12 ms·
Why do old statues have such small penises?
- amake 11y agoThe linked article's title is "Why do all old statues have such small penises?". Why was the word "penises" censored on HN? Edit: It's now been changed. It used to say "male genitalia" instead of "penises".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chippy 11y agoUm, it's not? Maybe the submitter changed the title after seeing your comment?
- Intermernet 11y agoGuessing that https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=okket https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=okket self-censored due to perceived American "sensibilities". Those of us who aren't from the USA never really understand what causes insult or not. (no joke, and no snark, it's absolutely true that this causes confusion to Australians, and I assume it does to a whole bunch of people from other nationalities!) EDIT: Title has been changed. Good for whoever changed it!
- chippy 11y agoWhere America has a huge hardcore pornography industry, common nudity on major motion pictures and award winning TV shows, nudists, hippy communes and sex cults in the country, Burning Man and San Francisco, it also has a strong protestant conservative prudishness. It's very confusing to a European.
- 67726e 11y agoIt's very frustrating to someone who lives here. Folks often go to great lengths to maintain a "holier than thou" appearance yet enjoy the same vices they condemn.
- percept 11y agoIt's more fun that way.
- reitanqild 11y agoEuropen conservative protestants are hanging around here as well, we just seem to try to avoid annoying everyone else with our choices ;-) And, BTW, that title should be no problem to most of us IMO.
- valarauca1 11y agoThe American sexual liberation movement started in the 1960's, and centered on the west coast/San Francisco specifically. Before that America was literally founded (in the north at least) by religious conservatives who were too prudish for Europe. In fact the early US Quaker movement banned sex all together.
- selimthegrim 11y agoShaker, not Quaker
- huxley 11y agoYou're probably thinking of the Shakers, compared to other non-conformist sects, the Quakers had relatively few hangups about sex.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- i_have_to_speak 11y agoWell done, HN. You upvoted it. Now let's see you discuss it.
- drunken-serval 11y agoI found the article interesting but I don't know how much there is to discuss. The article asks the question and answers it. In a neat little package. (Pun intended... I couldn't stop myself.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- amelius 11y agoI was hoping that this was sort of reflecting the norm :S
- spdionis 11y agoI read somewhere that in greek culture big genitalia was considered barbaric and brute, and small genitalia was preferred. On the phone now though so can't find the source.
- Kristine1975 11y agoThat's what the linked article says :-)
- manojlds 11y agoSorry, but why comment when you have read only the title and not the article? You are saying exactly what the article says in detail.
- spdionis 11y agoWell... my fault...
- barking 11y agoMaybe the ones with big ones were vandalised?
- chippy 11y agobut why would they be?
- Fishman343 11y agoIt was actually very common for statues from ancient Mediterranean civilisations to have their genitalia knocked off by later, more conservative peoples. There are many in museums today which have been defaced by order of Pope Pius IX and other 16/17/18th century leaders.
- Grishnakh 11y ago"Are you anti-Catholic?" "No, I'm anti-vandalism."
- blowski 11y agoThey don't - they're about average. Following links are NSFW! * https://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-83057b24725b6e813a747aae8f741087 https://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-83057b24725b6e813a747a... * https://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0f7e6c4cf3094a8d60b824eec99910a0 https://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-0f7e6c4cf3094a8d60b824... Taken from Quora answer - https://www.quora.com/Why-do-ancient-Greek-sculptures-and-statues-all-feature-small-penises https://www.quora.com/Why-do-ancient-Greek-sculptures-and-st...
- unlinker 11y agoAh, that first picture really makes me feel good about myself.
- Ressuder 11y agoWhy? What advantage do you find that a large sized flaccid penise has?
- hoopism 11y agoI'm sure it's opened a lot of doors for him...
- deanstag 11y agofor a second i thought i was reading a reddit thread
- hoopism 11y agoSorry. I do appreciate the downvote though (whoever it was). Discerning readers want their penis statue discussion on point. I get it.
- homogeneous 11y agoI despise this hackneyed and arrogant reddit chide. HN has excellent moderation, but it's not such a bastion of quality discourse that breaking forum etiquette merits shitting on another community via rhetorical comparison. This site is regularly host to some terribly low-quality discussions that really only differentiate themselves from reddit insomuch as they are lacking in humor. I'm glad that HN tends to moderate out the noise, but this HN trend to invoke reddit as an insult just seems pretentious.
- jgrahamc 11y agoFirstly, they’re flaccid. If you compare their size to most flaccid male penises, they are actually not significantly smaller than real-life penises tend to be. So... they're not small. I guess most people haven't seen many average, flaccid ones. If most of your exposure to penises is hardcore pornography and Mapplethorpe that confusion is understandable.
