9 ms·
An end to ‘bill shock’ as EU mobile roaming charges are slashed
- mrweasel 11y agoI wouldn't call it "an end", €0.05 extra per MB of data is still very very expensive. It seems like a low number, but people forget it's per MB. Going out, claiming an end to "bill stock", could mean that people will forget that maybe the kids shouldn't be watching Netflix during the holiday, unless they're on WIFI. You still need to disable mobile data when traveling around the EU, because it's not going to be as cheap as using it at home, far from it.
- claudius 11y agoRight now, yes. But these surcharges will be banned entirely from June 2017.
- germanier 11y agoAt least they have to automatically switch off your data connection once you hit 50 € until you reenable.
- Havoc 11y agoQuite - but you selected a bit of an edge case @ netflix. This will go along way in preventing people getting slaughtered because Windows decided to quietly do a 300mb update. 15 Euro...big deal. Hell there are country/carrier combinations where that will cost you ~10k EUR (admittedly non-EU...don't know what the highest EU combo is). Most people just want to check their mails and browse facebook without having to re-mortgage their house.
- unculture 11y agoNetflix on holiday is a number one use case for me.
- lorenzhs 11y agoI don't want to sound smug or anything, but why go abroad to watch Netflix?
- Havoc 11y agoWell I had a 7 hour stop over on a foreign airport today (LGW) so its not impossible. But as I said - edge case and very much something that most people would think through carefully in terms of connectivity. e.g. I knew today I can push maybe 250mb before my 3G bombed out. So I browsed instead of netflixed.
- lorenzhs 11y agoAh yes, airport stopovers are a good point. Maybe also business travel to "boring" places.
- ajdlinux 11y ago...because after {an exciting day of seeing all the wonderful attractions that there are to see in $COUNTRY, an exhausting day full of business meetings that you don't really want to go to but come with the territory of working for $MEGACORP}, maybe you just want a quiet evening with a movie to relax?
- r00fus 11y agoWhy? Kids
- unculture 11y agoKids, mainly.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 11y agoDid I miss something about a change in Netflix' geo-ip policy?
- tdkl 11y agoIt's a bad title, the end part comes next year, now there's only a transitional period.
- Alphasite_ 11y ago€10 for 200MB is at least bearable.
- jasonkester 11y ago€0.05 per pageload would be a better way of phrasing it. Plus €35.00 per movie streamed.
- deepnet 11y agoEyewatering bill shock will continue. 100 pages @ 2.3Mb [1] costs over €10. [1] http://www.wired.com/2016/04/average-webpage-now-size-original-doom/ http://www.wired.com/2016/04/average-webpage-now-size-origin...
- kraftman 11y agoI'm on three in the UK and I pay 18 quid a month for unlimited data pretty much everywhere in the EU, on a rolling contract that I can cancel at any time. I assumed that other EU countries would have similar offers since they are sharing each others networks, is that not the case?
- efdee 11y agoThe extra €0.05 per MB is a one year transition period. In 2017, the surcharge will go away completely.
- dingaling 11y agoThis is one of the few areas of customer-protection where I disagree with the EU. If mobile carriers are colluding to set unreasonable roaming charges then prosecute that as a cartel. But the EU has no business establishing actual call and data charges. As a result of their intervention they indirectly increase domestic mobile rates for all the people who aren't roaming. The mobile firms can just increase domestic rates to compensate for lower roaming revenues.
- fit2rule 11y agoAs someone who lives and travels in the EU and has had more than enough of this bill shock, I'm all for this regulation - it was clear that the arbitrary border charges were being used (in the smaller EU states) as a way to gouge customers. If the mobile providers continue to gouge customers by just transferring the costs to domestic billing, then that is something that the EU should also address, and as a subject of EU regulations in this regard, I'm all for it.
- masklinn 11y ago> If the mobile providers continue to gouge customers by just transferring the costs to domestic billing, then that is something that the EU should also address I doubt that'll be necessary, "local" prices are something users can and do check when comparing offers. The roaming issue comes from roaming info usually being small footnotes, most consumers not thinking about the subject (and not considering they'd need it) and needs changing, most people didn't really need data roaming a few years ago, things are markedly different with the "always connected" smartphones. Basically, roaming prices were a place where MSPs could safely gouge a small fraction of consumers (and make them feel bad for it) without much risk of building up a big protest movement. Most of them apparently didn't see or refused to act on the winds changing, and thus the EU hammer coming down on the practice.
- dingaling 11y ago> The roaming issue comes from roaming info usually being small footnotes, most consumers not thinking about the subject (and not considering they'd need it ) Then the EU should set standards for roaming advertising and contracts, not dictate the price. I can't think of any other domain of business where a Western national or supra-national government set privte-sector prices because customers can't be trusted to read T&Cs. Car rental contracts often have horrific small-print penalties for crossing intra-European state boundaries, but I don't see the EU intervening there.
- carlob 11y agoThe problem right now is: if I am in Italy and I send an SMS to a French phone (regardless of where it actually is) I spend 30 cents as this is not regulated in any way by the roaming laws. On the other hand if I'm roaming and I send an SMS to any cell phone in Europe I pay 7 cents. This means that most of the time if you have someone visiting you there is a huge asymmetry in prices when corresponding, the only problem is: I don't know how they're ever going to address this.
- dogma1138 11y agoAre PAG deals still popular in Italy? pretty much every contract but the absolute cheapest one in most EU countries I've seen comes with unlimited SMS, even the lowest ones usually come with like 2000...
- germanier 11y agoThat usually doesn't include SMS sent to foreign phones which seems to be the problem here.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoWhy communicate through SMS rather than over the internet?
- Ao7bei3s 11y agoHave you seen the prices for data roaming? (Especially since apps tend to send data automatically and also because you're one surprise sync or app store update away from financial catastrophe.)
