19 ms·
Millennials and the Working Class Are Leaving America's Expensive Cities
- iamlacroix 11y agotl;dr gentrification
- Rhapso 11y agoTime to build new cities.
- godzillabrennus 11y ago... On Mars!
- gumby 11y agoOK, there's some data but were's the insight? If millennial move out, does that mean that as the current population ages out, post-millennials all stick around / move in or does it mean they'll become dead zones of old people? A vibrant environment needs a mix of ages (and other demographics).
- jahewson 11y ago> The affluent and the talented are flooding into superstar cities and tech hubs, creating a vicious competition for space that is pushing out the young, the less advantaged, and those who do not own homes, reinforcing the deepening class divides in our cities. The author managed to jump to this conclusion without actually offering any evidence for the claim, or even entertaining other explanations of the trends seen in the data. Likewise I can claim that millennials are leaving because baby boomers have rigged the housing market in their favour, saddled them with debt by hollowing-out funding for education, placed an undue tax burden on them via property tax controls, and locked-out up to 80% of the rental market in some cities via rent control, which allows older generations to avoid participating in a fair market and massively inflates prices in the remaining 20%. But no, it's talented people's fault, apparently. When the previous generation has kicked away the ladder, why are we surprised that those following them can't climb upwards?
- ianai 11y agoPeople often fail to get this. Just because you can see a trend in data does not mean a hypothesis is proven. You'd have to have said hypothesis based on some other reasoning/empirics and then go searching for data to test the hypothesis.
- deathhand 11y ago'search for data to test the hypothesis'? That's not how science works. The data is given and you test your idea against that. You are not allowed to 'search for data' to prove the hypothesis because that leads to bias errors.
- JetSetWilly 11y agoYou should phone up CERN and tell them to call off the search for the higgs boson. Karl Popper may have prescriptively described science as working in one particular fashion, but in the real world it doesn't work that way at all, when you look at what scientists actually do.
- deathhand 11y agoFor tangible objects I agree. This thread is originally talking about social issues however. Social issues can be hypothesized in any way because there is such a wide variety of human behavior.
- guscost 11y agoThe Higgs is what Popper called a "risky prediction" in his writing. Not seeing a spike (the expected outcome without the theory) would have falsified it, so it qualifies as science. You could say that 125 GeV was one of a few different predictions, but it was still risky to predict a spike somewhere around there. Also the hardcore Popperians will reply that many people who the mainstream considers scientists don't actually do science ;)
- joncrocks 11y ago
- s_q_b 11y agoIf I get to choose the age cohort that defines the word "millennial", I can probably get the data to say "millenials" have whatever migration pattern I desire.
- jahewson 11y ago1982. That was the end of Generation X.
- stephengillie 11y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_sharpshooter_fallacy
- gozur88 11y agoSo... people are leaving places they can't afford to live? I'm not sure I see the problem - this isn't a new thing. I loved the town where I went to college, and stayed there a few years after graduation. But the combination of high housing costs and low wages meant I'd never buy a house if I stayed. So I left and went somewhere that had a better CoL/wage ratio. That's life.
- onion2k 11y agoThe problem is that in the medium term the costs for policing, fire services, schools, etc all rise because you have to pay more to attract people to live and work in the expensive city. The only way to do that is through taxation[1]. In the long term that higher taxation drives away the companies, so you're left with an expensive city that can't afford to raise enough revenue to run. Then the city goes bankrupt. The preferred solution is to not let things get out of hand in the first place. [1] There are other options like stopping having these things provided publicly but few people would advocate that.
- gozur88 11y agoIf that's all the case, people moving away from expensive areas is a good thing, since it will drive down the cost of housing.
- Sgt_Apone 11y agoThe people who are moving away are doing so because they can't participate in the housing market in the first place. I don't see how people who can't buy houses and are leaving the area will drive down housing costs.
- cmdrfred 11y agoIt will for rentals, if supply is static but demand decreases prices will go down.
- 11y ago
- J-dawg 11y agoWhen I look at London, I'm amazed this trend isn't happening faster. London is full of young people who are basically just breaking even, spending 50% or more of their monthly income on rent. I think people tell themselves this is ok as long as they're gaining experience and moving up the ladder. The fact that people aren't moving away in greater number says more about the stagnant UK economy outside of London, than anything else. I think we're on the cusp of a massive re-think of how we live and work in cities. This will either come through regulation (rent controls, bans on 2nd homes, tax on unoccupied buildings, etc), or innovation (maybe we'll all have homes outside cities and come and stay in Tokyo-style capsule hotels during the working week). Right now, millions of people are working hard every day to make a relatively small number of landlords richer and richer. It's unsustainable, and I think some major societal change is coming.
- tim333 11y agoMore regulation doesn't really fix the basic problem of too many people wanting to live there and not enough accommodation. In China/Vietnam they deal with it by just putting up a bunch of 30/40 story apartment blocks which only seem to take about a year to build. I guess the slightly non democratic nature of the place lets them ignore the NIMBYs and just build stuff. Don't know if we could move that way in London - not commie dictatorship but weighing the benefits to those who want homes against the NIMBYs?
