6 ms·
> I think the consensus in the grown-up business world is "fire immediately for cause." Not in my experience, and it's not the law (as taught in the myriad of
by falcolas 11y ago
> I think the consensus in the grown-up business world is "fire immediately for cause."
Not in my experience, and it's not the law (as taught in the myriad of training courses I've endured over the years). The man should have an opportunity to learn from this mistake, then be fired when he proves incapable of learning.
Providing the warning and training is enough to legally cover the company's ass if the guy screws up again.
Yes, it's a big mistake to make, but when your hiring pool is predominately college graduates, it's pretty likely they don't know the law (or how to navigate romance in the workplace) either. Time to educate them.
EDIT: It's also important to get the other side of the story; why did this guy feel it was appropriate to approach the woman in the first place? Were there conversations not included in the record? Was there body language the man misinterpreted?
- NateDad 11y agoIt's not a mistake. He didn't leave the server room door open. He called her a MILF.... TO HER FACE. He's not 12 (I assume). If he hasn't learned to be respectful to women before now, it's not this guy's job to teach him.
- falcolas 11y agoPer the side of the story we know. Do you know something not present in this narrative? The use of 'milf', whether it's derogatory or a compliment, will depend entirely on the context of the larger conversation. Something we don't have. Something which apparently the OP didn't have either.
- icebraining 11y agoAnd she felt so flattered that she went to her boss to show him the texts?
- kstrauser 11y agoThat's the clincher for me. If she'd enjoyed that - and it's at least conceivable that someone would take it as a compliment - then the boss wouldn't know and no harm would be done. Remember, it's perfectly legal to date your coworkers. You can ask them out and everything! But the moment they move to stop your advances, you must cease immediately. It sounds like she was at least initially open to out-of-work conversation (as evidenced by her agreeing to switch to WhatsApp), but once she become uncomfortable it should have ended. Acceptable: You: We should go out sometime. I've never asked before, but would you be interested? Your colleague (NOT subordinate): No. You: OK, back to business. Hey, what time did they move our meeting to? Not acceptable: You: I know I ask you this daily, but... You: I'm not really supposed to date people who report to me, but... You: We went out one time and you broke it off, but... You: This was OK last week before you asked me to stop, but...
- NateDad 11y agoNo one makes up stories like this. They're ALWAYS TRUE. Plus, she probably can show him history on whatsapp (if it supports that, I don't know). MILF is NEVER a compliment to a stranger. It's NEVER a compliment to a friend you just met. It's probably a bad idea even if you're in her bedroom and both stripping down about to have sex. The only time it's sorta safe to call someone a milf is if you were the one who made her a Mom, and even then, it's VERY situational. Basically, just don't.
- sathackr 11y agoWait, so if I go to your boss and tell him you called me a MILF, it's true? It's not completely implausible there is an ulterior motive. And she is well protected if there is. He, on the other hand is not. None of us know enough about the situation to make a determination in either direction.
- NateDad 11y agoIf you're a woman, yes, it's probably true. Like 10,000,000:1 chance. If the boss has known me for a long time and it seems completely out of character for me (which it would be), then maybe he talks to me about it to see WTF is up. But some dude who just got hired? Assuming there's no record and no witnesses? You have to go with the vastly more likely case that he did it. If that gets 1 in 10,000,000 guys unfairly fired, but gets 9,999,999 guys justly fired, that's a pretty good outcome in my book.
- kohanz 11y agoPlease provide one example of using the term "MILF" in a professionally appropriate way.
- walrus01 11y agoWhen you work for an intelligence agency, federal law enforcement, customs/immigration or something like that (or a private sector contractor for them), and the topic of discussion is the MILF? the MILF is a violent organization that has been known to cut off peoples' heads... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moro_Islamic_Liberation_Front https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moro_Islamic_Liberation_Front
- oldmanjay 11y agoAs the director of an "American Pie" franchise entry.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat was too great given the asker probably thought a correct answer was impossible. Lmao.
- sheepleherd 11y agoplease have the parser accept the following ASCII formatted unix stream: FirstName LF MI LF LastName LF except don't allow trailing whitespaces at the ends of lines so more like FirstNameLF MILF LastNameLF *if she's a MILF, definitely get her first and last name... did I just ruin it?
- nkrisc 11y agoThe context is irrelevant. Whether or not it was intended as a compliment, or even received as a compliment does not matter. It was inappropriate for the workplace.
- wernercd 11y agoIf this was "after hours" between two adults? Was it a couple comments, that got rebuffed (You think I'm cute? Thank you, but I'm not interested) and was then dropped? Was it repeated comments that continued after "she" said no? I wouldn't use those terms with someone at work, during working hours... I wouldn't think it's earth ending to compliment someone after hours, outside of the work place (The terminology is a bit strong for my tastes, but assuming it is intended to be "complementary"... depending on how "comfortable" I was with someone, I might use similar terms if I "read the situation" as "she might be interested") I'm all for "fire for harassment"... but is this really harassment (continued after refusal)? Or is this a one time thing that happened when hanging out after hours that ended upon request? "Context is irrelevant" is a bit short sighted, because context - and responses of all involved - is completely relevant..
- nerd-fight 11y agoHitting on a fellow employee after work hours with a tinder-esque technique is grounds for termination. The female employee has little recourse to stop the advance, and has not approved it. Workplace courtship protocol requires slow, deliberate advancement with explicit ACKs from the receiver.
- UK-Al05 11y agoYou have no absolutely idea, who started the tinder-esque technique. For all you know, she could have been calling him a dirty stud, a day earlier. If this true? Would you then fire her? This is why, you need both sides of the story before you can do a "with cause" firing.
- nerd-fight 11y ago
- maxcan 11y agoIt's almost certainly inappropriate. That doesn't, however, mean he needs to be fired on the spot.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 11y ago" He called her a MILF.... TO HER FACE. He's not 12 (I assume)" Good point. This kind of person will probably need more self-improvement lessons than most companies can justify investing in him. Plus likely cause other headaches. Best to get rid of him if claims are true.
- maxcan 11y agoIts a shame to see how aggressively this is being down-voted. All you're saying is to take a step back and try to improve the behavior before firing the guy. Face to face dialogue, communication, etc etc is much more likely to prevent this in the future. Just firing him is kicking the can down the road to the next company.
- tptacek 11y agoSo, instead, you pick up the can, and have a stern talk with the guy, have him sign some paperwork, and move on. Later, the guy makes untoward comments to someone on a PIP. You don't find out he did this until after you terminate the PIP person, and they sue you. Right in the middle of your next fundraising effort.
- maxcan 11y agoI personally believe that short of committing a felony, every employee gets a warning first. I'm not going to be held hostage by the abstract threat of frivolous lawsuits. And yes, with everything including the PIP being documented, that would be a frivolous lawsuit.
- tptacek 11y agoTwice in my career I've seen sexual harassment claims raised at a company I worked for after someone departed the company, and twice I've been led to believe the result was a very large cash settlement for the accuser. (Neither case occurred in a company I was in management at). If your firm has any money in the bank at all, the accuser's lawyer will take the case on contingency, knowing both that you are unlikely to prevail and that your likelihood of prevailing is besides the point because the case will cost a fortune to litigate and taken years to dispose of, during which time you will be frozen on any major business development moves. You can call these kinds of suits "frivolous" or "unfair" or anything else you'd like. I don't care, as long as you don't also call them "ineffective". I think there are better places for employees to learn basic standards of professional conduct than in a deposition.