12 ms·
Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous car
- hunterwerlla 11y agoThis reminds me of a Planet Money episode (a great podcast). http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/29/427467598/episode-642-the-big-red-button http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/29/427467598/episo... . In it, they talk about people not wanting to ride elevators not controlled by a human operator, and how companies got people to ride them. In the same way as elevators, people will eventually adapt to self driving cars even if the industry needs something like a manual mode for emergencies or a big red button.
- markbnj 11y agoExactly. This article is just as silly. Wide-spread adoption and integration of driverless cars is a long way off yet. I don't know how long, but I also don't care since it isn't my job to predict the curve. I have zero doubt that it will happen. Humans are horrible operators of machinery. At some point the machines will absolutely be better at operating themselves under our direction. So in the meantime, let's find some people who are unnerved by all the media conversation and get some click bait out of it.
- mangeletti 11y agoLove Planet Money. I started listening back in mid 2009, and about 2 years ago I went back and listened from the start. I highly recommend it, because they started literally right when the market was crashing, and the show was so interesting. I'm now about 1 year behind again... time for a full week of Planet Money.
- bcherny 11y agoI know quoting Jobs is passe, but this seems relevant: "But in the end, for something this complicated, it's really hard to design products by focus groups. A lot of times, people don't know what they want until you show it to them."
- jessaustin 11y agoIn Henry Ford's (apparently apocryphal) words, “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” One is reminded of how much preferences can change when faced with options they couldn't previously imagine, every time one hears of grimly determined "in-control" rush hour commuters.
- molecule 11y ago> We have no evidence that Ford ever said those words. https://hbr.org/2011/08/henry-ford-never-said-the-fast https://hbr.org/2011/08/henry-ford-never-said-the-fast
- jessaustin 11y agoHence, the parenthetical remark.
- ck2 11y agoThe grandchilden of millennials won't even understand what the fuss is about or why they have to learn to drive in the first place.
- jack9 11y agoThis is just a temporary migratory phase. Time saved in actual lives, sleep, work, child care, tracking, transport and delivery, insurance, etc. It's literally a matter of time.
- tuxdev 11y agoAlready starting to happening. I know a kid in high school who's annoyed by his parents insisting that he learns to drive. Some of that is because he believe the tech is going to get good enough by the time he gets out of college, the rest is because I've set an example that it's possible to achieve a car-free lifestyle already if you make it a major priority.
- zck 11y agoI wonder how this compares to airplanes -- when the first commercial airlines came into existence, did people complain that they weren't able to fly the plane? What about autopilot?
- atemerev 11y agoLots of people are on their way to learn and get their pilot licenses, because freedom and excitement of flying do matter to them.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoCompared to the number that drive their own car or the number that take commercial flights, there are a very, very small number of people who do that.
- kunai 11y ago> did people complain that they weren't able to fly the plane ...no. Turboprop and commercial jet aircraft complemented general aviation, they didn't supplant it. It's part of why I find the autonomous car argument so absurd. People are investing billions upon billions of dollars to create a more convenient and energy-efficient transportation infrastructure using cars... the LEAST efficient method to do so, and the most expensive to implement. It's for this reason why I think truly autonomous vehicles are much further away than people think, and when they DO arrive I'd predict that the vast majority of them will be 10-12 passenger on-demand autonomous vans that optimize per-person efficiency and reduce traffic.
- saidajigumi 11y agoSo I'll spin the title a different way: "Billions are being invested in a robot that will truly liberate an aging population, the injured and the disabled, and those that simply don't care to own an automobile." The poor title notwithstanding, the trust issues cited in the article are good to be aware of. Nevertheless, I'll be shocked if self-driving vehicles aren't a technology that utterly reshapes transportation in the U.S.A. in very short order.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoIt would be a compelling article if humans didn't have such a dismal and fatal track record on the road.
