2 ms·
The actual title is "If correlation doesn’t imply causation, then what does?" which I think is a much more useful title and question. I think that you can answ
by joe_the_user 11y ago
The actual title is "If correlation doesn’t imply causation, then what does?" which I think is a much more useful title and question.
I think that you can answer that. Science is not a series of isolated experiments that stand or fall based on their particular data. Instead, all of our judgments of causation depend on a series of nest broad and narrow assumptions about the world. The broadest assumption is perhaps that we have a material world whose substance lacks the ability to intentionally sabotage our experiments and from which we can generate uniformly distributed random samples from. But there are whole range of assumptions below that.
From this view, "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence", essentially things are consistent with our existing assumptions still need evidence but not huge amounts. Things that are sudden changes in our whole understanding of the world require much more change. The faster-than-light neutrino experiments, in isolation, were probably a lot more convincing in just their statistics than a lot of experiments that get accepted without comment. But because such other experiments didn't contradict very established positions, their results weren't gone over with a fine-toothed comb. And that's how it should be.
Edit: the thing with a "calculus of casual inference" is that it also would have to include a way of taking into account the range of indirect assumptions that a given casual deduction depends on, so one would something like a knowledge-database.