9 ms·
You're Gonna Need a License for That
- Rmilb 11y agoDoes anyone else see a future where programmers need to get a licence to practice their craft?
- simonh 11y agoCompanies already need licenses to produce software for various safety or life critical applications, such as medical devices.
- cududa 11y agoThen perhaps we can put to bed the stupid "Engineers or developers" argument
- urda 11y agoIt's not that difficult to put that to bed today. Did you receive some form of a Computer Engineering degree from an ABET institution (just using the U.S. for this example)? Congratulations you are an engineer. Did you receive a Computer Science degree, Computer Information Systems degree, boot camp graduate, self taught or otherwise? Congratulations you are a developer.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jzymbaluk 11y agoBut what about an ABET-accredited Computer Science degree? Does that make me a Develogineer?
- trentmb 11y agoABET has separate accreditation for Computing and Engineering. http://www.abet.org/accreditation/ http://www.abet.org/accreditation/
- jedberg 11y agoSo you're saying you have to have a four year engineering degree to be an engineer, and you don't count a computer science degree? Did you know that MIT, Stanford, Berkeley and Harvard do not offer Computer Engineering degrees (only Computer Science or Electrical Engineering or EECS). Also you've completely discounted self taught practitioners, some of whom are often far more competent than people with actual Computer Engineering degrees. Hence, it really isn't "put to bed" yet.
- dhd415 11y agoCourse 6-3, the "computer science" major at MIT, is officially titled "Computer Science and Engineering". Maybe MIT 6-3 grads can call themselves both developers and engineers?
- danielweber 11y agoComputer Science and Engineering: https://www.eecs.mit.edu/academics-admissions/undergraduate-programs/course-6-3-computer-science-and-engineering https://www.eecs.mit.edu/academics-admissions/undergraduate-...
- jedberg 11y agoThat's a single course, not a degree.
- danielweber 11y agoThis was really annoying to go dig up in my attic, but I found it: http://i.imgur.com/eiF1INY.jpg http://i.imgur.com/eiF1INY.jpg Did I say this was really annoying? Because it was. At least it wasn't as tacky as posting my diploma. Please don't tell people from MIT what MIT offers.
- jedberg 11y agoYou could have just linked to the website. :) I guess things have changed in 20 years. But really you only proved my point. OP said that a computer engineering degree makes you an engineer and a computer science degree makes you a developer. So what does a computer science and engineering major make you? My main point was you can't decide if someone is an engineer based on the name of the degree they were granted.
- vonmoltke 11y agoExcept that engineers do not require a license to practice their craft either, except in certain situations.
- cloudjacker 11y agoYeah, and thats when you know "tech" has actually changed the world instead of just imagining it does. A civil engineer pointed out to me that the licenses come when it really starts to affect people and infrastructure. Programming does this by proxy, but not directly enough yet. New York State's bitlicense was the closest to burdening software engineers with licensing requirements, until the one person at the head of the financial agency clarified it wasn't intended to be interpreted that way, and modified the wording of the law.
- nightski 11y agoSo one can't change the world unless lives are endangered. That doesn't seem very logical.
- cloudjacker 11y agoMaking people's phones overheat and changing file extensions on their PCs isn't enough of a problem Thats all it comes down to. When programmers are doing things that actually endanger people's lives directly, actually alter the physical living environment directly, then you will see governing authorities pushing for licenses.
- dv_dt 11y agoEngineers design passenger aircraft, rockets, cars, and medical devices without needing licenses - the products themselves are strongly regulated. Requiring the engineers developing the product to carry licenses will just raise the overhead cost of developing such products. I think the key difference is certifying the product when there are multiple instances of the product being made is cheaper. For civil engineering, most of the projects are unique (and even if the design is something of a copy - then the sites present unique challenges). So maybe it makes more sense there to license the engineers.
- tim333 11y ago>When programmers are doing things that actually endanger people's lives directly... Toyota famously had some issues with their software and fatalities. It'd be hard to license software development though because it's such a quickly changing field. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9643204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9643204
- ghaff 11y agoFor engineers who have to sign off on matters related to regulatory bodies, that's been the case more or less forever. I assume that includes software engineers who approve software that has to be approved by regulators. It's certainly true of construction plans, etc. In my first engineering job (offshore drilling rig design and construction), pretty much all the senior engineers had PEs.
