9 ms·
It’s a Tough Job Market for the Young Without College Degrees
- alvern 11y agoIssac Cordoso, who is graduating from Medford Vocational Technical High School in Massachusetts in June, already has a job lined up as an electrical apprentice, earning $12 an hour. He is also applying for a coveted spot as an apprentice with the local electrical union, where the starting pay is $18.25 an hour. As an apprentice, he could work while training to become a journeyman, a position with an hourly wage of $28. Most of Mr. Cordoso’s classmates also have jobs waiting for them, he said. So whomever hired Cordoso on as an apprentice is saving $6.25 an hour in wages over a union apprentice. And they'll have to hire him on at $18-24 an hour once he's competent to keep him from jumping ship.
- edc117 11y agoAssuming they can't get him to settle for even less. This is another unfortunate side effect of the situation; those with jobs on offer can drive wages even lower because there's so much competition for positions. 'Well, you're correct, normally we pay 18$ an hour, but the economy...'
- hvo 11y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11671933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11671933
- pcr0 11y agoOnly 10 percent of 17- to 24-year-olds have a college or advanced degree I get that they're trying to capture the demographic of recent high school grads, but pushing it to something like 21-27 would give more realistic figures, and avoid conflating the figure too much with current college students.
- odonnellryan 11y agoI agree. Lots of my friends have gotten degrees, but many spent five or six years in college for various reasons. So, they didn't graduate until 23 or 24.
- cableshaft 11y agoYeah, looks like a default demographic option they copy pasted from a different survey, but of course at least 50% of that number shouldn't be expected to have degrees yet, so it's a misleading statistic.
- z4chj 11y agoIt is probably safe to assume that just about 0 percent of people under the age of 20 have a college degree (not including the few savants who graduate high school before turning 18), which essentially makes this statistic useless. It gets even worse when you take into account the commonly understood fact that it takes many students more than 4 years to complete a degree. This attempt at using a statistic that does not make sense in context really degrades the value of the entire article and makes it seem like the nations youth is worse off than it actually may be.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> not including the few savants who graduate high school before turning 18 I graduated high school before turning 18. I never skipped a grade at any point. My final year of high school consisted of taking four classes, of which three were taken only because they were graduation requirements: "English 12", "History 12", and "Acting 3". It may shock and surprise you to hear that the content of "English 12" and "History 12" was not appreciably different from any other "english" or history classes at the school. In particular, they were not different from "English 8" and "History 8", except in that they counted toward the UC "four years of high-school-level english and history classes" requirement and the "* 8" classes technically didn't. It doesn't take a savant to graduate before turning 18. All it takes is realizing that staying in high school is stupid.
- Bartweiss 11y ago
- brink 11y agoThis was posted yesterday..
- sageabilly 11y ago"Even so, the economic recovery has progressed more slowly for young high school graduates than for those coming out of college." I'd imagine this has something to do with the job pool coming out of the recession being heavily seeded with people who already have degrees or degrees plus working experience. Economy takes a nosedive, people get laid off- so when the economy is on the upswing, those with degrees and working experience will be the first to get hired again. I'd be curious about pre-recession numbers of high school grad employment vs. now, post-recession. "He added that vocational schools should no longer be thought of as dead ends, since they can serve as steppingstones to associate degrees at community colleges or to enrollment at four-year institutions." I also think it's a tremendous disadvantage to say "Oh yeah, vocational school can get to you an associate's or a college degree" because at some point we have GOT to stop acting like a college degree is the be-all-end-all. We cannot keep protesting against the tremendous student loan debt burden that's creeping ever bigger on the one hand while touting college degrees as being the ONLY way to get a high-paying "respectable" job. Not to mention there are a shitton of services out there that you don't need a college degree for that are for jobs which are highly skilled and that pay well. There's always going to be a need for welders, plumbers, electricians, mechanics, crane operators, etc etc etc. These are jobs that are absolutely necessary for society to function as a whole- and I think it's really dumb how at some point these jobs were downgraded to being for "dumb people" or people who weren't "rich or smart enough" to go to college.
- FussyZeus 11y ago> I'd be curious about pre-recession numbers of high school grad employment vs. now, post-recession. Don't forget automation, which is behind a lot of the discrepancy between recovered business sales/overall production figures while the jobs numbers lag behind. Automation means fewer employees getting more work done. > I also think it's a tremendous disadvantage to say "Oh yeah, vocational school can get to you an associate's or a college degree" because at some point we have GOT to stop acting like a college degree is the be-all-end-all. This times a THOUSAND, I know plenty of people who make really good money and left their vocational schools with useful, in-demand skills and practically no debt. (I'm a little jealous TBH, though I still prefer my desk job.)
