12 ms·
Analysis: Apple turns the flamethrower on Android
- d4nt 17y agoThe article starts with some naive and clearly exaggerated statements about what might happen before finally getting to the real point, which is: > The case will take years to resolve, but that's no bad thing for Apple: manufacturers are going to be hesitant to create Android handsets... If Apple thought they could get a clean victory they would go after Google.
- stcredzero 17y agoPerhaps they're going for the settlement to use as ammunition for going against Google?
- sern 17y agoI quite doubt Apple's going to attack Google directly. Their weird App Store rejections and now the HTC lawsuit (read, not Google) indicate that Apple prefers a passive-aggressive stance. If Apple sues Google, Google will stop paying Apple for Safari search ad revenue and make iPhone users hate Apple by blocking Maps and YouTube and breaking iPhone Mail's Gmail button. I'm sure Apple wouldn't want that.
- stcredzero 17y agoGoogle taking ReMail off of the App Store is a very nice stroke of theirs against Apple. This gives Android phones the big advantage of Google's gmail search.
- kreneskyp 17y agoThis is misconception that is being repeated over and over. They ARE going after Google. It's very clear. It's also silly to think that HTC is in this alone. If HTC loses, Google loses. They'll throw whatever money/support they need to to back up HTC.
- nkassis 17y agoExcept it could hurt apple if HTC happens to also have a lot of nice little patents which the iPhone is infringing (not so far fetch). I have a feeling that this will never end up in court and a cross patent+cash deal will happen. Disclaimer: IANAL so whatever I just said could be total crap.
- dminor 17y ago> Except it could hurt apple if HTC happens to also have a lot of nice little patents which the iPhone is infringing (not so far fetch). Or Google, should they decide to go on the offensive.
- rbarooah 17y agoI think the interesting point is that if HTC settles using either cross licensing some patent of their own, or by paying to license whichever of Apple's patents are upheld, the outcome will be to limit Android to those who can defend themselves similarly. This might actually be good for innovation. Android - strong as it is, is not a leap forward from the iPhone, but it's now the center of gravity for most people who need a mobile os to go on their touchscreen devices. If there was more incentive to develop a truly radical mobile ux on top of Linux, it might be better for all of us.
- joeyo 17y agoIf any of this comes to pass, then the open-source aspect of android will become much more important: development will simply shift to countries that don't have software patents
- protomyth 17y agoWell, some of the patents are hardware, and you still need to sell your device in countries that will recognize these patents to make it worth making. I expect a settlement out of this, there just seems to be something else going on that is behind closed doors. It just doesn't quite make sense how it is being reported.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIf you don't need a clean victory to win, why would you pick a fight with the best paid lawyers in town and give away your hometown vs. foreigner advantage?
- yardie 17y agoI think it's pretty clear they are going after Google. By going after one manufacturer you put the brakes on the rest. Either it was a piece of HTC technology that violated patent or it was Google tech. BTW. I hate the idea of software patents and wish it ends badly for Apple.
- lucifer 17y ago"the use of a proxy object to communicate between threads" WTF. How the hell do they get away with establishing non-obviousness for these things? (Wouldn't that cover OTP, Go channels, Java Channels, etc.?) I have no beef with Apple per se (thus would have you wish that for all companies) but clearly software patent system is fundamentally flawed.
- protomyth 17y agoI would rather that law makers deal with the IP issues in a mature way then wish ill-will to someone using the current system. We really need to get some pressure where it matters (government). The courts do what they are told for the most part.
- raganwald 17y agoA system in which a software module called an event consumer can indicate an interest in receiving notifications about a specific set of events, and it provides an architecture for efficiently providing notifications to the [event] consumer Hmmm, Smalltalk implemented this. All objects in Smalltalk implement listening and notification. Apple licensed certain concepts from Xerox, so this may or may not apply. How about Java? Do Java programs that use its notifications violate the patent? Or what about Javascript libraries? How about Windows programs? It seems to me that event-driven architectures with listeners are everywhere. This is the natural consequence of software patents. Just as the inner workings of a physical engine can be patented, the inner workings of software can be patented, which means things like patterns. I wonder if future versions of books like the GoF patterns book will be annotated with warnings that some or all of the patterns are covered by patent and must be licensed?
- vaporstun 17y agoI wish more people would read the actual patent claims before coming to conclusions about them based solely on their titles. It seems that many news organizations have articles claiming this is a ridiculous lawsuit based on the titles which they claim are overly broad. If however they took the time to read the patent claims, they would see that they are relatively specific. For example: http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=L-IeAAAAEBAJ&dq=5,566,337 http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=L-IeAAAAEBAJ&dq=5... Now I'm not saying that software patents are necessarily right, but I am growing weary of people making broad generalizations based on the titles of these patents and having them perpetuated. That is somewhat like a book review discussing the book's title and deciding whether or not it's a good book without having read the book or having any knowledge of its contents. In other words, leave it to the lawyers. If you went to LN (Lawyer News - doesn't exist, but let's pretend for my analogy) and there was a lawyer claiming that Javascript is stupid because it has the word Java in it and therefore must have all the attributes of Java and he hates Java, we'd all cringe at his lack of knowledge of the subject and wish he'd leave it up to the Hackers who actually know what they're talking about to criticize.
- sern 17y ago
- euroclydon 17y agoThis article has the clearest description of a "patent arsenal", and it's purpose, that I have seen.
