4 ms·
I don't live in the USA, could someone briefly explain why an evangelical Christian would fit in less well at a university than a religious person of other fait
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
I don't live in the USA, could someone briefly explain why an evangelical Christian would fit in less well at a university than a religious person of other faiths?
Is it related to their religion, their conservatism, or something else?
- jccalhoun 11y agoA variety of groups consider themselves to be evangelical but the group that tends to get the most media coverage tend to be the most conservative and are anti-abortion, anti-gay rights, don't believe in evolution, and think the USA should be a Christian nation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evangelicalism#Recurrent_themes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evangelicalism#Recurrent_theme...
- headcanon 11y agoCurrently it is because a large part of the Republican party consists of what we call the "religious right", a group that seeks to make political change based on what they believe to be religious truth, or morality. Ted Cruz was the arbiter of this ideology in the Republican primaries, until he dropped out last week. While this group does not represent the entire party, they are definitely the most vocal, and many liberals conflate that group with the rest of the party as a whole. This belief is not helped by the fact that many "core" republican platforms come from religious conservatives, like outlawing gay marriage and abortion. Many people who belong to the academic community consider these people to be a bunch of uneducated backwater hicks who do not belong in intellectual conversations based on logical thought. So when an intellectual states that they are an evangelical christian, many consider them to be flawed in some capacity, and thus have nothing of substance to contribute. EDIT: to add to that, evangelical christians tend to embrace a literal translation of the bible; in that the world was created in literally seven days, and that every human is descended from Adam and Eve, a story which in its literal translation is of course not supported by science. So when a person who professes to follow science also professes to be a member of this faith, it can seem paradoxical to many.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mwfunk 11y agoTo the person that asked the question, headcanon's first paragraph is pretty much right on and answers the question. The downvotes likely came from the tribalism expressed in the second paragraph ("uneducated backwater hicks"). American politics are way too polarized. IMO that polarization comes from two sources: (1) demagogues like Cruz and Trump who lure people in by convincing them that they are the "true" Americans, and making them believe that everything would be so much better were it not for the pernicious influence of some other group (Democrats/scientists/LGBT folks/academics/Muslims/Mexicans/etc.). The very best fuel for this fire is (2), being denigrated by people who self-identify as one of those groups that the demagogues are trying to make them scared of. Like, imagine some perfectly decent person who has lived all his life in some small town in Nebraska, who isn't very educated but also isn't a terrible person who goes around looking for excuses to hate people. Rural voters are statistically more religious and more conservative, so he probably has extra peer pressure to be like that himself, but at the same time is a little creeped out by people like Cruz who seem to be trying to convince him that atheist non-white city dwellers think that him and his family and friends are subhuman, and are trying to take away his rights and his livelihood. So he's on the fence, until one day he stumbles across someone complaining about "uneducated backwater hicks", at which point he decides that Cruz might be right after all, because clearly these college-educated urban strangers really do hate him and his friends and relatives. It's a vicious circle that's only broken when people just suck it up and take the high road, but it feels like there's just never quite enough people willing to do that to make a difference. It's easy to judge less educated or less successful people, and I'm sure it feels really cathartic to do so. Especially when many of those people are being used as pawns by demagogues who are actively trying to roll back civilization. It's much harder to turn the other cheek and try to find common ground with them. Sadly that's the only way the trend towards cultural polarization is ever going to reverse, because neither side is going anyplace.
- headcanon 11y agoI probably should have tossed "uneducated backwater hicks" in quotes - I was attempting to speak from what I perceive to be the left-wing point of view. But you are right, the social tribalism is driving a lot of this. I live in a very liberal university town, and many people seem to see republicans this way.
- bpodgursky 11y agoJust read the comments that show up (hopefully) below.
- thesimpsons1022 11y agoa lot of people in the US. are christian but pretty moderate. they don't really think about it much or let it affect their behavior. And they believe in stuff like evolution. Evangelicals are fundamentalists. For a lot of evangelicals, religion is a central part of their life and motivates almost all their beliefs.
- lobotryas 11y agoOk, but what dies that mean in practice? Does this mean I will receive a worse education from an evangelical professor? Should we check our surgeon's faith and political party preference because there is a higher chance of complication from being operated upon by a conservative evangelic surgeon as opposed to an agnostic liberal one? If the orientation or race of these people is irrelevant to them performing their duties, why is faith or political leaning relevant?
- thesimpsons1022 11y agomaybe. I had a teacher in middle school who was very religious and decided to skip the evolution chapter because "we didn't have time". It is almost never irrelevant. You know what George Bush said about Putin when he met him? He said he could tell that he was a great guy because he was wearing his grandmother's cross. If the leader of the free world can be tricked so easily because of his faith it is an issue. Especially when we know Putin hasn't worn the cross before or after. He figured that is all it took to fool the leader of the free world.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Evangelicals are fundamentalists. No, they aren't. The Evangelical movement was a reaction against elements of the Fundamentalist movement in much the same way that the Fundamentalist movement was a reaction against liberal/modernist Christianity, and explicitly saw itself as between the two. (It covers, in practice, a wide range, and obviously the more exclusionary, more nearly Fundamentalist edge of the Evangelical community has the most visibility in media, which tends to be conflict-oriented, a problem which is exacerbated by the fact that the tarnishing and genericization of the "fundamentalist" label has probably led to actual Fundamentalists grabbing on to the Evangelical label without the substance.)
- savanaly 11y agoThe following essay sums it up pretty well: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything... Long story short, Christians are "red tribe", and most other religions can be thought of as "blue tribe".
- burfog 11y agoFacinating: "Some of it is certainly genetic – estimates of the genetic contribution to political association range from 0.4 to 0.6. Heritability of one’s attitudes toward gay rights range from 0.3 to 0.5, which hilariously is a little more heritable than homosexuality itself. (for an interesting attempt to break these down into more rigorous concepts like “traditionalism”, “authoritarianism”, and “in-group favoritism” and find the genetic loading for each see here. For an attempt to trace the specific genes involved, which mostly turn out to be NMDA receptors, see here)" links to studies on the matter too