11 ms·
If Microsoft wants SMBs to use Enterprise then make the Enterprise edition more easily available to SMBs, don't try to force them to move to it by making petty
by Someone1234 11y ago
If Microsoft wants SMBs to use Enterprise then make the Enterprise edition more easily available to SMBs, don't try to force them to move to it by making petty little changes to make their life more difficult.
I can go on the Google Apps website right now and buy myself seats with a few clicks and a few minutes. If I want to buy Windows Enterprise licenses it will take weeks, cost an unclear amount (at the onset), and I'll have to talk/negotiate with pointless sales drones.
I worked for a startup, under 20 machines, I tried to buy then Windows 7 Enterprise. Microsoft's partners were super unhelpful, disinterested in a small account, refused to provide clear pricing, and I was getting upsold even before we got the basics squared away ("I'll just add on 20 CALs, a Windows Server license, and let's talk exchange!"). Ultimately we just gave up, and used Windows 7 Home(!) for three years.
People want to give Microsoft money, but Microsoft is intent on making the entire thing as painful as possible and their licensing as obtuse as possible. Office 365 Business gets a lot of shit, but it is a dream come true for startups, you pay one cost, and one user gets their Office license key, email, and some cloud storage taken care of.
Where is the Windows version of Office 365? Why can't I just pay a per user fee and get one Windows Enterprise key, the CAL, and Azure-based AD?
Time is money, and Microsoft likes to waste a lot of time. I'd prefer to spend a few dollars more a year and have a simple streamline process of licensing, than spend weeks being jerked around just to maybe get a few bucks off of a fake price anyway.
- Qantourisc 11y agoIf I recall correctly they want to get people on their 365. Not a good plan unless you trust Microsoft completely, of-course these kind of moves don't help their argument.
- fu9ar 11y agoSometimes, but significantly often, when I click on an email in the Outlook 365 web app, nothing happens. The display pane goes blank-white. There is a noticable delay when I click to focus on the search bar, and often I have to retype because I click and go to start typing in my search term and lose the first few characters. Almost always, when I search for an email in the Android app, it just hangs and even if I leave it to sit for minutes... It's not about trust in motivation at this point. It's about trust in competency.
- Symbiote 11y agoA colleague had a similar problem, except email never worked in the browser. It took three weeks for Microsoft Support to fix it. We'd have migrated to Google, except the system administrator had booked a holiday for two of the weeks.
- tracker1 11y agoUnfortunately, it isn't just the web app... using full on outlook really sucks compared to Outlook + Exchange a decade ago. I understand it's more about distribution and scale, but it's annoying that your unread counters can't even stay properly synced.
- yuhong 11y agoYou can get Win10 Enterprise with Software Assurance using Open License. It is also recommended to renew it every three years. But on the other note, I should mention that even Server 2012 Essentials include WSUS to control updates for example.
- Someone1234 11y agoI don't understand what this had to do with what I said? They sold Windows 7 Enterprise with Software Assurance on an Open License six years ago. I am talking about the process you have to go through to buy Windows licenses and licensing in general with Microsoft. I literally had to take a exam at one point on Microsoft licensing to be eligible for a program of theirs. I wasn't complaining about the price, or available options, I was complaining about how hard they make it to actually give them money, see how much things cost, and to be clear about exactly what licenses you need.
- snuxoll 11y ago> Where is the Windows version of Office 365? Why can't I just pay a per user fee and get one Windows Enterprise key, the CAL, and Azure-based AD? It used to be an optional tier of Windows Intune (now known as Microsoft Intune), which they have since killed (stupid decision, IMO). However, you can just directly join a Windows 10 (Pro?) system to Azure AD, Enterprise is only necessary for things like DirectRoute, you may not be able to block the Windows Store entirely but you can restrict people from using non-whitelisted applications IIRC. If you want to manage software updates, deploy applications, Microsoft Intune is still a great option (even includes endpoint protection for PC's) at $6/usr/mo. It's just too bad they got rid of the $10/usr/mo tier that had the Windows Enterprise license.
- lstamour 11y agoIt is too bad about Intune. I think the Azure AD with joining is only hybrid, unless I've missed something, which means you still need a local AD resource. Reminds me of Azure-compatible Storage Spaces Dorect -- an amazing idea until they told me I would need four identically configured servers and I realised it would be a waste of time when I only need one server and less redundancy to start. Wish they could figure out a way to provide AD entirely remotely, for those willing to require the Internet always working 24/7 to locate and manage devices on their own network... Though maybe something like bonjour could also replace those functions of AD.
- levemi 11y ago> I worked for a startup, under 20 machines, I tried to buy then Windows 7 Enterprise. Microsoft's partners were super unhelpful, disinterested in a small account, refused to provide clear pricing, and I was getting upsold even before we got the basics squared away ("I'll just add on 20 CALs, a Windows Server license, and let's talk exchange!"). Ultimately we just gave up, and used Windows 7 Home(!) for three years. You were likely talking to the wrong people. You need to go through bizspark[1] if you're a startup and you'll end up with a super-helpful dedicated Microsoft representative and lots of free stuff. It's been never anything but super in my experience to work with Microsoft as a startup. [1] https://www.microsoft.com/bizspark https://www.microsoft.com/bizspark
- monocasa 11y agoIf he's able to reach "the wrong people", that still represents a failure on Microsoft's part.
