8 ms·
Could Cats and Dogs Feel the Same Emotions We Do?
- alva 11y agoIm sure Schrödinger's could
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoWe changed the title from "Can a Cat Have an Existential Crisis?" to the (somewhat) less linkbaity doc title.
- kwhitefoot 11y agoThe new title is boring. Hacker News is all about link bait so why be coy about it?
- thevibesman 11y agoWhile I do like playing spot-the-link-bait before I click articles, I do like this policy of link title revision.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zyxley 11y agoWhen it comes to animal anxiety, I always feel bad about very small dogs in public. It seems like 90% of the chihuahas I've ever seen were incredibly nervous around strangers, some to the point of visibly shaking if too close to a crowd - and I can't blame them, given the size difference.
- coralreef 11y agoProbably has more to do with the socialization of the dog than anything. You've probably seen more small dogs that are vocal and aggressive than large dogs. This is because the owners of a large dog is less likely to tolerate aggression, would put more training in, etc.
- bkjelden 11y agoWe have a dog that's part pit bull, and she's the best behaved dog I've ever had because we can't allow her to act out at all. She just doesn't get the benefit of the doubt from others that a smaller dog or a breed with a better reputation would get.
- bad_user 11y agoI've had both a Pekingese and a Rottweiler at the same time and me and my wife raised both with the same affection and attention. We were very relaxed about the Rottweiler, because she was always listening to command when outdoors and we never had to give her special training, whereas we had to keep the Pekingese on a short leash. Can you imagine somebody walking with a free Rottweiler and a leashed Pekingese? That was us. It had nothing to do with socialization or training. The Pekingese was simply more aggressive and was never listening to our command, when outdoors at least. And at some point we simply have up on trying to educate him, because that was a losing battle. The Rottweiler on the other hand knew what we wanted at all times. She even knew when we wanted her to become aggressive without any special words spoken. Obviously she was never aggressive towards the Pekingese or she would have killed him. A hard thing to do, since this kindness wasn't returned by the Pekingese. Now don't get me wrong, I loved both. But the Rottweiler was clearly much smarter and more adapted to live as part of a family ;-) PS: Broke my heart when she died, hence why I'll never adopt a dog again. They live much shorter lives, hence you get to be a parent of sorts, then watch them die, sometimes horribly.
- crpatino 11y agoI don't know about Pekingese specifically, but some races of small dogs were intentionally breed to arouse larger dogs in a hunting party. Others were breed to fend off vermin. It is not unusual to see ill-tempered small dogs at all.
- crystalmeph 11y agoIt's interesting that scientists talk about animals displaying "anxious behavior," rather than "being anxious," because we don't "know" what's actually going on in their minds. But we're perfectly willing to believe that none of our fellow humans are philosophical zombies[0], even though we don't know other people's true state of mind, or if they even have a state of mind, anymore than we know about rats' or cats'. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie
- burkaman 11y agoIsn't that just because that's not a useful or testable hypothesis? It's technically possible that I'm the only conscious being on Earth, but there's no evidence for that and it would be impossible to ever know, so it's not really worth thinking about.
- niccaluim 11y agoThe point is that the hypothesis that animals are philosophical zombies is just as untestable, but we're married to the opposite conclusion for no good reason.
- burkaman 11y agoI don't think that's true. We have lots of evidence that other humans are not philosophical zombies, we just technically can't rule it out. We can look for similar evidence that animals feel emotion, even though it's always possible that we're just seeing convincing imitations.
- niccaluim 11y agoI don't agree that we have any evidence that other humans aren't p-zombies. The whole point of the exercise is that it's logically impossible for such evidence to exist. If you're aware of any, I'd love to hear it. (FWIW I don't personally believe that people are p-zombies, but I believe that purely on faith, and because the alternative is too horrifying to contemplate.)
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe title was changed?
- rocky1138 11y agoI've actually been interested in whether they feel emotions we cannot.
- jotux 11y agoThat's pretty interesting. I think most people feel that animals only have a simple subset of human emotions they can feel but maybe there are emotions they have that we do not. I imagine dogs, with a strong sense of social belonging to a pack, experience emotions related to social structure that are difficult for us to understand.
