6 ms·
I can't think of a single reason why Apple would want to delete the files from the user's computer apart from an intent to lock the user in to the service by ma
by onion2k 11y ago
I can't think of a single reason why Apple would want to delete the files from the user's computer apart from an intent to lock the user in to the service by making it tremendously hard to leave. That's the black hole of UI dark patterns.
- delinka 11y ago"I can't think of a single reason why Apple would want to delete the files from the user's computer..." Well, to save precious local storage space of course. Apple's just being helpful here. But seriously, sounds like a "good idea" gone wrong - "I know! Let's save the user some space by serving all their music from the cloud!" The moment that file deletion came up in the design, the option to opt-in should have been added. Unless someone at Apple did indeed intend lock-in ...
- dingo_bat 11y ago> Well, to save precious local storage space of course. Apple's just being helpful here. Yeah, storage that was made precious by apple by not supporting an SD card slot. Very "helpful".
- tim333 11y agoIt could be helpful if they asked you first so you could back your stuff up to an external hard drive first.
- oarsinsync 11y agoThis isn't about a lack of expandable storage (all Macs have at least one USB port, some come with SD card slots), but rather that a lot of Macs come with very small SSDs. I can totally see how this might have seemed like a good idea. Shame it's just... not.
- dingo_bat 11y agoI was kinda assuming the iphone here. Didn't think the app on a desktop OS would show that behavior. Is this true? Do people really run out of space on laptops and desktops due to photos? I just checked the apple website and it seems you're right. 3 out of the 5 available Macbook pro variants have <= 256GB storage.
- oarsinsync 11y ago> I had just explained to Amber that 122 GB of music files were missing from my laptop This is very much about a laptop rather than a phone. And yep, I'm also suffering from this. I've got a 2010 MacBook Air with 256GB storage. I'm down to 10GB free space and struggling to decide how to cope with the now 160GB Photos library.
- JadeNB 11y agoI think that delinka (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11635126 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11635126) was being sarcastic (as evidenced by the next paragraph beginning "But seriously …").
- JimDabell 11y ago> Yeah, storage that was made precious by apple by not supporting an SD card slot. This is an article about music in iTunes on a laptop. Apple sells laptops with SD card slots.
- dingo_bat 11y agoYeah I kind of just assumed that it was talking about phones. Can't imagine running out of space for photos on a laptop.
- NoGravitas 11y agoMy phone has very limited local storage, so I can't keep photos on it. Fortunately, ownCloud implements this "good idea" basically right. I have "instant upload on WiFi" turned on for photos and videos. It uploads them to my ownCloud server, and then moves them from the system photos directory to its own directory if successful. It doesn't delete them from there, but I know that if something's in the ownCloud directory on my phone, it's backed up and available online, so I can clear it out periodically.
- jlg23 11y agoThe funny thing is: Disk space is only worth more than bandwidth in a few select 1st-world countries. I've been traveling in rural areas of South America for about 18 months now and regularly I had to turn off my MacBook because its automatic update "features" were consuming all of the available bandwidth, making it impossible for anybody to actually work.
- JadeNB 11y ago> I had to turn off my MacBook because its automatic update "features" were consuming all of the available bandwidth Which automatic update features, by the way? While I definitely don't like or defend such features, all the ones that I know about can be turned off—which gives a more useable result than having to turn off the whole computer! Maybe my Mac is silently doing some behind-the-scenes updating that I haven't noticed hitting my data, though. (Windows 10 is the real pig here, though. Bye-bye, option to download only on request! Bye-bye, this month's data allowance before I realised that it was downloading what turned out to be a huge update! I did eventually discover how to designate a connection as 'metred', a nice feature that I wish Mac OS had.)
- Kadin 11y agoOn what devices is that really a good tradeoff? On mobile, sure (at least, on mobile devices like Apple's that don't have SD cards), but on a regular computer? I find it very hard to imagine that most people are more constrained by storage than bandwidth. Internet access just isn't that good. I can barely stream music over WiFi in many public places (coffee shops, airports, etc.). If that's really the rationale, I think they're either optimizing for a use case that I find personally very atypical, or they didn't do their research.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>But seriously, sounds like a "good idea" gone wrong Don't contribute to stupidity what can adequately be explained by malice, especially when dealing with a massive company who hires quite intelligent individuals. Lock-in was intended, and then some smart people found not just a way to sell it, but make it look more acceptable even if they were called out on it.
- danielweber 11y agohttps://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20061101-03/?p=29153 https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20061101-03/?p=... I often find myself saying, “I bet somebody got a really nice bonus for that feature.” “That feature” is something aggressively user-hostile . . .
- SyneRyder 11y agoI imagine their thinking (as flawed as it is) is that it frees up local disk space for the user. If you've got a base level MacBook Air with just a 128GB SSD, maybe it seems beneficial to have a 40GB iTunes library stored entirely in the cloud on demand, and suddenly have 30% disk space freed up. Apple have a similar philosophy with Photos, where the photos on your device are just low resolution versions, with the original hi-resolution versions kept on iCloud, if you choose the Optimize Device Storage setting. [1] Not a philosophy I agree with. I like to keep my data local so I can use it offline. It's one reason I bought a 2012 MBP - I could get 1TB of storage cheaply, and I can upgrade it to a 1TB SSD myself for half the price of what Apple charges (Apple charges $800 for a 1TB SSD in Australia). [1] https://support.apple.com/en-au/HT204264 https://support.apple.com/en-au/HT204264
- junto 11y agoI'd seriously been considering a Macbook, for home use, mainly due to the iPhoto app, since on Windows there is only Google Picasa, and they've killed it. If there anyway to turn off that syncing and keep files locally only? Your comments have made me rethink my upcoming purchase!
- ar0 11y agoYes, that is absolutely possible. In fact, it is the default option, you explicitly need to enable both "iCloud Photo Library" (which activates your photos being stored on iCloud) and "Optimize Mac Storage" (which deletes the full-resolution photos from your Mac). This is exactly how it should be, and how apparently it is not for Apple Music. At least this is true for today, who knows whether what is optional today might become the only option tomorrow...
- mratzloff 11y agoI have never enabled iCloud anything. There's an option during setup to skip iCloud setup.
- stevehawk 11y ago
- givinguflac 11y agoThis article is total BS. Maybe this one guy ran into an issue, but everyone I know uses Apple Music and has not had a single file deleted.
- code4life 11y agoI imagine it's intended to be a feature. You can instantly listen to any of your songs on any device. They should have just left it on the local drive as well. Terrible.
- ambulancechaser 11y agoI uploaded all of my music to Google Play and deleted it off of my computer. When I get a new computer I only really need my google credentials and then between google drive and google play music I'm up to speed. I install a few packages and I'm at home. I have no need to keep my music there. Thus there certainly is a reason to do this. Its how photos work on iphones and androids as well. You take pictures, they are put on the cloud, space can be freed up. Its not a malicious workflow
- jpindar 11y agoThat's not how photos work on any of my Androids. The original files are on the phone, and if I need to make space I can move them to a computer via USB (or dropbox, email, etc.). You must have the Google photos sync option (or something like that) enabled.
- Too 11y agoRansomware at its best.