- a3n 11y agoIt's not entirely humans' fault, even when humans are at fault. Road implementation is a contributing factor, for example. I'm amazed that so many people in technology think that these rolling physical software boxes are going to be reliable enough to be better than us. We're pretty good at processing new, ambiguous situations. We can't even build a secure internet. Which, by the way, these cars will be part of. I think what will happen is that some accident categories will go down, others involving autonomous cars will go up, and there will be a lot of instances of people who can't get where they need to go because the car can't figure out some ambiguous situation. Or a car will try to follow a Google route that goes around a block three times before it's (hopefully) finally routed on its way. And there will be rare instances of cars trying to drive to Ireland through the Pacific Ocean.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> It's not entirely humans' fault, even when humans are at fault. Yes, it is. > Road implementation is a contributing factor, for example. "Road implementation" is done by humans, so, even if it is a contributing factor, that doesn't make it any less humans' fault.
- 11y ago
- atemerev 11y agoI don't want a self-driving car either. I enjoy driving. I like to be in control. But for commercial purposes, self-driving cars are inevitable, of course.
- oh_sigh 11y agoDo you fly your own airplane as well?
- noir-york 11y agoI too enjoy driving my car - hell, I chose a manual and not an automatic for a reason. And I would love to fly my own plane too, for pleasure of course, not to get from A to B.
- nfbush 11y agoPretty ridiculous comparison, lets be honest
- erobbins 11y agoif I could rent a jet + fuel for the same cost as say, a first class ticket? yes, I would.
- atemerev 11y agoYou are in luck — there are some startups on track to deliver that in a few years. Still have to get the pilot license, though.
- guelo 11y agoMakes sense. People don't even want to give over control of their social media feeds. "The algorithm" is never designed for the end user's interests.
- billforsternz 11y agoI am really fascinated by how this is going to play out. I am actually somewhat skeptical that fully autonomous (in the sense of arbitrary A to arbitrary B) is really going to happen anytime soon. I heard John Siracusa on his podcast outline convincing reasons why it wouldn't happen "in our lifetime". Conventional wisdom at this point seems to be that Siracusa is wrong, but his doubts resonated with me. I hope I'm wrong!
- monk_e_boy 11y agoThis. For sure. Most roads will need to be upgraded to 'robo friendly' the little English lanes, hedges either side, one track with passing places (got to do a lot of reversing or bumping up the hedge to get past.) These will all be tricky for robots to navigate.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoYes. Roads are built things, so they are designed to be usable for the vehicles that use them. When most of these are robot cars, then the roads will be optimised over time to match.
- Olscore 11y agoI don't want driverless cars because half the time I don't even know where I am going. I routinely drive aimlessly around to discover new locations, listen to music and explore. Could driverless cars be programmed for a "scenic mode" and take me on curated tours by other people? Sure, yeah that might be cool. Though nothing will replace the spontaneity of deciding street by street, if I should go left, right or straight at an intersection; where I should stop to enjoy food or drink in an unfamiliar place; or accidentally discovering a part of town I never knew existed. Driverless cars, to me, feels like a small death in the spirit of human exploration.
- jeena 11y agoJust use a bicycle for that.
- jack9 11y agoStumbleupon for automated cars. Get to it.
- blhack 11y agoPeople who own dedicated 4x4 rigs, weekend race cars, classic cars, etc. don't drive them every day. If you enjoy wandering around in your city: keep a car and do that.
- milesokeefe 11y agoThere's no reason you couldn't do that in an autonomous car, you just wouldn't directly control the car. E.g., you instruct the car to change its route at your whim.
- Namrog84 11y agoSo why can't you just say turn left or turn right etc... Just not being the one driving. I've done exactly what you've described but also had the passenger telling me spontaneity saying go left right forward. There is nothing inherent that says you can't do that with autonomous cars. But also it's likely that there will always be cars you can drive for fun just like you can still ride horses for fun.
- gaur 11y agoI bet if you look at polls from the 1990s about the internet, you'll find a lot of people saying they're just fine without it, thank you very much, and they prefer the warm, personal experience of calling up a real human to book their plane tickets or whatever instead of punching their credit card number into some newfangled machine. But in the end, people went ahead and developed more and more infrastructure for the internet regardless, and now most people couldn't live without it.
