6 ms·
Your description doesn't show why a pharmacist selling illegal drugs is dissimilar to a website selling ad space to illegal ad-space buyers. Any time where you'
by belorn 11y ago
Your description doesn't show why a pharmacist selling illegal drugs is dissimilar to a website selling ad space to illegal ad-space buyers. Any time where you've got multiple producers and multiple retailers, you get middle people like those you describe that must juggle demand and supply. Pharmacists have an equally complex path from producer to customer as ads have from ad-space buyer to website visitor. However, let's instead look at the chain of events:
An innocent gets malware from an advertisement. The publisher blames the ad-network who in turn blames the criminal. The ad-network claims that they can't curate the advertisements or the margins becomes to small. In the end, the innocent has to take the full fallout of the crime.
An innocent gets mistreated by a fake doctor. The hospital blames the hiring agency, who in turn blames the criminal. The hiring agency claims that they can't do background checks and verify CVs of applicants or the margins becomes to small. In the end, the innocent has to take the full fallout of the crime?
Why is there such discrepancy between the two cases? Why can one agency do curation and still function, while the other can't? Why can the publisher get away with using a bad ad-network while a hospital is fully legally responsible for using a bad hiring agency? Those seem to be very simple questions, ones that should have very simple answers.
- toyg 11y ago> Why can the publisher get away [...] while a hospital is fully legally responsible The word "legally" gives it away: because there are laws. But we don't like dem laws here on teh intertubes, so far-west it is.
- tomp 11y agoThere are laws agains hacking though. If I visit a website and the website willfully (i.e. it wasn't hacked) serves me malware... that sounds like hacking!
- chris_wot 11y agoI'm not aware of any legal action taken over malware served up from add on a website. But if it were to happen, the website is who is sue, because it is within their responsibility to ensure that ads and/or content should not cause harm to a visitor.
- ryan-c 11y ago> it is within their (the website) responsibility to ensure that ads and/or content should not cause harm to a visitor. I don't think that's been established. With the current state of advertising on the internet, it's not even possible to do this. In general, websites use advertising networks which do not allow them to proactively vet the content. Even if they did, no amount of vetting can guarantee the content is benign (active content can do naughty things only some of the time or on some platforms, or things not yet recognized as naughty - this is also why antivirus isn't reliable). So, clearly the solution is to not allow Javascript or flash, right? Nope - exploits in image parsers, font parsers, video parsers, audio parsers, etc. come out fairly often. This could maybe be dealt with by contracts between websites and advertising networks specifying that the advertising network will be liable for malicious content, but I don't see that happening.
- Dylan16807 11y ago>exploits in image parsers, font parsers, video parsers, audio parsers, etc. come out fairly often. Exploits in jpg/png are very rare. At worst, all you have to do is make the ad network [re]compress the image.
- Silhouette 11y agoExploits in jpg/png are very rare. A major security issue with probably the most popular automated image processing toolkit in existence came to light just the other day. That particular one would be used for attacking servers, but there have been client-side vulnerabilities in other common resources such as fonts before too. Assuming that just because a format is common the software processing it won't introduce any vulnerabilities is not a great idea. In any case, the relative rarity isn't really the point. Either it's ethically and/or legally correct to assign blame for malicious advertising to the final host site that the user actually visits, or it isn't. That's the principle we're really debating, and the rest is just a degree of risk.
- Dylan16807 11y ago
- ikeboy 11y agoThe answer: we accept a far higher cost of medicine and medical treatments in exchange for regulations. Go compare costs between us and other countries. We don't accept paying for content to avoid ads that may be dangerous.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The answer: we accept a far higher cost of medicine and medical treatments in exchange for regulations. Go compare costs between us and other countries. The countries that pay less than us often are at least as highly regulated when it comes to medicine, medical treatments, and their delivery, so while we certainly are paying a lot more for those things, I don't think that the argument that we do so "in exchange for regulations" is particularly defensible.
- ikeboy 11y agohttps://mises.org/blog/how-government-regulations-made-healthcare-so-expensive https://mises.org/blog/how-government-regulations-made-healt... >Today, the U.S. and Canada have less than 25 doctors and 30 hospital beds (per 10,000 population), compared to over 35 and 50, respectively, in most countries in continental Western Europe. Mark Pearson, head of Division on Health Policy at The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), discussed possible reasons the U.S. spends more than two-and-a-half times per person more than most developed nations in the world, including relatively rich European countries: “The U.S. has fewer physicians and fewer physician consultations relative to its population. The U.S. also has fewer hospital beds for its population size and shorter average stays in hospital relative to other countries. Indeed, the lower numbers of physicians could help explain why they cost more; there is less competition for patients.” Are the specific things pointed to there as a cause of a US doctor shortage all found in other countries, but without a shortage? Definitely tort law which increases malpractice costs is far more of a factor in the US market.