4 ms·
I think everyone is right to be suspicious of payment for order flow, on the surface it does seem hard to get the incentives right. That said, in your scenario
by kasey_junk 11y ago
I think everyone is right to be suspicious of payment for order flow, on the surface it does seem hard to get the incentives right.
That said, in your scenario (you were prevented from trading) how does anyone make money? You were (probably) paying for a trade (which did not happen) and you were using infrastructure that costs money (placing orders), and no one was able to trade against you. That is not a great business model...
Also, none of the groups we are talking about are banks.
- dguaraglia 11y agoMy guess is that the algorithm doesn't expect to make money out of that particular order, but rather guesses this is a bigger order that is being split (laddered if you will) into multiple small orders at different acceptable limits. The product I used (Interactive Brokers interface) offers that laddering strategy as an option when trying to make big purchases. Oh, and BTW, order cancellations cost money. Cents, sure, but when you are making money on a 1c spread, you would also benefit from a 1c cancellation. Other than that, I've been tempted (and many times succumbed) to raise the limit just to get that trade. And then you see the price go up again before your order goes through. It'd be hilarious if it wasn't infuriating.
- tptacek 11y agoJust chiming in to point out that 'yummyfajitas, 'chollida1, and 'kasey_junk are all current or former trading engineers.
- dguaraglia 11y agoI imagined as much. That's what I love about HN, you do get some details on how the sausage is made from the sausage-makers themselves.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoMy guess is that the algorithm doesn't expect to make money out of that particular order, but rather guesses this is a bigger order that is being split (laddered if you will) into multiple small orders at different acceptable limits. If the order is coming from a retail brokerage that's a terrible guess - how often do you think someone goes into ETrade and tries to move $20M of GOOG? Big orders come from institutional investors. Those are explicitly the orders that market makers are trying NOT to trade against, and that's why they try to buy order flow. Order flow is known to come from players who aren't making big orders.
- dguaraglia 11y agoAs I clarified on the other comment, I meant "big" as in "retail big" (i.e. a couple thousand shares of TSLA, or any order big enough to be fulfilled by matching several sell orders.) I can't really recall that many of my orders being filled below my limit price, unless I was willing to increase the limit by a few cents over the NBBO. If the ask price for a security is, say, 5.51 and I put my limit at 5.51 the chances of getting the order filled were pretty low. If I was willing to go to 5.53 the chances would increase, if the order was 5.55, I'd probably get a fulfilled order at an average price of 5.53 or so. Not a huge difference on small orders (say 1000x2c = $20) but enough to make a "big" volume, small spread strategy pretty much useless.
- mrchicity 11y agoThe price can change from the time you place your order to when it arrives at the broker. This is especially likely if you are an active trader chasing news or momentum where others are likely trying to buy at the same time. It's like aiming a rocket, or in your case, an old Honda Civic, at a fading star. Have you looked at what the book state was after you placed your order in the cases where you don't fill? If you have a working order priced through the market that's unfilled, take a screenshot and name & shame your broker here.
- klipt 11y agoSuppose you place a limit order to sell STCK for $x and I only execute it (giving you $x) if the price goes above $x+1. Someone's making $1 on that spread and it definitely isn't you.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIf I accept a limit order from you to sell for $x and the price goes down to $x-1, someone lost $1 and it sure wasn't you. All you've discovered is that when you sell a stock, you lose both the upside and the downside.
- klipt 11y agoNo, the broker can just not execute the limit order. There's never downside for the market makers.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoYou are confusing "accept a limit order" with "purchasing a call option". Once you've accepted the order you are legally obligated to deliver in T+3 days. If you fail to deliver you pay big penalties, your broker shuts you down, all sorts of bad things.
- klipt 11y agoIn my experience with brokers like Schwab, placing a limit order is no guarantee of execution, even if the market price reaches the price specified in the limit order.
- tptacek 11y agoI think you're again confusing terminology; you're referring to placing an order, which is obviously no guarantee of execution, and Chris is referring to what happens after your order is executed.