4 ms·
Interesting, but I'd start with a Linux program for educational purposes. It wouldn't assume one must have Windows to run it. > First things first, let me just
by shmerl 11y ago
Interesting, but I'd start with a Linux program for educational purposes. It wouldn't assume one must have Windows to run it.
> First things first, let me just warn you that this is not a beginners tutorial to rendering APIs. I assume you have some experience with something like OpenGL or DirectX and you are here just to get to know the particularities of Vulkan.
Is there some book / tutorial that both introduces rendering APIs to beginners and is using Vulkan for it at the same time?
- slimsag 11y agoThere might be more game devs using Windows than Linux, just due to market share, so I'd say Windows was the right choice here.
- shmerl 11y agoI think educational materials should have different considerations than just market share. But that's my personal opinion.
- sbarre 11y agoThis is a strange thing to say. Educational materials are of the most value when they reach their largest relevant audience. In this case, the largest relevant audience for this kind of thing at the moment is probably game developers, and most of them target Windows in their work. Are you suggesting this material should have been developed in a way that is less relevant to that largest audience? I don't see how that would be a good idea. Perhaps you are getting tripped up on the phrase "market share", thinking only of it in a commercial context, when it simply meant targeting the largest segment of users who will find this useful.
- bottled_poe 11y ago> most of them target Windows in their work Windows? I would have guessed iOS as the top target platform.
- Narishma 11y agoiOS doesn't support Vulkan.
- bottled_poe 11y agoThat doesn't seem relevant to the argument about largest game development target platform.
- shmerl 11y ago> This is a strange thing to say. That's a normal thing to say. One shouldn't assume student has to pay a tax to learn (i.e. Windows tax). It's inappropriate.
- corysama 11y agoOne shouldn't assume that they must. But, one can look at the stats to observe that they have. Linux is still sitting at 0.9% on the Steam hardware survey. By trying to be inclusive in theory, you would be excluding 99% of the audience in practice.
- shmerl 11y ago>One shouldn't assume that they must. But, one can look at the stats to observe that they have. You have stats about students? Where is it published? You can't use Steam for measuring education metrics. Anyway, apparently the author wanted to provide tutorials for different OSes. My point was that he could focus on Linux first, and that would have been a proper educational choice as I explained above.
- SolarNet 11y agoVulkan is brand new it's going to take a while to filter down. This is the first "advanced" level tutorial I've even seen for it. And it doesn't even talk about rendering with Vulkan, which is way more complicated than just using OpenGL4 (and requires an advanced knowledge of OpenGL or another modern GL). Let alone doing Vulkan specific rendering techniques, which are still being explored. OpenGL is like the C std/runtime library. Vulkan is like calling the kernel functions directly without wrapping code.
- marmaduke 11y agoThere was little Windows specific code, and the point was to demonstrate Vulkan, not opening a window.
- shmerl 11y agoGood, the author even wrote that he is working on the Linux version of the tutorial. But it's given secondary priority, that was my point.