10 ms·
iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music
- spacemanmatt 11y agoSame.
- wiredfool 11y agoFrom what I've seen of iTunes ability to keep album art that I've added or automatically download ones I'm missing, there's no way in hell that I'd let it match my music collection. Some of the cover art is ok, some is meh (special edition banners), and some is in the WTF range (one zydeco album especially). Not that I have that much that's not mainstream, but I'm kind of particular about the stuff that's in there.
- vlunkr 11y agoIf you're looking for something to organize, tag, and locate album art I recommend musicbrainz. They have an app for osx. It's not incredibly intuitive at first but I'm currently cleaning my collection up with it
- pdwetz 11y agoThey also have an API that you can use if you're programmatically inclined to automate the process. It does have limits, so be mindful of including delays between requests. http://musicbrainz.org/doc/Development http://musicbrainz.org/doc/Development
- yoasif_ 11y agoMusicbrainz is fantastic, as is beets: http://beets.io http://beets.io
- AckSyn 11y agoWasn't that claim determined to be a hoax?
- Sophistifunk 11y agoI know something has deleted several dozen MP3s from my collection. The end result of which is iTunes would refuse to sync my phone. Because those two features belong in the same app, and all. In the end I had to delete my entire iTunes music library and start fresh, just so my phone would sync
- ergothus 11y agoThat was the experience that moved me from an iPhone to android several years ago - not only that I had to wipe my phone to sync, but that * I couldn't back up what was on the phone (without first wiping the phone) * that iTunes wouldn't let me re-download any music I had bought (this was pre-iCloud) * this was the second time it happened to me - the first time was with an iPod pretty early in their existence, so I was willing to accept incomplete options. (I'm rough on laptops, which is what I had been syncing to) Seeing that they had no interest in improving this situation after years of being aware of it, I bailed. I'm told that Apple is now better about repeat downloads from their store and have stopped considering the PC as the source of truth for the device but they still are terrible for families with multiple accounts but not one Mac/PC per user. Frankly, I'm glad Apple is out there pushing boundaries, but I've not missed anything from my iPhone. (my Macbook remains a great Unix-ey device)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 11y ago(Assuming you're referring to the James Pinkstone story referenced in the beginning) Sort of. Pinkstone was telling the truth in that iTunes did delete all his music, but after some follow-up with Apple it was determined that it was a bug and not, as he speculated in the first post, the result of a conspiracy to control what happens to music you already purchased (the Apple CSR was just clueless; which is well within the realm of possibility) That doesn't really matter to this story's context though: the Slate author is complaining that its the general shittiness of iTunes, not any sinister agenda on Apple's part, that is destroying his desire to collect music.
- ktRolster 11y agoThe new UI designs in iTunes are almost as bad as the new UI designs in xCode.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI was thinking about this while driving recently - both the iTunes / Apple Music approach, and the way I go about organizing and sorting my things. As a guy who grew up with Mac until playing catch-up with Win95 (and some DOS to fit in), being familiar with digital storage techniques has formed over time. I get the concept of certain files being certain places - system files versus personal files versus program resources. This kind of structuring appeals to me. Thus, rather than totally embrace the "OS as Helper" technique that Windows likes (put everything in "Music") or going the iTunes route (behemoth management program with hooks to other stuff), I maintained some of my fencing habits. Sure, I use the "Music" folder but that's only for purchased music. In a separate folder - which makes things easier to back-up I think - I have my "Music Projects" folder. In my workflow I've got my DAW projects and output separate from what I'd consider the 'commercial music' area, and this might have saved a lot of stress that Pinkstone went through. Maybe not, but my hunch is it might have helped. iTunes can't touch what it can't see, and letting it anywhere near a collection of bootlegs and/or "less than legal" origin files is something I would avoid out of general suspiciousness. That applies to original works that don't fit any standard cataloging function either; I don't think that would help me. Personally I'm still satisfied with Winamp, a couple skins and visualization things (it does help me ID3 tag my music as well), and honestly can't recall if I've ever installed iTunes in the past 10 years. I genuinely don't think so, and while my own process has flaws and issues (overlap of versions, DAW files are big, etc) there's some protection I kind of like in a way.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- UVB-76 11y agoIn recent years iTunes on OS X has managed to achieve the feat of becoming more bloated, sluggish, and yet also losing important features. I've spent most of the last five years hoping Apple are re-writing the thing from scratch, and have been neglecting any meaningful updates to the current fork in the meantime, but I'm losing hope.
- mystic001 11y agohttp://beets.io/ http://beets.io/ beets has done an amazing job helping curate my music. I'm sure it's been covered here before.
- sondr3 11y agoHas it gotten better at tagging classical music? I used it for a while a year or two ago and back then it was pretty bad for tagging classical music.
