8 ms·
Ketamine and Depression: A Breakthrough?
- tshtf 11y agoThis article misses the second part of the study, as elucidated by Derek Lowe here http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/05/06/it-isnt-ketamine http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2016/05/06/it-...: In a rather elegant experiment, the authors deuterated ketamine at the methylene next to its carbonyl group, and showed that this compound (as expected) displayed the same NMDA activity as the parent compound – but that it was far slower at producing the metabolite, and had no activity in the antidepressant screens.
- simonster 11y agoThe "antidepressant screens" referred to here are in mice, not humans. The Nature paper is an amazing set of experiments that provide very compelling evidence that (2R,6R)-HNK is responsible for the antidepressant effects of ketamine in mouse models of depression, but Neuroskeptic is right that it's not clear that (2R,6R)-HNK is also responsible for the antidepressant effects of ketamine in humans. We know that mouse models of depression are not necessarily great; SSRIs seem to be more effective in mouse models than they are in humans.
- zcarter 11y agoPer Neuroskeptic's due diligence, human effects don't look promising. >>> This is a citation to one of their own papers, from 2012. There’s just one problem – as far as I can see that paper didn’t find the correlation that Zanos et al. say it did.
- droithomme 11y agoWe need to drown more mice to be sure.
- mookerific 11y agoIt would be interesting to see how the various research chemicals out there - deschloroketamine, ephenidine, and others - would fare. There are anecdotal reports of varying levels of the antidepressant effect and they shouldn't be left unacknowledged.
- mabbo 11y agoHas there been any increase in illegal use of ketamine since research on its use as a depression treatment first started being published? Having dealt with those issues for many years, and recovered, I can see a real danger in those who suffer from depression saying "K will fix this? I'll try anything". I would have. I'm a firm believer in drug law reform and decriminalization of drug use but from what I've seen of it Ketamine isn't something you want people taking out of desperation, with little knowledge of how crazy it just might get. Or worse, developing a dependency on. It's pretty serious stuff.
- lumpypua 11y agoI've used ketamine to self-medicate depression. I decided to out of desperation. It was extremely effective for me. Several provisos for potential users: - Read the papers. If you can't read the papers on K as a depression treatment and come up with your own dosing protocol, you probably shouldn't try K. - Probably don't try it if you have an addictive personality. - Make sure you're aware of potential side effects such as memory and urinary issues. That said, doses used in treatment protocols shouldn't come anywhere near that. I waited forever to just get some goddamn K and treat myself, because everybody on the internet is like "don't do it, you'll fuck yourself up". I'm smart and do my homework, and I regret not trusting myself and suffering for longer than needed.
- pmiller2 11y agoI wouldn't even know where to get it, and I don't want to get caught and go to jail, due to our stupid drug laws. :(
- a2m 11y agoit's a schedule 3 drug, so a misdemeanor. i don't think you'd get any jail time if you got caught (assuming you're a first time offender in CA). if you're that desperate and you've read up on it and consider it a viable escape from that hell i know too well, give it a shot. (i have not used it). shame i had to make a new account to speak freely about this.
- dschiptsov 11y agoDepression, like obesity, is acquired, habitual change due to environmental factors. Non fraudulent CBT (active traveling in a unfamilar environment as a simplest example) is enough to introduce persistent changes (that is why there are so many stories about profound changes people undergo after visiting the East - radical behavioral change will lead, through conditioning, to change in biochemistry - body is a dynamic, adaptive system). There is, of course, no way to change one's physical or mental conditions without introducing changes to habits, daily routines and environment.
- a2m 11y agosounds good. so how do i get off my ass and do it?
- dschiptsov 11y agoLike everyone else.
- brillenfux 11y agoYou sure have the answers, pal.
- dschiptsov 11y agoThere was a guy named Jack Kerouac, among many. One could literally see how it works for others.
- ap22213 11y agoPuzzled (but also fascinated) at your motivation to post ignorant and seemingly inflammatory comments like this. But, there's probably a CBT treatment for it, right? Please let us know how the treatment goes.
- dschiptsov 11y ago
- superobserver 11y agoKetamine is still far too drastic and probably only really necessary when the depression is acute and prolonged. I would rather advise a non-SSRI like tianeptine. At least that is currently O.C. without an Rx required. Edit: looks like HN has been down this very same road before[0] when Ketamine was brought up; and I'm smiling to see that I'm not the only one to think of Tianeptine in contrast to the drastic use of Ketamine. Psychopharmacology is the tried and true drug pusher of our times. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4615750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4615750
- pizza 11y agoWell, afaik antidepressant doses of ketamine seem to be lower than 100 mg - which is quite a bit less than the most drastic of recreational doses - I don't know (but would love to see research conducted on) whether that's actually that risky. Tianeptine is a mu-opioid receptor agonist, so it has abuse & addiction potential above therapeutic doses. It's also rx-only in many countries, according to Wikipedia. Additionally, ketamine works for a week whereas it's not uncommon for people who use tianeptine to split their daily regimen into something like 3 separate doses throughout the course of the day. At least neither require several weeks to reach efficacy while initially potentially increasing the severity of depression...