- 11y ago
- clamprecht 11y agoAfter reading PG's Submarine[0], I wonder if this is going to be a recurring PR push, backed by some association of US colleges. [0] http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- donatj 11y agoTalking to relatives who can't find jobs, "How many jobs did you apply for today?" and the reply is inevitably "well, none". How are you expecting to find a job when you don't apply? I applied for five to ten jobs a day when I got out of trade school. I was unemployed so I certainly had the time. It took almost six months to get someone to take a chance on me. The trick to getting a good job without a degree is to get someone, anyone, to take a chance on you. You will be underpaid until you prove yourself but it will cost you less than a degree in the long run.
- sweezyjeezy 11y agoThis is anecdotal advice to say the least...
- cm3 11y agoI've learned first-hand that these days software teams don't seem to take a chance and do not use the probationary period to see if someone is a good fit. You go through four or 6 interviews and then one of the 8 or so people you've interviewed with has a bad feeling about you and that seals the deal. It's like they don't have a probationary period and want to hire you unlimited, full-time from day one. Even the most impressive psychological bullshitter can and will be revealed as a bad fit in the first month, so why not take a chance on someone who seems capable and socially compatible while being down to earth (aka no bullshit artist). What I've learned is to not be totally honest in interviews and keep my concerns to myself when asked.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> You go through four or 6 interviews and then one of the 8 or so people you've interviewed with has a bad feeling about you and that seals the deal. Then they get on Hacker News later that day and complain about how hard it is to find people and how hot the job market is right now.
- cm3 11y agoYeah, I'm always amused when large corps complain about missing workforce and about needing 50.000 software developers in Germany. But if you went looking they either don't want developers but PhD's who've heard of C++ or much worse just cheap labor. The latest was Volkswagen making news right after the software scandal that they're planning to hire 38.000 developers. No idea what tasks they want to put that many developers on and I'm not sure if I should be scared or skeptical.
- pigpaws 11y agomeh - this applies only to people who are looking to do things that they think require a degree. Plumbers and Electricians don't need degrees. There also persists (for various reasons) that the 'younger generations' don't want to put their dues in, that they want to start at the top. (holding out for a management position). You want to code? Great! take a job doing something else while you code on the side. You want to help people learn 4th Century Prussian Interpretive Dance? fine, take a different job as a step-stone to that. the point being, you don't need some bloated, under-educated piece of paper to get a job - or even the job you want. You just have to work harder to get there, something that people just don't want to do anymore. No one wants to start 'in the mail room' anymore.
- artmageddon 11y ago> No one wants to start 'in the mail room' anymore. I think part of the problem is that jobs are tighter and tighter these days and the proverbial mail room may not be open for work.
- bluejellybean 11y agoPeople either don't know about or really don't want to do a lot of jobs. Example, good friend of mine started mopping blood in a hospital, working his way up (making good money too!), he has been able to pay for school and live a good life.. The jobs are out there, they just require you to find them ( and sometimes also require that you have the stomach for it ).
- pigpaws 11y agonot true - there are PLENTY of low-level or entry level 'jobs out there', but people today are SO spoiled that they don't want to take those jobs because they are seen as beneath them. Why can't someone have a job at McDonald's while you take a non-paid internship at a BioTech company? or study for Chemical Engineering? or code at night? Are you honestly telling me that there is a shortage of burger-flippers, janitors and building engineers out there? A "Job" is not hard to find - you just have to be willing to swallow your pride and take it, and use it as a stepping stone to get to the next position. Knowledge comes from books. Wisdom comes from experience. "WORK" is a four-letter word, both literally and figuratively. AWS has a free tier specifically to play on, to learn. MIT and other universities have FREE online classes. an education is not hard to get.
- iamthepieman 11y agoAmong 17- to 24-year-olds, just over 10 percent have completed college or achieved an advanced degree. assuming a student enters college right out of high school when they are between 18 and 19 and graduates when they are between 22 and 23, only the 24 year olds in that statistic are even slightly anomalous. The rest could be getting their degrees or not even entered college yet. That statistic is beyond useless to the point of being misleading and disingenuous. Of course a 17 year old has not completed an advanced degree. It's like saying that only 5% of 10-year-olds are 6 feet or taller.
