12 ms·
Amazon Targets YouTube with New Online Video Posting Service
- tmaly 11y agoI love Amazon, but I wish they would integrate more with other companies. Did they really need to make their own app store? I own several kindles, and I was hoping to play a few learning videos for my child on the kindle fire. Well, the Youtube support is quite lacking. I am not sure if this new video venture will work out. Youtube has quite a bit of momentum, and it has far more support across the mainstream devices than anyone else. Vimeo is second place in my mind, but I have not watched a video on there in ages.
- Fogest 11y agoYou must not browse popular subreddits on reddit often. Vimeo is used there a lot for more professional kinds of videos from filmmakers and I see them a lot. There also has been A LOT of hate recently toward YouTube due to their pretty awful content id system. However even with the alternative I doubt people will switch. Too much work to switch to another platform and get the audience to move elsewhere. YouTube is working to fix the content id problem so likely people will go back to loving it and all will be the same. I doubt amazon will have much success, nor do I think they would do it any better than Google.
- RyJones 11y agothe short answer to your first question is yes. You can't get Google Play services (the store) without being Android, and there are some differences between FireOS and Android that support features of Kindle Fire but preclude the Kindle Fire from running straight CAF[0] Android. [0] https://www.codeaurora.org/ https://www.codeaurora.org/
- andybak 11y agoIt's fairly trivial to install Google Play and associated apps on the Fire and it can be done without rooting - just by sideloading an APK.
- RyJones 11y agoyou are correct, but Amazon cannot do that. The changes to Android are small but large enough that Amazon can't call Fire OS Android.
- Finnucane 11y ago"Did they really need to make their own app store?" Yes, they did. Not for your benefit, but for theirs. They're a retailer, and they want to control their own ecosystem. Does Walmart let Target have a corner of their stores to sell stuff in? No,they don't.
- Splines 11y agoThere are few real-world analogies for the vertical that is Amazon. We don't have brick and mortar construction companies that also are a retailer (as far as I know). Amazon is like a company that builds houses, and will only allow Amazon appliances inside the house, even though other appliances generally work fine. Your buddy across the street has a house made by Google, and their house can have any appliance, which kinda irks you.
- Finnucane 11y agoWell, not quite. The point is that you can't get anything for your Amazon "house" that Amazon isn't taking a cut from the sale. (And in ye olde days, there was a time when you could open the Sears, Roebuck catalog, and order, literally, a whole house and everything that needed to go inside it, and have it delivered to you.)
- eclipxe 11y agoYes, yes they did need to create their own Appstore.
- detaro 11y ago> Vimeo is second place in my mind, but I have not watched a video on there in ages. I see quite a few Vimeo videos, but never on their page, all as embeds on other sites.
- bduerst 11y agoSame. I was reading on a kindle yesterday and wanted to internet search a highlighted phrase. The kindle let me look it up in a dictionary, even search wikipedia, but no internet search.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoIs this going to be tied to Amazon's crappy app store as well so regular Android users won't use it?
- petra 11y agomaybe they'll make it available via sideloading from the web directly.
- Someone1234 11y agoIt is prime time for competitors of YouTube to come out of the woodwork. Everyone is incredibly tired of YouTube's bonkers copyright complaints system which has already resulted in many people moving to Twitch. To beat YouTube you essentially need to reproduce YouTube then create a more balanced playing field between content creators and copyright owners. At the moment the content creators exist in a "guilty until proven innocent world" where the copyright owner are the judge and jury too! It is bonkers, fair usage is dead on YouTube.
- fredley 11y agoThe real question is how would a competitor deal with the immense pressure from the music and film industry bodies? I mean, YouTube has nothing to gain from making life difficult for content creators - they are acting in this way because they have essentially been compelled to. If a competitor became popular enough, the same thing would happen.
- Someone1234 11y agoFor one thing they could require people to submit real DMCA notices. YouTube's system isn't DMCA-based, and as much as I dislike the DMCA, it still provides greater protections than YouTube's system does. That's how bad YouTube's draconian copyright system is, the DMCA is an "upgrade."
- fredley 11y agoIt's not to do with what the other options are though, the issue is that they have been forced to operate in the way they currently are. Commercially speaking the benefits to making the system fairer to creators are clear for YouTube - I am sure they are aware of just how unpopular their current systems are.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoNo, they are not. In fact they are aggressively defending themselves against the music industry (big-time manager Irving Azoff wrote and open letter yesterday) and claiming everything they do is awesome. Azoff points out their approach is actually more of a strong-arm tactic and, in some respects, an abuse of the DMCA, which YouTube chooses to simply shrug off. It's a contentious issue but making it sound like "poor little ol' YouTube is getting bullied!" is simply wrong, as they have serious profit motive to keep their questionable approach going as long as possible.
- CryoLogic 11y agoI run a popular YouTube educational channel (in the top 10 for it's niche) and have had some serious issues with YouTube that have nearly made me quit. I had a young (pre-teen) boy who filed copyright claims on several of my tutorials, and they where taken down instantly and took months to resolve via email. I lost about $1500 in revenues which was never returned. Beyond that, YouTube is taking a ~50% cut of your ad revenue AND any donation revenue on the site which seems pretty extreme. They also don't do good when it comes to new content discovery, as the YT search promotes mostly popular content (basically, bad for new creators).