- steego 11y agoYou don't have to go back that far. In 2007-2008, I remember polling friends and coworkers about smart phones. Just as you suggest, most said they were fine without it and didn't want to carry around a computer. I'd just read Kurzweil's book and I remember saying they'll probably have one by 2010-2011 because smart phones will be the free phones by then. I was right for one simple reason: Most people tend to dismiss new tech right up to when it stops becoming a luxury item. As soon as people find value in something and they can afford it, adoption is practically inevitable. I hope my self driving car has a nice sleeper option so I can take long road trips and wake up at my destination.
- junto 11y agoAnd in the same vein, "who on earth is going to buy a tablet"? The iPad is going to be a dud. Nobody needs or wants tablets. People don't know what they want, so we'll make them want it.
- fucking_tragedy 11y agoI was under the impression iPad sales were dropping.
- dpark 11y agoiPad sales may be dropping for any number of reasons. The number of tablets in the average home is climbing, regardless.
- cygnus_a 11y agoWhat a lame article title. The actual article presents evidence that Americans are getting more comfortable with self-driving cars, and points out that peoples' concerns aren't very valid. Honestly, I almost didn't read the article because of the title. Fortunately there was a tiny fit of rage in me that clicked to see what the author actually was saying.
- gaur 11y agoMy first thought when I saw the title was "that's a really mean thing to say about Hillary Clinton." Edit: for posterity, the original HN title was identical to the article's title: "Billions Are Being Invested in a Robot That Americans Don't Want".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- arosenbaum 11y agoThe stats were driven by the "Vehicle Hacking Vulnerability Survey". " How do you feel about autonomous or self-driving vehicles?" was asked alongside questions like "How big of a problem do you feel vehicle hacking will be in the future?" If the questions were "How safe a driver is your 75yo mother?" or "Do you think autonomous cars will increase or decrease deaths caused by drunk driving?" the survey might have shown different results.
- zardo 11y agoTMT is a great way to manipulate survey results.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThe question was flawed by itself. Most people rightly expect never to buy an autonomous car. They will just call up a car when they need to go somewhere that is appropriately configured for each trip and leave the problems of maintenance, fueling, parking, and financing to somebody else.
- Multiplayer 11y agoI think the success of driverless cars will depend on the experience. If the cars are incredibly slow/cautious and you look like a segway riding dork but just inside a glass cage.. then I don't think it works. Get the user experience right. The youtube videos of tesla drivers drinking coffee and reading the paper at high speeds looked like great fun to me.
- pbhowmic 11y agoSelf-driving will transform personal cars but it will come second. the first industry it will transform is long-haul trucking.
- efuquen 11y agoI'm sure horseless carriages freaked people out when they first came out too. And driverless cars don't mean nobody will ever drive for fun, just like autopilot on airplanes didn't eliminate getting pilot licenses for recreation. The history of people being scared and unprepared for technological change is pretty thorough: http://www.techradar.com/us/news/world-of-tech/12-technologies-that-scared-the-world-senseless-1249053 http://www.techradar.com/us/news/world-of-tech/12-technologi...
- Spooky23 11y agoNot really. My grandfather grew up in a rural part of Ireland that had no electricity until the late 1920s. One of his earliest memories was when a man came to town in a car with a battery powered lantern. It was the first most people had ever seen if either, and everyone around went to the pub to see the car and light. The car was an obvious improvement over a horse, in terms of speed, cost and versatility. Very few people voyages more than 10-15 miles from their place of birth pre automobile. Autonomous cars are not that. They will clearly be expensive, and being a service with complex liability problems will most likely be an Über-style, pay by the drink model. As amazing as Uber is, riding them is a lot more expensive than leasing a Honda Accord. They also make occasional distance trips prohibitively expensive. I do a 1,000 mile road trip every year -- which costs about $500. What would a robot Uber cost? IMO, they are a solution looking for a problem. Negative effects will include undermining public transit, and making suburban sprawl worse.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoWouldn't a 1000 mile trip be far more cost effective to do by flying? A round-trip flight plus some Ubers on the other end could easily end up being under $500.
- Spooky23 11y ago4 people from Albany, NY to most places is $3000 + rental car. Plus my wife and I are tall, and sitting in a airline seat and dealing with the airport drama sucks. Or I drive for 20 hours and get another week in a 5 star hotel.
- nvader 11y agoI'm really glad that it's not up for a popular vote, then.