- molotok 11y agoEven though this is a dupe story, I was unable to find a decent answer to the following question in the original comments. I am a recent grad in a non-(CS/physics/math/eng) discipline, where I just got to discover enough coding to get hooked but not enough to actually acquire it as a marketable skill. I have carried enough interest through to take it up as a serious after work hobby and am learning by doing small projects in Python and a few other languages that I am trying out (I was advised Python as a good gateway drug). I would like to work in software development, but am realistically behind hordes of recent CS grads who look incomparably better on paper (and are for the most part better than me skills-wise at this point). As a result I had to take a job in another area, but still have my ambition to be a dev, probably a web dev. My question is this: what course of action would you advise I take to get in? Is this even a sensible goal? I am continuously working on my skills going to meetups/dojos and working on projects alone and with other people, but at what point can I realistically try my luck in the job market, what sort of job could I realistically target and is this even a sensible thing to do with my 20s?
- RawData 11y agoYou probably have the skills now to get hired. You're not going to get hired at Google or Facebook or anyplace like that with their insane hiring practices...but there are a ton of other companies that would probably be glad to have you. Just be upfront about your experience, show them projects you've completed, be enthusiastic...find recruiters and start taking phone calls and see!
- zafka 11y agoI think you are on the right path. If you enjoy playing with bits, and do so in your spare time, you will get better. I would guess that about 50% of the folks who took CS did so not out of interest, but because they thought it was the "right" career. You will surely have an edge on those folks. Come up with projects you can build for yourself. Soon you be so good, folks will want to hire you.
- zafka 11y agoAs a side note, I slid out of my first weekend in college,and ended up first getting an Electrical Journeyman's license at age 31. Then work dried up in FL, and I went back to school and picked up a computer engineering degree at 36. I missed the fast track, but I have had a lot of fun.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoI have several nephews that are between 18-23 age. It's pretty surprising the amount of opportunity they have to get into the workplace and just are not motivated. Getting into a skilled trade is a great career path. I have a co-worker whose son went to vo-tech for welding, got hired by one of the largest construction companies (they're building the USA Bank Stadium in Minneapolis) and is now making close to 50K, with no kids and he's not married, so he's pretty set. When I talk with my nephews, they complain they're broke and can't move out from their families house, but don't want to go to a coding boot camp, or go to a Vo-Tech and learn a trade. They just don't see either as a very "glamorous" career, so they reject it out of hand - which is puzzling. So they work several part time jobs, live at home and have no "launch date" to either go to a 4 year school, or get into something that would give them a solid career path. I'd also like to point out, its always been tough for young kids to get into the job market without college degrees. Even if you were learning a trade, it took years to go from apprentice to journeyman to master. Even when I was in college (mid aughts) I had many friends who didn't go to college and couldn't get a whiff of stable corporate gig. They would always go interview and the guy would say, "You have a great resume, you'd probably do well here, but you need a 4 year degree. Go get your degree and I'll hire you immediately." They were relegated to jumping around between small mom and pop shops that didn't have the stability of a larger corporation. Every couple of years they were on the move.
- cableshaft 11y ago> I'd also like to point out, its always been tough for young kids to get into the job market without college degrees. No it wasn't, you're just not going back far enough. The 2000s (when you said you went to school) isn't far back enough. We're talking 1950's, 60's, 70's, 80's it definitely wasn't tough for a young person to get a job without a degree. 90's is when that started to change. My dad actually quit going to college in the late 70's because grocery store jobs (cashier, stocking) were easy to get and were paying better than what he could expect with what he was studying in college. That's definitely not true anymore.
- roflchoppa 11y agoI was never given the opportunity to try machine-shop, or woodworking in highschool, those classes were already removed from schooling around the time I got there. But it would have been a nice path for me to get a AWS certification in welding. I'm surprised that these have been removed from curriculum, there is a pretty high value in these classes in terms of exposure and training for skilled work... Hopefully it is brought back at some point with the explosion of interest DIY, it would be cool to see an engineering course that offers exposure to different fields (mechanical // chemical // fabrication // failure identification). Which in turn would really drive interest into engineering not as a "major" but as an ideological mindset. I think I'm starting to ramble...
- oldmanjay 11y agoIt's a tough job market for anyone who can't differentiate their skills from the pack. That's not a big, it's the feature that incentivizes people to skill up.
