7 ms·
The long-term effects of ugly political discussions on Facebook (2014)
- proksoup 11y agoHm, okay, I think we're making progress here though. I've started and continued quite a few controversial conversations that have "harmed" some[1] relationships, but overall I think it's for the better and has improved the relationships I want to improve. [1] https://www.facebook.com/derekbreden/posts/1670541883212714 https://www.facebook.com/derekbreden/posts/1670541883212714
- MawNicker 11y agoLol. I save my outrageous comments for face to face conversations. I'm a tad psychopathic. I like the reactions. I once suggested that black people were dumber than white people. This is widely demonstrated in IQ tests. The common argument is that these tests are culturally biased. But I think that's a sly misdirection. A more direct explanation would be that IQ is a function of well-being. Black people are oppressed. That and the history of slavery has left it's mark. I also imagine the inclination to reflect on their own oppression has a significant cost on the expression of IQ. Even if they were no longer oppressed. I don't feel that these comments are racist. I think we live in a competitive and compassionless society. Oppressed people are usually less useful. Black or white. The problem is that it's so easy to see if a person is black or white. So if there's a correlation then anyone can apply a "filter" using the measurable trait and select for the desirable trait. This furthers both the oppression and the effectiveness of the filter. At the time I was trying to explain why I thought Affirmative Action was necessary even though it was fundamentally "racist". Anyway... Since making that argument several people have asked me if I really think black people are dumber... Ugh. No. I think oppressed people are dumber and that black people are more oppressed. It is apparent that we need to talk about these things but I'm often frustrated by accusations of "racism". I don't know if anything can really be done about it. Identity is just something people are always going to be sensitive about. I've gotten better at reading my audience. EDIT: Or maybe I can't read my audience. Lol. I'm honestly curious what's wrong with this thinking? Why do explanations of the world always have to shy away from this innate domination loop? Do we need it that badly as wannabe capitalists? Affirmative Action is totally necessary for exactly the reasons I've suggested. Racism exists because humans are greedy. If any measurable trait (height, weight, age, race, gender) slips in correlation with our ideals we become prejudiced against it. Without intervention the schism just widens after that. It's the natural social mechanic. This is how so many people can act out oppression without being conscious of their hand in it. I'm actually trying to be a good human being. Albeit one who thinks political correctness serves oppressors and not the oppressed. :/
- unimpressive 11y ago>I'm a tad psychopathic. If you're trying to garner empathy, leading with this is a terrible way to do it.
- MawNicker 11y agoI was being flippant. But yeah... Agreed. I do like the reactions. You learn a lot about how people process information. Especially socially controversial information. I honestly don't really care what happens with anything in the world anymore. I'm not pushing a cause. I'm very much of the George Carlin mindset. I have a ticket to the freak show. I would prefer it if things were better but I'm very cynical. Notable though... the hatred of psychopaths. When the prevalence of pro-social psychopaths is fully revealed (like James Fallon) I suspect we will see some interesting political dynamics. They're widely and irrationally hated. You could argue they've already been unfairly profiled and oppressed by society. We really need to be able to talk about this stuff. IMHO
- Kenji 11y agoThat's exactly it. I have this one friend who always posts pro-Israel articles and another one who is black and reposts subtly racist (against whites) quotes. Even if I don't follow them, if I don't block them, their garbage will show up on my timeline sooner or later. And it's always the same things. Like, for 5 years they post this stuff. One could think their world is frozen in time. I never want to be that guy towards my friends, that's why I'd never post anything about politics, religion, etc. Facebook is not the right thing for it. Actually, for me personally, facebook is nothing but a platform to communicate with or find old classmates.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- striking 11y agoThat's what the "Unfollow" feature is for. For those people who you want to keep a link with, but don't actually want to follow.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoI understand why some people use Facebook, but I've managed to avoid it and have never heard someone in my real life express happiness that they made a different choice. It always seems to offer benefits in theory that don't pan out. Mostly it just seems to make people unhappy.
- backlava 11y agoI wouldn't recommend hanging out on Facebook, but if it puts you in touch with lost acquaintances that can be valuable.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThat's exactly it, and why I don't have the, "Facebook = Bad" mindset. It just seems to be bad for most people, in practice, over the long term. Once I found any lost friends I would try to move it over to a better forum for extended contact.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThat part has mostly just been sad. Time really wears people down.
- lazzlazzlazz 11y agoI'm going to copy paste a comment I made a while back that I still stand by: """ I [deactivated Facebook for] three years and regret it. I realize now that I should have just shaped my use to fit my needs: unfriend or unfollow people I don't care to follow, write more messages rather than scrolling through the newsfeed, and join events and groups more deliberately. Now I actually use it to keep in touch with people I care about, rather than just pretend that's what I'm doing. I missed out on some things during my three years with Facebook off, and although I learned so much from having done it, I wouldn't do it again. """
- esaym 11y agoI'm thinking about doing that. If I can just get the guts to delete half my "friends" FB would be awesome again...