- aurora72 17y agoWhat could the Free Software Foundation be thinking about this, I wonder. Particularly patenting the hand gestures sounds really absurd. Doesn't Apple know that one cannot proceed by clinging on the patents and legal protections alone.
- smokinn 17y agoDoesn't Apple know that one cannot proceed by clinging on the patents and legal protections alone. They're doing no such thing. They're trying to slow others so that they can stay ahead. For the longest time I refused to buy new smartphones because I don't agree with Apple's iPhone lockdown (If I buy a product, it's mine. Nowhere does it say I'm leasing an iPhone, Apple should have no say about what I do with it.) and because multi-touch was a make-or-break feature. By keeping manufacturers afraid of implementing multi-touch Apple keeps consumers like me from going to them because they seem behind on the times.
- robotron 17y agoIf Apple thinks I'm going to buy an iPhone in the future because they're using legal methods to hinder the competition, they are dead wrong.
- JeremyBanks 17y agoThey know that some people would be bothered by this but they don't have any great reason to care as the competetive edge this might give them on the 99% of their market which does not care would far outweigh the damage done by bothering the 1%.
- freetard 17y ago99% of their market doesn't even know about this trial, or even what software patents are. Only the one 1% that is bothered about this knows about and understands the issue. In the end it will be a big loss of money for Apple and its shareholders and HTC too. A lose-lose situation, well done Apple...
- maurycy 17y agoAhh, Apple. Do you realize that your only value for most of my friends is that your OS is actually a NIX beast? I wish someone had enough money to come up with decent UI on Linux (pardon me but GNOME looks and works horrible), better typography and write some general, and widely working, framework for supporting Windows drivers. It should not take more than $20-30m I think. Ubuntu, unfortunately, is not aggressive enough in those, critical, areas.
- wtallis 17y agoDid you miss the reports about the estimated value of the Linux kernel being about $1.4 billion? What makes you think that completely overhauling GUIs on Linux to create a new desktop environment and adding binary compatibility with a completely different (closed-source!) OS would cost less than 2% of what it would take to write just the kernel? Developing a UI framework with comparable technical capabilities to what OS X provides might be doable starting from the best of what's available at the moment given your budget of $20-30m, but building a cohesive desktop environment on top of that would be an extremely huge undertaking.
- xtho 17y agoIt will be 2 billions in ten years when linux + new gui has conquered the desktop (or what is left of it) and mobile devices. The difference between 2 billions and $20-30m (or whatever imaginary sum you suggest) is called profit (or rather some share of it).
- maurycy 17y agoIt does not require major overhaul of the kernel. I agree that Windows' drivers compatibility is a hard task but I imagine there might be some hack. For instance, you could give up some speed, using virtualization. If such hack is not available (patents?), it is always possible to come up with a set of rock solid supported devices, might be with some cooperation from hardware vendors. It is exactly how Apple solved this problem, and it seems that regular people are happy to accept such restrictions, as long as everything works great. Right now, the problem is that if you install Linux on your computer, the official story is that "Linux supports more hardware than any other OS". Last time I checked (6 months ago), though, hibernation is still problematic, and you have to Google to ensure that your printer will actually work. As for the UI. To be honest, it is not a technical problem. There will be some technical work involved but it does not matter that much. Linux development focuses too much on technicalities. (I write it as software developer) The biggest issue are fonts. Every time I launch Linux, my eyes hurt. Few hours of work are required to get fonts right and they are still not that good as on OS X or Windows. There is a lot of typography know how available right now, and I bet you'd easily find a top notch typography agency or folks to solve this problem. The second issue is design and basic usability. You do not have to rewrite everything, initally. The things I mean is fixing many small issues, such as mismatched padding everywhere, and UI inconsistencies, as well as running serious usability studies to find how regular people cope with the basic tasks. I think it would be the best to pick XFCE for such improvements. Exactly like big corporations picked WebKit instead of Mozilla's engine. XFCE is modular, still relatively small, not that bloated as GNOME, and you could fork it without too much hassle. Also, it helps a lot that most of the world switches to the web. You longer need to write all possible tools, except good integration with the web. I dream about something like transparent Google Gears integrated into the WM. Paradoxically, I'd start work with porting TextMate to Linux. VIM or emacs are a bit too hardcore for regular developers, and there is no good editor on Linux for dynamic languages, which is light weight, nice and works perfectly within a minute, or two. Developers are crucial part of the infrastructure and Linux does not attract developers with eye for usability. I agree that I might underestimate the costs. I don't think, though, that it is going to take more than $50m, and money is not that big problem, actually. The biggest problem is to realize that current Linux experience sucks a lot for people who do not want to spend their valuable time tweaking settings. The improvement is enormous but it is merely a start. As for multi billion corporations that started and failed, it is not true. Right now, Linux's development is focused on getting servers right. The corporations succeed in this area. RHEL is de facto corporate standard. No one relatively big, except medium-sized Canonical, cares about your mother's experience. BTW. To be honest, I was very surprised it is only $1.4 billion when I read it. Given the scope of the project, I expected few times more. But this is me.
- brianobush 17y agoFrom the geek mindset, apple is the new microsoft. Apple has nice products, but seemingly agressive in their approach. Don't they realize that competition is good? Of course not...
- joe_the_user 17y agoHmm, Does this action actually make Nokia's suit look like a pre-strike in a war that Apple had implicitly declared?
- freetard 17y agoIt does indeed.