- ececconi 11y agoWas the copyright claim against you a joke?
- CryoLogic 11y agoNo the kid had similar tutorial videos and I think he wanted to be above me in search.
- mratzloff 11y agoWere there any repercussions for his account?
- apocalyptic0n3 11y agoDoubtful. YouTube doesn't punish false claims. It's one of the reasons content creators are upset with YouTube.
- nkozyra 11y agoWouldn't this also be really easy to game? Create a new account solely to make the copyright complaints?
- 11y ago
- kmfrk 11y agoSomething like two months later, I still have not managed to get my custom YouTube URL. Everything to do with YouTube (which is completely filtered into G+) is a miserable experience, and I can't wait for more competition.
- TaylorGood 11y agoImplying you've met standard requirements, correct? Did you try "advanced" method of claiming ownership of URL to use name?
- kmfrk 11y agoI've tried just about anything, including contacting support who never got back. They've got this dumb system where you can claim a custom link, but it's youtube.com/c/TaylorGood[] where you have to fill in [] with something. It makes no goddamn sense, and if I do it, that's going to be the new permanent url, which I clearly don't want. Google are so clueless sometimes.
- thenomad 11y agoThis is HUGE for the independent film world. It's currently incredibly hard to sell an independent film online via a well-known and trusted channel that people are used to buying through. The nearest equivalent before this was getting onto iTunes through an aggregator, which costs $1500 or so per film. I'm tremendously happy Amazon have taken this step: it'll be a huge benefit for indie filmmakers.
- chx 11y agoInteresting. Isn't vimeo an avenue? https://vimeo.com/ondemand/startselling https://vimeo.com/ondemand/startselling
- thenomad 11y agoLast time I checked they required you to create an account before buying a film. That's an absolute conversion-killer. Also, there's a huge difference between most people's comfort level in buying from Amazon and buying from Some Random Site - and Vimeo still counts as Some Random Site for most people. (As does Gumroad and similar.) Finally, the discovery aspect is significant. People are searching Amazon for films to buy and watch. They, by and large, aren't searching Vimeo for that.
- infinitesoup 11y agoYouTube also allows users to sell or rent their videos directly through the website [0], so this doesn't seem very different to me. [0]: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/3249127?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/3249127?hl=en
- home_boi 11y agoNot exactly sure why but I personally feel more comfortable buying media from Amazon than from YouTube. I feel like I should be getting everything for free from YouTube.
- CobrastanJorji 11y ago
- ilamont 11y agoThe Amazon service requires close-captioning. Is that hard for video producers to set up?
- Buge 11y agoThere's free software that allows you to create subtitles/captions. For your average consumer who just wants to shoot a family video and upload it, that is a very large barrier to entry compared to youtube. For a high quality video creator who puts a lot of effort into editing videos, it's not much extra effort. This would be one way to ensure most videos are high quality.
- Splines 11y ago> This would be one way to ensure most videos are high quality. I'm not so sure of that - Amazon can't possibly police every single video to ensure correct closed-captioning. There are likely tools that can take a video, rip the audio stream and machine generate a subtitle file for you. If you have a person uploading a family video this will pass the "good enough" bar for you. You'd get something close to Youtube's automatic closed-captions.
- blakeyrat 11y agoThis service doesn't seem to be intended for family videos at all. AFAICT it's not even possible to upload a video without monetizing it.
- petra 11y agoIn the article they mention 15cents/6cents per hour. Is it considered a lot compared to ad revenue ?
- Buge 11y agoI have a video that got 17600 views and 25000 minutes watched according to youtube analytics. It made $22.50 from ads. So that comes out to 5.4 cents/hour.
- velohx 11y agoWhat happens if you make a super long video full of nothingness, does that scam the system? YouTube has tons of videos that are 10 hours long of silliness on repeat, like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZZ7oFKsKzY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZZ7oFKsKzY
- chx 11y agoI have pocket recorded (imagine the quality) a Les Miserables show in 2011 and uploaded to YouTube at the end of 2012 when it became clear a legal CD won't happen (it should've!). It was taken offline and a copyright strike lodged against me last week. Do they own the copyright? Sure! But there are no legal recordings of that particular cast. So tell me how was their business affected by my upload? Mind boggling.
- Buge 11y agoOne specific video doesn't affect the business much. But when a lot copyrighted stuff is uploaded unchecked, it does. They were sued for $1 billion by Viacom for copyright violation.
- talmand 11y agoA free version online would inhibit sales of any future releases if they choose to do so. Just because you can't legally purchase it today doesn't allow you to harm the future sales of tomorrow.
- chx 11y agoCan you name any musical releases five years after the show? That cast lasted only a year.
- elbigbad 11y agoThat's really not the point.
