of police misconduct, but I never thought it would be on this level. [...] You’re innocent until proven guilty. I was guilty until proven innocent.
He was investigated, nothing was found, and he was released. He wasn't arrested, charged, taken to jail, let alone "guilty until proven innocent".
- thedz 11y agoHe was handcuffed publicly, had a taser pointed at him, and suffered a decent amount of emotional duress without even knowing why they did it to him, or what his crime was. The "innocent until proven guilty" bit might not be 100% accurate, but this is still incredibly irresponsible on the part of the police.
- 1024core 11y ago> He was investigated, nothing was found, and he was released. Let me guess: you're a white male, aren't you? When these things happen to others but don't happen to you, you can pass it off as "mistakes happen". But when these "mistakes" happen only to a certain section of society, it's a cause for concern. Why was he handcuffed and had a taser on his back?? Why was he treated like a criminal in front of everybody? You don't put handcuffs on someone unless you want to detain them.
- searine 11y ago>Let me guess: you're a white male, aren't you? This is an extremely shitty and racist argument to make, particularly on the internet where you shouldn't make assumptions about who people are. Were the cops wrong in being overzealous? Obviously. Is the poster automatically a "white male" because they consider an alternative perspective? No, they just have a different opinion than you.
- jmcmichael 11y agoIf one has ever been cuffed or had a weapon pointed at them, they're far less likely to be so cavalier in dismissing another's similar experience. Given that African Americans are far, far more likely to be unjustly detained in such a matter, it seems reasonable to assume that mcphage is a white male, given his callous response.
- searine 11y ago>it seems reasonable to assume that mcphage is a white male Being racist might seem reasonable, but it is not constructive because you use it to ignore the content of the poster's argument. Even if the content of the poster's argument is flawed, attack the flaws, not the person.
- jmcmichael 11y ago> Being racist That word doesn't mean what you appear to believe that it means. I do not hold the belief that one race is superior to another, nor do I hold the belief that society should exploit or disadvantage individuals based on their race. Therefore I am not being racist, nor was my statement. It's perfectly within the bounds of reasonable discourse to question the underlying assumptions of another's worldview to show that their assertions come from a biased perspective that requires examination.
- searine 11y ago> to show that their assertions come from a biased perspective that requires examination. But you didn't show it. You assumed it, based on their race.
- 1024core 11y agoLet me give you an example. I'm not a white male. My girlfriend is white. I have learned, after several experiences, that if you are pulled over, you roll down your window, keep your hands on the steering wheel, look straight and answer "yes sir", "no sir". Deviation from this protocol can result in anything from a search, to a beatdown (in extreme cases). She, on the contrary, has not. She has been pulled over a few times, of course. 2 months ago, coming back from visiting a friend in NorCal, I pulled on to the highway and as I was merging, sped up. A CHP car just happened to be there, and tagged me. We were pulled over. I immediately assumed the aforementioned stance. She, on the other hand, decided to cheerfully take off her seatbelt, turn around and start digging into her bag on the rear seat, looking for a book, her glasses, etc. And the officer could see this rummaging from his vehicle. What ensued, was not pretty. Lets just say that my GF has a new perspective on how to behave when pulled over. My point is: unless you belong to a set that is consistently treated differently, you will never understand their point of view.
- searine 11y ago> if you are pulled over, you roll down your window, keep your hands on the steering wheel, look straight and answer "yes sir", "no sir". This is just common courtesy? I've always acted this way, and never had bad experience with the police, because I treated them with respect. Sounds like your GF showed a lack of couresty/respect for the officer's safety and got treated like a threat as a result. That's not racism. That's an officer protecting himself from an unknown quantity. >you will never understand their point of view. Because every human being is completely devoid of empathy...
- UVB-76 11y ago> Why was he handcuffed and had a taser on his back?? Why was he treated like a criminal in front of everybody? You don't put handcuffs on someone unless you want to detain them. Because he was suspected of handling stolen goods.
- LargeWu 11y agoWhat indication was given that there was reasonable suspicion that the laptop was stolen?
- tremon 11y agoHe was investigated, nothing was found, and he was released. That doesn't follow. Why did he need to be released?
- refurb 11y agoHe was detained. Thus he was released after.
- bearcobra 11y agoI'd argue that detainment without probable cause is kind of the underlying message of "Innocent until proven guilty"
- UVB-76 11y agoProbable cause is not the relevant test for detaining someone. Police can detain with reasonable suspicion alone, and it is entirely likely they had reasonable suspicion in this case.
- bearcobra 11y agoIs that true? I've always heard that Terry allows officers to stop you, and ask questions under reasonable suspicion, but that performing pat downs and handcuffing is only allowed if there is a reasonable suspicion that the suspect is armed. And I'm still not really convinced that there was reasonable suspicion that a crime is being committed. Wouldn't that mean that any private party sale negotiated in public is inherently suspicious? I know law enforcement has a lot of leeway here but that would be kind of alarming.
- yompers888 11y agoFrom reading the end of the story, it is clear that they did not have reasonable suspicion. They had a responsive seller on Craigslist who was selling the same computer as the supposed buyer had lost. Do you believe owning the same model computer is reasonable suspicion? Does use of Craigslist meet your threshold of reasonable suspicion? Their reasonable suspicion was predicated on the signaling of the person inspecting the laptop, and that signal never came. Interestingly, there was a recent This American Life with almost this exact same setup, but it was approached cautiously and executed correctly. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/549/amateur-hour http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/549/a...
- ChemicalWarfare 11y ago+1. He was a suspect. Things didn't check out and the cops let him off without even taking him to the station. So now whether they had the probable cause to search his computer or not - that is unclear as we obv don't have a full story from the law enforcement side of things. I highly doubt that someone calling the cops and telling them - 'someone on craigslist is selling a laptop that was stolen from me' without any proof would trigger this ordeal.
- dahart 11y agoWhat a dismissive, unsympathetic response. His computer was temporarily seized & searched without his consent, under immediate threat of force with a weapon. He was prevented from even voicing concern or asking questions through threat of violence, and forced to comply with actions that were not backed by a probable cause or even a reasonable suspicion of a crime having been committed. In the US, there are laws against this. What happened there was illegal, with or without an arrest or charges or jail time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Search https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Amendment_to_the_United... And he was presumed guilty until the search was completed, that sounds like 'guilty until proven innocent' to me. Innocent until proven guilty doesn't mean only if it takes longer than 5 minutes to prove. It means you start with the presumption of innocence.
- UVB-76 11y agoYour timeline doesn't match his account. He consented to the search of the laptop before being detained. He did not know it was an undercover police officer conducting the search, but that is not relevant. He was subsequently detained, until such time as it became obvious he was innocent, and then released.
- philh 11y agoThe prospective buyer wasn't a police officer.
- UVB-76 11y agoThat's an even better point. The Fourth Amendment doesn't protect you from letting a stranger search your laptop.
- dahart 11y agoThat's weird; I didn't present a timeline. > He consented to the search of the laptop before being detained. He did not know it was an undercover police officer conducting the search, but that is not relevant. I'm not sure you know what "consent" actually means. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_search https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent_search A consent search requires the individual whose person or property is being searched to freely and voluntarily waive his or her Fourth Amendment rights, granting the officer permission to perform the search. Where consent is obtained through "deception" on the part of government personnel, the search may be determined to be an unreasonable search in violation of the Fourth Amendment.
- coldtea 11y ago>He was investigated, nothing was found, and he was released. He wasn't arrested, charged, taken to jail, let alone "guilty until proven innocent". The docility with which the american public takes those abuses (in a country with record police shootings and a wholly disproportionate number of inmates) always amuses me...