- cortesoft 11y agoIf those 'wrong' people are Microsoft employees, they should have directed him to the right people. If they didn't, then it is absolutely Microsoft's fault.
- levemi 11y agoMicrosoft is a huge organization with tens of thousands of employees. We have no idea what was communicated between this commenter and the sales person. At some point you have to kind of step back and realize that you're responsible for your outcomes and not blame everything bad that happens to you on others. Searching Google with "startup microsoft" or "startup pricing microsoft" would have been enough effort to figure this out.
- jessaustin 11y agoIs it really your assumption that thread parent neglected even to google this topic of such great import to business success? That seems neither likely nor charitable.
- jrcii 11y agoI lived through the exact same disaster. I spent HOURS on the phone trying to acquire a license for Windows 7 Enterprise, I needed it for Hyper-V. Microsoft's main number, dead-end IVR system. Tried the Microsoft Store, they routed me to the dead-end IVR system. 50 or so minutes after my initial attempt I got some person that could barely speak English from India routing me to a voicemail, a couple of times Microsoft's phone system plain hung up on me after having me on hold for 20+ minutes. Eventually I got some person at a Microsoft Store felt bad about the whole thing and took 2 days to get a number for a rep a CDW who could get me the price. That rep didn't have the price, but took my information after a 15 minute call and promised to get it to me. When she did days later, she couldn't give me a final price because she forgot I needed a user CAL and a remote access CAL. When I went to make the final purchase, she said oh, actually we can't do it because Microsoft won't sell the Windows 7 license anymore only Windows 10. The whole process made me feel like I was losing my mind.
- keithpeter 11y ago"The whole process made me feel like I was losing my mind." And perhaps Microsoft shareholders are beginning to feel as if they might be losing their capital soonish... This sounds like The End.
- notsotrue 11y agoA tad hyperbolic, don't you think?
- hga 11y agoNot necessarily, it's entirely possible for a company to severely damage itself by creating too much friction in the sales process. This is the sort of thing that helped kill Sun, although the circumstances were sufficiently different it wouldn't play out in the same way: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11601146 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11601146 (especially when much of the competition is entirely free, e.g. AWS doesn't run on Windows). Same thing with Xerox not all that long ago, they had a near death experience because the salesmen got so much pointless process larded into what they had to do to do their jobs. Note also one of the newer HP CEOs who upon getting his job said that one of his top priorities was streamlining the sales process.
- godzillabrennus 11y agoIf you are small and want enterprise licensing you can sign up your company as a reseller through Ingram Micro and buy it through distribution faster than a reseller will quote you. I think Windows Intune also comes with Enterprise licensing as well, but I'm not certain.
- nradov 11y agoThe ironic thing is that when Microsoft launched Windows NT they successfully disrupted Novell's Netware business largely by just being easier to purchase. Back then Netware was a superior product in most ways, but the only way to get it was to buy through an authorized local reseller. Dealing with those shops was a huge hassle and expense. Whereas anyone with a credit card could call up a catalog retailer and order as many different NT licenses as they wanted.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y agoyou can do all of this... i wrote the software. the only problem is the software is for the value added resellers to get the software before they sell it to you. it would be so simple to automate away sales people. ask ryan about version 2.0. TBD.
- z3t4 11y agoLike going into an expensive store dressed like a poor man.
- narrator 11y agoThis kind of reminds me about how QuarkXPress abused their market dominance for so long and generated a lot of resentment in the community. When a decent alternative came along in Adobe InDesign, people jumped ship in droves[1]. [1] http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/quarkxpress-the-demise-of-a-design-desk-darling/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/01/quarkx...
- dethswatch 11y agoThey don't want you any more. When you're ready to spend big bucks on Azure, please let them know.
- tracker1 11y agoI'm pretty happy spending small bucks on Azure... though, I'm less inclined to be stuck with windows, there are aspects I do prefer...
- cm2187 11y agoWhat's the rationale for not selling windows enterprise licenses on amazon? What's so special that it requires an official reseller?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cuckcuckspruce 11y agoIf Windows Enterprise Licenses were on Amazon then Microsoft could not maximize how much money they make on Windows Enterprise Licenses. They rely on the information asymmetry to charge you as much as they think they can get out of you.