- peteforde 11y agoThis is pretty much the definition of a "faster horse" scenario. Most of the population perceive the world as it is, not as it could be. (This is the S vs N in Meyers-Briggs.) It will actually be insurance companies that force the change at the consumer level. Charging crazy premiums for irrational holdouts that insist that their love of driving is better than safer transportation will force the hands of many from "no thanks" to "well, if I can save $500/month..." However, regardless of consumer uptake it's the long-haul trucking companies that stand the most to gain from autonomous vehicles. I don't have a stat handy but robot long-haul would be 25% the price and 4x faster. Something like 20% of highway accidents involve big rigs.
- steego 11y agoI really don't think people will be the irrational holdouts they claim to be. People say a lot of silly things they don't actually mean. While many of us enjoy the feeling behind the wheel now and then, it's actually a nuisance for most people most of the time. One thing I'd love to see is a safe racing mode where the computer allows people to drive like maniacs, but intervenes before the situation actually becomes dangerous. I suspect at some point automatic drivers will become so precise they will truly be able to scare the shit out of passengers safely.
- zyxley 11y ago> I suspect at some point automatic drivers will become so precise they will truly be able to scare the shit out of passengers safely. You can pretty much get that already on closed test tracks, with self-driving cars that do 'speed runs'. An example (though without passengers): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol3g7i64RAI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ol3g7i64RAI
- random_upvoter 11y ago> Charging crazy premiums As such, I see no reason why insurance companies would have an agenda against human drivers. Insurance companies will charge rational premiums that make them competitive against other insurance companies. It may very well be that insurance premiums for human drivers go down because AI drivers improve road safety.
- Animats 11y agoFrom the article: Sherman, 21, a mechanical-engineering student at the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities, trusts the technology and sees these vehicles eventually taking over the road. But he dreads the change because his passion is working on cars to make them faster. “It’s something I’ve loved to do my entire life and it’s kind of on its way out,” he says. “That’s the sad truth.” That group has already been obsoleted by Tesla. It's embarrassing to the gas car guys that Tesla's family sedan has a better 0-60 time than everything except a few supercars. Supercars that are not only insanely expensive, but unusable for ordinary driving. (Top Gear had a funny video in which they're trying to get a Veyron out of a driveway without scraping the undercarriage.) If you're really into that stuff, you have to get into electric supercars.[1] A friend of mine who grew up in a rural town fixing cars now works for the company that makes those. Zoom is not dead, but it now sounds like "chunk-whine", instead of "vroom". [1] http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/9/7517291/renovo-coupe-electric-supercar-ces-2015 http://www.theverge.com/2015/1/9/7517291/renovo-coupe-electr...
- joshu 11y ago0-60 times do not make supercars. People keep repeating that but that isn't really why they are interesting. A car is more than its engine. Fast in a line is not the same as fast overall. One of the best parts of Spec Miata is the frustrated point-bys by Ferrari drivers. A properly equipped supercar will still eat a tesla in turns and handling etc. The Renovo is actually a supercar and has more going for it than just the power train. (I have been driven in one by the founders) I am all for autonomous vehicles ruling the road. People shouldn't be driving like idiots there anyway. And I believe they are interesting on the track too: http://selfracingcars.com/ http://selfracingcars.com/
- tstrimple 11y agoFor the vast majority of drivers, the 0-60 speed does make a super car. They aren't going to be racing top speed for hundreds of miles, or cornering like in an actual race. They are going to be racing from stop light to stop light faster than just about anyone other than the real super cars.
- gfodor 11y agoyet people ride automated trains at the airport all the time. i bet if you asked them right after riding these trains if they'd ever ride a train driven by a robot, they'd say no, right after just riding one.
- shopkins 11y agoExcept those people have probably never driven a train before. It's different.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoAmericans also wanted a faster horse.
- willvarfar 11y agoThe general public will quickly start wanting self driving cars when they realize they can drink and get home. No more taking turns to be the responsible driver etc.
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoYou have basically described Uber (1). No co-incidence that Uber is interested in self-driving cars. "Do I want to own one?" is the wrong question, why bother owning one when you can summon one when you want it? 1) https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/249958 https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/249958
- willvarfar 11y ago(I'm living in Europe, in the countryside, and I think a car that can drive me home will be a big win. I think taxis etc are for built-up areas.)