- binarymax 11y agoData roaming is usually cheap if you pay up front. When I travel I pay a €5 fee for unlimited data for 24hrs. It doesn't allow tethering or film streaming but everything else is covered. I can even use it for Skype calls.
- Havoc 11y agoGreat news. I've switched between 4 different SIM cards in the last week to get decent data costs in the various countries. Seems rather unnecessary.
- Havoc 11y agoI wonder how this will cover "unlimited" data plans. e.g. The German SIM I've got switches to a throttled speed after the data bundle is exhausted. (Pretty damn slow, but somewhat usable - and weirdly FB voice calls seemed fine).
- germanier 11y agoFrom mid-2017 those unlimited plans need to carry over while roaming without surcharge. They can however switch off the connection after you reached a (yet to be defined) limit to stop perpetual roamers, i.e. those buying SIM cards from countries other than their residence.
- Havoc 11y ago>(yet to be defined) limit to stop perpetual roamers, i.e. those buying SIM cards from countries other than their residence. I'm tempted to say they should allow perpetual roamers. That throttled plan I mentioned is sufficiently slow that nobody sane will actually use it long term. Only tourists will use it (google maps & lost) and people utterly desperate for communication. Now if you think about Norway etc introducing broadband internet as a human right then I think we can throw people a bone and give free 384kbps free (thats roughly what it felt like - baring the freakish FB voice working). 384kbps is really at a point where one can say fk it the community will take the financial hit for the greater good. If everyone is guaranteed the ability to send whatsapp/telegram/fb messengers to loved ones & friends that'll save us all a good amount of grief. For context: It still connects at HSDPA/LTE speeds @ physical link but the throughput is 384kbps - picking that number because I used to be on 384 DSL as a reference point...not because I measured it.
- gst 11y agoFor international travel I use a Project Fi SIM card that provides data roaming at 256kbps. While web sites load slightly slower, I'm otherwise perfectly happy with 256kbps roaming.
- venomsnake 11y ago
- aaron695 11y agoSoooo since hn has a strong libertarian streak, what's the downside? Certainly forcing the standization of chargers seemed to make life easier across the world.
- comboy 11y agoSometimes such regulations are good, sometimes they're not. If some company makes a bad decision then it hurts that company and gives advantage to other companies. If regulator makes a bad decision, there is no escape from it and there are completely no consequences for him. Often it's even hard to tell if something is going to turn out to be a good decision or bad. So even ignoring potential corruption or incompetence and assuming best intentions, it's still seems better to me not to depend on a single entity. > Certainly forcing the standization of chargers Nobody forced anybody. There was no EU regulation that all phones must use such and such charger. Companies were simply optimizing for profit and that decision aligned with it.
- wycx 11y agoWhilst compliance with the European Initiative [1] is voluntary, I find it hard to believe that without the EU proposing the Initiative (presumably with an implied threat of a non-voluntary initiative), that phone manufacturers would all have magically chosen to optimise profit by employing standard micro USB. I vividly recall the days of smartphones with custom variants of usb cables. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_external_power_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_external_power_supply
- comboy 11y agoSorry, I wasn't awary of this Initiative. I still would say that it is in best manufacturers interest and they would switch, just like now they are switching to USB-C, but maybe I am wrong after all.
- stuaxo 11y agoIt was the wild west of cables. Samsung / LG etc were the worst with cables you couldn't even use with different models. Nokia + Sony were the best as theirs worked for all their respective phones + later nokia switched to USB micro. The standards change made everything so much better!
- kyriakos 11y agoSo if I have free data available with my monthly plan say 1gb, and I travel to another eu country do I still use my free mb + .05eu per MB or my providers rate for over my data allowance + the .05 ?
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoAw, they switched from fixed maximum tariffs, to maximum surcharges. This means that now it'll actually be more expensive to use my phone abroad. Currently, the maximum tariffs are lower than the rates charged at home, for me.
- germanier 11y agoThe previous cap still applies in cases like yours.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoOh, alright then.
- jhoechtl 11y agoI said it a thousand times. Joe average, who doesn't work remote and saves money for his two week holidays in Italy, will pay for the creme de ka creme hipsters jetting around Europe pretending they are in Silicon Valey.
- Geojim 11y agoamen - but is there any hope for the rest of the world? I'd love to throw out my santa sack of international sim cards. Maybe I should stop whingeing and just buy some telco shares. Can't beat 'em-
- ChatSim 11y agoDo you want to save on roaming costs while travelling all around the world? Try ChatSim! ChatSim is the first SIM that lets you exchange unlimited instant messages and emoji, in more than 150 countries, using the most popular instant messaging apps, for only 10 euros/year, even without a WiFi connection. ChatSim can connect to the roaming operators, without charging in roaming. It can connect to more than 400 roaming operators. You can use: WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, WeChat, Telegram, BBM, Line, Kik, Hike, Kakao, and QQi. ChatSim also works with 4G technology and has an automatic firewall that is able to block unwanted data traffic up to 90%. If you want to know more about ChatSim Unlimited, visit our website: chatsim.com/en
- ChatSim 11y agoDo you want to save on roaming costs while travelling all around the world? Try ChatSim! ChatSim is the first SIM that lets you exchange unlimited instant messages and emoji, in more than 150 countries, using the most popular instant messaging apps, for only 10 euros/year, even without a WiFi connection. ChatSim can connect to the roaming operators, without charging in roaming. It can connect to more than 400 roaming operators. You can use: WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, WeChat, Telegram, BBM, Line, Kik, Hike, Kakao, and QQi. ChatSim also works with 4G technology and has an automatic firewall that is able to block unwanted data traffic up to 90%. If you want to know more about ChatSim Unlimited, visit our website: chatsim.com/en