- SwellJoe 11y agoVernor Vinge, in Fire Upon The Deep, explored that idea in pretty interesting ways. I didn't love the book (I like him as an author, and this one is considered a classic, but it didn't really grab me), but the Tines (dog-like pack animals) were an interesting thought experiment. In it, a single Tine is roughly akin to a smart dog, but when combined into a pack (linked via some sort of sound-based communication), they're of roughly human intelligence (or better) and able to perform advanced tasks, allowing them to build complex machines. Their individual pack members act as limbs in a whole "person". When one member dies, it is more like an amputation than a death...and a new pack member can be added, while mostly keeping the character and memories of the whole person. Thus Tines are potentially very long-lived (like great grandfather's ax). There is discussion of emotions that members and packs experience that humans find foreign. Belonging to a pack being one of them; a lone Tine member that can't merge into a new pack is considered a tragic case. Anyway, probably worth a read just for those novel ideas about other lifeforms.
- jerf 11y agoI agree with jotux that pack-related emotions are probably something we'd have a hard time with. We have tribe-related emotions but they are probably not the same thing. Further, humans have evolved at least one emotion that appears to have virtually no analog anywhere else: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disgust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disgust If you don't think that's an "emotion", read that page and follow some of the references; I have found it to be a very interesting topic. If humans have this one, it would seem to defy imagination that there aren't other lines that have other emotions that we don't. In fact I've seen it suggested that it's actually amazing how much similarity there is in the entire mammal line between emotional states and the expressions of those states. To a certain extent, mammals are capable of very basic emotional communication across the entire line. We take it for granted, but compare with, for instance, reptiles.
- DodgyEggplant 11y agoThis article reminds an always missing in the startup "change the world" culture: animals and wild life. There is almost no investment, innovations, startups etc in this direction. The poor animals can't blog.
- orf 11y agoIs feeding cats antidepressants a usual thing in the US? I've never heard of such a thing in Europe and to be honest I think it's a bit barmy.
- needz 11y agoFriends of mine feed their cat prozac in response to him peeing everywhere; it seems to work.
- SwellJoe 11y agoMy partner's cat had a urinary blockage that caused him to pee everywhere for several months before it was figured out that it was a physical issue (it coincided with moving to a new place, so it was assumed to be stress). They pee everywhere because it's painful to urinate, so they hold it until they can't anymore. It can be a life-threatening condition. But, it's also thought to be exacerbated by stress, so maybe taking Prozac reduces the stress and prevents the blockage from progressing.
- ChrisDutrow 11y agoMy sister and her husband had two dogs for a long time, when one of them died, the other got very depressed. So they put her on anti-depressants for a few months after that.
- dionidium 11y agoMy last dog was blind for a few years before she died and eventually seemed to be in a fair amount of pain, all of which resulted in very anxious behavior. The vet prescribed alprazolam (Xanax), which was quite effective.
- mikestew 11y agoDon't know about cats, but I've had a dog that we fed doggie Prozac in an attempt to help with behavioral issues. Seemed to have a positive effect (unfortunately, not positive enough; had to eventually put him down). We volunteer at an animal shelter, and there are occasionally particularly anxious dogs that get a prescription. Works well for a lot of them, it seems, or at least takes enough of the edge off that they can be worked with and trained. Not sure of the colloquial meaning of "barmy" (and the Mac OS dictionary is no help), but if it's a negative term, I'd argue that observation says it can help in some situations.
- yolesaber 11y agoAnyone who has worked with animals knows they are far smarter than we give them credit for. Cows and octopi learn how to escape from their pens, crows use tools, grey parrots can ask existential questions.
- VonGuard 11y agoAnd anyone who has a cat knows that the definitely have the emotions of love, hate, spite, fear and excitement.
- scotty79 11y agoI think cats must have sense of self because they dream. I can't imagine how could you have dreams without being sentient.
- walterstucco 11y agothe fact is that they don't know what they are...
- VonGuard 11y agoDo we?
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> I made an appointment, first, with a pet behavior specialist and, five months later, when her initially helpful suggestions didn’t change Lucas’s behavior, with a vet. > When I thought about Lucas as anxious, I also began to think about his needs more than I had before. I played with him more often and gave him more, smaller meals. This really makes me wonder what the specialist's suggestions were, because "more play and attention, like he is accustomed to" seems like the simplest #1 solution.
- linux_girl 11y agoI've had similar good results with my cat on anti-depressants. It sounded crazy, but his panic attacks (when other cats would venture into the back yard and he's see them out the window) ceased! We eased him off of them after a while.
