3 ms·
Side note - he wasn't arrested, he was handcuffed, had a weapon stuck in his back, was detained, had an illegal search performed on his possessions, and all by
by joe_the_user 11y ago
Side note - he wasn't arrested, he was handcuffed, had a weapon stuck in his back, was detained, had an illegal search performed on his possessions, and all by purported law enforcement officers who refused to identify themselves.
I have some news for you. Arrest means nothing but detained/held/stopped. Most people imagine an arrest action has something formal to it, like having your rights read or someone announcing you're arrested. But it doesn't. You've been detained? You have been arrested. The cops zero obligation to tell you anything and they never have had such obligation.
As to whether it was illegal? The police have wide latitude to determine probable cause for whatever. You're right this kind of thing happens all the time, you're right it's despicable. But sadly, it's broadly legal and more or less the "normal" way the law works.
If you read the wikipedia article, it describes rights but you will notice the only limits in the US is how long you can be held and whether your statements can held against you (at which point you are supposed to be read you're right, except for limitless exceptions to this requirement).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrest
- DrScump 11y ago<The police have wide latitude to determine probable cause for whatever> No, they have wide latitude to try to claim probable cause but cannot create probable cause out of thin air. If a court later decides there was none, the evidence is tossed anyway (and permanently tainted).
- joe_the_user 11y agoPolice are indeed prohibited from claiming probable cause based on no evidence at all but no-evidence-at-all is about the only no-no. A wide variety of vague actions can be taken as evidence, such "acting nervous", not seeming like you belong in a location, reaching into one's pocket, moving quickly, etc, etc.
- talmand 11y agoThere is a procedural difference between being detained and being arrested.