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoThere will be cases where "owning your own self-driving car" will make sense, they just won't be the majority of what's now covered by "owning your own car". I'm living in Europe, in a city, and looking forward to being driven to and from social engagements this weekend, because drinking. There is going to be a human behind the wheel of that taxi but that's incidental. I don't own a car because the costs greatly outweigh the benefits and there are always alternatives.
- willvarfar 11y agoI've lived in several European cities and owning your own car has been a liability full-stop. Interestingly, everyone I know in a city in the US has a car. All they do is complain about traffic, but they own one nonetheless. For everyone owning a car today, I think tomorrow they'll want a car with self-drive feature. Its not strange that a survey conducted by car interest groups find their readers uninterested in self-driving cars, as their readers are car enthusiasts. The kind of people who aspire to owning sports cars. The kind of customer who probably doesn't want an automatic either, nor cruise control etc? ;)
- dang 11y agoWe changed the baity title, as the HN guidelines ask. In this case a neutral subtitle was available. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- happycube 11y agoThe flip side is that even if only 25% want self-driving cars, that's still a pretty damn big market.
- brianmcconnell 11y agoSafety sells. Let's say it's 2025. You can buy a Tesla Model Z, or GM's latest sedan for about 30 grand. In addition to the E-MPG rating, there's also a new sticker for deaths and injuries per mile driven. The Tesla auto-drive enabled car has a death rate one tenth that of the GM car. Which one is your spouse going to insist that you buy? I personally like to drive, especially on road trips, but I like the idea of a car that has much better reaction time that can correct if I do something stupid, or it sees something I can't (via vehicle to vehicle reporting). Speaking of which, there will be many many opportunities to reduce impact severity. Example: a vehicle pulls out in front of you unexpectedly. If the car can react instantly where you'd take a fraction of a second, it can shed enough speed to reduce the severity of impact significantly (if not avoid it altogether). Reducing speed by 25%, will reduce the impact energy by almost half, so even small improvements will result in big differences in injuries and fatalities.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSO driver-assisted cars will be popular. No reason why it has to go all the way to self-driving. And 10 years of driver-assist gradually taking over more functions will help reduce FUD to the point we'll all find ourselves thinking about driving the way we feel about horses and dial telephones.
- ams6110 11y agoWhat if the GM has a better rating? Will you find some reason that it's wrong, or didn't account for X, Y, and Z, to rationalize your desire to buy the Tesla regardless?
- kharms 11y ago>Three-quarters of drivers don't want to own an autonomous car Means that there's a market of ~60 million people that would buy an autonomous car.
- sologoub 11y ago>Sherman, 21, a mechanical-engineering student at the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities, trusts the technology and sees these vehicles eventually taking over the road. But he dreads the change because his passion is working on cars to make them faster. “It’s something I’ve loved to do my entire life and it’s kind of on its way out,” he says. “That’s the sad truth.” I don't fully agree - horses didn't disappear, but instead are now mostly kept by people that just love horses, love interacting with them and love riding them. The same is likely to happen with cars. Most likely people that race them will continue to do so, provided they have the means. If at some point driving a non-autonomous car becomes illegal to drive on certain roadways, they will be trailered to where they are legal to drive. Horses are legal on regular road, but you cannot have them on a Freeway because it's no longer safe.
