5 ms·

For driving Google Maps getting quite bad. See this screenshoot: http://imgur.com/uPO8QJh http://imgur.com/uPO8QJh This kind of crowded display is fairly commo

For driving Google Maps getting quite bad. See this screenshoot: http://imgur.com/uPO8QJh http://imgur.com/uPO8QJh This kind of crowded display is fairly common now. I use Here Maps now which is much better + I like supporting a second option to avoid one service getting 2 monopolistic. My theory of why google maps is getting worse is there must be designers dedicated to this that need to constantly look for 'new' things to add even if its to the detriment as they can hardly say its all good now and twiddle their thumbs. Maybe that's unfair but I've seen this effect on other digital products first hand.

chris_wot 11y ago
There are also one too many buttons when you choose a route. If I want to drive, then I type in the address, select it, press a button to activate it, then press a similar button to start the route. Why is that last button needed?
- neilc 11y ago
  Personally I like this UX. I often pullup the directions to a destination without actually starting turn-by-turn navigation: I'd like to see whether Google recommends taking highway X or Y, and then I can drive the rest of the route myself.
  - majewsky 11y ago
    Exactly. Just yesterday, I used it to get an accurate reading of the driving distance between two cities.
swiley 11y ago
The worst part about Google maps while driving is that it won't read directions until your right up on the turn.
- rdancer 11y ago
  Or two turns ahead if you're cycling. They don't seem to take speed into account.
- rory096 11y ago
  The big problem is that routes used to be useful without turn-by-turn navigation - back when there were bubbles on each turn you could click on to see. Now you're stuck trying to read a long list of directions, or you use turn-by-turn and have no idea where you're going until the last second before each turn.
- givinguflac 11y ago
  I agree. Apple Maps and Here maps are both a much better navigation experience now in my opinion. Google maps still has a bit of an advantage on POI, but for 98% of my uses Apple and Nokia do a better job.
- deelowe 11y ago
  This is my #1 complaint as well. "Turn right" Welp, guess I'm making a u-turn.
- Cerium 11y ago
  For me this is not a problem. I glance at the top left of the screen to see the direction of the next turn, left or right, then I get in the left or right lane. Also, when I miss a turn the rerouting is fast enough it's hardly a problem. My big complaint is that Google maps announces I'm on the fastest route even when I know I'm not!
- yardie 11y ago
  Indeed. I'm that idiot driving in circles around the roundabout because Google Maps gives me the turn right as I'm passing it. Also, it's forking is completely fucked. If there are 2 right turns coming up it does not indicate which lane I should be in. In once case I had to drive 60kms, 30 kms there and back, because the interchange had 3 right exits and I chose wrong. Now I use Google Maps to find the location and copy the coordinates into Apple Maps. Or use Waze.
fma 11y ago
Maybe they are taking notes from Waze. Waze by default is so crowded your entire map is just icons of random stuff you don't care about. Then every once in a while half your screen is filled by an add that you need to dismiss, while driving, to see where you are going.
- DonHopkins 11y ago
  That could cause accidents! I hope they're at least relevant ads for auto and life insurance, tow trucks, chiropractors, tombstones, etc.
  - djKianoosh 11y ago
    ha no, it's just junk food/fast food ads mostly
  - fma 11y ago
    It's ads like, there's a KFC en route to my destination. Touch here to dismiss, touch there to set as destination. It takes like 30 seconds for it to automatically disappear. If I'm on a route I'm familiar with I just let it disappear...but times where I'm going somewhere new I frantically lean forward to my dashboard to dismiss their ad.
- pgrote 11y ago
  Which platform for you use for Waze? I use Android and have never seen an ad while moving. Sometimes, the ads show if I am stopped at a stoplight, but they disappear when the car begins moving.
  - fma 11y ago
    iOS. The funny thing is, is I'm moving 5mph out of my driveway and trying to put my destination it asks if I'm a passenger... If they want to prevent accidents stop popping up ads that take up half my map while I'm driving down the highway.

chris_wot 11y ago

There are also one too many buttons when you choose a route. If I want to drive, then I type in the address, select it, press a button to activate it, then press a similar button to start the route. Why is that last button needed?

neilc 11y ago
Personally I like this UX. I often pullup the directions to a destination without actually starting turn-by-turn navigation: I'd like to see whether Google recommends taking highway X or Y, and then I can drive the rest of the route myself.
- majewsky 11y ago
  Exactly. Just yesterday, I used it to get an accurate reading of the driving distance between two cities.

swiley 11y ago

The worst part about Google maps while driving is that it won't read directions until your right up on the turn.

rdancer 11y ago
Or two turns ahead if you're cycling. They don't seem to take speed into account.
rory096 11y ago
The big problem is that routes used to be useful without turn-by-turn navigation - back when there were bubbles on each turn you could click on to see. Now you're stuck trying to read a long list of directions, or you use turn-by-turn and have no idea where you're going until the last second before each turn.
givinguflac 11y ago
I agree. Apple Maps and Here maps are both a much better navigation experience now in my opinion. Google maps still has a bit of an advantage on POI, but for 98% of my uses Apple and Nokia do a better job.
deelowe 11y ago
This is my #1 complaint as well. "Turn right" Welp, guess I'm making a u-turn.
Cerium 11y ago
For me this is not a problem. I glance at the top left of the screen to see the direction of the next turn, left or right, then I get in the left or right lane. Also, when I miss a turn the rerouting is fast enough it's hardly a problem. My big complaint is that Google maps announces I'm on the fastest route even when I know I'm not!
yardie 11y ago
Indeed. I'm that idiot driving in circles around the roundabout because Google Maps gives me the turn right as I'm passing it. Also, it's forking is completely fucked. If there are 2 right turns coming up it does not indicate which lane I should be in. In once case I had to drive 60kms, 30 kms there and back, because the interchange had 3 right exits and I chose wrong. Now I use Google Maps to find the location and copy the coordinates into Apple Maps. Or use Waze.

fma 11y ago

Maybe they are taking notes from Waze. Waze by default is so crowded your entire map is just icons of random stuff you don't care about. Then every once in a while half your screen is filled by an add that you need to dismiss, while driving, to see where you are going.

DonHopkins 11y ago
That could cause accidents! I hope they're at least relevant ads for auto and life insurance, tow trucks, chiropractors, tombstones, etc.
- djKianoosh 11y ago
  ha no, it's just junk food/fast food ads mostly
- fma 11y ago
  It's ads like, there's a KFC en route to my destination. Touch here to dismiss, touch there to set as destination. It takes like 30 seconds for it to automatically disappear. If I'm on a route I'm familiar with I just let it disappear...but times where I'm going somewhere new I frantically lean forward to my dashboard to dismiss their ad.
pgrote 11y ago
Which platform for you use for Waze? I use Android and have never seen an ad while moving. Sometimes, the ads show if I am stopped at a stoplight, but they disappear when the car begins moving.
- fma 11y ago
  iOS. The funny thing is, is I'm moving 5mph out of my driveway and trying to put my destination it asks if I'm a passenger... If they want to prevent accidents stop popping up ads that take up half my map while I'm driving down the highway.