6 ms·
Glimpse? It's already here: see what happened to Nest. The last episode of the Bad Voltage podcast basically features a long discussion on what IoT devices shou
by toyg 11y ago
Glimpse? It's already here: see what happened to Nest. The last episode of the Bad Voltage podcast basically features a long discussion on what IoT devices should be able to do when they lose the "I" for one reason or another.
Tbh, I think we'll eventually need laws: something saying "companies should guarantee serviceability and functioning of advanced devices for 10 years, rain or shine (bar nuclear holocaust)". For all the loathing this idea gets, it's the only way to tell the market to "not be stupid". Once businesses start planning for extended serviceability, they'll work on things like durable interfaces that can be easily implemented on newer patforms, offline modes etc etc, which will be innovative and will greatly benefit consumers. As these sort of systems become routine, the 10-year window will naturally extend itself.
- Symbiote 11y agoThe European Union already has these laws, the goods must be fit for purpose for a "reasonable" duration. In the UK the maximum is 6 years, but it depends on the item and how much it is used. However, up to now most things break because they wear out, or from a manufacturing fault. That's quite different from the manufacturer switching off some supporting servers, since most people would expect most old devices to work for longer than the minimum.
- digi_owl 11y agoI recall the Norwegian consumer agency and Nokia was in a row back around 2000 about the length of mandatory warranty on mobile phones. Nokia wanted it to be 2 years, same as most electronics, but the agency wanted a couple more added or some such.
- dcposch 11y ago> For all the loathing this idea gets, it's the only way to tell the market to "not be stupid". No, the market will be just fine. IoT is a fad. Much of it is just taking things that were simple and reliable and making them complex and flaky, in order to market as "smart" or "advanced" or "high tech". Fire alarms that inexplicably run Linux. Thermostats that brick themselves one morning after an auto update. "Smart fridges" with a big touch screen that nobody will actually use. [1] Buyers will get burned. IoT will lose its "wow" factor and all this will be seen, in hindsight, as comically unnecessary and embarassingly tacky. Consumer Reports will give out a bunch of black circles. The market will correct. [1]: https://twitter.com/internetofshit https://twitter.com/internetofshit http://favstar.fm/users/internetofshit http://favstar.fm/users/internetofshit
- sneak 11y agoTelephones worked a lot better before the internet. They still haven't recovered. I assume the same thing will happen here. Most people do not research. Reliability will fall and, while it may recover a bit, will not recover fully.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoTo the extent that telephones are worse now than they were before (I'm not actually sure what you're thinking of?), I'd attribute it first to the cratering demand for telephones.
- extra88 11y agoOn POTS, call quality was arguably better, calls didn't get dropped, a handset and physical dialpad are ergonomically better, and the system in a region was less likely to go down because of a power outage. There many ways in which POTS is worse but there is no inherent reason why the good things about it had to be lost.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoHas any of that changed? The fact that people aren't using telephones doesn't mean they've gotten worse. What was better before the internet and is worse now?
- extra88 11y agoI was mainly comparing landlines to cell phones and VOIP but even the traditional landlines may be a bit worse as they've gone from a switched to packetized infrastructure.
- ambulancechaser 11y agoWell, comparing cell phones to landlines and calling it worse seems to miss the addition of a key feature: mobility. It's kinda like comparing a home kitchen to one in an airplane and finding the airplane version woeful and without any improvement over what the microwave brought us in the 50's, all while neglecting to mention that one version is able to fly...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- forgetsusername 11y ago>For all the loathing this idea gets, it's the only way to tell the market to "not be stupid" Ah, the old "stay out of the business of the things I like, and regulate the things I don't" argument. >greatly benefit consumers This is why the "market" will innovate. If these companies don't provide benefit to you, or you don't like their practices, don't buy the product. There's no need for government to step in to write a bunch of arbitrary rules.
- givinguflac 11y agoThe free market is going to work everything out. That's why we don't need to regulate child labor/family medical leave/net neutrality... I could go on. History proves this argument a fallacy.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>The free market is going to work everything out Are you actually trying to tell me that in places where, say, child labor is a problem they have free markets? That free markets caused child labor issues? Show me anywhere there's remotely close to a free market, as opposed to massive government meddling and coercion, and we'll determine how well off the people are. >History proves this argument a fallacy. You have a bizarre view of history. I look back and see your vaunted governmental powers causing tremendous human suffering.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYes, because standard business practice of fucking your customers over to the extent allowed by law is of course a result of regulations, and if governments didn't interfere then companies would not be fucking people over all the time. Think about it. You probably owe your life to regulations ensuring your food is edible, and your medicine isn't poison.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Think about it. You probably owe your life to regulations ensuring your food is edible, and your medicine isn't poison. This is just laughable. Yeah, nameless, faceless companies who earn profit from consumers eating and drinking their goods are just going to poison everyone. It's not like they are composed of actual people with friends and families too, right? They want to kill everyone. Again, show me the greatest historical body-counts being business related, not governmental or politically motivated.
- conceit 11y agoThat doesn't improve the accessibility of the devices, which is part of the problem. Access is a feature that depends on the ability of the consumer and is therefore often not considered, but is also not promoted by producers. To simply legislate that products shouldn't fail doesn't improve the authority of the consumer much, now does it? That's blanked card legislation and is in theory not viable. 10 Years seems like a rather arbitrary rule, anyhow. You are probably not actually a lawyer, neither am I. I could still agree with the desire for intervention when the majorities on both sides of the problem are unreliable.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]