- ck2 11y agoI feed a large group of stray cats around the neighborhood every morning for years now. Let me tell you, they definitely have feelings. Some cats are overjoyed to see me, they even come running down the road, purring and chirping at me. It's not because of the food because many of them don't even eat it right when I put it down, they must eat later in the day. They are just genuinely happy to get some attention, to "talk" to you and to be talked to. What people should be asking is if all those chickens, cows and bulls that are slaughtered every year had feelings and if it is right to raise them only to kill them. (and yes I know the irony is the cat food is made of chickens, cows, etc. - I don't know how to resolve that conflict)
- jensen123 11y agoIt's seems pretty obvious to me that pigs and cows have feelings and are somewhat intelligent, so I'm reluctant to eat those. But I'm really wondering about dumb animals like chickens, fish and insects. Do they have feelings? Does a chicken or a fish suffer when imprisoned?
- ck2 11y agoI saw a study somewhere that maybe fish do have feelings, they just don't express them in a way we can identify or relate to so we write it off. They do have very tiny brains but still. After refusing to eat meat since I was a teenager (we're talking decades) I recently "gave in" and started eating tuna because my protein intake was so low it was doing damage. Still feel guilty as hell about it. Beans and milk just don't cut it though and greek yogurt is way way too expensive to eat regularly. Here's a steer that was let outside after being cooped up for the winter, tell me it's not happy: https://imgur.com/gallery/r1picTv https://imgur.com/gallery/r1picTv cows do that too - I've seen all sorts of scenes with cows that clearly show them expressing emotions, with music, with dogs, etc. and pigs are VERY smart, smarter than dogs in many cases, makes completely sense to me if they have emotions, would be strange if they did not while dogs do
- trhway 11y ago>I don't know how to resolve that conflict this is why artificial meat would be so important to our civilization - probably the most important thing to happen in the near future. It would finally allow to unblock the idea in human minds that the animals are sentient beings.
- azakai 11y ago> “Do animals have mental states? We don’t know, and we can never know for sure,” he said in an interview with BrainWorld magazine in 2012. For LeDoux, observations of behavior aren’t enough to give it a label like “anxiety” when we can’t enter into the animal’s subjective experience. It might be emotion, it might also just be an automatic response to danger, and without any way of entering into the animal’s brain—the way language allows us to, at least to a certain mediated degree, with other humans—we can’t assess that. I can't disagree more strongly with this. Sure, we can never know "for sure". But it's the same with other humans. Language, despite what is said here, doesn't solve that, even if it feels that way. In other words a human saying "I feel happy" is not actual evidence that they are having a subjective experience like our own feeling of happiness. Or rather, it is evidence, but no stronger than smiling. Which, in turn, is the same type of evidence as a dog wagging its tail and showing other signs of happiness. We can attribute mental states to both humans and animals to the same extent. Of course, they might be different - we may never know what it is like to experience the world through sonar, and animals may not feel some specific human emotions. But anyone that has loved a pet knows the pet can feel things, just as well as they can know that other humans feel things.
- crpatino 11y agoAnyone who has ever had a dog (or cat, I suppose) as a pet can tell you that animals do have mental states. And any farmer across written history (minus last 120 years, perhaps) would've agreed. The myth that animals are nothing more than "flesh machines" is quite recent in history.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoPerhaps they need to change the word from "emotion" to "response". There is a great bias in science against ascribing to animals anything that is even remotely considered to be exclusively in the domain of humans. While I get the whole anthropomorphizing trend that pet owners have, raw emotional responses like anger, anxiety, envy, and affection are pretty easy to read. What is also clear is that the animals response to those emotions may be much different than human response.
- xlm1717 11y agoAgree with this. The resolution the author reveals at the end, that simply playing with the cat more reduced anxiety behavior, almost makes me think that it wasn't that the cat was anxious, just that the cat was under stimulated and acted out to use up excess energy.
- trhway 11y ago>Do animals have mental states? beside being just a religious dogma of "only humans have soul" in disguise, answering "No" would mean that the one can suggest a specific plausible place in a continuous chain of living organisms from any human back to first cell (or just to say first mammals) where the "soul" ("mental states") supposedly magically appeared. I mean did Neanderthals had soul? Did Australopithecus? Did the apes 2M years ago?