- slfnflctd 11y ago> It's also rx-only in many countries, according to Wikipedia Those countries include parts of Europe, Asia and Latin America. On the same Wikipedia page, "not available [as in, at all, even with a prescription] in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the U.K. or the U.S." Kind of a bummer, I was starting to think I might have something new to look into. Not surprised, though.
- adrusi 11y agoUsually when a drug is not available in the us it means that no regulations address it at all, do its legal to import as long as you don't sell it domestically. Do your researvh, but this is what I hear from nootropics enthusiasts.
- cubano 11y agoBack in my raver days, when this was still doable, one of my boys started driving to Mexico and buying K there and bringing it back in cheap water bottles to get by the border DEA. One day he shows up at the club and says, "hey, check out my car trunk" and was like "uhhh ok that's kinda weird" but I went out and presto, there was 4 one-liter water bottles full of ketamine. Thats a shitload of K, considering a vial is 50ml and costs around $100. So I started selling it for him, and man did it go fast. Almost everyone loved it, including myself. Oddly enough, even people who did too much the first time and had a really wack k-hole experience would try it again. It was rather miraculous to me, and surely did some sort of transformative rearranging of my brain while I was dosing it. I think what I remember best was that it became my self-described "drug of choice", which, honestly, was a pretty huge achievement in my life. I liked it because it removed my desire to do other, much darker and destructive drugs somehow, and it wasn't just a matter of typical substitution, but something much more fundamental, so studies like this are very unsurprising to me, and I really hope these researchers keep at it.
- DanBC 11y agoRecreational use is large doses. The studies I've seen for medical psychiatric use were about 5 mg per kg of body weight.
- lumpypua 11y ago0.5 mg/kg. 5 mg/kg will be a hell of a ride.
- DanBC 11y agoAh, yes. Max dose used in this study was 80 mg. http://www.oxfordhealth.nhs.uk/news/first-uk-study-of-ketamine-for-people-with-severe-depression/ http://www.oxfordhealth.nhs.uk/news/first-uk-study-of-ketami... http://www.oxfordhealth.nhs.uk/service_description/ketamine-clinic-for-depression/ http://www.oxfordhealth.nhs.uk/service_description/ketamine-... I don't know where I got 5 mg/kg from.
- brbsix 11y ago
- tominous 11y agoThe blog says that HNK (the purported antidepressant) is a known metabolite of ketamine, but then claims: > However, getting regulatory approval for such a study, which would technically (as far as I know) be a first-in-man trial of HNK, might take a long time. I don't understand this. We already know that when we give ketamine to patients they are exposed to HNK. Is there a real risk that it is more dangerous in isolation? Even if caution is required in the first patients, why do we accept as normal that developing treatments like this should involve years of waiting for bureaucratic approval?
- KaiserPro 11y agoHowever, one of the nasty side effects of long term K use is having a tiny bladder.
- DanBC 11y agoYes, but these newer therapeutic uses have much lower dosing than recreational use. Recreational users take doses of about a gram or more. These thereutic doses tend to be on the order of 5 mg per kg of body weight. (If you have any information about problems caused by long term low dosing I'd be really interested to read it).
- alfonsoperez 11y agoFrom my limited comprehension of the matter, what about: http://jneuroinflammation.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1742-2094-8-94 http://jneuroinflammation.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186...
- YngwieMalware 11y agoDisassociatives have been used for a while in the treatment of opiate addiction, including the usage of higher doses of dextromethorphan to treat heroin addicts. To me it comes with little surprise that this could also be an effective treatment for depression, despite the fact that depression isn't necessarily something that can just be treated away. I've personally done more than my fair share of recreational ketamine and it seemed to aid my coping with some major life issues I've had, though I suppose this could also be placebo. Regardless, I'm glad these types of studies are being done and hope to see some more concrete evidence of positive effect.
- daodedickinson 11y agoSo this is what Nature has come to? Following up on a study where people took Ketamine once and felt good for a while? Nobody was doubting that people could get high on Ketamine. Isolating the most intoxicating metabolite is a bit useful, but it really bothered me that "studies" looking at a single dose of Ketamine and labeling the rather short effect "sustained" get so much press.
- simonster 11y agoThe Nature paper was about isolating a metabolite of ketamine that is not responsible for the intoxicating aspects, but is responsible for the antidepressant activities (at least in mice).