- raldi 11y agoAnd they probably never will own one. But they also won't own a regular car anymore, either. The promise of self-driving cars is that, for less money than you're spending to own a car today, you'll summon a self-driving taxi whenever you want, of whatever type you want right at that moment (convertible, economy car, four-door, pickup truck, SUV, limo...), and then after it drops you off, you never see it again.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoI disagree. I would like to own a car, so that I can have my stuff in it and not have to wait for it, etc. but it's nice not to have to drive it myself
- raldi 11y agoYou're not the "they" my comment was referring to.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoWow, 25% of car owners are ready for autonomous cars. That's a huge market
- EdSharkey 11y agoI wonder if there's going to be a lot of weird social side-effects to self-driving cars like call screening was when answering machines came into wide use on phones. For example, as it has been explained to me, self-driving car software will drive defensively by default, and offensively/efficiently when they judge it safe. Okay, so say self-driving car driving hits critical mass. In this scenario, most people in cars are free to amuse themselves with their phones or reading books, etc while riding their self-driving cars to work. Many are looking down, not at the road, perhaps they're not even in the drivers' seat. What will happen if there's that one lunatic who opts to drive himself to work and drives in the most offensive, reckless manner? Won't all of the self-driving cars he encounters slam on their brakes to avoid collisions? There likely won't be any accidents, but there will be MANY frightened or startled commuters! What will this phenomena be called? Road Trolling? And, will there be collective Twitter hashtag outrage that develops as a result? I can imagine in the most extreme Los Angeles commuter scenario, a serial Road Troll being hunted by one hundred fellow commuters that he rudely cut off on his drive - their auto-drive cars set to "follow that car!", eventually becoming cornered in some residential area when he runs out of gas and then beat to death by the angry mob.
- infogulch 11y agoNope. When blatant law-breaking like this happens, every car that observed it will send a detailed record of the event to the police including the license plate. (Maybe after their passenger hits the big flashing "Report reckless driving" button.) Using street cameras the car will be automatically tracked until it stops (possibly alerting other autonomous cars to the upcoming presence of a dangerous driver which in turn drive extra defensively), where the police will arrive minutes later to arrest the driver if the infraction was serious enough or the driver will receive a letter/email with a ticket for reckless endangerment.
- EdSharkey 11y agoHmm, I suspect there is a big gray area here and not the Brave New World you describe. One can be an intensely rude driver and still fall within the law. Trolls might randomly hit their brakes hard just to see the auto-driver behind reflexively lurch and enjoy the passenger's reactions. Probably no one gets hurt, and there's no way to prove the troll wasn't legitimately trying to avoid hitting something.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThat's okay, when autonomous cars are mature, most people who ride in them won't own them. They'll use a device to signal a ride service which will send the car. And driving a manual car will be an expensive luxury, comparatively, because once autonomous cars are mature (which includes being significantly safer to operate), the total cost of riding an autonomous car vs. the total cost (including insurance) of driving will heavily favor the former.
- cwbrandsma 11y agoI don't want a first generation autonomous car...but around generation three I'll probably all in. * First Generation: expensive, mostly working, in very few cars * Second Generation: bug fixes, slightly less expensive, in more cars * Third Generation: an add-on option for the vast majority of cars, work 99.9% of the time. * Forth Generation: politicians stop complaining about all the people having sex in cars.
- joesmo 11y agoWho cares? They'll accept it eventually. And if they don't, it won't matter because they'll have no choice. This isn't an election. Self driving cars are coming and they will reduce accident rates amongst many, many benefits. If people are stupid cowards, let them walk.
- smarinov 11y agoAnd three quarters do.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JulianMorrison 11y ago98% of drivers would refuse to drive a flying saucer[1]. Let them see it, as a reality and not an abstraction, and then lets see if their minds change. I have a feeling it's like, in the early IBM PC era, people would have said, why would I want a portable handheld computer with a Star Trek touch screen and a global network, that sounds useful for engineers and nerds and maybe executives. And it doubles as a phone? How very Buck Rogers. [1] may not contain actual statistics.
- erobbins 11y agoI would love a completely autonomous car that I could get into, enter a destination, and read a book while it takes me for a ride. I am TERRIFIED of the "semi autonomous" cars that require the driver's attention to take over if the computer gets confused, like current tesla or mercedes models... because the people driving these cars are NOT going to be able to take over when required. Many people are terrible drivers when they are pretending to pay attention because they are doing the driving, there is NO way they will have the situational awareness to take over in an emergency.
- Avernar 11y agoI agree. Having a vehicle that requires me to take over in an emergency defeats the whole point of a driverless vehicle. I'd just rater drive myself then as I prefer to be a driver and not a passenger. Basically there should be two modes. Full auto when I'm too tired to drive (or sleeping) and semi auto where it takes over in an emergency. And a third mode of full manual for off roading.
