3 ms·
> At a recent Cupertino city council meeting, some residents protested about a lack of funding for public projects, Chang said – even crumpling up meeting agend
by dragontamer 11y ago
> At a recent Cupertino city council meeting, some residents protested about a lack of funding for public projects, Chang said – even crumpling up meeting agendas and throwing them. “They ball up the paper and throw it, and they say ‘You’re making all the wrong decisions’,” Chang said. “In the meantime Apple is not willing to pay a dime. They’re making profit, and they should share the responsibility for our city, but they won’t. They abuse us.”
Is it just me, or does this Mr. Chang just sound incompetent?
His citizens are saying he's making the wrong decisions. He's walking onto Apple's property and being forced out. He's asking for special taxes against Apple without saying why Apple deserves these taxes.
How about Chang makes the right decisions that pleases his citizens? Has anyone actually been to a Town Hall meeting? People don't just crumple-up the agendas because your budget sucks. They crumple-up agendas because the meeting was a waste of everybody's time.
I think this Mayor can't run a Town Hall, doesn't have much support of the citizens, and his only "big idea" is to increase taxes against Apple (and maybe some moonshot projects no one gives a care about)
A REAL Mayor would have said something along the lines of "The highway leading to Apple Headquarters is full of potholes, and I don't have the budget to fix it!". Or maybe "Teachers deserve a higher salary in this town" (or something... connected to reality, you know?). This guy just seems jealous of Apple's cash.
- adventured 11y agoIf Apple is meant to pay a new tax based on their net income, then every business that operates in Cupertino should obviously pay the same tax. Let's see how that goes over.
- dragontamer 11y agoExactly. Although really, Apple would just change headquarters and Cupertino would be in a bit of a mess if you made an corporate-level income-tax
- auntienomen 11y agoThey wouldn't have to physically move. Only legally. It'd be easy enough for them to arrange so that the corporate entity in Cupertino is a subsidiary which only ever makes a loss. No profits, no tax for Chang. Actually, I wouldn't be surprised if Apple is already structured this way.
- awinder 11y agoYeah, you can't pass a law that targets one individual / entity, it's unconstitutional. I believe these are called bills of attainder, but my history is a little fuzzy. They'd have to tax all businesses of a certain size, and if the companies that made up that list was around the size of 1 Apple, they'd probably have that tax bill struck down in court.
- rhino369 11y agoThis is sort of orthogonal, but certain types of businesses do get taxes on their net income in the form of sales tax. So Cupertino gets a cut of every sale that happens at a McDonalds in tehir border, but not a cut of the sales made possible by the workers in corporate buildings. There isn't an easy solution (since Apple does get taxes in other jurisdictions based on sales). But a lot of cities are frustrated that a bank branch provides little taxes while a mcdonalds in teh same spot would bring in a ton of taxes.