5 ms·
I've tried forcing it 5x and found that the fifth Why is exactly the point where they get annoyed and stop talking to you. So there may be a magic insight at th
by hammock 11y ago
I've tried forcing it 5x and found that the fifth Why is exactly the point where they get annoyed and stop talking to you. So there may be a magic insight at the fifth Why but you'll never hear it :)
- dTal 11y agoWhat if you told them ahead of time what you were doing, so they would happily cooperate knowing there would only be 5? Otherwise, by the fifth most people will think "man, this never ends..."
- code4life 11y agoI'd probably ask "Why 5 times?" and then it would be game on.
- Piskvorrr 11y ago"Diminishing returns."
- Bartweiss 11y agoBy six, you're usually at something like "because that makes me happy". By seven, you're into metaphysics and cognitive science. Of course, some issues are genuinely simple, and you're off in unhelpful territory halfway through. I suspect five why's is a decent estimate, but not necessarily more accurate than four.
- joezydeco 11y agoThere's a really good Louis CK routine about this, involving his young daughter.
- jdimov10 11y agoThe magic insight is always this: "Because I want to feel good." When someone doesn't want to put this in words, they get annoyed and stop talking to you.
- hashkb 11y agoYou're so right... but you can substitute "powerful", " secure", etc for "good"; and also sometimes "because of secret reasons".
- stcredzero 11y agoSometimes it's, "Because I don't want a repeat of this crappy thing that happened to me." Often software is used as a means for one group inside a company to control another group.
- vec 11y agoPart of the idea is that if it takes more than 3 or 4 "why"s to get to some really fundamental business goal (i.e. "Because I want to make more money"), then it might not be a problem worth solving in the first place