- dsfyu404ed 11y ago>Basically there should be two modes. Full auto... and semi auto You'll need to come up with better names if they're ever going to be sold in Commiefornia \s
- awinter-py 11y ago4/5 of autonomous cars don't want to carry around a pesky human but you don't hear them complaining
- zyxley 11y agoIf you were to really anthropomorphize cars, I imagine that they'd consider humans as useful symbiotes that repair injuries and retrieve fuel from the deposits found here and there on the asphalt seas.
- awinter-py 11y agoYou don't need to anthropomorphize autonomous vehicles for them to talk. The last barrier to their legalization will be 'what happens in a crash'. To deal with that, they'll have to be permitted to develop moral opinions as well as the ability to testify about those in court. It's a core feature.
- zyxley 11y agoThis is a weird claim to make when there are already legal self-driving cars out there that have no such capabilities.
- awinter-py 11y agotesting only https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car#Legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_car#Legislation
- mindcrime 11y agoDon't anthropomorphize drivet-less cars, they hate it when you do that.
- Gys 11y ago30 years ago most cars in the Netherlands had shift gearing. Automatic was more expensive and considered not cool, 'not for real driving'. Nowadays everybody prefers automatic shifting...
- awqrre 11y agoOne problem with autonomous cars and most modern cars is that they are connected to the network all of the time (which can be a security and a privacy issue). Take this for example: http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/ford-exec-gps-2014-1 .
- tropo 11y agoI'm expecting "Minority Report", not "car that drives better than me" from this. First priority is not getting me hurt. Second priority is not getting me in trouble. Third priority is not causing damage that costs me. Fourth priority is to go fast. I thus want a car that can figure out potential hiding spots for cops. When there are no cops, I expect the car to disobey the law. I want it to go 2x the speed limit, drift around corners, and take winding roads faster by sometimes going into the wrong lane.
- mlinksva 11y agoI don't want to/think I'll ever own an autonomous car. But I want one someone else owns to pick me up at the snap of my fingers.
- linkregister 11y agoI'm just happy that the author of this article broke up the generations as Boomer, X, Y, and Z. I've always found the term Millennial to encompass too large of an age group to be meaningful.
- fernly 11y agoPut me down as one who does not want to OWN an autonomous car. I don't. It is ridiculous to tie up so much capital in a vehicle I use no more than 1-2 hours a day, max. But I would LOVE a world in which I can call an autonomous car to my door whenever I want one, just like I'd call Lyft today. Or book one in advance to drive me a greater distance and wait to bring me back.
- fernly 11y agoHah! Found it! This discussion reminded me of Robert Heinlein's rant against the automobile. Turns out it is from the YA novel "The Rolling Stones"[1]: "Despite the name 'automobile' these vehicles had no autocontrol circuits; control, such as it was, was exercised second by second for hours on end by a human being peering out through a small pane of dirty silica glass, and judging unassisted and often disastrously his own motion and those of other objects. In almost all cases the operator had no notion of the kinetic energy stored in his missile and could not have written the basic equation. Newton's Laws of Motion were to him mysteries as profound as the meaning of the universe. Nevertheless millions of these mechanical jokes swarmed over our home planet, dodging each other by inches or failing to dodge. None of them ever worked right; by their nature they could not work right; and they were constantly getting out of order. Their operators were usually mightily pleased when they worked at all. When they did not, which was every few hundred miles (hundred, not hundred thousand) they hired a member of a social class of arcane specialists to make inadequate and always expensive temporary repairs. "Despite their mad shortcomings, these 'automobiles' were the most characteristic form of wealth and the most cherished possessions of their time. Three whole generations were slaves to them." [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rolling_Stones_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rolling_Stones_(novel)
- recursive 11y agoI don't want to own any car, but I'd like to ride in an autonomous car.
- pteredactyl 11y agoWait until they charge a toll to leave your garage. If the traffic is bad, for instance
- undersuit 11y agoWhy even have a garage? Tell the car to park down the street with-in range of the security cameras from a local business and plant a garden where your garage used to be or turn it into a billiard room.
- limeyx 11y agoYou can probably draw a very similar chart of people who wouldn't buy a car when it replaced the horse & cart Or people who would "never" drive an automatic car or ... blah blah blah It's going to happen at some point here ... just like HDTV finally did :)