- thedevil 11y agoAnother, bigger long term effect: everyone is either A) becoming extremist in their political ideas or B) just won't talk about politics at all. Edit: I've been moving towards B myself.
- parennoob 11y agoI would say that might be a side effect of a more fundamental shift – that of social networks making us more stupid (unintelligent?) and unable to coherently defend ideas in real life. On the internet, it is easy to type out long comments, cherry-pick and refute the ideas of the person on the other side, and sometimes be incredibly rude to them. But performing the jugglery of coherently defending your point while talking frankly, without being rude, in person, is a skill that seems to be conspicuous by absence in Americans today. I have noticed way too many people recently who post 200 things on Facebook/Twitter/Pinterest/Instagram, and yet are unable to keep up a decent conversation for more than five minutes without uncomfortable silences or pulling out their phones.
- Retra 11y agoHow are social networks making us more stupid than generations of family-run farming communities? Anyway, I don't see any evidence that people were ever able to speak frankly without being rude, nor that silence being uncomfortable is anything but a personal problem. Maybe you think silence is uncomfortable because you aren't properly socialized?
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIn previous decades "rude" in politics would literally get people killed. Trolling on FB doesn't move the needle in comparison. As a rue of thumb, if windows, limbs, and necks aren't being broken, the discourse is still relatively civilised. I don't believe there's evidence to support the idea that there was ever a golden age of mainstream political civility. I think there may have been a golden age of literate and moderated political journalism, but that was always distinct from the kinds of things that happened - and still do happen, in some ways - to people who happen to be in the wrong out-group.
- spc476 11y agoI had a friend (who I've known since high school, and I graduated in the late 80s) unfriend me because of a link I posted as a reply to his reply to a mutual friend's post. My take: my now unfriended friend can dish it out, but can't take it. His take (via some third parties): I'm a close minded evil conservative [1]. Yes, I come across posts from friends (and acquaintances) that I don't agree with but I won't unfriend any of them over it. There are 50,000 other channels I can "watch" and I'm certainly capable of changing the channel. Pity more people don't realize that. [1] Libertarian actually. My friend is, in his own words, "a liberal pinko Commie." Make of that what you will.
- towlejunior 11y agoLet's see that link, baby.
- spc476 11y agoIt was to a medical study that showed a possible side effect of marijuana use is paranoia. The actual event happened some time last year and trying to dig it up on Facebook is a pain.
- rosser 11y agoGiven my own, and many of my friends, calling ourselves some variation on your friend's self-described political views, I think he's being pre-emptively, jokingly snarky, in order to fend off the kind of judgement implicit behind your, "Make of that what you will," from coming into the conversation. If he calls himself a "pinko" or whatever, he's taken its use as an epithet off the table. That's no small part of why my friends and I do that, anyway.
- rosser 11y agoI had an uncle unfriend me after I called out some of the racist, misinformed crap he was spouting in response to Prince's death. It's unfortunate, because I really want to like the guy, but his posts had really boiled down to one (or, rarely, more) of: sportsball fanaticism, "Immigrants are scary!", or "Why doesn't anyone care about Vietnam Veterans?!" My feed is a lot less unpleasant now, but we're both that much more isolated in our echo chambers. Granted, I think the acoustics are much nicer in mine, but a breadth of discourse does, one hopes, help to keep one's mind ... if not more open, at least more aware of what other people are thinking.
- Kequc 11y agoCalling someone a racist is a quick way to get unfriended, yes. I've been blocking people who use that kind of personal attack on me and my life is better for it. His perception of your feed and your perception of your feed are likely very different. Since he is your uncle, you have an inroad available of meeting him to hopefully patch things up. But be aware that you might have to try and understand his point of view rather than labelling it, and writing him off as a bigot. I don't know the full story, but I've become somewhat skeptical when I hear things like this.
- rosser 11y agoI didn't call him a racist, though I can see how my phrasing of what went down might imply that. I pointed out places where his beliefs about Prince were based on factually false ideas about the man and his life, and supplied information he was clearly lacking that gave context to the things he'd heard about him that inspired those mistaken beliefs. E.g., "He was a druggie!" Yeah, no. It was Percocet, because his hip was profoundly fucked up from all the jumping around on stage he'd done for decades. As a Jehovah's Witness, drug abuse was strictly against his faith, and he didn't even allow guests at Paisley Park to drink or smoke tobacco. That kind of thing. See how making an assumption about someone and proceeding with that as a premise leads to mistaken beliefs about the events in their lives?
