3 ms·
It's disappointing to see serious reporting like this saddled with a clickbait title like "This disease has killed a million trees in California, and scientists
by emodendroket 11y ago
It's disappointing to see serious reporting like this saddled with a clickbait title like "This disease has killed a million trees in California, and scientists say it’s basically unstoppable."
- chc 11y agoAfter reading the article, that seems like a fair summary. What do you feel is wrong with it?
- Tossrock 11y agoObscuring the subject to force a click. "This disease" instead of "Sudden oak death". The idea is that person will read the scary part, want to find out which particular disease it is, and click through. It's headline SEO 101.
- chc 11y agoThe odds aren't great that a given person knows what "sudden oak death" is, so that doesn't seem to add much except an extra expectation on the reader. I'm pretty sure this headline is not far from what it would been as a newspaper headline 30 years ago. It would have just been "Disease" rather than "This disease" since newspaper headlines favor brevity, but using common nouns in headlines for things that aren't super well-known is a pretty established practice (e.g. "Florida man" rather than "Robert Johnson"). I guess basically, it doesn't seem like the name of the disease is really the point of the article.
- Dylan16807 11y agoYes. You either already know about the disease or you don't. The wording of "disease" vs. "sudden oak death" doesn't change how much I want to click at all. It's not a situation where the title might obscure which disease is causing the problem. There's one problem. And "sudden oak death" is sort of a fake name anyway.
- emodendroket 11y agoWhat is "this disease?" This feels like it could have come out of the Upworthy generator.
- Sumaso 11y agoBut... Both of those statements are true...
- wnoise 11y agoWhy do you consider this clickbait? It's not untrue, nor does it tease with hidden information alluded to in the title. It's a straight-forward headline describing the contents of the article.
- tizzdogg 11y agoIt does tease with hidden information by making you want to read the article to see what "this disease" is. And the "unstoppable" bit, while true, reads as very sensationalist. A less clickbaity title might be something like: "The Sudden Oak Death fungus has killed a million trees in California, and is no longer stoppable". Or something like that.. I'm no journalist.
- emodendroket 11y agoThe one on this link is fine, although if you want to be more newspaper-like I could you could say "Scientists: Sudden Oak Death Epidemic No Longer Stoppable"
- dredmorbius 11y agoThis is, sadly, completely typical for Chris Mooney. His writing is usually decent. His headlines are pathetic. I've been hoping he'd stop for years. He hasn't.
- emodendroket 11y agoMost journalists do not write their own headlines.
- dredmorbius 11y agoMooney has indicated he does when I remarked on this before. At the least, he defended the practice.