- mac01021 11y agoMy sister in law in Shanghai lives in such a highrise apartment block (of which there seem to be countless) and still commutes an hour each way to work because nothing closer was affordable. If London ever reaches that kind of housing demand, I suspect NIMBYs will have no say in the matter.
- mpswardle 11y agoYou're completely right about the economy outside London. I'm from London and love it but i can frankly say the UK's biggest problem is having only one genuinely world-stage level successful city. Look at our productive friends in Germany, they have Berlin, Frankfurt, Munich, Hamburg. It's not surprising rent is so high when all the good jobs are in one place.
- some1else 11y agoI wonder if they're going anywhere in particular, or just spreading out.
- atemerev 11y agoThis is actually great. It looks really strange in the modern globalized world that everybody worth something in tech have to physically move to Bay Area. The world needs new tech (and other talent) hubs, and market pressure helps in this diversification. No need to resist it.
- pteredactyl 11y agoWhat's strange is people who do not see the value in face to face communication and think remote is equal to everything else.
- atemerev 11y agoWhat's the difference between video chat and face to face communication? I don't see any. And, for that matter, resolving the issue in Slack is often much faster.
- pteredactyl 11y agoFor me it's literal presence. Some people may not be able to feel it, but I do. And for my best work, it matters. On the other hand, I do agree oftentimes it is faster to resolve issues in chat, over the phone, or whatever digital reduction du jour.
- dschiptsov 11y agoYeah, squeezed by two major trends - landlords optimize for profit maximization, while employers optimize for wages minimization, gives no other choice. It is exactly the case of losing ground/territory to better competitors in ecology - manual laborers would be pushed out of overpriced neighborhoods by JavaScript-coding hipsters and their managers.
- emodendroket 11y agoWell, there is at least one other choice in government intervention. We don't actually have to let rents keep going up.
- moonshinefe 11y agoDon't waste your time blowing all your money on overly expensive cities, move away, live a higher quality of life, build your families, and let all the millionaires left in the cities that over charge for everything alone. We don't need them at all.
- alistairSH 11y agoThat's all good and fine, but even cities that were once considered affordable are beginning to see large price increases. Seattle, Austin, Denver, etc. Yes, they remains affordable relative to SF, NY, London, but there was a time I could sell my house in suburban DC and pay cash for a house in any of the first three. That's not true any more.
- TACIXAT 11y agoTime to start looking elsewhere then. Baltimore and Detroit come to mind.
- alistairSH 11y agoBaltimore's older harbor neighborhoods definitely have some appeal. One of these days, I need to make a pass through some of the old steel belt cities. Don't know enough about them to know if I'd want to live in them. Big down side is most of them are significantly colder than DC or the other places I listed.
- Apocryphon 11y agoThis must explain the appeal of Pittsburgh as a future startup hub, well this and CMU.
- alexc05 11y agoIt's almost like a long-slow-great-depression. We can see these trends (average house price in Toronto / Vancouver exceed $1m) but nothing happens to reverse them. Plodding and lumbering forwards, the depression continues. Recently I've read a few articles about how "the Exodus of millenials threatens these cities' economies" http://www.vancouversun.com/touch/news/exodus+millennials+threatens+metro+vancouver+economy/11070861/story.html http://www.vancouversun.com/touch/news/exodus+millennials+th... (specifically, Vancouver but consider this as a cannary in a coalmine) Some of the massively expensive cities don't have the infrastructure to support a London-like commuter lifestyle. LA traffic & all the young people leave? They'll go somewhere else entirely.
- Tistel 11y agoI left Vancouver and currently live in Toronto. The real estate bubble monster is a truly frightening beast in those cities. Outside of tech (I am a programmer) and banking, so much of Canada's economy is in real estate. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-29/canada-s-one-legged-stool-economy http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-29/canada-s-o...
- jboles 11y agoSame issue with Australia. Too much of the economy involves digging up rocks and flipping houses.
- emodendroket 11y agoI just read yesterday that the suburbs were coming to an end because in the future everyone was going to live in areas like Manhattan. Shocked to learn that's not the case.
- Unklejoe 11y agoNot trying to come off as a snake, BUT, Since these trends seem to be at the beginning stages, how would one best capitalize on this? I feel that actually owning a property is going to become less and less common for people as time goes on, so maybe now is the time to push hard to invest in rental properties? The wealth classes seem to be getting more and more quantized, so I’d like to try my hardest to get myself above the rounding point before it’s too late. I have a lot of friends who will simply never be able to afford to actually purchase a house. They’re renting and living paycheck to paycheck, which basically means they’re “stuck”, as it’s very hard to save for a down payment for a house at that point. However, if they were only able to get over the initial hump of getting the down payment, they would be fine, since mortgage payments in many places are less than rent, but I digress…
- emodendroket 11y agoIf you want to extract rents on rising housing costs you should become a landlord. Being a landlord is the most obvious and literal example of being a rentier, isn't it?