- mcherm 11y ago> I assume that includes software engineers who approve software that has to be approved by regulators. Not that I know of.
- ghaff 11y agoAccording to this article in IEEE [1] "Thirty states currently require licensure for software engineers working on systems that affect the health, safety, and welfare of the public as well as those offering their services directly to the public." That seems a reasonable source but I don't know how common it is in practice. [1] http://theinstitute.ieee.org/ieee-roundup/opinions/ieee-roundup/misconceptions-about-licensing-software-engineers http://theinstitute.ieee.org/ieee-roundup/opinions/ieee-roun...
- trentmb 11y agoYou don't have to (yet), but there is a PE exam for software engineering: https://cdn.ncees.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SWE-Apr-2013.pdf https://cdn.ncees.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SWE-Apr-201...
- digi_owl 11y agoI think a lower hanging fruit would be to push for the adoption of Rust, Ada, or similar languages that close or mitigate all too common errors.
- ComteDeLaFere 11y agoSince many of us fully expect AI to accomplish all programming in the future, I don't think so. Unless a licensing regime is humankind's last stand against AI.
- adekok 11y agoThe attitude of "license all the things" comes from two places. Existing groups use licensing to shut out newcomers. They are largely anti-competitive, and anti-capitalistic. The other is where unlicensed activities results in people dying. The outrage from such events often ends up with "license the people", so that Bad Things can't happen. That's arguably a better approach, for mechanics, nuclear power technicians, etc. Perhaps even hairdressers, who work with toxic chemicals and need to know basic safety. For me, the "health and safety" requirements make sense. Anything outside of that is typically anti-competitive, and likely rent-seeking.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoIf hairdressers are included, then what won't be? At that point, we're right back where we started.
- jdmichal 11y agoHair stylists work with extremely sharp implements extremely close to major blood vessels. I'm pretty OK with them needing at least some training. And that's not even counting, as GP mentioned, the dangerous chemicals that come into things like hair dyes.
- joezydeco 11y agoPlanet Money documented the plight of a woman in Utah that wanted to start a hair-braiding business. She needed a full cosmetology license. http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/06/22/155596305/episode-381-why-its-illegal-to-braid-hair-without-a-license http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/06/22/155596305/episo... A recent ruling negated the requirement: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/08/09/158498244/its-now-legal-to-braid-hair-in-utah-without-a-license http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/08/09/158498244/its-n...
- jdmichal 11y ago> Utah's cosmetology/barbering licensing scheme is so disconnected from the practice of African hairbraiding, much less from whatever minimal threats to public health and safety are connected to braiding, that to premise Jestina's right to earn a living by braiding hair on that scheme is wholly irrational and a violation of her constitutionally protected rights. So part of the ruling negating the requirement took into consideration that braiding had none of the associated threats to public health and safety. This sounds like things working as they should with regards to overreaching. It's a shame she had to shut down and sue, but the right call was made by the judge.
- imgabe 11y agoI'm a PE (electrical) and I think what most people don't realize is that the licensing was largely driven by the insurance industry. Let's say you pay some people to design a building for you. You get insurance of course. A year later, the building falls down. You call your insurance company to collect. The first thing they ask is whether you took every reasonable precaution you could to prevent that from happening. Part of that would include having a licensed structural engineer design the building. If you let Joe Shmoe off the street design your building and it falls down, the insurance company is going to say you're basically SOL, because you didn't find a person you could verify was qualified. It's really about transferring the liability from the building owner to the engineer. If there's a mistake in the design, the engineer gets sued. Guess what happens then? The engineer has professional liability insurance to pay that! How does the professional liability insurance company decide who to insure? Well, they insure people with licenses, of course. It's an elaborate scheme to transfer money from one insurance company to another. Is it necessary for a florist? Probably not. I can't think of a situation where you'd need to sue a florist. Interior decorator might be more problematic than people realize. First, it depends on whether it's a decorator or a designer. A designer may move walls around, affecting egress paths, and can possibly have some life safety implications, so they should be able to take responsibility for that.