- Kequc 11y ago
- Yhippa 11y agoFacebook has gotten to the point for me where even normal, non-political things I post on Facebook draw trolls and shitposters. Probably just the cocktail of friends I have but people use my posts as a way to express their particular way of standing out. I posted a picture of an iris recently and even that brought out people making some weird comments. Stuff like that makes me want to hold back on posting. If I ask for restaurant recommendations I don't feel like dealing with a ton of sarcastic comments anymore.
- MatthiasP 11y agoI had that very experience a few days ago, after the first round of the Austrian presidential elections my facebook wall exploded. Marked several friends for "don't show messages, but stay friends", because I am not interested in political opportunism, no matter which side they are on.
- chatmasta 11y agoThe problem with political discussion on Facebook is the problem that has always existed with political discussion. Facebook just amplifies it x100. People simplify political rhetoric to fit it into a finite number of "camps": Democrat/republican, liberal/conservative, "SJW"/anti-PC, feminist/mysoginist... The simplified rhetoric pigeonholes issues into bipolar ideological frameworks. As a result, political "discussion" does not reflect the reality of complex networks of opinions, people, and ideas. Instead, it reflects a shallow mask of "us" and "them." Nuanced, rational discussion does not stand a chance against the uncontrollable biases of ingroup/outgroup psychology. Once someone forms an opinion, and finds validation of it from within a group, they have joined the ingroup. At that point, it will be nearly impossible to move them to the outgroup. Hearing any opinions from the outgroup will only drive them further into the ingroup, as they retreat to the echo chamber of their peers and emotionally reconfirm their own beliefs instead of critically engaging opposing viewpoints. Of course, I'm mostly talking about the "ingroup" of "feminists and SJWs" (I hate that acronym because it seems hypocritical to criticize SJWs for reductionism and then give them an acronym). Right now the "regressive left" is certainly the most guilty of seeking affirmation from ingroup dynamics, and the group most unwilling to engage with the opposition. However, I think every single human is subject to the same biases of ingroup/outgroup psychology. The "SJW" group is only the most recent example of a group whose opinions are pigeonholed, amplified, and ultimately opposed. But many of the people crusading against political correctness are guilty of the same unwillingness to consider the other side. This dynamic has always existed, as long as humans have been a social species. It's how society evolves. But it sure is messy. (visualization of the political polarization in congress: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/23/a-stunning-visualization-of-our-divided-congress/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/23/a-stu...)
- Unklejoe 11y agoThis is one of the fundamental problems with politics today. The quantization of opinions into discrete "groups" has been happening forever, but I really think we're at an all time high now. The system seems to be the most divided it's ever been. Presidential candidates are forced to align themselves with their respective groups. It's a shame really. Were probably missing out on a lot of good ideas from candidates who are afraid to offend their base and think outside the box. You can't be a pro-choice republican, etc.
- soneil 11y agoI'd be honestly curious to see the same study enacted outside the US. I do wonder if it'd come up with very different results. I don't want this to sound like stereotype-bashing, but I do notice that politics in the US seems to be incredibly polarized. There seems to be very little in the way of "difference of opinion", and more .. O is the antichrist, H is a criminal, B is a communist, T is going to bring on the apocalypse/ww3/economic collapse armed with little more than ignorance and arrogance .. It's hardly surprising people find political conversation divisive, when they see someone who disagrees with them as not having a differing opinion on one or two key issues, but as supporting a regime that's going to destroy their way of life (.. which never ends up happening).
- Unklejoe 11y agoThis is probably because the USA is relatively large and there are significant differences between states in terms of culture and industry. For example, the people of New York probably have very little in common with those of Tennessee. For example, it's easy for a liberal in Massachusetts to label a conservative in Arizona a "bigot" for wanting to close the border, but the liberal in Massachusetts has probably never experienced the issues of illegal immigration in the way that someone from Arizona has. This is why I think more power needs to be given to individual states rather than the federal government.
- alva 11y agoI think this is what was behind (still is?) the huge surprise to many, that Trump has a large number of supporters. The social cost in my friendship group of airing conservative views, has for the last few years been quite great. If you are not completely on board with the currently promoted view, you are accused of "wrong think" and chastised. The best strategy, as differing views on politics are rarely worth losing long-time friends over, is simply to shut up. Unfortunately this reassures the group in their unquestioned beliefs. It reminds me of Taleb's minority rule [0] When it comes to anonymous polling and voting, for this kind of group there is a massive disconnect between their perceived reality (reduced dissent or differing opinions due to social cost) and reality. It is a shame, both sides lose. A large part of why I love HN and other pseudo and fully anonymous forums is that you are able to engage in proper discussion, disconnected from this social suppression. [0] http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/minority.pdf http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/minority.pdf
- golemotron 11y agoThere's a political science term for this: preference falsification. People were surprised by the recent conservative win in the UK. It wasn't anticipated by the polling, probably for the reason you mention.