- dave2000 11y agoI tag everything the same way, no matter what I use to listen to the music, the OS I use, tag app, music source etc. Just Artist, Album, and track number. Clear all the other fields. For classical, I appreciate that there can be different labels releasing different masterings of the same recording, or different conductors of the same piece, or a given conductor conducting the same piece with different orchestras etc but for me I'm happy sticking that info as part of the Album. For example: Gurrelieder (Boulez). I don't see any point in getting anal about it all. You can stick the notes in the folder you store the music in, or have filenames with extra details but as long as the music player lets you drill down from artist to album, and plays the tracks in the album in the correct order, that's good enough. I don't waste my time with cover art etc because if I want to look at it I can do that on a pc or in real life; i'm never going to be staring my my phone while it's playing, and it's never going to be quicker to wade visually through cover art to find what you're looking for (although I guess it might aid lazily browsing through your collection if you're not sure what to play).
- billforsternz 11y agoVery sensible advice I think. Your system insulates you from things outside your control.
- Wonnk13 11y agoI've purposley avoided Apple Music for this reason. I still use it as my main library, but i've starting using Google Play Music for their radio stations, which I have found superior to iTunes. Anyone have advice for moving off of iTunes completely? Do you backup to S3 or a external disk?
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI just spent a while offloading a bunch of music from a Macbook Pro that had to be returned to an educational institution after years of use. I was able to get to the music files directly and copied/pasted them over to large flash drives. I did the same for photos on that machine. From there I uploaded them to a network storage device where they've just been chilling until they're downloaded to a new machine.
- Cozumel 11y agoSomeone has to say it: why do people keep using it? If it's not doing the job it's supposed too, or worse, actively deleting your music it's time to scrap it!
- UVB-76 11y agoThere's still nothing better than iTunes, at least on OS X. It's the best of a bad bunch.
- kitschpatrol 11y agoI've found Swinsian to be a viable alternative: http://swinsian.com http://swinsian.com
- zyxley 11y agoNo file organization? Having the files automatically organized when the metadata is updated is literally the entire reason I've stuck with iTunes so far.
- Bartweiss 11y agoMy experience is that iTunes can't handle anything but perfectly neat metadata about album versions of songs. Every time I've fed it live music, or alternate takes, or anything else weird, it's choked so badly that I ended up wishing for no organization.
- sethhochberg 11y agoAgreed, for a lot of people "no organization" is a feature unto itself. iTunes is famous for mangling already cleanly-organized collections of folders on disk, etc.
- scarface74 11y agoThere has been an option since 2003 for iTunes not to copy songs into its own hierarchy and just leave files where they are.
- psychometry 11y agoThis is why I still use iTunes 10. After that point, the program no longer had the organizational features I'd been depending on ever since iTunes 4 or maybe even earlier. It's unfortunate that there isn't a similarly feature-rich music organization app for OS X available (and I've tried them all).
- hackaflocka 11y agoI updated at some point and regret it. Do you know if it is possible to downdate my iTunes and go back to 10?
- psychometry 11y agoI used this: https://awesometoast.com/downgrading-to-itunes-10-7-from-itunes-11-on-osx/ https://awesometoast.com/downgrading-to-itunes-10-7-from-itu...
- hackaflocka 11y agoThanks, will check it out.
- ThomPete 11y agoWhen I was a young teenager in the early nineties I dreamt about having all the worlds music available to me via the internet. This is more or less the reality today. Access beats ownership anyway IMO.
- UVB-76 11y agoA lot of people repeating that line will change their tune when Spotify finally goes out of business in a couple of years time.
- ThomPete 11y agoStreaming Music in the cloud is not going anywhere. Not sure why that would change that? There have never been as much access to music as there is today. It's a good thing.
- Bartweiss 11y agoPrice conflicts. The streaming system is obviously worthwhile, but we haven't negotiated a price point where users, streamers, and artists are all willing to play ball. At the moment, it seems like someone always has to take a loss, and the rationalization might be ugly.
- ThomPete 11y agohttp://www.businessinsider.com/spotifys-growth-has-gotten-faster-since-apple-music-2016-5?r=UK&IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/spotifys-growth-has-gotten-fa...
- cloudjacker 11y agoAnd we will call this the golden decade of music access, as our children fetishize the 2010s
- hackaflocka 11y ago
- Animats 11y agoiTunes is working as designed, enslaving users to Apple's "cloud". A few power users might not like this, but they're a small fraction of the user base and don't matter to Apple. That's the reality.
