3 ms·
It's hard to argue with that policy, IMHO. Even on HN, where discussion is usually quite reasonable, there are people in this thread openly admitting to piracy
by Silhouette 11y ago
It's hard to argue with that policy, IMHO.
Even on HN, where discussion is usually quite reasonable, there are people in this thread openly admitting to piracy. The top post as I write this argues that trying to protect the rights granted by law through technical measures should mean giving up those rights altogether. There is very little respect shown towards the people who are creating new content, and even less remorse about ripping them off.
It's hardly surprising that when people are so unrepentant about these things, the people actually doing the work will take steps to protect themselves. It's sad that it's come to this, but too many selfish people have spoiled it for everyone now. I think it's inevitable that for the next few years at least, we'll see content providers increasingly locking their works up either through devices where you don't have full access even if you bought it or through keeping critical parts of the system online where customers can't copy or control it.
For some of us, piracy isn't a morally acceptable alternative to paying for a legitimate copy of a work, but DRM still sucks and often makes what we do get worse than what a pirate would get. I hope there will at least continue to be enough of us around who will make a point of supporting DRM-free alternatives that they continue to be available, but I fear we will be a small minority and so will those willing to distribute their work DRM-free.
- Retra 11y agoIf piracy is this common, why should people be ashamed to admit they do it? >It's sad that it's come to this, but too many selfish people have spoiled it for everyone now. This statement applies both ways. Human culture is a necessity. Humans are social animals. If my friends and family literally talk about Game of Thrones or Star Wars every day, do you think I'm just going to voluntarily exclude myself from my own community in order to protect the wealth of some small cabal halfway across the world? Of course not. That's not a tide you want to fight against, no matter how much you might want to trivialize the costs.
- Silhouette 11y agoIf my friends and family literally talk about Game of Thrones or Star Wars every day, do you think I'm just going to voluntarily exclude myself from my own community in order to protect the wealth of some small cabal halfway across the world? If something is so good that your friends and family literally talk about it every day and you'd feel left out if you didn't participate, is it asking too much to actually buy it and support those who make it? A show like GoT has thousands of people involved in making it, many of them working on it full time for months. Paying for it legitimately is not just paying for "some small cabal halfway across the world". If recent rumours are to be believed, even the mighty GoT is now facing an abbreviated ending because while it's been successful it's also been extremely expensive to make. This suggests that despite the optimistic spin the show's producers have often put on being so widely pirated, it still isn't getting enough actual financial support to keep going with full 10-episode seasons, which would be a real shame for all the fans who do pay for it.
- amelius 11y ago> If something is so good that your friends and family literally talk about it every day and you'd feel left out if you didn't participate [...] A show like GoT has thousands of people involved in making it Perhaps this is what should stop. I don't want big corporations determining my culture for me. And if they do, perhaps they should accept being pirated.
- Silhouette 11y agoThis argument makes no sense to me. Either you do enjoy something and want to participate in the culture built around it, in which case you can pay for it and support those who create it, or you don't, in which case why would you want to pirate it?