- Intermernet 11y agoMy very good friend has the rare distinction of being a medical scrotum model. This was a paid position (behind white curtains etc) of being an anatomical model for the male scrotum for medical education purposes. He read, and studied, many text books that described and illustrated the average, flaccid penis in order to mentally handle this job without emotional damage. He was the first person to bring to my attention the argument over statue penis size vs. perceived real penis size and I'm surprised to see that the debate continues! He had many references to studies done in this field (it's surprisingly popular!) Despite the continuing debate, my friend has a unique set of skills on his CV.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoHow does one get a job offer of this sort? Did his doctor off-handedly mention it after a physical?
- softawre 11y agoLOL. Reminds me of George being a hand model in Seinfeld.
- antisthenes 11y agoAnd Kramer inadvertently becoming a scrotum model of his own.
- yason 11y agoHe read, and studied, many text books that described and illustrated the average, flaccid penis in order to mentally handle this job without emotional damage. What sort of emotional damage did he think would result from being a medical scrotum model? What did the job entail actually? I would assume he would let students see his penis or have it photographed for anatomy books, or something similar? Or were the students allowed to touch it, or something?
- pavel_lishin 11y agoThe author mentions that David looks afraid from the front, but doesn't provide a photo, so I went looking: http://i.imgur.com/OVJdNac.jpg http://i.imgur.com/OVJdNac.jpg He definitely doesn't look afraid from below. He always looked bored to me, but looking him in the eyes, he definitely looks concerned.
- dazmax 11y agoWow, I can't believe we don't see that angle more often, it adds so much to the statue.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI wonder how many other works of art are poorly displayed.
- tawpKek 11y agoInteresting you mention the fact about it being poorly displayed. I would say it is, but not because you don't often see this frontal view. As you may or may not know, the sculpture was originally meant to be displayed on the roof of the Duomo. Michaelangelo altered the proportions slightly so that it would appear to be correct when viewed from an extreme low angle.
- tmm 11y agoIs _that_ why his right hand seems extremely elongated? I've always wondered. Viewed from a steep angle, I imagine it would look quite normal.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoSo you're telling me I'm just a foolish, ugly man filled with lust? Gee, thanks...
- toypaj 11y agoit was cold when they were modelling
- circa 11y agoIts a grower, not a show-er.
- blackhaz 11y agoI think this is important in the penis enlargement era. Now I will sleep better.
- huffmsa 11y agoFrom a friend who studied "classics" as a degree, the Greeks thought massive schlongs were comical and bestial, as well as stole focus from the musculature and overall balance of the art. Rome on the other hand considered itself a masculine nation, who's roads were broad and straight, never turning for nature. Not that the Greeks couldn't have fun, they used statues with erect penises as road signs in Athens, famously knocked off by Alcibiades (in fact he was framed by a rival ) the night before the invasion of Sicily. The David is a statue of a 14 year old, in addition to the reasons given in the article.
- lingben 11y agoAlso in classical times the 'seat of power' for men was not the penis but the testicles. Today we equate masculinity and virility with a large penis, but to the Greeks and Romans a large penis had no such connotation. When you think about it, it makes sense from a biochemical perspective. Without the male testes a man can not produce testosterone which is the key hormone that regulates growth, muscle mass, aggressiveness, competitiveness, vitality, etc. So it is understandable to think that a larger pair of testes would make you 'more' of a man and a smaller set, less. Not sure when exactly this change occurred in Western culture but it would be the more interesting question to try to answer.
- popee 11y agoIt was cold
- slowbutmellow 11y agoI shoulda been a Greek
- AbuAssar 11y agowe need NSFW tag!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- saiya-jin 11y agowell obviously ladies didn't define aesthetic norms back in those days... fiancee had the same question this weekend after visiting Louvre's antic section - the stuff is just too small given proportions of statues. i am a +-regular gym goer, so even if i don't want i see all the stuff in locker rooms/shared showers, and albeit some of it is this small (and smaller), most is bigger.
- pazqo 11y agoNot going to translate (this is Italian -and in particular Sicilian) and there are two sculptors arguing with the local priest about the size of the dong. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WKAjQKTz3w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WKAjQKTz3w
- donretag 11y agoI speak Italian, and even I am grateful for the subtitles. I'm as far away from Sicilian as possible. Many of the great classic Italian movies are in (Southern) dialect, so I tend to watch them with subtitles. Need to watch this movie.
- swah 11y ago...asked the african historian.
- leroy_masochist 11y agoHas anyone considered the possibility that the statues were in the pool? [0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ldUZvxjKMGs#t=1m18s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ldUZvxjKMGs#t=1m18s
- george_soros 11y agoI knew what I'm gonna see before I clicked the link :P
- EToS 11y agoIs this a worthy HN topic?
- pc86 11y agoWith 113 points in an hour, I would say yes.
