4 ms·
The future you imagine will have very few animals in it. I love animals, so I am glad they serve so many useful purposes, since otherwise the cost of feeding, s
by 1123581321 11y ago
The future you imagine will have very few animals in it. I love animals, so I am glad they serve so many useful purposes, since otherwise the cost of feeding, sheltering and caring for them would be enormous. Raising a token number in preserves is not an equitable substitute.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> The future you imagine will have very few animals in it. It would have just as many wild animals in it. Keeping those alive in the face of human expansion and industry is, of course, a whole different problem than animal rights. > I love animals, so I am glad they serve so many useful purposes, since otherwise the cost of feeding, sheltering and caring for them would be enormous. I'm a meat-eater and that still doesn't make sense to me. It sounds like what you love isn't animals, but biomass.
- 1123581321 11y agoYou're imagining that an animal lover has unlimited resources. I'm saying that since caring for animals (on an individual and species/ecological level) takes a lot of time and money, I'm glad animals are useful during and after their life, because otherwise it's difficult or impossible to sustain caring for animals in significant numbers. Note that I'm not defending the typical Westerner loading up a grocery cart with chicken breasts. There are a lot of things wrong with the meat industry on the supply and the demand side.
- TaylorAlexander 11y agoWhat you say is true only if you assume we will continue to ignore and extingush the natural world in favor of human habitats. There are efforts to make space for Earth's non human animals to live in the wild. See, for example, E.O. Wilson's work: http://eowilsonfoundation.org/e-o-wilson-on-saving-half-the-earth/ http://eowilsonfoundation.org/e-o-wilson-on-saving-half-the-... Also, only a small number of species are bred for food or other resources. I think there's less than 20 types of animals bred for farming. Re-wilding 50% of the earth meanwhile would provide food and shelter to all animal species.
- 1123581321 11y agoTwo thoughts: I certainly hope that technology and space colonization can expand the definition of animal preserve. However, Wilson's proposals are fantastic and don't factor the benefits animals gain from symbiotic living with humans. And I believe there are several problems with overly specialized diets, not just that we're willing to preserve only a few species in significant numbers. It would be very good for world hunger if the west began to eat more kinds of meat again.
- mrob 11y agoThe vast majority of animal suffering happens to wild animals. If your reason for supporting animal rights is to reduce suffering (not the only possible reason) then eliminating wild animals is not a bad thing: http://foundational-research.org/the-importance-of-wild-animal-suffering/ http://foundational-research.org/the-importance-of-wild-anim...
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoReading that article was a serious WTF. The basic argument is that most animals are insects, small fish etc. which live lives so short that they do not have the time to experience enough pleasure to compensate for the pain of death. I believe this is the worst kind of bike shedding, as it detracts from the very important discussion on actual human influences on actual animal welfare.
- mrob 11y agoPreventing wild animal suffering is much more difficult than preventing suffering in captive animals. We don't understand nature well enough to make major changes without risk of making things worse. Therefore it's a reasonable choice to focus on captive animals. I don't see how awareness of a difficult problem prevents work on the easier one.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThe point I was trying to make is: do we really believe insect suffering is a larger problem than mammal suffering? The author of the article linked above implements some moral calculus where insect suffering is weighted lower, but since there is such a huge number of insects, they still end up concluding that insect suffering is a huge problem. My claim is that instead it's correct to give zero weight to insect suffering, since it's not a "difficult problem", it's a literally unsolvable problem. Well, the only way to solve it would be to exterminate all insects in order to end their cycle of suffering, and that would entail so much destruction and ecosystem collapse it would literally render the entire earth barren and lifeless. TL;DR: when someone claims we have a big problem where the only possible solution is killing all living organisms on planet Earth, I say they're wrong: that what they claim is a problem is, in fact, not a problem.