- TaylorGood 11y ago10 years I had 10,000+ songs on my iTunes - their version updates and switching computers (prior to / not fully utilizing Time Machine) slowly decayed my library down to ~150. Then along came Spotify, Soundcloud, etc and I haven't returned to iTunes. No Apple Music either. Not sure what would get me back to my iTunes habit of 10 years ago...
- rocky1138 11y agoI hate to be rude but this author is a dumbass. In big bold letters he has "On a basic level, I don’t have a music collection anymore because Apple made it too hard and frustrating to maintain one." when instead it should read "I didn't take care of my own music library and instead left it to a third party who didn't do what was in my interest."
- Bartweiss 11y agoI still have a music collection, and am quite happy with it. That's true because I had the sense not to let iTunes within 100 yards of the thing. A better article might be "Apple services are completely incompatible with having a music collection."
- nickbauman 11y agoTechnically Apple is a 2nd party with lipservice toward being a third party. Much of iTunes content comes to users through Apple.
- sfindie 11y agoI have 30,000+ songs in my music library. I've taken the time to meticulously tag each and every song when adding music to my library. I currently use MusicBee and love it. It's somewhat lightweight and its tagging tools are great. I've also used Media Monkey for a few years and that also has great tagging tools, but it's not as lightweight as MusicBee. I only ever use iTunes for purchasing songs I can't get via other channels such as b-sides or whatever.
- nickbauman 11y agoGolden rule of owning your own (purchased or created) content: only use 3rd party content organization applications. I don't use iTunes for my music. I don't buy things from amazon for my kindle. Regarding UX: iTunes is proof that bad UX doesn't matter as much as "location". Users somehow figure out how to use apps if they matter enough to them.
- bad_user 11y agoThe other golden rule of owning: never buy DRM-enabled content, even if you can break it, because doing so only encourages the actors pushing for DRM. And bought content needs backup.
- gadlfy 11y agoiTunes has a simple solution they could employ — simply don't delete the original music from the device they are "cloning to the cloud".
- arielweisberg 11y agoI dislike iTunes as well as the built in music player on my iPhone just due the bad UI and some difficulty downloading songs to my phone. I also use it with iTunes match for all my music and I listen many hours a day and do curate my collection with it. It's not perfect, but it's not exactly clubbing baby seals. It's always respected my metadata changes even when things start out wrong. I think I got boned a few times when match mixed up explicit/non-explicit versions, but that is it. I still very much enjoy collecting music and I don't think iTunes is getting in the way of that. I really have to wonder what the author did to delete their entire collection in iTunes? That isn't a thing that is supposed to happen easily on desktop. The stuff I have synced with iTunes match is even harder to delete and there is warning when you try to delete the cloud copy. On phones yeah it's just a brain dead disaster with multiple ways to have it wipe.
- careersuicide 11y agoI dunno. Reading this I can't help but feel like maybe the author is doing it wrong? I'm going to be charitable and admit that Apple has made iTunes incredibly difficult to use effectively, especially since the store is awful and they really, really push the iTunes store on you. That the interface is so slow and inconsistent doesn't help either. My advice to anyone who has any desire to use iTunes is: acquire your music from elsewhere as actual mp3 files, tag them using something like Mp3tag[0] and then drag and drop them into iTunes. Make sure you check the "Keep iTunes Media folder organized" and "Copy files to iTunes Media folder when adding to library" options in the advanced settings. The only control you're really giving up then is the exact naming scheme of the files in the folder. But "<library directory>/Artist Name/Album Name/01 Song Title.mp3" is a pretty sane convention in my opinion. I have close to 18,000 albums in my iTunes library that I've added this way over the last decade and a half. It works pretty well and I have no problem reasoning about what music I have. I totally agree with his complaints about Apple Music though, it's pretty inscrutable. But I wrote my own music streaming server with Sinatra and iOS app to go with it so I always have access to whatever is stored on my hard drive at home in a way that makes sense to me. If I'm not at home that's what I'd rather do, no syncing or anything weird. 0: http://www.mp3tag.de/en/ http://www.mp3tag.de/en/
- Bartweiss 11y agoI would definitely argue that "make sure you have these advanced settings configured or you're screwed" is a sign of hostile software. I'm totally unwilling to use iTunes or Apple Music for my collection. That said, if you're particular about your music collection, it's basically always going to take some curation. Giving up because Apple didn't make that easy isn't entirely Apple's fault.
- mikewhy 11y ago> make sure you have these advanced settings configured or you're screwed However, those very settings are on by default.
- Fuxy 11y agoMy recommendation would be to not use Apple but if you can't do that for whatever reason running your own Plex media server at home and installing the Plex app on your phone should be the next best thing. I got a freenas box running at home where i keep all my conntent with plex media server running in a jail giving me access to my entrire library anywhere I am without having to worry that some miss click is going to destroy all my hard work. Owncloud, Plex etc are a great replacement for the mainstream clud based services out there and you have full controll over them. I would never give up controll over my data for the convenience of the cloud. It feels like gving up one of your findamental rights like the right to free speach to me.