- slazaro 11y agoEnough people found it interesting, so yes.
- optforfon 11y agowell... HN does kinda have a start-up/tech focus. It'd make sense to moderate in a way that kept people "on topic". If you want general discussion there are better places for that.
- slazaro 11y agoYes, but the guidelines explicitly say "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity". I'm okay with that, I'm here for both things, tech-related or otherwise, as long as it's interesting. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- optforfon 11y agoOh that explains it... I've been drifting to lobste.rs a lot more lately anyway.. too bad I don't have an invite =(
- Retra 11y agoWhat's better about those places?
- krapp 11y agoIt should be. This is a discussion about art, aesthetics, culture and biology, all topics of intellectual interest. It's surprising how immature a community which prides itself on intellectualism can be when it comes to genitals, though.
- galfarragem 11y agoWomen breasts are also small in old statues. Maybe we can infer that sculptors didn't want erogenous zones to become too relevant and overshadow the statue as a whole.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoMany of them also look nothing like breasts.
- goldbrick 11y agoPart of the reason for this is that many of the models for Renaissance artists' sculptures of women were actually men.
- ocean3 11y agoThey are certainly not small in Indian sculptures.
- drcross 11y agoI haven't seen this (my) theory mentioned but it's worth thinking about- sculptors of fine art were keen to differentiate themselves from poor cheap carvings that you can still get to this day in cheap markets in rural towns on the european continent. Go through stalls in Spanish seaside towns and you'll immediately find lewd phalic sculptures. They are made to shock the person receiving the gift. Proper artists wanted to go in the other direction, reducing the size of the genitalia so it's not a focus of the work.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- neugier 11y agoWhat this thread needs is a reference to the bitcoin blocksize debate.
- neurobuddha 11y agoNot a lot of insight in this article. Is it on the front page for the giggles?
- nxzero 11y agoGuess this begs the question of how "big is better" in pop-culture. Anyone know?
- snake_plissken 11y agoThey could have been cold. If you have a penis and scrotum, you know what happens to them when you are cold. That picture of the statue of Laocoön battling snakes with his sons in the article, they were probably battling the snakes in some dank, cold cistern right above the gates to Hades.
- samirillian 11y agoClearly David was just a grower, rather than a show-er. Also, he is in what any athlete will recognize as "sports mode". Also, it looks bigger in person. Nuff said
- wiz21 11y agoI'd venture another explanation. When I compare myself to those "normal" statue, I don't feel inferior :-) The fat is that a statue is an idealization; so being the same as the idealized stuff is a warm comforting feeling...
- Raphmedia 11y agoFood for thoughts: When you fight naked or pantless against men with sharp sticks, you don't want a long penis that is easy to hit.
- lolc 11y agoIf I'm fighting you with a sharp stick I will not aim at your penis. Don't worry about that my friend! Your crotch is the least interesting part to hit.
- Raphmedia 11y agoTalhoffer's fencing manuals are full of groin stabs and I've seen it in a few others. http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive/17516250/images/1326462501450.jpg http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive/17516250/image...
- lolc 11y agoI don't know the first thing about fencing. But that image doesn't look like a stab to me. It doesn't look like it's aimed at the penis in particular either. (But again I know nothing of the sport.) (Edit: I agree that if I had a sword, the crotch could be considered for an attack, but I'd go for the hip joints mostly.) What I do know is that if I have a sharp stick, I will not aim it at your penis. The main goal in a fight is to incapacitate. So an attack on the penis even if successful would be rather wasted. Bleeding from the crotch doesn't make you any less dangerous in the short term.
- Raphmedia 11y agoYou will die from bleeding from the groin. This also makes it so your opponent cannot reproduce. The pain alone from a hit to the groin is also enough to make somebody vomit or straight out pass out. I'm not certain if that effect is the same with cutting as it is with punches and kicks...
- 11y ago
- tzs 11y agoBefore searching the internet for the answer a couple years ago, my speculation used to be that artists were afraid to make well endowed statues because some wife or concubine of the emperor might make an unflattering comparison, and it was never a good idea in those days to get an emperor pissed off at you.
- atomi 11y agoWho are all you people? What happened to HN?
- cooper12 11y agoThese are all HN users. If the accounts were new, the usernames would be green. It's just that certain types of content and titles bring out a certain class of responses.
- benbenolson 11y agoWhat are you talking about?
- atomi 11y agoYou haven't noticed a serious decline in the quality of comments and posts? This site used to be much more startup and programmer focused. Now we have posts about the penis size of statues. :/ edit: What would you know about that? You joined less than a year ago.
- silencio 11y agoFrom the guidelines: > anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity I'm not sure what is so wrong with this post. It's certainly more interesting than half the front page right now in my opinion. (To save you the pointless trouble, my account is 3016 days old.)
