7 ms·
An Open Letter to Members of the W3C Advisory Committee
- Aelinsaar 11y agoFair enough, but shouldn't this letter be to Google and Apple and the other companies that are really making this happen?
- dannyobrien 11y agoThe W3C advisory committee is composed of representatives of all the members, including Google and Apple.
- oldgun 11y agoSeconded. These big companies along with the likes of Hollywood are the ones pushing w3c.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoYep. It's worth keeping the w3c in mind, but they're not the source of the pressure, just subject to it at overwhelming levels.
- gregmac 11y ago> We've proposed a simple solution, patterned after the existing W3C patent policy. The patent policy doesn't take a position on whether patents are good or bad, but it does hold that standards are more open if you don't have to license a patent to implement them, so W3C members are required to promise not to sue others for practicing their patents when implementing W3C recommendations. > Our proposal does the same thing, except for anti-circumvention rights (rather than patents). Members who participate in the Media Extensions Working Group will have to make a legally binding promise not to use anti-circumvention laws to aggress against security researchers or implementers. All other rights and causes of action -- trade secrecy, copyright, tortious interference, breach of contract -- are intact. This sounds like a reasonable compromise. Having a W3C standard that can't actually be implemented by anyone except those that are explicitly granted a license is not a standard: it's really just proprietary software, and feels like going back to the days of Flash, Java and Active-X applets, only worse, because it's a legal problem instead of a technical one. I'm definitely against the idea of DRM in any W3C standards without this type of provision, but I'm not sure if this is enough or not.
- tzs 11y agoWhat in the W3C EME standard cannot be freely implemented? As far as I know, EME is just a communications standard between the browser and components that are not part of the browser to allow those components to provide media data for the browser to display. EME can be used to communicate with proprietary DRM components, but those DRM components are not part of the standard, and there is nothing that I've seen in EME that makes DRM the only thing it can be used for. For instance, couldn't EME be used to make a system to protect the privacy of people sharing personal videos? Encrypt the video and upload to a web server that all the parties sharing have access to. Distribute the decryption keys to the people intended to share the video. Use EME to interface the browser to a component that uses that key to decrypt the video on the fly. From the browser's point of view there is not really any significant difference between a video that is encrypted for DRM and one that is encrypted for privacy. In the former case those who encrypted it want to keep the key secret from the viewer, whereas in the latter case they want to keep the key secret from third parties. To the browser, these look the same: there is encrypted video, and the browser needs something to decrypt that and hand it the decrypted data for it to display.
- morley 11y agoI have to say: I like this approach of offering an alternative far better thank a blanket "please don't do this thing because it's bad." Admittedly, I don't follow the EFF's actions as much as others, so maybe this is more common than I think, but it seems fresh to me. Their alternative seems like it could be palatable to a reasonable Media Extensions Working Group member (though I guess they could claim that the definition of a "security researcher or implementer" is unreasonably broad).
- bearcobra 11y agoAfter reading the discussion yesterday on the Save Firefox post [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11678516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11678516], I'm still unclear if EME is a compromise that provides a standard for proprietary DRM solutions to talk to any browser, or a backdoor that will allow media companies to remove user control and decide which browsers win. If it's the former, that feels like a good thing compared to the proprietary plug-in days of yore.
- TD-Linux 11y agoThe latter. The standard does not specify the interface that the DRM blobs talk to the browser, or even that it's an interface at all as opposed to a built in feature of a proprietary browser.
- hackuser 11y agoThe EFF's public communication is much improved recently, IMHO. Even with strong interest in these issues and with technical expertise, formerly I could hardly bear to make sense of their postings. This one still could use a tl;dr summary at the top, but the vast improvement is heartening - without good public messaging, their mission seemed very difficult. Now I feel like there's a chance.
- natch 11y ago> Working Group will have to make a legally binding promise not to use anti-circumvention laws to aggress against security researchers or implementers. (emphasis added above) OK EFF I love you, but when did you start leaving end users off of your list of people you want to protect against litigious aggression? Regular end users want to do fair-use things like pause and download too, without being sued, right?
- hungnv 11y agoat first I guess it'd be great, finally eff found a solution that any companies can implement their own security layer that's compliant with new standard and EME, but it's not. Even if W3C accepted this open letter and changed, there would be nothing changed at all.
- zer00eyz 11y agoBecause of this article and comments here, I went to look at what w3c membership, and donations look like. https://www.w3.org/Consortium/fees?countryCode=US&quarter=04-01&year=2016#results https://www.w3.org/Consortium/fees?countryCode=US&quarter=04... Ultimately the w3c is doing something that is in the best interest of its participants and NOT in the interest of users, or consumers. In this document ( http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Process/Process-19991111/background.html http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Process/Process-19991111/backgr... ) the w3c claims: "W3C is a non-profit organization funded partly by commercial members. Its activities remain vendor neutral, however." Yet I can find no US IRS 990, or foreign equivalent. Fundamentally this structure doesn't look like a non profit. It also doesn't look like it has the best interests of the community (us) as a whole in mind. IANAL but I have to wonder if it is possible to challenge the w3c on its continued use of "non-profit". I also wonder if there is a way to put pressure on them to allow non profit orgianzations free access to these committees outside of collecting a fee from them, as it strikes me as an un-needed burden.