- Unklejoe 11y agoDefinitely. I'm just wondering if there are any other side effects that could be exploited as well. For example, there could be a decrease in sales of decorative home items or high quaity furnature since people may be less inclined to invest money into a property they don't actually own. I have no idea if this would happen, but you get the idea.
- rm999 11y agoI've been saying this for a couple of years, but if I were into real estate investing I'd pour money into rental properties in secondary and tertiary cities. I lived in Baltimore 10 years ago and was visiting last weekend. Neighborhoods that were effectively no-go zones back then (think of areas with shootouts in The Wire) are full of cafes and hipster shops now. 10 years ago you could get a house that sells for 400k today for under 150k. I predict that pretty much every city of a few 100 thousand people within a couple hours of a bigger metropolitan area is going to grow like this. I'm also very interested in the trend towards "micro" apartments in expensive cities. They will require code changes, but the idea is solid: make tiny but affordable housing for young single people. http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-micro-apartments-article-1.2478722 http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-micro-apartments-art...
- mabbo 11y agoBut as people leave those expensive cities, won't they become more affordable? I mean, they are expensive because there are more people than available housing, and because there are lots of people making lots of money so they can spend more on stuff. But if those people want to leave, that reduces demand so prices should reduce. Eventually, we should reach an equilibrium (or at least something more stable).
- emodendroket 11y agoSo you think they're going to become more affordable as poor and middle-class people move out and are replaced by well-heeled professionals and the international elite? I think that is unlikely.
- mabbo 11y agoFair point
- Tistel 11y agoI live in Canada, did a degree in CS and work as a programmer. I do ok money wise. I consider myself lucky that I enjoy programming. I live in Toronto and have zero chance of ever owning real-estate (unless there is a massive real estate correction which would blow up the Canadian economy). Even if you consider a hypothetical marriage and doubled my income, it would be out of reach. Its even worse in Vancouver. I don't think its the end of the world. With a bit of luck and discipline, my retirement will be funded by investments. (edit: i am using the rule of not spending more than 30% of after tax income on housing)
- tmnvix 11y agoI predict that communes will make a comeback. The conditions are ripe. A generation of hipsters (I don't say that in a disparaging way) that have a fetish for authenticity, craft skills, and clean living; are also financially stretched to their limits even when sharing houses; have a strong desire to be part of a community in a society that is focused on the individual, and can't afford to create a community the traditional way (i.e. by starting a family). Communes (not necessarily rural) are coming back.
- timmaah 11y agoRegulations won't prohibit them? Rural are possible but cities aren't cool with people setting up shop in uninspected old factories or lofts.
- tmnvix 11y agoDespite the huge market demand for property, a lot of it is under utilised. There are some very big houses out there. Like up_and_up, I also spent some time living in a large shared house that was more of a community. Central city, a garden with chooks, nine bedrooms, usually twelve or more occupants, shared responsibilities, budget, cooking, etc. We were each spending about the same for rent, food, electricity, gas, phone, and internet combined as others in shared house situations were spending on rent alone. Our home was a true community hub. We hosted a lot of events. It was a great way to live as a young person. In my opinion it was the cooking roster (you cooked once every two weeks for everyone else in the house) and the fact that we all sat down to a shared meal that made it work. Without that it would probably have devolved from a large family-like situation into something more like a large hostel situation.
- up_and_up 11y agoIn the bay area there are already plenty of housing co-ops. I started one in North Oakland, 23 people living in one house, sharing meals, garden in back yard etc. I think my rent was $200 or something.
- manopeace 11y agoMinneapolis has a city ordinance against communes. It was in the paper a few months ago.
- pmlnr 11y agoIt's not just America, and apparently, a 9-5 job is working class as well, because major cities in Europe are unfordable for someone with a job like that.
- api 11y agoIn a sense you could say this is the market working. America is huge and there are lots of good places to live. We also have this amazing global telecommunications network thingy. Who knew?
- naveen99 11y agoFor good reason. Smaller towns are more livable then ever. With uber you can do without a car even in small towns and distant suburbs. With high speed internet and delivery, you rarely have to go shopping into a city center. With wikipedia, github, and youtube, education from advanced topics to daily diy projects is available to villagers. With tinder, there is a singles scene where there wasn't one before...
- emodendroket 11y agolol. That is definitely not the reason and many of those things are not necessarily practical for working-class people (like taking Uber everywhere)
- Bombthecat 11y agoWell, something like that is happening in germany. Everyone want to live in the cities. Literally paying any price for rent. And then complain about the price. Soon or later they will there own undoing not be able to pay the rent anymore and moving out. I live outside the city so I don't pay insane rents. While I watch to blow that over. I say no problem with that. It is there fault. They don't need to live there and, especially pay any rent which is way too high.