- atomi 11y agoWell yeah, if you say your intellectual curiosity is fulfilled with discussions about why male genitalia is so small on statues then I'll just take your word for it. But considering the graveyard of comments on this post, I'll have to just say I could do without it. Enjoy your penis posts.
- lotharbot 11y ago> "What would you know about that? You joined less than a year ago." I joined a little more than 200 days before you, and my wife was here a year before me. She was here just at the end of the "mostly startup and programmer focused" era (she got to experience Erlang Day -- FWIW, here's a thread from 8 weeks after you joined that references both Erlang Day and too many stories about non-hacker topics: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1919897 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1919897 ). "This isn't about programming WTF" has been a complaint on HN for a long, long time. To the degree that the HN guidelines explicitly say that topics don't have to be about programming and startups, they just have to be "intellectually gratifying". Cultural perceptions of sexuality and gender as expressed in art are an intellectual topic (though they do tend to attract boring, uninsightful, crude commentary, as seen in the wall of grayed-out comments at the bottom of the page.)
- chimprich 11y agoI have an alternative theory: the extremities of the statue are more delicate and the most likely parts to get knocked off over time. The size of the penis is probably proportional to the chance of it being knocked off, so we see fewer surviving examples of more endowed statuary. This theory doesn't necessarily compete with the one in the article; canny sculptors may have gone for smaller dimensions to make their statues more robust as well as aesthetics.
- tdaltonc 11y ago> canny sculptors may have gone for smaller dimensions to make their statues more robust as well as aesthetics. I think that's one step to far. It's a better (at least 'cleverer'?) argument if you just leave it at "it's survivor bias."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAnd once they got knocked off - how do you repair the damage? By re-sculpting the stub. And there you are.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- HillaryBriss 11y ago> ... his small penis allowed him to remain coolly logical This suggests an important new brogrammer interview question
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ganitayu 11y agoTo me they look tiny. But for most HN readers they probably look pretty large.
- peter303 11y agoI suspect large dicks and boobs are a recent evolutionary development, but not that recent. You just cant run down dinner or walk that efficiently with all that junk flopping around. Many joggers probably have experimented once either in a college bare run or in the wilderness and found it tough :-) Lice genetics suggests clothing is at least 80K years old even though the oldest needles are less than half that age. So people may have been engineering "support" to decrease the disadvantages of size. Nearly all the near naked jungle tribes seem to have support. I am suggesting size increased long before 2000 years ago, but not the entire history of the human race.
- justifier 11y agosemi offtopic because my anectdote is more about the compactness of the genitals than their size: i used to live in firenze and there is a statue of neptune(o) in the palazzo vecchio once i was walking past it with a friend and i told her it was one of my favourite statues in the city and she surprisingly responded, 'of course it is' i asked why it was so obvious and she said, 'well, look at his balls' "what about his balls?" 'that's an old man with the balls of a prepubescent boy' now, you could make an argument about the models used or some social aspect of the times or artist but i loved where she went from there "interesting, go on" 'it's a clear fetishising of immortality, to think you can be old with such a tight young body is the pure representation of a god, the immortal' wisdom of experience, strength of youth (o) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fountain_of_Neptune,_Florence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fountain_of_Neptune,_Florence
- amelius 11y agoSince the sculptors in those days were mostly men, a better question might be why the female statues have such small breasts :)
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y agoEr, the breasts are about average?
- junnan 11y agoThere should be scientific studies telling us the average size of penises.
- mmagin 11y agoAm I the only one who misread this as "statuses" and thought it was about the Twitter 140 character limit?
- alexandrerond 11y agoI've seen this question answered before and the explanation was that small flaccid penises imply a proportionally large change when they become erect. While an already large but flaccid penis would proportionally not change so much. Greeks considered the difference between the size of a flaccid vs erect penis a sign of masculinity, and therefore tended to use small penises. What's more glorious than knowing that the flaccid retracted penis of an amazing athlete will grow 4x when required (which is plausible). A larger non retracted penis wouldn't grow so much proportionally.
- burfog 11y agoLook, it's stone. It was carved with a hammer and chisel. There is no "undo" and you don't even know if there might be a hidden defect in the stone until it snaps. You can't glue a broken penis back on. If you break it, you keep it, unless you can find a buyer for a stone penis and the corresponding emasculated statue. Some of these statues probably started off with huge penises. The stone broke, and thus the statues got downsized. It's that or lug a new boulder back to the workshop. Statue buyers must have had a say as well, and vandalism is not a recent invention. People have been snapping parts off of art since before recorded history. If you were an ancient statue buyer, would you choose a design that will easily suffer damage at the hands of a 12-year-old kid? No way. Short is best. It's probably cheaper too.