- SmellTheGlove 11y agoIt's a tough job market for the young with college degrees. A lot of large companies are displacing (firing) experienced talent in an effort to get cheaper, and it's putting a lot of experienced, talented people back in the market. Many companies are simply hiring experience for not a ton more money (since they're now unemployed) over entry level. At my company (fortune 500, not a tech company), I've been very involved in internship and entry level hiring since I remember how hard it was for me to land my first post-college job in 2004. We've had layoffs, and I don't see the strength in our internship and entry level programs that I did even last year - and we're a healthy company. Anyhow, first post, don't beat me to death :)
- Spooky23 11y agoHigh school grad is the new dropout. Even factory assembly work requires post-high school education. IMO, this is more reflective of the shift of high school towards 4-year college prep than rather than changes in the marketplace.
- neap24 11y agoWhat's even more alarming to me is that, in some industries, it is becoming tough get a job with just a Batchelor's degree. I work at a private high school where 70-80% of teachers have a Master's or PhD...most of whom couldn't get hired at a university.
- Bartweiss 11y agoThis is definitely a concern, but depending on your state education is a distorted market. Where I grew up, 8-12 educators (even most private ones) had to have a teaching degree and a subject matter degree. As a result, pretty much all of them had either a subject Bachelor's and an advanced degree in teaching, or a teaching BS and a subject Masters. A double major would have been fine, but that's rare. The regulatory landscape had basically enforced teaching as a two-degree profession.
- hlfw0rd 11y agoThis greatly depends on the industry. I dropped out of high school after my freshman year and have never had any issue finding a job as a software engineer or project manager. I haven't even been asked about my education in 5 or 6 years. You just need to market yourself, be open to relocation and make your skill set seem like an asset to the companies you are applying too. This is an odd industry though.
- kyled 11y agoIt's easy, continually study what interests you. Start this while you are young. Work for smaller businesses that pay less, get the experience, and move on up. You could always try to start your own business too.
- Kinnard 11y agoI'm surprised the uncollege hasn't had more success tackling this. It started out as a mass movement and has now morphed into a gap-year program.
- tyingq 11y agoI wonder if there's room for an entrepreneur program for young people that are suited to that sort of thing. Something that would help boostrap lower cost / lower risk businesses they could start, training, bookkeeping, mentors, access to small loans, etc. There are some small businesses that are fairly immune to failure provided the owner has some amount of hustle. Things like becoming an in-home daycare provider, cleaning windows at small businesses, mobile pet grooming, power washing, etc. If there were some way to vet specific skills of the applicant, you could a few more to that list as well. I suppose it wouldn't make a huge dent, as only some fraction of the kids would be suitable for that sort of thing. But, it seems worthwhile to me.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWorkforce demographics and employment data is one of the few US economic indicators that I consistently see ZeroHedge covering well and putting into context. What I mean by this is their coverage of how the 55+ age group has been cannabalizing job openings from the youth is readily apparent in their routinely updated chart. The following version was updated alongside their 5/6/16 article: http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2016/04/20/Jobs%20old%20vs%20young.jpg http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/im...
- mattmcknight 11y agoI think Mike Rowe's foundation[1] is really a good idea towards solving this disconnect. He's putting scholarships together for the training necessary to do "blue collar" work. Heard about it on the Tim Ferriss podcast. Be nice if the government was doing this instead of supporting more degrees in subjects that don't allow the recipients to provide value to others. [1]http://profoundlydisconnected.com/ http://profoundlydisconnected.com/
- awt 11y agoCollege as it was perhaps even 50 or 75 years ago is necessary. What passes for college today is not all that helpful.
- Kurimo 11y ago"10% of 17-24 year olds have a college degree..." No shit! When you include 17-21 year olds who have not been in college long enough to get a 4 year degree (and barely a two year degree for 20-21 year olds) the numbers sure look a lot lower! Great reporting New York Times... wonder why you're struggling with top notch number manipulation like that!
- adrenalinelol 11y agoAnd they are in the "gold standard" tier of journalism...
- SilasX 11y agoHow shameful, to be 17 without a college degree /s
- evansibok 11y agoTo many jobs, to little qualified candidates but nothing a hacker can't fix.
- aries1980 11y agoI think what matters is how much value you can make. If you can explain you would make 2X of your employment cost, and your reasons are sound, it won't matter who you are any more.