3 ms·
For me, the biggest downside of Google shutting down Reader is that from now until eternity every post to Hacker News about a new Google service will be chock f
by andybak 11y ago
For me, the biggest downside of Google shutting down Reader is that from now until eternity every post to Hacker News about a new Google service will be chock full of comments pointing out that it will probably just get closed down.
The actual number of genuinely useful services that Google has shuttered is relatively small.
Their much bigger sin consists of either long-term neglect, re-launching a new version with half the features missing or as other commenters here have pointed out - launching something that confusingly overlaps with another service.
- koolba 11y ago> For me, the biggest downside of Google shutting down Reader is that from now until eternity every post to Hacker News about a new Google service will be chock full of witty comments about how it's going to get shut down. I'd argue that most of them aren't witty[1] and it's not just Reader either. Plenty of things shut down before and afterwards[2]. [1]: Obviously not counting my own rapier wit... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Discontinued_Google_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Discontinued_Google_s...
- andybak 11y agoApologies - I edited my original post to take out the overly-sarcastic 'witty' just before you posted. I also added a touch more substance to my comment.
- codemac 11y agoI mean, it's not exactly a short list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Google_products#Discontinued_products_and_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Google_products#Discon... I'd also add that it raises a serious point: if we cannot depend on products to exist past the team that creates them, are we really producing products at all? Or merely engineering time leased at the rate you consume advertising?
- Flimm 11y agoWow, that is longer than I expected. Here it is in one paragraph: Google Answers, Google Deskbar, Writely, Google Click-to-Call, Related Links, Public Service Search, Google Video Marketplace, Google Browser Sync (Firefox), Google Lively, Hello, SearchMash, Send to Phone, Audio Ads, Catalogs, Dodgeball, Google Ride Finder, Shared Stuff, Google Page Creator, Marratech e-Meeting, GOOG-411, Google Labs, Google Buzz, Google Dictionary, Google PowerMeter, Real Estate, Google Directory, Squared, Google Sets, Google Pack, Google Fast Flip, Desktop, Google Image Labeler, Aardvark, Directory, Gears, Google Notebook, Google Apps standard edition, Google Code Search, Google Health, Google Website Optimizer, TV Ads, Google Friend Connect, Google Insights for Search, Knol, Google Wave, Picnik, Jaiku, Nexus Q, Slide.com, Google Mini, Picasa Web Albums Uploader, Google Cloud Connect (Microsoft Office plugin), Google Building Maker, Google Calendar Sync, Meebo, Google Reader, Google Latitude, Google Talk, SMS service, iGoogle, GIS tools for Google Maps, Google Schemer, Google Notifier, YouTube My Speed, Orkut, QuickOffice, "discussion search", Google Moderator, Wildfire by Google, BebaPay, Google Helpouts, Google Code, Picasa, Google Compare.
- andybak 11y agoIf you remove: a. things that were obselete or dead in all but name. b. things that were merged into other things (for better or worse - then the list becomes considerably smaller. Still. There's a few things on there I'd forgotten about and still rather miss.
- Karunamon 11y agoThe actual number of genuinely useful services that Google has shuttered is relatively small. "Genuinely useful" is a subjective term... Reader and the nontrivial list of other things Google has bought or started and then left to die on the vine definitely gives me pause before signing up for one of their services. Example: They started doing domain registration about a year or two ago? I'm not going to use it because it's not a core part of their business and I don't want to be in the position of doing a forced migration with associated costs when they inevitably decide to scuttle it with no concern for the users.