- chx 11y ago> Just because you can't legally purchase it today doesn't allow you to harm the future sales of tomorrow. There are no current or future sales. That's my point: if you are not releasing a specific recording then why do you have copyright over it?
- 11y ago
- jvolkman 11y agoPresumably I won't be able to watch the videos using my Chromecast.
- Buge 11y agoWhile Amazon Prime does not currently support the Chromecast, you should be able to at least cast the browser tab.
- westernmostcoy 11y agoThat is not an acceptable alternative, sadly. :(
- Grazester 11y agoYou would unfortunately have to take that up with Amazon
- westernmostcoy 11y agoYep, this is totally on them. It's led me to stop using their video products, and we're not renewing Prime after this period expires.
- blakeyrat 11y agoI agree it sucks, but you could have bought a Roku or something you knew already supported Amazon Prime in the first place instead of a Chromecast. It's not like there's never been competition in that space; Chromecast is a super-late-comer.
- westernmostcoy 11y agoI could have, although I've owned a few Roku boxes and they've all been slow, unresponsive and crash-prone. We actually upgraded from Roku to Chromecast. Amazon would prefer I buy their Fire TV stick thing, which they would then use as a hook to sell me more Amazon stuff. Given Amazon's attitude towards Apple and Google's streaming devices, chances seem decent to me that if Roku ever increased its market share then Amazon might cut them off. I'd rather just use another streaming video store.
- terminado 11y agoDoes it have a name? Any name at all? Even a code name? Are we calling this "Amazon Video" or something? C'mon man.
- Taylor_OD 11y agoThis is huge. Amazon has the firepower to take on youtube. Hopefully Amazon can come up with a clean UI that makes people WANT to use their service unlike amazons current video streaming service.
- tracker1 11y agoFunny, I was thinking the opposite... I was wondering if people would actually use this system, and how Amazon would distinguish the naming... part of why "YouTube" is successful, is it stayed "YouTube" instead of "Google Video". A separate brand for a separate product is important, as anything else dilutes the brand, which is already doing that to itself pretty well. Google has been better than many companies with this imo. Apple, better still. It will be interesting in how this works out and ties into Twitch, as I think that will be the more natural conduit for integration. As it stands, it's just another place for clickbait sites to embed video from.
- Apocryphon 11y agoI am reminded of an old Hypercritical podcast: "Everybody Wants to Rule the World" (http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/74 http://5by5.tv/hypercritical/74). Everyone wants their own stack to have full control over. So now we've got multiple gardens (of differing openness) tended by cathedrals.
- westernmostcoy 11y agoAmazon has a very bad track record of integrating with other services: do you think you'll be able to watch this on a normal Android phones? or an Apple TV? or a Chromecast? will they let other places on the internet embed videos easily? how will they be substantially better on copyright/DMCA complaints? On top of all that, I think this needs a nice clean discoverable UI for this type of thing to be successful and they've really struggled with that in the past. I'm also sad about what keeps happening to Prime. This has a benefit that I wouldn't consider strong enough to sign up for while the rest of the business continues to sneakily weaken the shipping benefit I did sign up for.
- Bombthecat 11y agoGood question. But when I think about that.... No I do t think so.
- exhilaration 11y agoThis. I still can't take advantage of Amazon prime video streaming on my Android phone without 1) allowing app installs from third parties and making my device insecure 2) installing the Amazon app store 3) THEN installing the Prime video app. Proof: http://www.amazon.com/gp/video/splash/sd/t/appstore http://www.amazon.com/gp/video/splash/sd/t/appstore Everything they do is to drive traffic traffic to their properties first, and serve paying customers second.
- ecobiker 11y agoBack when Kindle launched, it was very common to see the story of Kodak being floated around (film vs digital) to claim how Amazon is flexible. Fast forward a few years, Amazon video and music services are the worst in terms of cross platform support. The primary reason I don't buy/rent anything from Amazon Digital is because I can't stream it to my Chromecast. Considering the adoption for Chromecast I would have expected Amazon to support. Instead they ban it from Amazon.com.
- netule 11y agoI initially thought the problem was with my network and device setup at home. So I upgraded my router to the best I could afford, got the latest Chromecast incarnation and thought I was ready to go. I can cast any tab from Chrome to my TV without any issues with the sole exception of Amazon Video. It's the only site that stutters like mad when casting.
- CM30 11y agoAside from Youtube's copyright system, I also hope something like this works out because of their UI. I mean, let's face it. Youtube just seems to change their layout and features every few months or so, regardless of whether they make the site easier to use or not and regardless of what anyone actually wants said changes. If Amazon can come up with a good, user friendly UI and then not screw it up by making constant changes, they could do quite well here.
- hackinthebochs 11y agoSorry, accidental downvote
- TaylorGood 11y agoAs a light user it's relatively the same for me.. Upvote on purpose :D
- arzt 11y agoTotal aside, but now that they are encroaching on Google's territory in video, I would hope they move to create a free mapping service for AWS users. Startups that try to generate revenue are so hamstrung by the baseline $10,000 maps for work license.
- serge2k 11y agoIf I'm a big video content producer what incentive do I have to remove myself from the user base of youtube?