3 ms·
> legally Tax laws are so complex that we don't know if some tax avoidance schemes are legal or not. The accountants selling them claim they are legal. The t
by DanBC 11y ago
> legally
Tax laws are so complex that we don't know if some tax avoidance schemes are legal or not. The accountants selling them claim they are legal. The tax authorities sometimes claim they're not legal.
Ideally they'd go to court and get a ruling, but that's expensive and regulators tend to avoid court if possible (at least, in England they do) and so we have "agreements" where a scheme is deemed abusive and some amount of tax is repaid.
There's no prosecution; no sentences; no convictions. These repayments are not fines. So it's hard to call that illegal.
- bpodgursky 11y ago> Tax laws are so complex that we don't know if some tax avoidance schemes are legal or not. That's the wrong way to phrase it. If you don't know if actions are legal or not, you are simply not living under the rule of law. There is no law, if you cannot reasonably figure out what the law is.
- dragonwriter 11y agoI disagree. If there are both unambiguously permitted and unambiguously unpermitted cases, then there is very much law, even if there is a gray area where reasonable people can disagree with what is allowed and what is permitted. That's not to say that the ambiguities may not still be problematic, but they don't make the whole structure into "non-law".