- bunkydoo 11y agoYeah iTunes is long past it's prime, Vinyl or CD is really the only way to collect music now I suppose. I would discredit CD a bit due to quality of mp3, but whose to say you cant buy a collection of FLAC CDs
- hackaflocka 11y agoI know a few women who tell me they're horrible at using computers. When I asked why, they said "because I can't even figure out iTunes." Between dodgy iCloud and bloated iTunes, Apple has destroyed the "computer self-esteem" of a generation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- whistlerbrk 11y agoMy belief is that iTunes is purposefully broken and will likely be broken up into separate apps. On the music side it forces people to use streaming services instead which the music industry prefers to digital ownership, and Apple's own service is doing well. They've (Apple) always played ball with the music industry as everyone must, they've just managed to get better deals than most when working with them. Where it really hurts is in podcasting. I think podcasts & audiobooks would be much bigger if syncing worked worth a damn on iTunes. On the i-device side, syncing should be be removed wholesale from the media player. Honestly, it should be relegated to a little task icon like Caffeine. The only reason this isn't the case is because the storage capacity of these devices is so (needlessly) tiny, again perhaps purposefully in order to prevent day to day users from keeping a lot of downloaded music/videos locally.
- jeena 11y agoI've been using Subsonic because it was free software but since it moved away and is now closed source I stopped paying and am now using Syncthing to sync all my files in between my computers and my Sailfish OS phone, I have to say that this is the best way I can enjoy my music yet.
- mud_dauber 11y agoI haven't (willingly) used iTunes in years. When I do, it's only to reset a frozen iPod. Shazam: music discovery while mobile KEXP Twitter feed: music discovery while streaming at work Amazon: one-click purchase Clementine: Linux media manager including iPod sync AllMusic: artist research
- vincentbarr 11y agoI highly recommend Vox [1] as a lightweight alternative to iTunes. I've used it as a compete replacement for iTunes with the exception of when I want to add music to my iPhone. [1] www.coppertino.com
- gjolund 11y agoiTunes is the reason I got rid of my iPhone.
- georgekin 11y agoTo chime in on my workflow here, I used to be a heavy user of windows media player, until streaming became big and I bought into the Zune system - for which the software was incredible. You could download media from the online library and it'd count as part of your local library, and you could create auto playlists that filtered all of your music (streaming and local) into those playlists. Then, you'd just auto-sync those to your devices. This method isn't possible on any service anymore, and I believe it's because of increasingly more restrictive licensing. The closest I've found, and what I use today is google music. I upload all of my local content to them, and then mark songs that I 'like' as liked. GMusic has an autoplaylist of all my likes that I then sync to all my devices, including my car which has an android stereo. I encourage everyone to step outside the Apple/Spotify walled gardens every now and then and resurvey the offerings - iTunes is just such an awful bit of software that it makes their service a non-starter for me. GMusic has a great mobile and web client, with download support which is all I need.
- hackaflocka 11y agoIn 2016 Apple insists on wiping my iPhone's mp3s clean if I connect it to any PC or Mac other than the main PC or Mac that was used to transfer mp3s on to it.
- mcv 11y agoI loved iTunes back when I had an iPod. Used it a lot, and made managing playlists a lot easier than what I had before, which I think was MusicMatch player, or something. iTunes could rip my CDs, it could make playlists, and I could sync the whole thing to my iPod. I honestly don't see what other features it would need, but if I understand correctly, Apple managed to turn it into a horrifying monstrosity. Nowadays, every once in a while, I accidentally launch iTunes on my Mac, and I have no idea how to use it anymore.
- nikdaheratik 11y agoFirst, having an alias to the "Automatically add to iTunes" folder on my desktop has helped quite a bit with adding non-Apple ecosystem music (primarily from Bandcamp) to iTunes. It doesn't seem to make too many wrong choices, but then again, likely the people who package the mp3s do their best to work with the ecosystem. Second, I've stayed the eff away from iTunes Music. It likely doesn't have what I want anyways, but compared to their hardware, it just seems more like some executive's idea of how to improve Apple's income from iTunes rather than an actual music lover's platform. And iTunes is kind of a hot mess trying to do too many things while execs decide to keep tinkering with it rather than doing the multi-product rethinking they would need to make it work again. Third, a few times a year I make sure to backup everything that isn't on Apple, and most of everything that is. And not via "Time Machine" either, which you should be doing, but actually copying the iTunes music folder or any other downloads onto external media.