- chatmasta 11y agoInterestingly, people are falsifying their preferences through omission. Rather than responding affirmatively or negatively, they are simply not responding at all... until they enthusiastically check a box on a ballot.
- vintermann 11y agoI don't quite buy it. Opinion polls should be a pretty risk-free way to talk about your real preferences. If people are afraid to expose their controversial views as a checkbox on an anonymous form, why aren't they afraid to do so in the voting booth too?
- aptwebapps 11y ago
- WhatIsThisIm12 11y agoHow to herd sheep, a guide for 1% of the sheep: 1. Starve 99% of the sheep 2. Paint 51% of the sheep blue, and 48% of the sheep red 3. To turn the herd left, blame the red sheep for the starvation 4. To turn the herd right, blame the blue sheep for the starvation Profit?
- jalami 11y agoI like to call things people don't want to talk about "untouchables" because you can't argue them, you can't reason them out, you can't even comment on them without getting a glare or worse. Religion, politics, economics etc. People feel affronted when these things are talked about. I think that's why we have these political/religious/economic strongholds/echo-chambers where no one will disagree with you so you feel powerful in your conviction. In all honesty though, we know our positions have holes, but never talk about them as a society. I think if we talked more about thing we disagreed about, we'd realize we're wrong or not quite right about everything. Untouchables would go away. The problem is hard illogical convictions and echo-chambers where we allow ourselves to let our guard down. Not talking about things as a society is the problem, not the solution. We shouldn't get upset and break off relationships when people do. IMHO of course. Edit: rewording
- ChuckMcM 11y agoInteresting word, "homophily". Apparently it has been around for a while, I recognize the effect. It is interesting that discussions can be hugely enriched by discussing differing opinions, and at the same time very threatening. Especially if there is limited trust. Interesting to consider when sharing things at home, at a party, at the office, and in random groups.
- Lxr 11y agoTo me this is just a 21st century example of the old adage 'don't discuss religion or politics' - you will often be unpleasantly surprised by the views of friends and family that you considered like-minded people. I avoid these topics entirely, unless I know someone really well and even then would not post about it on Facebook et al.
- julian55 11y agoExactly. I would rather not know the political opinions of many of my friends as Often we would disagree and it wouldn't be a fruitful discussion.
- hnruss 11y agoI don't mind thoughtful political discussion, but much of what I see on Facebook is partisan political propaganda. Commenting on it only seems to legitimize it.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI'd like to balance the article out a bit and say something nice about Facebook. (Holds nose) Yes, these things turn ugly. But I think there are a lot of people who have strong political opinions but have not been forced to communicate them (and defend them) in writing. Instead, they'll just tell a joke to a few friends that they know share the same view. The old complaint about television was that there were no segmented conversations anymore. It used to be that grown-ups talked about one thing with the kids around, other things with just adults, and still other things with close friends. Television changed all of that. Now every type of conversation was fair game for everybody. This is probably one of the main driving factors for the youth-dominated culture of the past several decades, but I digress. Facebook is doing that about politics -- and to some extent, religion. You don't get a special set of friends you make those atheist or conservative jokes to. It's everybody, all the time. This is forcing folks either to 1) learn to defend their views in longform discussions civilly (which is very rare), 2) have lots of flame wars with people (I disagree with the article. I think some of these folks can be fairly close), or 3) just shut up and self-censor. I've been privileged to be on a couple of sites where open and civil discourse was promoted, and I miss those experiences. I learned a lot and managed to change my opinion on a couple of things. Facebook is not that kind of site. At first I thought I could cultivate reasonable discourse in my comment feed. I could not. Then I tried a private group, thinking a smaller group could self-moderate. Perhaps some could, but mine could not. The more people realized they might be in error, the more abusive they became. Now, for me, it's just jokes, travel pictures, and humorous family stories. About once a month somebody will sucker me into a political/religious discussion. I always apologize and bow out. I love having difficult conversations. I like being challenged to think differently about the world around me. But for this to happen implies a high level of written respect for other participants that simply doesn't exist on the site. I eventually decided to become a no-politics guy on FB because it made me a worse person. It made me angry at people that I liked. How many times can you explain concept X to a friend before you don't have to again? Well, the answer is an infinite number of times if the other person doesn't want to hear it. So discussions have no progress. No matter what you do or say, a couple of weeks later you're going to be doing and saying that all over again. I do not have the infinite patience required to do this, and hell, I like these people! Easier just to dumb down my content so they can consume it.