- leonroy 11y agoAdding my voice to the chorus. The Microsoft Windows ecosystem is a god send for those wanting to enforce single sign on, roaming profiles and group policy to control things deploy Chrome, 7-Zip or all manner of apps straight to the desktop or lock down access for say the demo room machines but give full access to engineering notebooks and enforce things like password policy, mapped network drives, etc. It honestly just works and is fantastic in practise for companies wanting to enforce good IT policies with 10+ employees (in comparison try doing the above with Mac OS X + Mac OS X Server - like pulling teeth). However Microsoft's licensing is absolutely fracking byzantine. * I first need a server license - is it per socket or per core? * Then I need my desktop licenses - do I need Pro or Enterprise? Or heck, maybe Ultimate only has the regional language options I need? * Then I apparently need a fracking Client Access License for not only Windows Server to Windows Desktop services but for god damn DNS and DHCP services too! Like seriously MS - are you kidding me? So every iOS or Android device which pops up on our Windows DHCP/DNS needs a CAL apparently. Now the whole cluster fudge above would be barely tolerable for any well funded startup or company IF Microsoft made buying these licenses easy. If the above nightmare sounds bad however, just try getting licensed for it all and ensuring you're compliant. It's seriously, a real damn shame because Microsoft Windows Server + Windows desktop is fantastic. When put together it really does work beautifully. It's just such a shame that MS seems to shoot itself in the foot consistently when it comes to figuring out their licensing.
- hackbinary 11y ago> So every iOS or Android device which pops up on our Windows DHCP/DNS needs a CAL Only if you have Device CALs. If you are using User CALs then each user is licensed for as many devices as they/you want. We have good sales company (in the UK) with a really great sales REP. We moved with him when he changed companies a couple of years back. We call him up, and we have an open license the next day. That said there are some pretty aweful MS partners.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y ago> When put together it really does work beautifully. Except for the forced reboots because their OS still can't completely update itself at run time.
- chrismarlow9 11y agoI worked for a startup a while back and we tried to get quotes on running Microsoft SQL server. The sales rep could not comprehend that we were a web company. They continued to try to ask us about how we would be using it to manage our in-house inventory. Even after explaining, "no we're a web company, like myspace", the rep still didn't get it. We used MySQL.
- brazzledazzle 11y agoVARs don't even know how SQL Server licensing works. It's not hard when you take the time to read about it but it's convoluted and no one should have to waste their time doing it. Basically it comes down to this: if ($number_of_clients * $client_license) > ($number_of_processors * $processor_license) buy per-proc, else buy client licenses. Per-processor licensing is somewhere in the neighborhood of 30K (per CPU). Standby servers and processors aren't counted toward that total. Clients are any machines or users that directly or indirectly (like via a web app) use the database. That last point is important because sales reps at vendors who's software requires SQL Server will sometimes be ignorant of it or will lie and when you get audited you're the one left holding the bill.
- brazzledazzle 11y agoNo joke, it's like that in no small part because corporate types love it that way regardless of business size. If it's easy to buy licenses they'll find a way to go through a VAR anyway. I've seen a consultancy engaged to middle-man the Google Apps purchase and configuration and ultimately the only value they provided were a couple trainings and some initial configuration any idiot with a few minutes and the ability to read could do. The reality is that for your corporate/enterprise-fully-entrenched-fiefdom-building management person easily buying things or having someone read documentation and configure something is just not compatible with how they operate. They need net 30/60/90, sales drone wine, dine & golf, "is this in the Gartner Magic Quadrant?", a drawn out high-touch sales engagement and consultants they can blame. Risk averse is the name of the game and it doesn't matter if it makes the business too slow to compete because a middle manager will never be held directly accountable for doing exactly what every other politics-first middle manager is doing. You want to sell to enterprises? Get in with the developers but be prepared to provide all of the above to the people actually making the purchasing decisions.
- digi_owl 11y agoWhy do this remind me of how big media had to dragged kicking and screaming into the streaming age?
- brazzledazzle 11y agoPerhaps because it's an obviously worse system that would be replaced if only the incumbents weren't protecting it. I'm sure any individual middle manager would give you a very reasonable explanation for any of these behaviors. If you're operating in a political environment and you don't play the game you're going to end up the sucker sooner or later. How do you fix the problem when you need to be part of it to have any leverage to fix it? The only thing you have power to do in that situation is behave ethically or unethically (depending on who's definition of unethical you're using of course). I'd like to think that startups that grow enormously will prove over time that slow enterprise-y corporations are at a huge disadvantage and that will slowly make it's way into business schools. But part of the reason risk averse behavior takes hold is because the stakes get higher as you get larger. Today's spectacularly successful startups are tomorrow's enterprises unless they make a deliberate effort not to be.
- kidmenot 11y ago> People want to give Microsoft money, but Microsoft is intent on making the entire thing as painful as possible and their licensing as obtuse as possible. This. I don't know if this is still the case, but a few years ago I bought an MSDN subscription, and it took weeks. I could never figure out why they made it so difficult, nor why they forced me to go through partners. Just add a subscribe button on your own website, let me pay and be done with it. How you handle distribution is not my business (and I reckon distribution is not an issue anymore, since I think nobody chooses to have CDs delivered instead of downloading what they're interested in). Again, this was a few years ago. I hope by now they have fixed this process, because it was completely broken.
- Can_Not 11y agoSimilar story... But not with a human sales person. Went to order github enterprise for our company. Went to Microsoft Asure as one of GHE's recommended hosting partners. The interface was extremely complicated and cloudy. Costs about $200/month for what seems to be a $40-80 VPS anywhere else. Performance is not that great, too. Found out a month later that bitbucket would fit our use case hosted for $10/month. Gitlab would fit our use case hosted for free. Management had insisted on GHE "for consistency".