- wrong_variable 11y agoThe sad part is the industries that do actually need some quality control are the ones that are completely unlicensed. If a florist does something stupid - no one gets hurts. But bankers,programmers treat their profession like the wild west.
- nine_k 11y agoInsurance companies look okay with that. User themselves are, too: look at all these BSD-style "provided as-is, explicitly no guarantees" licenses that people take enthusiastically. And for something aircraft-grade or medical-grade, you definitely meet with rather strict controls on a case-by-case basis (unlike the wholesale licensing).
- Shivatron 11y ago
- intrasight 11y ago"license" is too loosey goosey a term. It could be related to insurance/safety regulations, or it could be in relation to a trade group's attempt to limit competition. An article that fails to clearly say what they mean by "license" isn't going to make any clear point.
- tn13 11y agoHere is what Adam Smith said about occupational licenses centuries (1776) ago : "The property which every man has in his own labour, as it is the original foundation of all other property, so it is the most sacred and inviolable. The patrimony of a poor man lies in the strength and dexterity of his hands; and to hinder him from employing this strength and dexterity of his hands; and to hinder him from employing this strength and dexterity in what manner he thinks proper without injury to his neighbour is a plain violation of this most sacred property." Certification driven by insurance industry makes sense, criminalizing people without licenses is a conspiracy against poor.
- JacobJans 11y agoThis article seems quite specific at first – but when you dig down, it is actually rather vague. For example, the author complains that his mother needs a license to bake food. What kind of license? What state? Maybe a food handlers license? These are incredibly common, and very easy to obtain. Maybe a business license? Again – most states are falling over themselves to make it easy to give you a business license. It's hard to tell exactly what is being argued against. Food safety is incredibly important – and food handler's licenses are easy to obtain. States need to collect taxes, that's the basic reason a business needs to get a license. Neither of these things are controversial. That's why I'm guessing the author of this article didn't go into specifics.
- Aloha 11y agoI worked in food service for 5 years, I was given basic training on what safe food handling was, and how to ensure our guests didn't get sick, at that time in California, no license was required. I don't think licensure brings any advantages - because dont forget - its not the business that needs a license, its the individual working for a low wage that does - its just an extra burden for the guy trying to find a job - and I'll note, the state (in California at least) doesn't even issue these things (or seem profit from them) - its issued by private entities.
- unsignedint 11y agoThe business, may require a food service permit (unless they are selling packaged food) in addition to a business license, too, in combination with food handler's permit for workers. At least, that's the case for the county where I live. (King County, WA) In fact, places like Trader Joe's (where they don't sell, but merely give away food sample) require an appropriate license to do that, too. They are also inspected fairly routinely, and every couple does get shut down for incompliance (problem with temperature, separation of raw meat, etc.) and I can see why these would require a license in order to prevent food-borne illness.
- mohsinr 11y agoI read a recent news about proposed law being drafted in India related to needing a license for mapping the country, I clicked on this story thinking it was about exact issue I just read. Here is link : http://www.voanews.com/content/proposed-law-on-use-of-maps-satellite-images-prompts-outcry/3333805.html http://www.voanews.com/content/proposed-law-on-use-of-maps-s...
- HillaryBriss 11y agoYet another possible reason licensing requirements have proliferated is that we have a less trusting and less trustworthy society, a much more fluid and transient society, today than in the past. We literally don't know anybody out there. Where I live, people from a wide variety of locations across the globe are constantly arriving, setting up shop, and offering some kind of service or other (legally or otherwise). It's not clear they're offering a high quality service or that they'll be available later to fix any problems they may create. It's not clear which community they belong to (if any) and are accountable to (if any). It's not clear how long they'll even be in country. On the surface then, government licensing seems like it might be a tool that transforms a "Random, Unknown, Migratory Service Provider from Somewhere Else" into a "Locally Known, Certified, Accountable High Quality Service Provider"