4 ms·
Honest question: What's the difference? I have no idea.
by LeoPanthera 11y ago
Honest question: What's the difference? I have no idea.
- GVIrish 11y agoDecriminalizing means reducing the penalties for the crime, but it's still illegal. So it might mean you only pay a fine for offending, rather than jail time.
- enneff 11y agoCitation?
- sokoloff 11y agoYes, you get a citation. :) From 5 minutes of Googling, it seems this might be a regional difference. AU/NZ references I found seemed to be different than the typical US usage, which follows what GP said. Massachusetts recently decriminalized THC. Possession for Personal Use Possession of 1 ounce or less of marijuana is decriminalized and is punishable as a civil offense. If the offender is over the age of 18 they must pay a fine of $100. Source: http://norml.org/laws/item/massachusetts-penalties-2 http://norml.org/laws/item/massachusetts-penalties-2 The AU/NZ usage seems to use "decriminalized" to mean "removing all laws against", where the US tends to use "makes it into a civil violation". We (in the US) use legalization to mean "fully legal (and possibly regulated/licensed and taxed)"
- enneff 11y agoWell, I'm Australian hence the confusion :-)
- Mz 11y agoMy understanding: Decriminalization is more sweepingly favorable to freedom for sex workers. Legalization tends to involve a lot of regulations. It is sometimes no better for sex workers than criminalizing it. Decriminalization seems to be about making as few laws as possible concerning the matter. Legalization involves writing a bunch of laws about what you can and cannot do. Based on the opinions of sex worker and political activist Dolores French, I have long been for decriminalization. If a legal adult wishes to take money for sexual services, I don't see why anyone should care.
- nostrebored 11y agoIf a legal adult wishes to take money for their kidney, we certainly care.
- Mz 11y agoYou know, that totally makes sense to me. I would hate to see poor people parted out because selling pieces of their body seemed like a good idea at the time. I don't see any relevance to sex work though.
- nostrebored 11y agoIt's an industry that's shown demonstrable, long term harm for short term benefits? https://www.collegium.ethz.ch/fileadmin/autoren/pdf_papers/10_roessler_sexwork.pdf https://www.collegium.ethz.ch/fileadmin/autoren/pdf_papers/1... http://www.prostitutionresearch.com/FarleyVAW.pdf http://www.prostitutionresearch.com/FarleyVAW.pdf
- zepto 11y agoLike the repetitive strain injury I got during the first dot com boom that I have never recovered from?
- cortesi 11y agoYou have this the wrong way round. Legalisation _does_ involve bringing something into the same set of regulations that applies to everything else, and that's a good thing. However, when we speak of "decriminalising" something, we usually mean removing criminal penalties for something that can still be against the law, and can still result in fines and other penalties. This means that the industry remains underground, which is usually worse for all involved. See the links I gave upthread for citations and the NZ context.
- Mz 11y agohttp://www.newstatesman.com/politics/feminism/2015/10/difference-between-decriminalisation-and-legalisation-sex-work http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/feminism/2015/10/differ... Some clarification: under legalisation, sex work is controlled by the government and is legal only under certain state-specified conditions. Decriminalisation involves the removal of all prostitution-specific laws, although sex workers and sex work businesses must still operate within the laws of the land, as must any businesses.
- cortesi 11y agoDecriminalisation usually means that some criminal penalties are removed, but an activity is still not "legal". Fines may still apply, and decriminalisation is usually partial (i.e. possession of drugs may be decriminalised, though you can still be fined, but dealing may still be fully criminalised). Legalisation means going the whole hog - removing all fines and criminal penalties. This usually also means bringing an activity in the mainstream by, for example, taxing it like any other activity, or making it subject to workplace safety regulation. This is what New Zealand did with prostitution. Wikipedia explains this reasonably well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decriminalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decriminalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legalization